Levente I.
Szekeres
a,
Sára
Bálint
a,
Gábor
Galbács
a,
Ildikó
Kálomista
a,
Tamás
Kiss
a,
Flemming H.
Larsen
b,
Lars
Hemmingsen
c and
Attila
Jancsó
*a
aDepartment of Inorganic and Analytical Chemistry, University of Szeged, Dóm tér 7, Szeged, H-6720, Hungary. E-mail: jancso@chem.u-szeged.hu
bDepartment of Food Science, University of Copenhagen, Rolighedsvej 30, 1958 Frederiksberg C, Denmark
cDepartment of Chemistry, University of Copenhagen, Universitetsparken 5, 2100 Copenhagen, Denmark
First published on 2nd May 2019
Hg2+ and Cd2+ complexation of a short hexapeptide, Ac-DCSSCY-NH2 (DY), was studied by pH-potentiometry, UV and NMR spectroscopy and fluorimetry in aqueous solutions and the Hg2+-binding ability of the ligand was also described in an immobilized form, where the peptides were anchored to a hydrophilic resin. Hg2+ was demonstrated to form a 1:
1 complex with the ligand even at pH = 2.0 while Cd2+ coordination by the peptide takes place only above pH ∼ 3.5. Both metal ions form bis-ligand complexes by the coordination of four Cys-thiolates at ligand excess above pH ∼ 5.5 (Cd2+) and 7.0 (Hg2+). Fluorescence studies demonstrated a Hg2+ induced concentration-dependent quenching of the Tyr fluorescence until a 1
:
1 Hg2+
:
DY ratio. The fluorescence emission intensity decreases linearly with the increasing Hg2+ concentration in a range of over two orders of magnitude. The fact that this occurs even in the presence of 1.0 eq. of Cd2+ per ligand reflects a complete displacement of the latter metal ion by Hg2+ from its peptide-bound form. The immobilized peptide was also shown to bind Hg2+ very efficiently even from samples at pH = 2.0. However, the existence of lower affinity binding sites was also demonstrated by binding of more than 1.0 eq. of Hg2+ per immobilized DY molecule under Hg2+-excess conditions. Experiments performed with a mixture of four metal ions, Hg2+, Cd2+, Zn2+ and Ni2+, indicate that this molecular probe may potentially be used in Hg2+-sensing systems under acidic conditions for the measurement of μM range concentrations.
Hg2+ can form extremely stable complexes with linear, {HgS2} type coordination mode with thiol ligands, e.g. Cys (logβ2 = 39.4–43.6),19–21 BAL (log
β1 = 44.8),22etc. The formation of this binding mode was observed during the interaction of Hg2+ with many CXXC-type proteins, such as MerP,16 NMerA,23 and Atx1,24 and with cyclic25,26 or linear27,28 metalloprotein model peptides, etc. The presence of amino acids with high rigidity and/or helical penalty (e.g. Pro and Gly) in the positions of X1 and X2 increases the Hg2+ binding efficiency by preorganising the peptide structure. Moreover, the Hg2+ complex of the rigid CDPPC peptide displays an exceptionally high stability constant (log
β = 40.0) even compared to the effective CPPC sequence.29 There are also examples for the formation of bis complexes with a {HgS4} binding mode among proteins bearing a CXXC motif (HAH1,24 rubredoxins,30etc.).
