Reza Zadmard*,
Ali Akbarzadeh and
Mohammad Reza Jalali
Department of Organic Chemistry, Chemistry and Chemical Engineering Research Center of Iran, P. O. Box 14335-186, Tehran, Iran. E-mail: zadmard@ccerci.ac.ir; Fax: +98 2144787785; Tel: +98 2144787719
First published on 24th June 2019
Multicomponent reactions (MCRs) include several aspects of green chemistry principles, so it is obvious that chemists in different areas are increasingly interested in providing their product by multicomponent approaches. MCRs can be very useful in supramolecular chemistry, especially to produce novel supramolecular derivatives. Therefore, there are several reports of highly-functionalized calix[4]arene derivatives obtained by MCRs instead of conventional stepwise protocols during the last decade. In this paper, we have particularly focused on the exploitation of upper rim and lower rim substituted calix[4]arenes in multicomponent approaches as a facile and convenient synthetic strategy. The value of this method lies in its operational simplicity, mild reaction conditions and structural diversity of the products. Interestingly, in most cases the products afforded by this method offer unique features and applications which are highlighted in the following sections.
Calix[4]arenes are basket like cyclic phenol formaldehyde tetramers which create a hollow cavity flanked by a hydrophobic upper rim (aromatic moiety) and a hydrophilic lower rim (hydroxyl groups).8–10 The possibility of divers functionalization at lower and/or upper rim as well as unique conformational properties have made calix[4]arenes versatile templates to design outstanding supramolecular structures with several binding sites in an array complementary to a potential guest.11–13 The molecular hosts based on calix[4]arene scaffold have been employed in many applications,14,15 such as chemical sensing,16–18 drug and gen delivery,19–22 enzyme mimicking,23,24 stationary phase,25–27 extractants,28,29 enzyme inhibitors,30–32 catalysts33–35 and etc.
Multicomponent reaction (MCR) is defined as a chemical process between more than two substances which afford a more complicated product through formation of multiple bonds in a single step.36–38 In the point of view of green organic synthesis, MCRs possess many advantages over conventional approaches such as high atom economy, simple operation, affording highly functionalized molecules in lower reaction and purification steps, saving energy and resources.39,40 Nowadays, owing to structural diversity of the multicomponent reaction products, many industrial and academic researchers are interested in developing new biologically active compounds through MCR protocols.41,42 A survey of the literature reveals that increasing efforts have been made to develop novel calix[4]arene derivatives through MCRs during the last decade. Also, there are several reports on using calix[4]arene derivatives as organocatalysts in MCRs which are not within the scope of this review.43–45 Actually, the purpose of this review is to summarize all of the works conducted using MCR protocols to synthesize novel multi-functionalized calix[4]arene derivatives. As will be shown in further sections, most of the products have special recognition properties.
The Ugi-4CR is an isocyanide-based multicomponent reaction between an isocyanide, a carbonyl compound, a primary amine, and a carboxylic acid that affords α-acylamido amide derivatives as peptide-like structures. The use of compound 3 in Ugi-4-component reaction (Ugi-4CR) to produce a series of calix[4]arene peptoids was firstly described by Varma and coworkers (Scheme 2).
Additionally, the reaction of dialdehyde 3 as the carbonyl compound with some of chiral N-protected alpha-amino acids such as Boc-glycine, Boc-L-alanine, and Boc-L-tryptophan has afforded the products which have the potential to establish one more peptoide bond at the lower rim (Scheme 3). However, the synthesis of similar calix[4]arene derivatives is otherwise very difficult and involves multiple steps. The products obtained by this method have several non-bonding electron pairs which make them able to conduct intermolecular interactions with suitable guests. Among these new calix[4]arene derivatives, compound 3a has shown a significant change in colour and UV absorption toward the Cu2+ cation in CH3CN, even in the presence of other metal cations (Fig. 1).
