Open Access Article
Wenxiang Wanga,
Mifa Chena,
Yuzhong Niu
a,
Qian Taoa,
Liangjiu Bai
*a,
Hou Chen
*a and
Zhenping Chengb
aSchool of Chemistry and Materials Science, Ludong University, Yantai 264025, China. E-mail: bailiangjiu@163.com; ldupolymchen@163.com
bJiangsu Key Laboratory of Advanced Functional Polymer Design and Application, College of Chemistry, Chemical Engineering and Materials Science, Soochow University, Suzhou, 215123, China
First published on 9th October 2017
As promising intelligent materials, self-healing materials have the capability of healing or repairing inflicted damage. Simply, inexpensive and commercial synthetic process is one of the hard issues. By using a facile one-pot two-step methodology, polyacrylonitrile-r-poly(butyl acrylate) (PAN-r-PnBA) was successfully prepared and modified to Fe3+/tetrazole-based metallopolymers (MPs) with significant self-healing properties. FeCl3·6H2O was used as a catalyst to modify cyano groups with sodium azide (NaN3) and generate tetrazole group for coordinating with FeCl3·6H2O itself. The results indicated that the prepared MPs without any stimulus, can rapidly and autonomously heal inflicted damageat ambient temperature. These self-healing materials which were rapidly prepared with commercial and inexpensive substrates could facilitate the potential for application in a wide range.
Metallopolymers (MPs) or metal–ligand (M–L) complexes23,24 can be designed as functional materials with high mechanical properties based on a wide range of thermodynamic and kinetic parameters. Some prominent examples of self-healing materials have been reported by using reversible M–L interactions. Furthermore, the MPs prepared by the interaction of M–L have excellent mechanical properties. For example, a series of functional materials, based on the coordination of dopamine24,25 and metal ions, are reported with notable self-healing properties. Harrington M. J. et al. reported26 that self-healing functional materials like mussel byssal threads were developed through the coordination between Fe and catechol ligands. A novel polymer with bidentate triazole pyridine ligands, which cross-linked with Fe2+ or Co2+ salts,27 was developed with notable self-healing performance. As mentioned above, these methods have the advantages of providing a favorable selectivity and design of MPs, but most of the polymers are achieved by designing complex monomer polymerization and difficult synthetic process.
Tetrazoles28,29 which have a five membered ring containing one carbon and four nitrogen atoms are heterocyclic compounds. Polyvinyltetrazoles (PVTs)30–32 and its derivatives have attracted broad attention because of their interesting properties (high thermostability, biological activity and good solubility) and wide applications (polyelectrolytes, distinctive complex, dynamite and biocompatible material). However, the vinyltetrazole33 is not a common monomer for commercial source because of the difficult synthesis. To the best of our knowledge, there have been no reports and research on self-healing materials by using coordination with tetrazoles groups and metal ions from PVTs or its derivatives.
Polyacrylonitrile (PAN)34–36 and its copolymers are commercial polymers for preparing fibers, membranes and so on. By using simple and efficient synthesis, the cyano groups in PAN can react with sodium azide (NaN3) to prepare PVT30–32,37,38 with various molecular weights. Matyjaszewski et al.39 reported well-defined PAN and PAN-co-PSt prepared by atom transfer radical polymerization (ATRP). Then, the prepared polymers were successfully modified by the “cyano-azide” type of click chemistry with NaN3 as a reactant and zinc chloride as a catalyst. After the click chemistry of cyano-azide under microwave radiation, functional PVT-grafted resins11 with high capacity for the adsorption of heavy metal ions were successfully prepared by Wei and coworkers.
Herein, we designed a PAN-r-PnBA random copolymer with the M–L complexes strategically embedded in the soft matrix having low glass transition temperature (Tg). By using a facile one-pot two-step methodology, polyacrylonitrile-r-poly(butyl acrylate) (PAN-r-PnBA) was successfully prepared and modified to MPs with significant self-healing properties. Iron(III) chloride hexahydrate (FeCl3·6H2O) was used as a catalyst to modify cyano groups with sodium azide (NaN3) and generate tetrazole group for coordinating with FeCl3·6H2O itself. The prepared MPs without any stimulus have rapid and autonomous self-healing capability with good mechanical strength under ambient conditions.
N bond of cyano 1a and FeN3Cl2 took place readily to form the intermediate (A); pre-coordination of the nitrogen atom of the CN group of 1a with iron azide to form complex (B) would accelerate this cyclization step (Scheme 2). After washing by methanol, MPs which tetrazole moieties coordinated with ferric ion were simply and easily obtained with the self-healing capability.