In its complexes, Cd2+, similar to Zn2+, prefers to possess a tetrahedral coordination sphere with two or four thiolate moieties but Cd2+ has a higher thiophilic character. When the coordination sphere of Cd2+ is not saturated by thiolate groups, the complexes are stabilized mostly by complementary binding of other functional groups. Interactions with the carboxylate groups of Glu and Asp units probably play a role in the selectivity of CadA and ZntA.31 Besides monomeric bis complexes with a pure {CdS4} coordination mode, the presence of dimeric species with a mixed Cys-Glu ({CdS3O}) coordination was also observed in a system of Cd2+ and a 71 amino acid long polypeptide, derived from CadA, at pH = 6.0.31
CXXC moieties are potentially applicable as metal ion binding units in Hg2+ and Cd2+ sensing systems, since their interaction is typically characterized by a well-defined stoichiometry, high efficiency and selectivity. Since these metal ions can accumulate in the food chain and therefore ingested by humans, they pose significant health risks, and therefore their fast, selective sensing and remediation are highly prioritised.8 Sensing schemes for these metal ions, based on fluorimetry,32 potentiometry,33–35 impedance measurement,36 protein-functionalized microcantilevers,37 or differential surface plasmon resonance38etc., have already been proposed. Peptide ionophores can be designed with an ability for signalling by introducing fluorescing residues or amino acids bearing fluorescing side chains into their sequence.39–41 Metal ion binding to peptidic probes mostly induces fluorescence quenching, especially with Cu2+ (ref. 42–53) and Hg2+.42,48,54 However, chelation can also enhance the fluorescence (CHEF) via electronic interactions between the fluorophore and the altered coordination sphere. This is very frequent with Zn2+ (ref. 43, 46–49, 51 and 53) and Cd2+ (ref. 43 and 46–49) but examples are also known with Ag+,42,46–48 Pb2+ (ref. 46 and 47) and Hg2+.48 In addition, the metal ion promoted conformational change of the peptide may lead to a “close contact” and thus to a Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) effect between different fluorophore residues.46,50,52,54–56 Aggregation induced emission (AIE) enhancement can also be utilized for the analysis of metal ions.57,58 The response mechanism and the sensitivity and selectivity of a peptide sensor designed for a specific metal ion is highly influenced by the quality and quantity of the binding groups, as well as the fluorophores themselves, in addition to the amino acid sequence and the higher order peptide structure. Although many fluorescent peptides have already been tested as potential sensor candidates for Hg2+, Cd2+ or other metal ions, examples where the studied ionophore bears a CXXC motif are rather scarce. In the unique case of the short dansyl-CPGCW-NH2 peptide, the intervening amino acids between the two Cys residues provide high backbone rigidity for the ionophore. Upon excitation of either of the two fluorophore units, Cd2+ ions induced a significant enhancement in the light emission of the dansyl group. Rather interestingly, Hg2+ and Zn2+ were shown to have no effect on the fluorescence response of the molecule.56 Another notable, previously studied dicysteinyl peptidic probe possesses a CXXHC binding motif combined with dansyl and Trp fluorophores. This probe displayed a ratiometric turn on response for Hg2+, Cd2+, Pb2+, Zn2+, and Ag+ ions upon the excitation of either of the two fluorophore units.46 In addition, Joshi and co-workers also observed a turn-on response for Zn2+ with two fluorescent peptides containing a Cys and a His residue in a 1,4-arrangement.47,49
Optochemical sensors, constructed by the covalent attachment of fluorescent peptides to the surface of solid carriers (e.g. optical fibers), may allow in situ trace analysis of toxic metal ions with low sample quantity requirements. Such systems may present simple alternatives to currently used reliable, but expensive and robust laboratory-based instrumental methods. Despite the fact that several studies have already reported the successful design of such sensors,32,59–61 there have only been very few attempts to characterize the metal capturing peptide elements both in their dissolved and immobilized forms.47,49
With an aim of exploiting the metal ion binding properties of the CXXC motif, we designed and synthesized the short, DCSSCY hexapeptide in an acetylated and amidated free form (Ac-DCSSCY-NH2 (DY)) and in an immobilized, resin-attached form (DY-NTG). Compared to other aromatic amino acids, Tyr is less hydrophobic and still exhibits a reasonable quantum yield (0.14).62 The fluorescence of Tyr has proved to be applicable in determining the Cu2+ complex stabilities of different peptides,63–65 in spite of the relatively close excitation (λEX = 275 nm) and emission (λEM = 304 nm) maxima of the fluorophore.62 Accordingly, this simple ligand and the obtained data may be relevant in the design of peptide-based metal ion sensing systems.
