A.
Ciżman
*a,
E.
Rysiakiewicz-Pasek
a,
M.
Krupiński
b,
M.
Konon
c,
T.
Antropova
c and
M.
Marszałek
b
aDivision of Experimental Physics, Faculty of Fundamental Problems of Technology Wrocław University of Science and Technology, Wybrzeże Wyspiańskiego 27, 50 – 370 Wrocław, Poland. E-mail: agnieszka.cizman@pwr.edu.pl
bInstitute of Nuclear Physics, Polish Academy of Sciences, Radzikowskiego 152, Kraków, Poland
cGrebenshchikov Institute of Silicate Chemistry, Russian Academy of Science, Nab.Makarova 2, Saint Petersburg, Russia
First published on 4th August 2017
We report the synthesis and characterization of iron-bearing sodium borosilicate glasses with an Fe2O3 content lower than 10 mol%. Using Mössbauer spectroscopy we demonstrate that Fe ions most probably have a tetrahedral oxygen environment for an iron oxide content higher than 5 mol%. Additionally, the Mössbauer results along with the X-ray diffraction studies indicate the formation of magnetite nanoclusters. The electrical conductivity of iron-containing sodium borosilicate glasses is studied over a wide temperature range. The impact of iron content on the dielectric permittivity and electrical properties is discussed. Finally, ionic conduction is identified in the high temperature region and its physical origin is explained. A similar activation energy of the dc conductivity and the activation energy of the electrical relaxation suggest that both the relaxation and conduction processes can be ascribed to the same type of entities.
Sodium borosilicate (SBS) glasses belong to a large glass family with a wide variety of applications. Owing to their low thermal expansion coefficient, low dielectric constant, relatively high electrical resistivity, good chemical stability and high chemical resistance, SBS is used in microelectronics10,11 and as a host material for porous matrices with controlled porosity.12,13 Such porous glasses are known to be the basis for many composite materials.14,15 The structure of SBS glasses can be considered as a three-dimensional network of corner-connected [SiO4/2] tetrahedra and three- and four-coordinated boron forming the [BO3/2] and [BO4/2] boron–oxygen groups.16,17 It was reported that addition of iron oxide as the network modifier or the glass-former involved the conversion of the [BO4/2] boron–oxygen tetrahedral group to triangular BO3 structural units, thus resulting in a decrease in the polymerisation degree of the [SiO4/2] tetrahedral group.18 Moreover, Fe2+ cations that are predominantly in the sixfold coordination occupy interstitial sites near the trigonal boron–oxygen groups, whereas Fe3+ ions are four-coordinated and appear to substitute a silicon. It was observed that the redox equilibrium Fe3+ ⇆ Fe2+ in the glass melt depended on the melt temperature, its cooling rate, the gas composition in the furnace as well as the melt composition.18 SBS glass modified in this way is widely used as a nuclear waste form,19–21 also in medicine for a targeted magnetite crystallization,22 and it is considered as a system for the production of semiconducting fibres23 as well. Although much effort has been devoted to the study of the structural, dielectric and optical properties of various oxide glasses containing Fe2O3 as a glass former,1–12 insufficient studies have been carried out on SBS glasses doped with Fe2O3. In fact, the presented results on the physical properties of sodium borosilicate glasses doped with a low content of Fe2O3 have not been reported so far.
Our goal in this work was to investigate the influence of iron ions on the electrical conductivity and dielectric properties of the iron-doped SBS system. The glass structure was studied by X-ray diffraction. In order to infer the redox state of iron and its local environment, we employed 57Fe Mössbauer spectroscopy. The main part of the presented investigation of the interesting physical properties is oriented towards future applications in areas of multiferroic elements, optics, nanoelectronics, sensors, biotechnology and medicine. Nanoscale multiferroic elements based on magnetic porous matrices with different shapes and sizes of pores can have totally different magnetic and electric properties. For industrial applications, stable states, well-controlled switching behaviour, and small dependence on size variations are highly desirable. Understanding and controlling these properties of the nanoscale multiferroelectric elements requires thorough investigation of SBS glasses with a low iron content in order to preserve the dielectric properties of porous glass matrices.