The FT-IR spectra for MPs with different amounts of FeCl3·6H2O and NaN3 are shown in Fig. S1.† For PAN-r-PnBA, a typical peak at 2250 cm−1 is the characteristic absorption of cycno (C
N) stretching vibration. A typical peak at 1726 cm−1 attributes to the C
O stretching vibration of the ester groups in the nBA. For MPs, based on modified PAN-r-PnBA (MPAN-r-PnBA), the peak at 2250 cm−1 becomes weak due to that the C
N in PAN is partially modified to tetrazole groups. The broad peak at 3400 cm−1 represents the skeleton stretching vibration absorption peak of the tetrazole ring. In addition, the new peak at 1671 cm−1 attributes to the characteristic absorption of the Cl–Fe stretching vibrations. These results indicate that the chemical modification of MPs is obtained. Energy dispersive spectrometer (EDS) spectrum test of the MPs is also shown in Fig. 1(a). From the results, it can be seen that the metal element Fe is contained in addition to the basic elements C, N, O of the copolymer. The elemental proportions of C, N, O, Cl and Fe are 60.4%, 17.2%, 15.8, 3.6% and 3.0%, respectively, which is consistent with the results of coordination with the tetrazole group. Fig. 1(b) shows the UV-vis spectra of PAN-r-PnBA and MPs. The concentration of absolute absorbance of the three polymers is 2.0 mg mL−1. From 800 nm to 250 nm, the relatively stronger absorption at about 270 nm for M–L complexation than that of PAN-r-PnBA indicates the presence of coordination between Fe3+ and tetrazole ring,22 which are prepared through the reaction of cyano group with NaN3 catalyzed by FeCl3·6H2O. By using differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) in the heating rate 10 °C min−1, the glass transition temperature (Tg) of copolymer and MPs is also measured. From Fig. 1(c), the results show that the Tg of PAN-r-PnBA is about 8.14 °C. Copolymer PAN-r-PnBA exhibits a Tg which is parently lower than that of the homopolymer PAN. This proves that the presence of nBA units in PAN-r-PnBA could dramatically decrease its glass transition temperature. It is also found that MPs, in which the cyano groups of copolymer are partly replaced to tetrazole groups, could dramatically decrease its glass transition temperature. The Tg of MPs with 25
:
1, 50
:
1, 75
:
1 are 2.05 °C, −1.60 °C, −2.34 °C and −8.50 °C, respectively. The increasing Tg from −8.50 °C to 2.05 °C is caused by the increasing amount of Fe3+ and the coordination between the tetrazole groups and metal ions. These results demonstrate that coordination between the tetrazole groups and metal ions can enhance the intermolecular interactions between the polymer chains more drastically, thus significantly affecting the self-healing properties.
In the initial state with the 0.01% strain, it is worth noting that the G′/G′′ is 6986.8 Pa/3139.8 Pa, 10
717.5 Pa/2592.2 Pa, 13
686.9 Pa/2592.2 Pa and 19
354.6 Pa/4154.6 Pa with the molar ratio of [polymer]0/[NaN3]0/[FeCl3·6H2O]0 of 100/1/1, 75/1/1, 50/1/1 and 25/1/1, respectively. It is notable that G′ increases with the increasing molar ratio and is all bigger than G′′ for MPs. The increase of G′ may be caused by the interactions of metal–ligand bonding by 4VT functional group with ferric ion. In addition, it is clear that G′ is larger than G′′, when the strain is in the range of 0.01% to 10% (Fig. S2†) to 45% (Fig. 2(a)), 60% (Fig. 2(b)), 470% (Fig. 2(c)), 80% (Fig. 2(d)), with the increased amount of [NaN3]0 and [FeCl3·6H2O]0, respectively. This results show the prepared MPs materials of 50/1/1 could withstand relatively large deformation damage. Moreover, it indicates that MPs show excellent adhesion behavior, which was the result of the modified cyano group to 4VT group at ambient temperature. However, the value of G′ is less than G′′ with further increasing the strain.
