K.
Chernichenko
a,
B.
Kótai
b,
M.
Nieger
a,
S.
Heikkinen
a,
I.
Pápai
*b and
T.
Repo
*a
aDepartment of Chemistry, University of Helsinki, P.O. Box 55, FIN-00014, Finland. E-mail: timo.repo@helsinki.fi
bResearch Centre for Natural Sciences, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Magyar tudósok körútja 2, H-1117 Budapest, Budapest, Hungary. E-mail: papai.imre@ttk.mta.hu
First published on 10th January 2017
2-(Dialkylamino)phenylboranes containing the BXZ group, where X, Z = C6F5, Cl, and H, were prepared in a few synthetic steps and demonstrated the cleavage of H2 under mild conditions. Depending on the nature of the dialkylamino group, X, and Z, the stability of the produced zwitterionic H2 adducts varies from isolated solids indefinitely stable in an inert atmosphere to those quickly equilibrating with the initial aminoborane and H2. Using a combined experimental/computational approach on a series of isostructural aminoboranes (dialkylamino = 2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperid-1-yl), it was demonstrated that the electronegativity and the steric effect of the substituents generally follow the trend C6F5 ∼ Cl ≫ H. This observation is useful for designing new FLPs for practical applications. As an example, we demonstrated the hydrogenation of alkynes to cis-alkenes under mild conditions that was catalyzed by a chloro-analogue of the C6F5-substituted aminoborane developed previously. The presence of a BHCl group in the aminochloroboranes or in their H2 adducts features facile redistribution of the H and Cl atoms and the formation of polychloro and polyhydrido species.
Motivated by the development of cost-efficient and light weight FLPs for catalytic applications, we have been studying ansa-aminoboranes (where “ansa” refers to the close vicinity of amino and boryl groups), in which the C6F5 groups of the borane moiety are replaced with elemental substituents X (where X = H, halogens). Recently, we have reported two archetypical C6F5-substituted ortho-aminophenylboranes, 1a and 2a differing in the Lewis basic amino component (Fig. 1).5 The presence of a highly sterically demanding 2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperid-1-yl amino group (TMP) and a sterically accessible dimethylamino (Me2N) group substantially affected the thermodynamics and the reactivity of H2. Whereas 1a produced an extremely thermally stable H2 adduct, 2a reacted with H2 reversibly, showing smooth intramolecular protonation6 and other unexpected behaviour. The replacement of a single C6F5 group with H in 2a provided 2b serving as a catalyst in an unprecedented metal-free selective hydrogenation of alkynes into cis-alkenes. Aminoborane 2b has also been shown to insert readily into sp2-C–H bonds of simple arenes and alkenes.7 On the other hand, the complete replacement of the C6F5 groups in 1a with hydrogens gave aminoborane 1b that activates H2 reversibly8 and efficiently catalyses the C–H borylation of hetarenes with pinacolborane.9 In continuation of our efforts, we report herein new ansa-aminoboranes, the derivatives of 1 and 2, in which the C6F5 groups are partially or completely replaced with Cl or H atoms.10 We studied H2 addition to these aminoboranes following the established dichotomy between ortho-TMP- and ortho-Me2N-phenylboranes such that the former defined general reactivity patterns, whereas the more labile and reactive Me2N compounds were used for catalytic implementations.
According to spectroscopic Lewis acidity scales, inorganic boranes BX3 (X = H or halogen) have similar acidities to B(C6F5)3.11 These data are supported by experimental results on the H2 splitting by FLPs comprising chloroboranes as the Lewis acidic component.12 At the same time, comparative reactivity studies of isostructural FLPs with systematic C6F5 → Cl replacement at the Lewis acidic site and motivated by the development of catalytic applications have never been addressed previously and, therefore, are of particular interest.