UV/pH titrations were conducted in the presence of 0.5 and 1.0 equivalents of Hg2+ ions within the range of pH ∼ 1.8–11.0 (Fig. S2†) and representative absorbance traces from selected wavelength values are depicted in Fig. 1A. The significantly larger absorbances observed at pH = 1.8 at λ ∼ 210–230 nm in the presence of Hg2+ relative to the metal ion free sample originate from S−–Hg2+ charge transfer bands and clearly indicate peptide binding to the metal ion, as was also observed previously for other systems of Hg2+ and cysteine containing peptides under acidic conditions.29,69–71 Furthermore, the absorbance increase, induced by Hg2+-binding, seems to be proportional to the applied Hg2+:
DY ratio (Fig. 1A and S2B†) between pH ∼ 1.8–7.0. At the same time, absorbances in the higher wavelength regime, i.e. around 295 nm, are almost identical independent of the Hg2+ concentration. These findings suggest an unvarying speciation up to neutral pH at any Hg2+
:
DY ratio (and even up to pH 11.0 at one equivalent of Hg2+ per peptide) and the high energy charge transfer band, characterized by an absorption maximum below 220 nm (see the calculated difference spectra in Fig. S3†), indicates a {HgS2} type coordination mode in the complexes formed.26,29,69,70,72,73
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Absorbances at selected wavelength values as a function of pH, recorded for Hg2+![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
A remarkable difference between the speciation in Hg2+:
DY 0.5
:
1 and 1
:
1 above pH ∼ 7.5 is reflected by the A vs. pH profiles at 295 nm. The absorbances observed for Hg2+
:
DY 1
:
1 up to pH = 11.0 are nearly identical to those obtained for the free ligand suggesting that the bound Hg2+ has only a minor influence, if any, on the deprotonation of the Tyr sidechain group. The remarkably different A295 nmvs. pH trace of Hg2+
:
DY 0.5
:
1 (Fig. 1A) suggests a fundamental rearrangement in the coordination sphere of Hg2+ above neutral pH, most probably induced by the coordination of a second ligand and the formation of additional S−–Hg2+ bonds. LMCT bands with maxima around 240–250 nm or 280–300 nm in the UV spectra of Hg2+–thiolate complexes were previously assigned to signatures of trigonal {HgS3}74,75 or (pseudo)tetrahedral {HgS4} species, respectively,30,75,76 and this suggests that the two DY ligands bind Hg2+ with both of their thiolates under basic conditions (see Fig. S3†). The slight bathochromic shift of the absorption maximum, observed above pH ∼ 9.5 (Fig. S2A†), is presumably the effect of the deprotonation of the Tyr residues of the bound ligands taking place without metal ion assistance. This interpretation is further supported by the fact that isosbestic points are observed above pH 10 at λ ∼ 264 nm and ∼282 nm (Fig. S2A†), indicating a simple transition between two species.
The pH-dependent series of UV spectra recorded for Cd2+:
DY 0.5
:
1 and 1
:
1 (Fig. 1B and S4†) indicate metal ion coordination via the formation of thiolate–Cd2+ bonds from pH ∼ 4.5. The A240 nmvs. pH profiles, representing the evolution of S−–Cd2+ charge transfer bands,77–83 suggest that metal ion binding is essentially complete by pH ∼ 6 at 1 eq. of Cd2+ per ligand; however, the curve for Cd2+
:
DY 0.5
:
1 is characterized by a narrow plateau near pH 6 and a second step levelling off above pH ∼ 7.5 (Fig. 1B). This indicates a different complexation pathway when the peptide is in excess over Cd2+. One may presume the formation of bis-ligand species, as was also reported for the Cd2+ binding of other short, two Cys-containing peptides.79–81,84 This is also supported by the systematically higher absorbances observed for Cd2+
:
DY 0.5
:
1 relative to those observed both for Cd2+
:
DY 1
:
1 and for the free ligand (Fig. 1B). Indeed, the molar extinction coefficients for λ = 240 nm that one may estimate for the species present at pH ∼ 8.0 at 0.5 and 1 eq. of Cd2+ per ligand (25
100 M−1 cm−1 and 11
700 M−1 cm−1) correspond well to four and two thiolate coordinated Cd2+-centres, respectively.77,78 The further increase of absorbance above pH 8 (at any Cd2+
:
DY ratio) is most likely the consequence of the deprotonation of the Tyr sidechain phenols; nevertheless, other processes that may affect the coordination sphere of the metal ion, e.g. proton release(s) from Cd2+-coordinated water molecules, may also contribute to the observed spectral changes under alkaline conditions.