Fig. 1 (a) UV-Vis spectra of 3a in the presence of Cu2+ and different metal cations (40 equivalent) in CH3CN. (b) The color change of the solution, upon Cu2+ was added: (i) 3a alone; (ii) 3a + Cu2+. |
The UV-Vis titration revealed an isosbestic point at 296 nm in the range of 0–4 equivalent of Cu2+. By Increasing of Cu2+ concentration between 4–30 equivalent, a new peak began to appear at 274 nm, as well as the complex band at 474 nm continuously increased and the colour of the solution gradually turned from colourless to orange. Addition of more Cu2+ did not lead to any further significant change in the absorbance spectra. The UV-Vis spectral changes of 3a were also observed in the competitive presence of other metal cations which imply that Cu2+:3a complex is unaffected even in the presence of 40 equivalent of many other cations49
Additionally, Varma and coworkers have successfully used compound 3 to synthesize of dihydropyrimidine derivatives via well-known Biginelli-3-Component Reaction (Biginelli-3CR) in good to excellent yields. An extended library of dihydropyrimidine derivatives with important biological properties has been available by Biginelli-3CR which was firstly reported in 1893 by the Italian Chemist Pietro Biginelli.50 The reaction of compound 3 with ethyl acetoacetate (or acetyl acetone) and urea (or thiourea) was carried out in acetonitrile as solvent, using phenylboronic acid as a non-toxic and cheap catalyst (Scheme 4). In some cases, significant inter-molecular interactions were revealed by the investigation of aggregation behaviour in non-polar solvents like chloroform.51
Another reaction was conducted by Zadmard et al. between compound 3 with Meldrum's acid, isocyanides and primary amines in dry CH2Cl2 to produce various calix[4]arene based hexamides in a convenient manner and good yields (Scheme 5).
The presence of amide groups leads to increased hydrogen bonding affinity of the molecule and makes it a suitable host to embrace a guest such as a protein. Moreover, these amide groups can improve the water solubility of hydrophobic calix[4]arene moiety. Fluorescence quenching study revealed that among all the derivatives, compound 3e has the highest binding affinity toward β-lactoglobulin (BLG) protein (Scheme 6). Additionally, three-dimensional (3D) fluorescence spectroscopy investigations proved a complex formation mechanism for the interactions between calix[4]arene hexamides and BLG which did not cause considerable conformational changes in the protein structure (Fig. 2).
3D fluorescence spectroscopy is a suitable method to gather detailed information about the conformational changes in proteins.52 Thus, the 3D fluorescence spectra of BLG (A) and 3e:BLG complex (B) are shown in Fig. 2 and the corresponding characteristic parameters are listed in Table 1. In this figure, peaks a and b respectively were assigned as the first-order Rayleigh scattering peak (λex = λem) and second-order Rayleigh scattering peak (2λex = λem). Moreover, peak 1 refers to tryptophan and tyrosine residues in BLG, and peak 2 is the spectral response of the polypeptide backbone structure in BLG protein. Rayleigh scattering peaks a and b were intensified by the addition of compound 3e. This was probably due to formation of 3e:BLG complex which increases the diameter of BLG. Furthermore, the intensity of peaks 1 and 2 significantly decreased without any variation in maximum emission and excitation wavelengths. The obtained results disclosed that any change in microenvironment of the tryptophan and tyrosine did not occur.53
Systems | Peak | Peak position λex/λem [nm nm−1] | Intensity |
---|---|---|---|
BLG | 1 | 280/340 | 589 |
2 | 230/340 | 271 | |
BLG:3e (1:2) | 1 | 280/340 | 327 |
2 | 230/340 | 95 |
Also, the binding affinity of compound 3f toward some proteins has been investigated in a similar study (Scheme 7). Surprisingly, it was found that the binding affinity of 3f toward lysozyme (Lys) is significantly higher than the others (Table 2).
Proteins | KA (M−1) |
---|---|
Lys | 2.96 × 106 |
BLG | 1.14 × 105 |
BSA | 8.34 × 104 |
HSA | 7.84 × 104 |
As most of tryptophan residues in Lys have polar-uncharged and hydrophobic amino acids in their vicinity, it is possible to establish hydrogen bonds and hydrophobic interactions toward compound 3f at the same time. One of the advantages of using compound 3f as a Lys inhibitor is that the formation of Lys:3f complex cannot be considerably affected by the presence of biologically important metal ions.54
In the most recent work, one-pot 4-component reaction of compound 3 with 1,1-bis (methylthio)-2-nitroethylene, 1,2-ethanediamine, and malononitrile was carried out in ethanol as solvent and in the presence of 10 mol% piperidine as a basic catalyst under reflux condition to afford the new multifunctional calix[4]arene 3g (Scheme 8).