Frustrated aminoboranes can exist in several forms as illustrated in Scheme 2. The intramolecular N–B dative adducts and the μ-H-bridged dimeric species possess a reduced reactivity potential in comparison to the unquenched open structures. The aminoboranes 1a, 1e, and 1c exist in their open forms as evident by the 11B NMR shifts typical of non-coordinated boranes: 55.8, 62.2 and 62.3 ppm, respectively.16 A combination of highly sterically demanding TMP and B(C6F5)2 moieties in 1a prevents the formation of an intramolecular N → B dative bond. Despite the smaller size of a chlorine atom as compared to the C6F5 group, both 1c and 1e have unquenched acid/base sites. In line with the experimental findings, DFT calculations predict open equilibrium structures for 1a, 1e, and 1c.
![]() | ||
Scheme 2 (a) Appearance of ansa-TMP-phenylboranes as the open and the quenched forms; (b) conformational variation in compounds 1a–1c. |
The closed forms (i.e. four-membered ring structures with internal B–N dative bonds) could not be identified as energy minima on the potential energy surfaces. Computations point to the coexistence of two conformers for these aminoboranes with the phenylene bridge occupying either the equatorial (structure A) or the axial position (structure B, Scheme 2b) of the piperidine ring.17 The former structure is predicted to be slightly more favoured for all aminoboranes 1a, 1e, and 1c (for details, see the ESI†). Monochloroborane 1d appears as a doublet in the 11B NMR spectrum evidencing its monomeric form. Variable temperature (−12–90 °C, in toluene-d8) 11B NMR spectroscopy revealed a strong drift in the chemical shift of 1d (δ = 20–42 ppm) attributed to a very rapid equilibrium between its open and dative forms, which is supported by calculations as well (see the ESI†). We showed previously that the trans-dimeric form of dihydroborane 1b dominates in solutions whereas in the solid state it is the exclusive form as evident from X-ray diffraction analysis.8
Owing to the existing equilibrium between 1d, 1c, and 1b in solutions, the reaction with H2 “freezes” it to some extent, producing mixtures of chloroborodihydride 4d contaminated with varying amounts of 4c and 1b (Scheme 3). Dichloromethane and 1,2-dichloroethane are advantageous solvents for producing mixtures rich in 4d owing to the higher content of 1d in these solvents. Previously, we reported that the addition of H2 to ortho-TMP-dihydroborane 1b is a rapid and thermodynamically nearly neutral process. The equilibrium can thus be shifted towards the H2 adduct 4b by using a more polar solvent, higher H2 pressure and low temperatures (72% conversion in CD2Cl2, 10 bar H2, −15 °C).8
The solid state structures of H2 adducts 4c and 4e were determined using single crystal X-ray diffraction (Fig. 2). The structure of 4c displays the proximity of the NH and BH hydrogens pointing to the existence of a dihydrogen bond similarly to that observed for analogous ansa-aminoborane-H2 adducts.5,18 Interestingly, the X-ray structure of 4e does not involve this type of interaction, but instead, H⋯Cl bond formation is apparent. To characterize the structure of dihydrogen adducts 4a, 4c–4e in dichloromethane solution, the HN–HB bond lengths were studied by 1D NOE 1H NMR spectroscopy and they were compared to data from DFT calculations (see the ESI† for details). Similarly to the solid state, a pronounced preference for the dihydrogen-bonded isomer in solution was established for 4c by both methods. Adduct 4d could not be isolated in the pure form, therefore, only solution-phase computational and NOE data are available, which indicate that dihydrogen-bonded species are clearly favoured in DCM solutions.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Structures of chloroborohydrides 4c and 4e in a solid state (displacement parameters are drawn at the 50% probability level). |
The structures of the transition states located along the H2 splitting pathway (TS1a, TS1b, TS1c in Fig. 3) share common features with those of the previously investigated FLP systems.19 The slightly elongated H–H bond, the pyramidalization of the borane unit, and the typical end-on N⋯H2 and side-on H2⋯B arrangements of the reacting partners are all in line with the electron transfer reactivity model.20 In the case of 1a and 1c, the activation barriers are fairly low (ΔG‡ = 17.7 and 16.1 kcal mol−1, respectively),21 which is consistent with the observed reaction rates. Likewise, the thermodynamics of H2 additions to 1a and 1c, resulting in 4a and 4c, are substantially exergonic and the computed reaction free energies are similar (ΔGr = −12.0 and −11.1 kcal mol−1). Although the open form of aminoborane 1b is still rather reactive with an unprecedentedly low barrier (TS1b is only 11.8 kcal mol−1 above open-1b + H2), the overall barrier is predicted to be slightly higher (20.5 kcal mol−1) than those with 1a and 1c, which is clearly due to the reactant state stabilization arising from dimerization. For the same reason, the reaction with 1b becomes thermodynamically less favoured as well (slightly endergonic in toluene).