The deprotonation processes of the carboxyl group of the Asp residue, the two Cys-thiols and the sidechain phenolic function of Tyr in the free DY ligand can be clearly followed by the gradual shifting of the corresponding CβH2 resonances or the CδH and CεH signals of Tyr towards lower chemical shifts in the relevant pH-ranges (Fig. S6†). The presence of Hg2+ has only minor effects on the shape and chemical shift of these resonances (with the exception of the slightly more influenced CβH2 signals of Asp – see later), suggesting that Hg2+ does not bind to these moieties. As opposed to this, below neutral pH Hg2+ binding of the two thiolates is represented by the collapse of the Cys CβH2 signals of the unbound ligand and the emerging new resonances attributed to the bound molecule (see the effect of the increasing Hg2+:
DY ratio at pH = 5.7, Fig. 2A). This indicates that the ligand exchange dynamics is moderately slow at this pH, relative to the NMR timescale.
The pH-dependence of resonances observed with 0.5 eq. of Hg2+ per peptide agrees excellently with the UV data and with the formation of a bis-ligand complex with a {HgS4} coordination geometry. The fact that the chemical shifts of the Cys protons lie in between those of the free peptide and the resonances of the mono-complex (see the broad peaks around 2.9 and 3.2 ppm in the middle spectrum in Fig. 2B) may simply reflect that Hg2+ quite efficiently attracts electrons in the {HgS2} type species, but that this effect (per cysteine) is less pronounced in the {HgS4} structure. Consequently, the deshielding effect on the Cys protons caused by Hg2+ coordination is weaker for {HgS4} than for {HgS2} structures. It is also interesting to note that the signals of the Cys CβH2 protons are hardly observable around neutral pH at a 0.5:
1 Hg2+
:
DY ratio (Fig. S7A†), possibly as a consequence of severe line broadening. This might imply that the increase of pH and approaching the range where the thiol groups of the unbound ligands deprotonate have an influence on the ligand exchange rate and that ligand exchange dynamics also affects the observed Cys CβH2 resonances.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Distribution of species in the Hg2+![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Species | log![]() |
pKa |
---|---|---|
a pKaCdxHyLz = log![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
||
[HL]3− | 10.05(1) | 10.05 |
[H2L]2− | 19.29(1) | 9.24 |
[H3L]− | 27.56(2) | 8.27 |
[H4L] | 31.36(2) | 3.80 |
pKaCdxHyLz![]() |
||
[CdHL]− | 22.61(4) | 9.83 |
[CdL]2− | 12.78(8) | 11.48 |
[CdH–1L]3− | 1.3(2) | — |
[CdH3L2]3− | 47.6(2) | 6.7 |
[CdH2L2]4− | 40.9(1) | 9.9 |
[CdHL2]5− | 31.0(2) | 10.6 |
[CdL2]6− | 20.4(1) | — |
[Cd2HL]+ | 25.4(2) | — |
log![]() ![]() |
12.56 | |
log![]() ![]() |
8.21 | |
log(K1+H/K2+2H) | 4.35 | |
NP.d | 279 | |
FPe (cm3) | 0.004 |
Evaluation of pH-potentiometric data obtained for Cd2+:
DY reveals that Cd2+-binding occurs above pH ∼ 3.5 and the first dominant species, formed in parallel with a small amount of a dinuclear species, is a mono-protonated mono-complex independent of the metal ion to ligand ratio (Fig. 4).
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Distribution of species in the Cd2+![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
The composition ‘[CdHL]−’ corresponds well to the coordination of both thiolates to Cd2+ and to a protonated Tyr phenol group in this species. Obviously, the Asp carboxyl function is deprotonated in [CdHL]−; however, since the formation of this complex spans the pH-range where the Asp sidechain of the free ligand also deprotonates, pH-metric data are not conclusive with regard to the Cd2+-binding of this group. Previous studies on short oligopeptides containing both Cys and Asp residues reflected, however, that participation of the available carboxylate groups in Cd2+-binding is possible,80,81,83 even if two thiolate donors are also coordinated.80,81 Binding of the Asp sidechain of DY to Cd2+ is supported by the stability constant calculated for the Cd2+ + [HL]3− = [CdHL]− process (logK1+H = 12.56). This value is nearly identical to the stability that may be calculated for the relevant, {CdS2O2} type complex of a short phytochelatin peptide ((γ-Glu-Cys)2-Gly – PC2, log
K1+H = 12.57)80 and significantly higher than the stability of the protonated mono-complex of ACSSACS-NH2 with only two coordinating thiolate groups (log
K1+H = 10.22).84 The remarkable extra stability observed for the mono-complex of DY is presumably only partly related to the additional binding of the Asp carboxylate group, and may also be a consequence of the more favoured CXXC amino acid pattern vs. the CXXXC sequence in the ACSSACS-NH2 heptapeptide.