To obtain two glassy phases, the studied glasses were heat-treated at a temperature above Tg (T = 550 °C) for 144 hours, which is sufficient to reach the phase equilibrium. The Tg values of the studied glasses are in the range 500–504 °C.24 These values correspond to the glass transition interval of the low-melting boron-rich phase. Thus, in the studied glasses, the equilibrium structure, corresponding to the heat treatment temperature (550 °C), is frozen (stabilized). In our experiments, the maximum temperature for measuring the dielectric permittivity and the conductivity did not exceed 600 K (327 °C), that is, it was significantly lower than both the Tg values and the isothermal heat treatment temperature T, which had no effect on the structure of the phase-separated glasses under study.
Sample code | Composition (as-analyzed mol%) | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
SiO2 | B2O3 | Na2O | Fe2O3 | FeO | Al2O3 | |
SBS | 74.93 | 18.28 | 6.73 | — | — | 0.06 |
SBS-Fe3 | 71.08 | 18.38 | 7.09 | 2.76 | 0.69 | — |
SBS-Fe4 | 71.26 | 17.17 | 7.31 | 3.23 | 1.04 | — |
SBS-Fe6 | 70.09 | 15.72 | 7.13 | 4.76 | 2.30 | — |
SBS-Fe10 | 68.79 | 11.83 | 7.07 | 7.13 | 5.18 | — |
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 XRD patterns for the xFe2O3–8Na2O–(22 − x)B2O3–70SiO2 glasses. The vertical offsets were used for clarity. The positions of reflections for the bulk magnetite are indicated. |
In all cases, the peaks corresponding to the crystalline magnetite phase appear. Additionally, the broad peak at a position of about 23 deg is visible. It originates from the amorphous phase of glass and its intensity is similar to that of all samples. In contrast, the intensities of the peaks arising from the magnetite phase change and increase with increasing amounts of Fe2O3 introduced into the glass during the synthesis.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Mössbauer spectra were recorded for the samples containing iron. Different regions on the graphs represent contributions from the different sites. |
For the description of the spectra, the best fitting was achieved by using four Mössbauer components: two sextets and two quadrupole doublets. The mean values of the fitted parameters together with the ratio of the integral peak intensities of the electrical quadrupole splitting A−/A+ and the ratio of the corresponding lines of Zeeman splitting A2/A3 are given in Table 2. The ratio of the lines A1/A3 was fixed for all magnetic sites and is equal to 3. The isomer shifts, fitted to all spectra, were corrected according to the used source. The main component in all Mössbauer spectra is a strong quadrupole doublet originating from iron atoms in the Fe(1) site. Such a doublet with a similar isomer shift and quadrupole splitting was already reported for sodium borosilicate glasses27,28 and it corresponded to the high spin Fe3+ ions (S = 5/2). The isomer shift for the samples with the highest iron content suggests a tetrahedral oxygen environment of Fe(1) sites,28–30 while for samples SBS-Fe4 and SBS-Fe3 the mean centre shift decreases which indicates a lower coordination. A high electric quadrupole shift of about 0.9 mm s−1 for this component indicates a significant distortion of the Fe3+On polyhedra in the glass structure, which induces a large electric field gradient on the 57Fe nuclei of spherically symmetric Fe3+ cations.27 The low intensity doublet related to Fe(2) sites corresponds to the Fe2+ ions (S = 2) with parameters similar to those reported in ref. 27. As in the case of Fe(1), the mean centre shift slightly decreases with decreasing iron content, which suggests an evolution toward lower coordination.28
Sample | Site | c [%] | B hf [T] | IS [mm s−1] | QS [mm s−1] | A − /A + or A2/A3 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
SBS-Fe10 | ||||||
Fe(1) | 33.1 | — | 0.22 | 0.94 [0.48] | 1.72 | |
Fe(2) | 5.9 | — | 2.27 | 0.76 [0.32] | 0.55 | |
Fe(3) | 37.0 | 45.8 [0.5] | 0.68 | 0.0 | 2.16 | |
Fe(4) | 24.0 | 48.7 [0.1] | 0.27 | 0.0 | 2.29 | |
SBS-Fe6 | ||||||
Fe(1) | 79.8 | — | 0.21 | 0.93 [0.55] | 2.10 | |
Fe(2) | 20.2 | — | 2.16 | 0.91 [0.33] | 0.43 | |
SBS-Fe4 | ||||||
Fe(1) | 57.6 | — | 0.18 | 0.93 [0.50] | 2.09 | |