The binding property of compound 3g with four selected proteins was investigated by fluorescence quenching titration. Among them, BLG showed the most dramatic decrease in the fluorescence intensity without any shift in the maximum emission wavelength (Fig. 3). These results imply a strong interaction between 3g and BLG without considerable conformational changes in the protein structure.
As shown in Table 3, the binding constant for 3g:BLG complex was found to be significantly higher than the binding constant for the three other proteins.55
Proteins | KA (M−1) |
---|---|
BLG | 1.06 × 106 |
Lys | 2.66 × 105 |
BSA | 9.04 × 104 |
HSA | 5.22 × 104 |
Kabachnik–Fields reaction, a named 3-component reaction of an aldehyde/ketone with an amine and a di-/trialkyl phosphite, provides a useful procedure to yield α-aminophosphonate derivatives.56,57 These valuable organophosphorus compounds have many intriguing biological activities. Actually, they are key substrates to obtain α-aminophosphosphoric acids which are α-amino acids analogues and can exhibit a broad range of biological activities. A series of novel calix[4]arene based α-aminophosphonate derivatives were described by Stoikov and his coworkers through Kabachnik–Fields reaction. In this reaction the amino alkyl derivatives of p-tert-butylcalix[4]arene (compounds 4 and 5) were used as the platform to construct α-aminophosphonate fragments at the lower rim of the calix[4]arene annulus (Scheme 9).
Previously, acyclic α-aminophosphonates such as diethyl(2-(octadecylamino)propan-2-yl)phosphonate a and diethyl((octadecylamino) (phenyl)methyl)phosphonate b were successfully used as an efficient and selective carrier to transport some diacids and α-hydroxy acids through a certain liquid-impregnated membrane (Scheme 10).58
Scheme 10 Two acyclic α-amino phosphonates a and b as transmembrane carriers for hydroxycarboxylic acids. |
But in this work, the use of p-tert-butylcalix[4]arene as a platform with three-dimensional structure could modify the selectivity through preorganization of binding sites.
The transport ability of compounds 4a and 5a for studied hydroxycarboxylic acids was considerably different from acyclic α-aminophosphonates a and b (Fig. 4). This implies the higher degree of preorganization of functional substituents and the importance of structural and geometric correlations between the binding sites and substrates.59
In another study, novel lower rim α-hydrazinotetrazolocalix[4]arene derivatives were achieved by Ugi-azide-4-component reaction of calixarene dihydrazide 6 with an aliphatic ketone compound, cyclohexyl or tert-butyl isocyanide, and trimethylsilyl azide (Scheme 11). The developed protocol is an operationally simple method to afford the desired products in good yields under mild conditions.
Furthermore, the metal cation binding properties of compound 6a as the model compound were investigated by fluorescence titration with cations as metal perchlorates (Scheme 12).
As shown in Fig. 5, fluorescence quenching study indicated that compound 6a toward Ni2+ had the highest association constant (Ka = 1.70 × 107 M−1) to form a Ni:6a complex. Fluorescent sensors for Ni2+ detection are rare and in most of cases, they have serious interference problems from other heavy and transition metal ions. The compound 6a as a specific fluorescent sensor can form complex with Ni2+ even in the presence of other metal ions such as Li+, Na+, K+, Ba2+, Mn2+, Co2+, Cu2+, Zn2+, and Hg2+ at 1 equivalent (Fig. 6).11
Fig. 5 Fluorescence intensity changes of compound 6a in CH3CN upon addition of 1 equivalent of various metal perchlorates. |
Calix[4]arene diamine 8 was also used by Deng et al. in a simple one-pot 4-CR. This reaction was carried out between one equivalent of compound 8 and two equivalent of an aldehyde, benzil, and ammonium acetate in refluxing acetic acid to construct two imidazole rings, which are directly linked to the upper rim (Scheme 15).62
Two similar upper rim aminocalix[4]arenes 9 and 10 were applied in a 3-component approach by Mirza-Aghayan et al. In order to synthesize three novel acridine-calix[4]arene derivatives 9a, 9b and 10a (Scheme 16). The reaction was conducted in the presence of 6% tungstophosphoric acid hydrate as an efficient heteropolyacid catalyst in boiling ethanol as solvent.