Furthermore, the additional coordination of one of the internal peptide carbonyl groups, as suggested for PC2, is also possible in the [CdHL]− complex of DY resulting in a {S−,S−,COO−,CO} donor group environment around the metal ion. The pKa value determined for the [CdHL]− = [CdL]2− + H+ process (pKa = 9.83) is very close to the pKa of the Tyr residue in the free ligand indicating that the sidechain phenolate is not bound to Cd2+, similar to what was concluded for the Hg2+ complexes of DY (suggested schematic structures for the Cd2+:
DY complexes are shown in Scheme S2†). Calculation of the apparent dissociation constant for the Cd2+
:
DY mono-complexes at pH = 7.0, according to the equation Kd = ([Cd2+]free × [Ligand]free)/[Cd2+]complexed, may allow the comparison of the Cd2+-binding affinity of DY to other relevant cysteine containing peptides or proteins. The calculated Kd = 9.1 × 10−10 M value indicates a slightly larger Cd2+-binding affinity of DY compared to that of the PC2 phytochelatin peptide (Kd = 1.7 × 10−9 M)80 but a substantially stronger Cd2+-binding relative to the reduced glutathione (Kd = 1.4 × 10−5 M).86 However, the average dissociation constants determined for the α and β domains of MT-2 metallothioneins (Kd = 1.0 × 10−15 M (α) and 0.1–1.0 × 10−12 M (β))87 clearly reflect a more efficient Cd2+-coordination by these proteins, provided by the thiolate-clusters.
At twofold DY excess over Cd2+ the bis-ligand complexes start to form from ca. pH 5 and become fully dominant by pH ∼ 8 (Fig. 4A), as also suggested by the pH dependent evolution of the S−–Cd2+ charge transfer band and the calculated molar extinction coefficient for λ = 240 nm at Cd2+:
DY 0.5
:
1, vide supra. The two proton release processes, leading from the four-thiolate coordinated [CdH2L2]4− complex to [CdHL2]5− and then to [CdL2]6−, are assigned to dissociation processes of the non-coordinating Tyr phenol sidechains (see Table 1). The stability constant calculated for the protonated bis complex ([CdHL]− + [HL]3− = [CdH2L2]4−, log
K2CdH2L2 = 8.21) and the relative stability of the protonated mono- and bis-ligand species (log(K1+H/K2+2H) = 4.35) indicate that binding of the second ligand is substantially less favoured than that of the first one. Very similar data have been reported for the bis complex formation of the phytochelatin pentapeptide PC2 (log(K1+H/K2+2H) = 4.39)80 leading to a four thiolate coordinated species. The relative positions of the two Cys residues in DY and PC2 are different (CXXC and CXC) just as the overall charges of their relevant mono- and bis complexes (DY: −1/−4, PC2: −2/−6); nevertheless, the two peptides are of similar sizes. This suggests that the relative binding strength of the second DY or PC2 ligand is determined by similar factors, i.e. the notably high stability of their mono-complex and steric hindrance (bulkiness of the peptides) but the log(K1+H/K2+2H) values are probably not large enough to assume a major change in the coordination geometry of Cd2+.
For the experiments in the Hg2+:
DY system pH = 6.0 was chosen to apply a close-to-neutral condition while avoiding the appearance of bis complexes and thus maintaining a relatively simple speciation that should be desirable for a molecular probe. In view of the outstanding affinity of DY towards Hg2+ that, in contrast to Cd2+, results in a complete binding of this metal ion even at rather low pH values, we recorded Hg2+
:
DY ratio dependent emission spectra at pH = 2.0, as well.