Naturally, the trend obtained for the Gibbs free energies of the reaction is closely related to the variation of the Lewis acidity of boryl units in the 1a–1c series. In light of the hydride affinities of B(C6F5)3, BCl3 and BH3 boranes (ΔGha = −72.5, −64.2 and −46.3 kcal mol−1, respectively),22 one expects somewhat larger differences between the thermodynamics of H2 addition to the corresponding aminoboranes 1a, 1c and 1b. However, our energy decomposition analysis reveals that the proton affinity of the TMP group is notably influenced by the nature of the boryl substituent, and also that the acid–base cooperativity taking place through the ortho-phenylene linker in these aminoboranes is an important factor.23 This self-compensatory reactivity potential mechanism operating via a conjugated phenylene linker is a remarkable feature of the ortho-aminophenylborane FLPs.
![]() | ||
Scheme 4 (a) Decomposition of 4c, 4e and 4d with the formation of chloroborates 5c, 5e and 4c; (b) formation of 4c and 4dvia “retrodismutation”. |
Additional evidence for such a decomposition pathway is provided by demonstration of a “retrodismutation” reaction: dichloroborohydride 4c, aminoborane 1b and H2 produced 4d upon heating for 4 h at 10 bar H2 pressure and 80 °C. Similarly, the reaction between trichloroborate 5c, 1b and H2 results in the formation of varying amounts of 4c and 4d with their ratio depending on the ratio of the starting materials. Trichloroborane 5c can be completely converted into 4c and 4b provided 1b is present in sufficient amounts (Scheme 4b).
The formation of the B–H/B–Cl exchange products during the addition of H2 to the ClB(C6F5)2/2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine and BCl3/2,6-dimethylpyridine FLPs was reported previously.12 In the absence of the stabilizing factors, the easy redistribution of Cl and H atoms between chloro- and hydroborates seems to be a common reactivity pattern for these species. To gain deeper insight into the thermally-promoted transformations of 2-(TMP)-phenyl-chloroboranes and their adducts, we examined a series of reactions involving various H2 and HCl addition/elimination steps computationally as shown in Scheme 5. The results are summarized in Fig. 4 in the form of a free energy profile.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Computed Gibbs free energy profile for the series of reactions shown in Scheme 5. The zero level of the diagram is arbitrarily chosen at 4c. |
It is apparent from this profile that the adduct 4c lies in a free energy minimum with respect to H2 and HCl elimination. The barrier towards H2 elimination is notably lower, therefore 4c → 1c + H2 might be the first step of the thermally induced transformation and decomposition. Although H2 elimination from 4c is unfavoured thermodynamically, this reaction may shift towards the formation of 1c as H2 is continuously discharged from the solution in these experiments.
The reaction between 1c and 4c to produce 5c and 4d is thermodynamically feasible as calculations predict ΔGr = 0.3 kcal mol−1 in toluene and 1.4 kcal mol−1 in DCM for this process. We found that this transformation can occur in a single step via a concerted H−/Cl− exchange (for the identified transition states, see the ESI†). The related activation barrier is fairly high (ΔG‡ = 30.2 kcal mol−1 in toluene and 26.9 kcal mol−1 in DCM), but it is consistent with the experimental conditions (120 °C, 24 h).