After large strain deformation (γ = 1000%), a 1% of strain is immediately applied for a period of time and it is found that the mechanical property of MPs could fully recover without any loss (Fig. 3(a) and S3†). Repeated dynamic strain step tests are carried out on MPs to investigate the self-healing property, in which γ is alternated with 1% (200 s) and 400% (200 s) for ten cycles. As shown in Fig. 3(b), when a lower strain (γ = 1%) is applied to the 50
:
1 MPs, the value of G′ and G′′ keep constant (G′ is larger than G′′). However, when subjected to a large strain (γ = 400%), G′ drop dramatically within a few seconds and become lower than G′′ in value. After large strain deformation (γ = 400%), a 1% of strain is immediately applied for a period of time and it is found that the mechanical property of MPs can recover to its initial value instantaneously without any loss (Fig. 5(b)). After ten cycles test, the G′ and G′′ can still recover to initial value without significant decrease. This phenomenon indicates that all the fabricated MPs are totally reversible and endowed with outstanding self-healing property.
:
1, 75
:
1 and 50
:
1), is characterized with the same gauge length and stretching speed. The stretch process is shown as Fig. S4.† The mechanical performance of tensile strength can be increased by the increasing percent of the incorporation of PVT and the amounts of Fe3+. For example, By increasing the ratio from 100
:
1, 75
:
1 to 50
:
1, tensile strength is remarkably increased from 1.80 MPa, 2.5 MPa to 3.8 MPa, respectively. In our self-healing experiment, MPs films are typically cut into two pieces and then put together to heal itself about 4 hours. The self-healing efficiency of MPs films, which is closed to the ratio of the original to self-healing tensile strength, are also illustrated in Fig. 4(a). Without any external stimuli, the tensile modulus can reach the original levels after about 4 hours at ambient temperature. The self-healing efficiency of 100
:
1, 75
:
1 and 50
:
1, is about 85.7%, 90.8% and 94.7%, respectively. The results show that different molar ratio of MPs films have excellent self-healing properties. Additionally, by using loading-unloading cyclic tensile tests, the mechanical properties of self-healed MPs are discussed in depth to study the effects of coordination of 4VT and Fe3+. Self-healed MPs are recycled to 10 cyclic tensile tests between the strain 0% and 100%. These MPs are not broken and returned to their original length. For instance, the stress of these MPs is 72.8%, 83.2% and 85.5% of its original values about 10 strain cycles (Fig. 4(b–d)) in the molar ratio of 100
:
1, 75
:
1 and 50
:
1, respectively. It indicates that all of the MPs can reversibly break and reform in the process of loading-unloading cycles. Therefore, the coordination of Fe3+ and tetrazole group deliver remarkable self-healing performance.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Tensile stress–strain curves of self-healing MPs (a), mechanical recovery curves of MPs with the molar ratio of 100 : 1 (b), 75 : 1 (c) and 50 : 1 (d) (AN : Fe3+) under 10 cyclic tensile tests. | ||
In order to clearly demonstrate the self-healing ability of MPs, the healing experiments were carried out by two different colored strips (added with or without malachite green). Fig. 5(a) shows that the two strips have different colors. Afterwards, the two strips were cut from the middle, and the different colored strips were intertwined and healed at ambient temperature for 30 min, as shown in Fig. 5(b). Fig. 5(c) shows that the two color strips have been healed together. The stretched strip was subjected to a tensile test in Fig. 5(d). The results show that MPs exhibits excellent self-healing properties at ambient temperature.
To observe the self-healing process, PAN-r-PnBA and different molar ratio of MPs films are sealed at ambient temperature and observed in metallurgical microscope. Then the films are cutted off with a scalpel and placed on glass substrates. An optical microscope is used to observe the self-healing process of these films. Fig. 6–8 and S5† show the variation of cracks at different times, which show self-healing properties of MPs. In Fig. S5,† for the PAN-r-PnBA copolymer without the coordination between tetrazole group and Fe3+, the crack of PAN-r-PnBA copolymer dose not heal even after 12 hours. After the modification of PAN-r-PnBA, the MPs films show different levels of self-healing property. As shown in Fig. 6, it gives the result that the crack is completely repaired after 4 hours at ambient temperature. The 75
:
1 MPs film can rapidly heal the crack after 1 hour without additional treatment (Fig. 7). Moreover, the self-healing films of 50
:
1 is almost completed the self-healing process within 30 min (Fig. 8) at ambient environment. In addition, the self-healing process of MPs film is taken a video. In the video, the MPs is completely cut off from the middle and healed at room temperature. After two minutes, the MPs can be healed together. All of these results indicates that MPs with highly tetrazole groups have excellent self-healing properties.
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c7ra09621f |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2017 |