João R.
Vale
ab,
Arto
Valkonen
c,
Carlos A. M.
Afonso
*b and
Nuno R.
Candeias
*a
aFaculty of Engineering and Natural sciences, Tampere University, Korkeakoulunkatu 8, 33101 Tampere, Finland. E-mail: nuno.rafaelcandeias@tuni.fi
bInstituto de Investigação do Medicamento (iMed.ULisboa), Faculty of Pharmacy, Universidade de Lisboa, Av. Prof. Gama Pinto, 1649-003 Lisboa, Portugal. E-mail: carlosafonso@ff.ulisboa.pt
cDepartment of Chemistry, University of Jyvaskyla, P.O. Box 35, 40014 Jyväskylä, Finland
First published on 12th October 2019
Organosilicon compounds are versatile units with a wide range of uses from medicinal chemistry to the field of organic electronics. An unprecedented method for the synthesis of novel diaryl-substituted silacyclopentenols via blue-light promoted intramolecular [2 + 2] photocycloaddition of acyl silanes is herein disclosed. Additionally, the present findings demonstrate the influence of the olefin substituents in controlling the regioselectivity of the intramolecular Paternò–Büchi reaction, providing silacycles different from previously reported ones. The high degree of functionalization of these compounds makes them attractive precursors to other synthetically challenging silacyclopentanes.
Notwithstanding the role of silicon in drug discovery,2 organosilicon compounds have also gained notoriety in molecular electronics10 and polymer science.11 Conjugated organosilicon materials are particularly promising for the organic electronics and photonics field.12 The insertion of silicon atoms in conjugated organic motifs changes the HOMO and LUMO energy levels, creating a new broad class of important semiconductors. The 5-membered conjugated silacycle silole is a particularly interesting building block in this research area and in the development of silicon-containing polymers.13 Given the natural abundance of silicon and its lack of intrinsic toxicity, processes targeting the synthesis of organosilanes14 and the modification of C–Si bonds are becoming more available.15 Despite the versatility and importance of silacycles, methods for their preparation are somewhat scarce.16 Silacyclobutanes (SCBs) are generally synthetised by the convenient intramolecular silylation of in situ prepared Grignard reagents.16 Due to their high ring strain and Lewis acidity, SCBs are often used as precursors to other organosilicon compounds through ring opening/expansion reactions catalysed by transition metals.16,17 Even though ring expansion of SCBs can also provide silacyclopentanes under specific conditions, the most direct method for their synthesis consists in the addition of metal treated 1,3-butadienes to dichlorosilanes.18,19 The synthesis of silacyclopentenes through palladium-catalysed silylene-1,3-diene [4 + 1] cycloaddition20 allows flexibility on substitution of the cyclopentene core.
Considering the importance of the cyclopentane motif in bioactive compounds,21–26 we reasoned that new methods for the preparation of 5 membered-ring silacycles are needed for several fields of molecular sciences. From a synthetic perspective, achieving the cyclopentene moiety would be preferable due to potentially further functionalization of the double bound, such as asymmetric oxidative transformations.27,28 Silacyclopent-2-enes are especially challenging as the ring is usually constructed from a highly functionalised silane (Scheme 1a),29–31 imposing limitations on the degree of substitution on the cyclic core. Further modifications of silacyclopent-2-enes have also been reported32–35 but additional functionalization of the cyclopentene ring is rare and synthetic flexibility on olefin substitution is often limited. Amongst the aforementioned scaffold, silacyclopent-2-enes bearing an allylic alcohol are of particular interest. Tomooka's group has utilised such compounds in the synthesis of various functionalised silacylclopentanes, some presenting biological activity, via Mitsunobu, Tsuji–Trost, and other transformations.34,35 Additionally, similar silacyclopent-2-en-4-ols have been used in the synthesis of a polyol motif present in several natural products.36
In 2008, Portella et al. reported a photochemical [2 + 2] cycloaddition of acylsilanes (Scheme 1b).37 Upon irradiation, acyl(allyl)silanes undergo intramolecular Paternò–Büchi reaction, producing bicyclic oxetanes in moderate to good yields and providing a new method for the synthesis of SCBs. While new 1-alky-6-oxa-2-silabicyclo[2.2.0]hexanes could be prepared by this way, irradiation of benzoyl(allyl)silane resulted in an intractable reaction mixture. Since the relative stability of the triplet biradical intermediates in the Paternò–Büchi reaction plays an important role in its stereo- and regioselectivity,38,39 we envisioned that substitution on the olefin moiety with a radical stabilising group could tame the reactivity of the intermediates, altering the reaction profile observed by Portella. This could alter the regioselectivity of the cycloaddition, and the subsequent oxetane ring-opening would eventually yield silacyclopentenols (Scheme 1c).