As Fig. 5 clearly shows, the increase of the concentration of Hg2+ leads to a significant drop of emission intensities, following a linear trend until reaching a 1:
1 Hg2+
:
DY ratio both at pH = 6.0 and 2.0. This correlates well with the calculated complex speciation (Fig. 3) and indicates a strong and complete binding of 1 eq. Hg2+ per DY. However, it also suggests that the ligand cannot capture a second Hg2+ ion in solution, which is also a desirable property for a Hg2+ sensor. Although different species dominate at the two selected pH values (HgH2L at pH = 2.0 and [HgHL]− at pH = 6.0), the observed trends in the decreasing fluorescence emission intensities are nearly identical in the two cases. This suggests that the protonation state of the uncoordinated Asp carboxyl group has no impact on the Hg2+-induced quenching of the Tyr fluorescence.
Different possibilities may be considered for the mechanism of the metal ion induced quenching of the fluorescence of DY, as suggested by Chen's in-depth overview of the interaction of Hg2+ with proteins containing aromatic amino acids.88 Indeed, Hg2+ was shown to quench the fluorescence of the vast majority of tested proteins, especially of those that contained Cys residues near the aromatic amino acids.88 Although direct interactions of both of the studied metal ions with the Tyr residue of DY have been excluded in our systems, an overlap between the thiolate-related absorption bands and the Tyr emission might cause quenching via energy transfer. Besides, metal ion promoted conformational changes in the peptide structure may also play a role in the altered fluorescence.
We also tested the Hg2+-induced quenching of the fluorescence of DY in the presence of 1.0 eq. of Cd2+. Since the latter metal ion is not bound to the peptide at pH = 2.0 (Fig. 4) it has no influence on the emission intensities at any Hg2+:
DY ratio. Nevertheless, 1.0 eq. Cd2+ per DY at pH = 6.0 induces a notable fluorescence quenching, as compared to the Cd2+-free sample, reflecting that Cd2+–DY complexes are present at the start of the titration. When this sample is titrated with Hg2+ the observed fluorescence is gradually quenched down to the same level as seen in the absence of Cd2+, suggesting that the DY-bound Cd2+ is completely displaced by Hg2+.
In view of the potential analytical applicability of such a molecular probe the most promising findings of the above experiments are the significant fluorescence response of the ligand, proportional to the Hg2+-concentration up to a 1:
1 Hg2+
:
DY ratio, as well as the remarkable metal ion binding selectivity that is also manifested in the Hg2+-mediated changes in emission intensities. In this context, the data series recorded at pH 2 (Fig. 5) demonstrates selective binding of Hg2+ at low pH, which may be used to eliminate interferences from other metal ions, such as Cd2+, in a fluorophore based Hg2+ assay. A quick assessment of the potential analytical figures of merit for Hg2+ sensing under our measurement conditions yields an estimated limit of detection of ca. 2 × 10−7 M and a linear dynamic range exceeding 2 orders of magnitude.
Since metal ion complexation processes could be slower at the resin bead-supported binding sites as compared to the solution phase, first we determined the contact time necessary for a complete equilibration in the reaction of Hg2+ and DY-NTG. Samples were prepared at pH = 2.0 by adding Hg2+ ions in concentrations corresponding to 1.5, 2.0 and 3.0 eq. of Hg2+ relative to the theoretical loading of the resin, i.e. to the available immobilized peptide chains (0.227 mmol g−1; see the sample preparation protocol in the Methods section). The excess of metal ions ensured that the concentration of Hg2+ could be conveniently and accurately measured by ICP-MS after the termination of the reaction. The studied samples were shaken for 30, 45, 60, 120, 180 and 300 minutes. Three additional samples, prepared with 0.33, 0.66 and 1.0 eq. of Hg2+ per peptide, were also tested by using 60 and 120 min contact times. Analysis of the remaining Hg2+ concentrations in all these samples showed that up to 1.0 eq. of Hg2+ per ligand the concentration of the metal ion was stable after 60 min (or even less, as suggested by other preliminary tests); however, a 120 min equilibration time seemed to be necessary for samples containing metal ion excess. Accordingly, a contact time of 120 min was used for all further experiments, including those performed with the reference compound, Ac-NTG.