As for the destiny of the tentative 4f formed via the H/Cl redistribution at the initial stage of 4e thermolysis (Scheme 4a), we suggest that it decomposes by the intramolecular protonative splitting of the B–C6F5 bond that produces 1b and C6F5H as detected experimentally. Such a reaction was previously shown to proceed surprisingly easily in the ortho-aminophenylborane core.6 Besides, we revised the thermal behaviour of compound 4a and found that its decomposition via a similar protonative pathway becomes apparent at 150 °C (see the ESI† for details).
Substrate | 2c, mol% | Time, h | Conversionb (Isol. yield), % |
---|---|---|---|
a 125 ml Schlenk tube was charged with 0.5 mmol of alkyne, a catalytic amount of 2c and 6 and 0.35 ml of 1,2-dichloroethane, pressurized with H2 (2.2 bar) and stirred at respective temperatures. b Conversions were determined by the 1H NMR analysis of crude reaction mixtures. | |||
![]() |
5 | 3 | 100 |
![]() |
5 | 24 | 100 |
![]() |
5 | 24 | 56 |
![]() |
5 | 24 | 100 (90) |
![]() |
10 | 24 | 92 |
Internal alkynes were converted into respective cis-alkenes within 24 h or less at 100 °C and 2.2 bar H2 using 2c as a catalyst. Remarkably, sterically hindered amine 1,2,2,6,6-pentamethylpiperidine (6) serves as an efficient promoter enhancing the catalytic activity approximately two fold. Under standard conditions, only 5 mol% of both 2c and 6 loadings are sufficient for reaching complete conversions of acetylenes. At the same time 2a appears to be more catalytically active than 2c, because the majority of substrates are completely hydrogenated with the aid of 2a in 3 h at 80 °C. Regarding the feasibility of catalysis and high cis-stereoselectivity during hydrogenations, we suggest that the mechanism of catalysis by 2c is very similar to the one previously reported for 2a/2b though the details are yet to be established in the ongoing studies.
The attempted thermally promoted dehydrogenation of ammonium chloroborohydrides (H2 adducts) leads to the redistribution of B–H and B–Cl substituents resulting in the isolation of polychloroborates 5c and 5e. These processes are feasible only under conditions when H2 is discharged from the reaction as shown by the reversible formation of chloroborohydrides in “retrodismutation” experiments. For C6F5-substituted borates the decomposition involves protonative cleavage of the B–C6F5 bond yielding C6F5H. In the molecules of the studied ammonium chloroborohydrides, a protic hydrogen atom can be connected to either a Cl or H atom of the BH(Cl)X unit through intramolecular Cl⋯H or dihydrogen bonds. We found that these forms are usually nearly equal in energy and can be easily interconverted via rotation around the B–C bond.
Experimental and computational comparisons between isostructural chloro- and C6F5-substituted aminoboranes revealed a high degree of similarity in reactivities to H2, which is reflected by the energetics of the overall reactions and transition states as well as by the stability of H2 adducts. This similarity was pronouncedly demonstrated by the similar catalytic abilities of chloro- and C6F5-substituted aminoboranes 2c and 2a in the hydrogenation of alkynes. Simple and lightweight FLPs derived from boranes with elementary substituents are promising catalysts for hydrogenation and C–H borylation reactions and studies of their catalytic properties are currently in progress in our groups.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experimental procedures, NMR spectra, crystallographic data, and detailed computational analysis. Crystallographic data (excluding structure factors) for the structures reported in this work. CCDC 1511243 (2c), 912583 (4c), 912582 (4e), 912585 (5c), and 912584 (5e). For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: 10.1039/c6dt04649e |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2017 |