Acylsilanes have attracted immense scientific interest since their first preparation by Brook in 1957.40 Despite the extensive research conducted on these compounds in the past few decades,41–43 novel methodologies that utilize acylsilanes as powerful reagents in organic chemistry are still being reported.44–46 Experimentally, the use of aromatic acylsilanes is particularly attractive as they do not undergo side reactions involving the carbonyl α-carbon.47 Moreover, they show an absorption maximum at around 425 nm, thus allowing photoexcitation using visible blue light. The handling of acylsilanes requires special precautions as they are known to undergo Brook rearrangement to a reactive carbene after photo-irradiation or thermal conditions. This carbene has been shown to undergo insertion reactions in polarised heteroatom-hydrogen bounds,48,49 cycloadditions to aldehydes50 and alkynes,51,52 cross-coupling reaction with organoboronic esters53 and even C–H insertions54–56 under harsher conditions. Carbene formation and its subsequent reactions are then possible competitive destructive pathways to the [2 + 2] photocycloaddition. This influence can be minimised by using dry, aprotic solvents and by protecting free alcohols or amines in the acylsilane starting material.
Scheme 3 [2 + 2] photocycloaddition of cinnamyl silane 3a, acid-catalysed isomerization to 5a, and crystal structure of 3,5-dinitrobenzoylated 6a. |
Compound 4a proved to be unstable to silica column purification and overall acidic conditions, producing alcohol 5a and other products. After optimization, we found that treating 4a with catalytic NaHSO4 in tert-butanol leads to complete and selective isomerization to 5a, in 82% overall yield. Its structure was proven through esterification with 3,5-dinitrobenzoylchloride to yield 6a and following single crystal X-ray diffraction analysis of the obtained ester.
Realising the potential of the photocycloaddition–isomerization sequence as a direct and selective way to obtain 2,3-arylsubstituted silacyclopent-2-en-4-ols, we synthesised a series of acylsilanes 3 to be submitted to the same transformation (Scheme 2). Sila-hemiaminals 2 were obtained in very good yields, containing a wide range of functional groups in the aryl moiety. Nitro-substituted aromatics however failed to add to the silylchloride reagent, presumably due to the low nucleophilicity of the lithiated intermediate. Issues related with the instability of the lithiated anion of 1 bearing electron-rich groups in Ar1 were overcome by tBuLi addition to a stirring solution of 1 and silyl chloride. The syntheses proceeded with cross-metathesis of intermediates 2 with styrenes. Low to moderate yields were obtained in some cases due to incomplete conversion of 2, as the dimerization of styrene to stilbene was a fast competitive reaction. 2-Pyrididyl, 4-cyano- and 4-dimethylamine-benzene resulted in complete deactivation of the catalyst, as no reactions were observed after several days at reflux. The detrimental effect of nitrogen bases and N-heterocycles in metathesis reaction is known and still a problematic issue in this field.59
Despite the synthetic challenges, a series of seventeen aryl-substituted acylsilanes 3 were obtained and tested in the intramolecular [2 + 2] photocycloaddition reaction (Scheme 4). The reaction scope appears to be quite vast, withstanding electron withdrawing and electron donating substituents, as well as ortho, meta and para substitution. Gratifyingly, both variations at 3- and 2-positions of the 2,3-diaryl-silacyclopent-2-ene-4-ol could be performed. The reaction tolerates the presence of substituents prone for further derivatization such as acetyl (5e), nitrile (5g), aldehyde (5h) and silyl ether (5n). Formation of sulfur heterocycle derivative 5o contrasts with its oxygen homologue 5p, for which only traces could be observed. Also ortho-methyl substitution on the ketone side (Ar1) led to the recovery of starting material even after 8 hours of irradiation.