The effect of pH on the Hg2+ binding ability of DY-NTG was monitored between pH = 1.0 and 6.0 by preparing samples of ∼1.0 eq. Hg2+ per DY ligand. In good correlation with the complex speciation determined for the Hg2+:
DY system in solution (Fig. 3), no variation in the bound metal ion quantity was observed. Consequently, the immobilized peptide resembles well the Hg2+ binding ability of DY in solution up to a 1
:
1 Hg2+
:
DY ratio, as indicated by the binding of ca. 95% of the added Hg2+ ions to DY-NTG independent of the applied pH (Fig. S11†).
Hg2+ binding to DY-NTG was investigated at pH = 2.0 as a function of the Hg2+ concentration in a range of 0.774–6.49 μmol/10.0 mL sample representing ca. 0.34–2.86 eq. of metal ions per available immobilized peptide (Fig. 6). The bound quantity of Hg2+, calculated from the remaining metal ion concentrations of the samples in contact with DY-NTG, increases linearly up to ca. 1.0 eq. Hg2+ per peptide. At this specific point the bound quantity of Hg2+, as measured by ICP-MS, indicates that nearly 95% (2.07 μmol) of the added Hg2+ ions (2.20 μmole) are bound. As seen in Fig. 6, the bound Hg2+ quantity further increases in parallel with the increasing Hg2+ concentration of the samples and the obtained curve follows a saturation-like trend converging towards what appears to be ∼2.0 eq. bound Hg2+ per peptide. This suggests that other, weaker binding sites also participate in metal ion binding and the quantity of Hg2+ ions, captured at these sites, cannot be explained by the metal ion binding ability of the non-peptidic parts of the resin, considering the value measured for the reference Ac-NTG (0.0354 mmol g−1). In some of the previously published studies on the metal ion binding abilities of cysteine containing peptides,89–91 immobilized to various matrices, the authors also reported about the presence of binding sites with different affinities in their constructs.91 Since solution phase experiments with the DY peptide showed that it was able to bind only one Hg2+ ion per molecule, the coordination of the second metal ion must be attributed to binding positions originating from the immobilization of the ligands. These positions are probably less accessible than the primary binding positions and might require a slow structural change of the solid supported ligands, as suggested by the longer contact times needed for equilibration when metal ion excess is used.
These results demonstrate that DY-NTG efficiently binds Hg2+ even at low pH (pH = 2.0) and the bound quantity linearly increases with the increasing metal ion concentration in samples where the Hg2+ content does not exceed the theoretical Hg2+-binding capacity of the resin.
In order to test whether DY-NTG displays a selectivity in the binding of Hg2+, two types of samples containing the resin and four selected metal ions, Hg2+, Cd2+, Zn2+ and Ni2+, were prepared. Since data for Cd2+:
DY showed that this metal ion cannot be bound by the ligand at pH = 2.0, which most probably also holds for Zn2+ or Ni2+, the metal ion selectivity experiments were performed at pH 6.0 by applying 1.0 or 2.0 equivalents of all the four metal ions, relative to the available immobilized peptide, in both types of samples. The results obtained reveal a dominance of Hg2+ in occupying the available binding sites of DY-NTG, especially at twofold excess of the metal ions relative to the peptide where only Hg2+ is bound by DY-NTG. However, a significant amount of Cd2+ (0.59 μmol), besides 1.96 μmol Hg2+, was also captured from the sample containing 1.0 eq. of all the four metal ions (Fig. 7). These data represent ca. 90% and 24% binding of the added Hg2+ and Cd2+ ions, respectively. Consequently, at pH = 6.0, Cd2+ can successfully occupy presumably mainly some of the lower affinity sites of the resin, even in the presence of 1.0 eq. of Hg2+ per peptide. Since Cd2+ induces a notable quenching of the fluorescence of DY in solution it may potentially act as an interference in the Hg2+-binding of this molecular probe at pH = 6.0 and in samples with sub-stoichiometric M2+
:
peptide ratios. However, Zn2+ and Ni2+ cannot compete with Hg2+ or Cd2+ in binding at the lower affinity sites.