Scheme 16 Acridine-calix[4]arene derivatives synthesis from 3-component reaction of compound 9 (10). |
Acridine derivatives have remarkable ability to reversibly intercalate into the helical structure of DNA, so the interaction of acridine-functionalized calix[4]arene derivatives with calf thymus DNA (CT-DNA) was investigated via fluorescence titration experiments in aqueous solution. The obtained results showed compound 9b has a larger association constant (Kf = 2.18 × 107) than compound 9a (Kf = 3.75 × 106). Furthermore, association constant in compound 10a (Kf = 6.36 × 107) revealed that the increase of the number of acridine moieties could not considerably improve the affinity toward CT-DNA.63
Along the same lines, a highly selective fluorescent chemosensor for NADH was described via a pseudo-five-component reaction of two equivalent of mono-aminocalix[4]arene 9 with 4-nitrobenzaldehyde, Meldrum's acid, and tert-butyl isocyanide in CH2Cl2 (Scheme 17).
This reaction led to formation of a dimeric structure of calix[4]arene. The product showed unique selectivity toward NADH to form a 1:1 stoichiometric complex and was able to detect at least 16.3 μg L−1 NADH over various biomolecules with a binding constant of 3.74 × 105 M−1. Actually, for compound 9c, the variation of the fluorescence intensity during complex formation with NADH in the presence of equal amounts of different biomolecules was almost constant. Additionally, the 31P NMR spectra of NADH was significantly changed after formation of complex with compound 9c which indicated that NADH phosphate groups interact with the amide moieties of the chemosensor through hydrogen bonding (Fig. 7).16
Two new calix[4]arene based receptors 11a and 11b were introduced for saccharide recognition in aqueous solution by Mirza-Aghayan et al. For this purpose, the mono-aldehyde calix[4]arene 11 as a carbonyl compound was used in two different MCRs (Schemes 18 and 19). In the first one, novel 1,4-dihydropyridine-calix[4]arene 11a was achieved through a pseudo 3-CR of compound 11 with two equivalent of methyl 3-aminocrotonate in the presence of TMSCl. The interaction of 1,4-dihydropyridine-calix[4]arene 11a toward some mono-and disaccharides was investigated via fluorescence and 1H NMR titration. The obtained results revealed that compound 11a has a 31-fold greater binding affinity for sorbitol (2.35 × 105 M−1) relative to mannitol (7.50 × 103 M−1), but lone 1,4-dihydropyridine didn't show any selectivity between the two sugar alcohols. In continuation of this study, 2-amino-pyrimidine-calix[4]arene 11b was afforded through a 3-CR between the mono-aldehyde calix[4]arene 11, ethyl cyanoacetate, guanidinium carbonate and catalytic amount of NH2-SBA-15. The product as a saccharide recognizer displayed highest binding affinity toward glucose (3.13 × 105 M−1) and fructose (3.60 × 105 M−1) over the other saccharides.64
Scheme 18 1,4-Dihydropyridine-calix[4]arene synthesis from pseudo 3-component reaction of compound 11. |
Another use of upper-rim aldehyde substituted calix[4]arene was presented by Varma et al. (Scheme 20). In this work, a solution of dialdehyde 12, ethyl acetoacetate, and urea in acetonitrile was heated under reflux in the presence of catalytic amount (10 mol%) phenylboronic acid to afford the corresponding dihydropyrimidine derivative 12a in quantitative yield. One of the special features of this case is direct connection of aromatic nucleus to the stereo centres in two dihydro pyrimidine substituents. In addition, two further upper rim dihydropyrimidine substituted calix[4]arenes 12b and 12c were synthesized through replacement of ethyl acetoacetate by acetyl acetone and urea by thiourea. Although these three calix[4]arene derivatives showed no significant binding affinity toward investigated cations and anions, the study of the aggregation behaviour by 1H NMR spectroscopy in CDCl3 revealed compound 12a tends to aggregate due to its intermolecular hydrogen bonds in solution.51
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2019 |