Scheme 4 Scope of the [2 + 2] photocycloaddition of benzoylsilanes 3. aPPTS (10%) was used instead of NaHSO4. bNo acid treatment was needed. |
In order to better understand the dramatic change in regioselectivity of the [2 + 2] photocycloaddition of 3a compared to its terminal olefin analogues, DFT calculations were performed and the energies of the possible biradical intermediates compared (see ESI† for details). The Paternò–Büchi photocycloaddition typically occurs through reaction of a carbonyl compound in the excited state with an alkene in the ground state. Time dependent DFT studies on 3a and 7 show that the first vertical transition corresponds to populating the singlet excited state with comparable energies for both molecules (ca. 64 kcal mol−1, Scheme 5a), through a carbonyl n → π* transition between HOMO−1 and LUMO, as can be observed in the case of 3a (Scheme 5b). As triplet excited states for both molecules are generally ca. 11 kcal mol−1 more stable than their singlet counterparts, they likely undergo intersystem spin crossing. Analysis of the molecular orbitals of 3aT1 verifies that LSOMO and HSOMO correspond to the half-occupied n and π* carbonyl orbitals, respectively (Scheme 5c).
The two paths concerning the attack of the carbonyl oxygen of the triplet excited state to the olefin moiety of the allylsilane were considered‡ (Scheme 6). Comparing the formation of the two biradical species upon either exo and endo attacks of the oxygen to the cinnamyl moiety, a preference would be expected towards the former path due to stabilization of the radicals by the aromatic ring in 3a:br5. The less than 1 kcal mol−1 difference in the stabilities of the biradicals derived from 7 nevertheless suggests two competing mechanisms. Since, when starting from aliphatic acyl(allyl)silanes, Portella et al. observed the exclusive formation of the 6-endo-trig cyclization-derived product (Scheme 1b), benzoylsilane 7 was synthesised and irradiated in order to determine the effect of the carbonyl substituent on the reaction outcome.
After irradiation of 7 in hexane for 8 hours, we observed complete and clean conversion to the structural isomers 8 and 9, in 1 to 1.5 ratio, respectively (Scheme 7). Both compounds proved to be unstable to silica column chromatography. Indirect detection of compound 9 was possible after acid treatment with PPTS and isomerization to the isolable allylic alcohol 10 in 41% overall yield, which was further functionalised with 3,5-dinitrobenzoyl chloride to give ester 11 for X-ray diffraction analysis (Scheme 7). Despite the many attempts in isolating compound 8 or its decomposition products, we could only verify its presence through identification of characteristic peaks in 1H and 13C NMR spectra of the reaction mixture, in accordance with previous oxetanes characterization by Portella et al.37 (Scheme 1b).
Experimentally, the lack of regioselectivity for the cycloaddition of compound 7 is in agreement with its DFT predicted reactivity, highlighting the need of a radical stabilising group connected to the olefin in order to promote complete regioselectivity towards the 5-exo-trig pathway.
In order to demonstrate the versatility of these unprecedented 2,3-disubstituted silacyclopentenols as precursors to other silacyclopentanes, compound 5a was subjected to known transformations (Scheme 8). Diastereoselective epoxidation with m-CPBA quantitatively delivered 12a, a candidate precursor to a series of polyols. Ethanolysis of a transient carbocation formed after acid treatment of 5a yielded ether 13a. In addition, olefin reduction with 1 atm of hydrogen in the presence of catalytic palladium on carbon quantitatively yields the silacyclopentanol 14a as mixture of two diastereoisomers (syn/anti = 1.4:1). Finally, inspired by the structural similarity of selective COX-2 enzyme inhibitors60 derived from cyclopentane, the removal of the hydroxyl functionality of 5a was attempted. Gratefully, use of Yamamoto's HSiEt3/catalytic B(C6F5)3 system61 allowed deoxygenation to 15a in reasonable yield. The use of such compounds as bioisosteres of cyclopentanes could pave the way in the adoption of the new intramolecular [2 + 2] photocycloaddition in the silicon/carbon switch strategy. Oxidation of allylic alcohol 5a was accomplished using excess MnO2 in cold DCM, giving ketone 16a quantitatively. Low temperatures are vital as 16a proved to easily isomerize to the silyl enol ether 17a under thermal conditions.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experimental protocols and NMR, computational and X-ray diffraction data. CCDC 1935510 and 1935511. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: 10.1039/c9qo01028a |
‡ The possible intermediates involved in the paths derived from the attack of the carbonyl carbon to the olefin moiety were also considered, although leading to biradicals considerably higher in energy (see ESI†). |
This journal is © the Partner Organisations 2019 |