The strong Hg2+-binding affinity of DY in acidic samples (pH = 2.0) is preserved even in the resin-supported form. The immobilized DY displays a nearly complete Hg2+-binding ability up to 1.0 eq. of Hg2+ per immobilized peptide is added. However, a further, saturation-type increase in the amount of bound Hg2+ is observed from samples containing Hg2+ ions in excess (from 1.0 to 3.0 eq. per ligand), suggesting a role of lower affinity binding positions in metal ion binding. This is in slight contrast to the Hg2+-coordinating features of the peptide in the solution phase where no signs of dinuclear/oligonuclear Hg2+-complex formation are seen. Indeed, binding of Hg2+ beyond 1.0 eq. per immobilized DY possibly occurs via structures that may exist only under the ligand-rich conditions present in the swollen resin beads and/or by the participation of the PEG chains in metal ion coordination. The presented experimental data, including the remarkable, concentration-dependent quenching effect of Hg2+ on the fluorescence of the ligand and the efficient Hg2+-binding of DY either in a solution or immobilized form show the potential of such simple bio-inspired systems in metal ion sensing. In addition to this, our metal ion selectivity experiments suggest that interference from other metal ions may be avoided by using acidic pH.
In our view, this work presents a fine example for the advantages of a combined study of metal binding molecular probes in solution and immobilized forms as by this method the altering effects of immobilization on the metal ion binding characteristics can also be unravelled, thereby promoting the development of practical metal ion sensing constructs.
Fluorescence emission spectra were recorded on a Hitachi-F4500 spectrofluorimeter in the wavelength range of 285–400 nm applying an excitation wavelength of 278 nm and slit widths of 5 nm (excitation beam) and 10 nm (emission beam), using a 1.0 cm × 1.0 cm quartz cell equipped with a PTFE cap. For samples of Hg2+–DY, the experiments were performed at two pH values (pH = 2.0 and 6.0; T = 298 K) by varying the Hg2+-concentration (c = 0.0–75.0 μM) and, accordingly, the Hg2+ to peptide ratio. The initial concentration of the ligand (cDY = 28.0 μM) varied only as a result of the slight dilution during the titrations. The pH of the samples at pH = 6.0 was monitored during the titrations and corrected, when necessary, by the addition of small volumes of a 0.01 M NaOH solution. There was no need for pH-correction in samples adjusted to pH = 2.0. Experiments were also performed in the presence of Cd2+ ions where a constant 1:
1 concentration ratio of Cd2+ and DY was maintained. Variation of the fluorescence intensity as a function of pH was monitored in samples containing Cd2+ and DY in different concentration ratios (0
:
1, 0.5
:
1 and 1
:
1).
The background-subtracted spectra were corrected for the inner filter effects according to the equation:62
Fcorr = Fobs × 10(Aex+Aem)/2 |
pM + qH + rL ⇌ MpHqLr |
The applied concentrations of the metal ions were calculated on the basis of the theoretical peptide loading of the resins and the increase of resin mass during the synthesis, according to
All of the presented data are the results of duplicate experiments except that of the Hg2+ binding capacity of Ac-NTG obtained from five repetitions.
Determination of metal ion concentrations in the solutions was accomplished on an Agilent 7700x inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometer (ICP-MS). The instrument was used in the helium mode of the OSR3 collisional cell. Calibrating solutions were prepared from a certified monoelemental Hg stock standard solution (CaPurAn M324.5NP.L1) and trace quality deionized lab-water (Millipore Elix Advantage 5 + Synergy) to perform a multi-point calibration. The mass peaks of 201Hg and 111Cd isotopes were utilized for quantification with 209Bi and 103Rh signals, respectively, as internal standards (using the Agilent no. 5188-6525 internal standard mix). Prior to all measurements, the autotuning of the ICP-MS instrument was performed according to the manufacturer's specifications, using standard solutions supplied by Agilent. All labware was cleaned before use with ultratrace grade nitric acid and hydrochloric acid (BDH Aristar Ultra), thoroughly rinsed with the above trace quality deionized lab-water and finally dried under a laminar flow clean bench.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c9dt01141b |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2019 |