Fe(2) | 7.9 | — | 2.16 | 0.91 [0.33] | 0.50 | |
Fe(3) | 23.0 | 43.1 [0.6] | 0.67 | 0.0 | 2.0 | |
Fe(4) | 11.5 | 46.5 [0.2] | 0.21 | 0.0 | 2.0 | |
SBS-Fe3 | ||||||
Fe(1) | 61.7 | — | 0.11 | 0.91 [0.50] | 1.72 | |
Fe(2) | 14.7 | — | 2.05 | 0.87 [0.34] | 0.55 | |
Fe(3) | 12.6 | 45.2 [0.6] | 0.59 | 0.0 | 2.0 | |
Fe(4) | 11.0 | 47.8 [0.2] | 0.16 | 0.0 | 2.0 |
The presence of two Zeeman sextets for Fe(3) and Fe(4) sites in the Mössbauer spectra (which can be assigned to the magnetite phase) can be well correlated with the magnetite peak widths from the XRD patterns. In the case of the sample with the highest iron content (SBS-Fe10), the magnetite peak widths are the smallest, resulting in sharp and well-defined Zeeman lines with IS, Bhf, and QS being very close to the parameters known for iron ions in the bulk magnetite at room temperature.31 The profile of the Zeeman sextets for the samples with a low Fe content (SBS-Fe4 and SBS-Fe3) exhibiting wider XRD peaks and smaller magnetite crystallites indicates the inhomogeneous and disturbed environment of the iron cations. The distribution of the magnetic moment of individual magnetite grains resulted in a decrease in the mean hyperfine fields and in a broadening of the lines. In contrast to these results, the Mössbauer spectrum for the SBS-Fe6 sample did not show magnetic hyperfine interactions. This can be explained by a very small grain size in this sample (approx. 8 nm as calculated using the Scherrer equation32,33), which entails the continuous fluctuation of the magnetic moments of each magnetite cluster related to superparamagnetic effects. In such a case, if the relaxation time of the superparamagnetic particle is greater than the lifetime of the excited nucleus, it experiences an average zero field only and Zeeman splitting cannot be observed.34
The frequency dependences of the dielectric loss tanδ for the SBS-Fe4 sample at various temperatures are shown in Fig. 4. The maximum dielectric loss shifts toward higher frequency with increasing temperature, indicating a thermally activated behaviour.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Frequency dependences of the dielectric loss tan![]() |
A similar frequency dependence of the electric permittivity and the dielectric loss tanδ was found for all glasses. The increase in ε′ is attributed to an increase in the Fe content, and it is expected to be a result of the conduction and polarization coupling into a single process. The temperature dependence of the real part of the conductivity on the frequency f on a logarithmic scale (where f = ω/2π and ω is the angular frequency) is shown in Fig. 5 for SBS-Fe10 glass.
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 Temperature dependence of the conductivity, σ, at several temperatures for SBS-Fe10 glass. The data are connected as a guide to the eye. |
For all investigated samples, the curves have a similar shape which is typical for amorphous materials. For all samples, the conductivity dependence observed for high frequency follows the Jonscher power law. For our glass systems, in order to obtain the dc conductivity, ε′′ (1/ω) data have been fitted.9 The temperature dependences of the dc conductivity are shown in Fig. 6 for all samples.
The observed dependence obeys a simple Arrhenius formula σDC = σ0 exp(−EDC/kBT), where σ0 is the pre-exponent, EDC is the activation energy for dc conductivity, T is the temperature and kB is the Boltzmann constant. For each glass in the present study, the activation energy (EDC) was determined from the slope of log σDCvs. reciprocal temperature (1/T) as shown in Fig. 6. The values of the activation energy EDC are collected in Table 3 for all samples.
Glass | E ac [eV] f = 10 kHz ±0.5% | E M [eV] ±0.5% | E dc [eV] ±0.5% | τ σ [s] |
---|---|---|---|---|
SBS-Fe10 | 0.38 | 0.96 | 0.97 | 0.024 |
SBS-Fe6 | 0.46 | 0.94 | 0.94 | 0.023 |
SBS-Fe4 | 0.54 | 0.90 | 0.90 | 0.016 |
SBS-Fe3 | 0.57 | 0.89 | 0.88 | 0.004 |
SBS | 0.60 | 0.90 | 0.85 | 0.003 |
The electrical conductivity in sodium borosilicate glasses is related to the transport of sodium ions through the glass network. It is stated that because of heat treatment of the investigated glasses, the sodium ions are present mainly in the sodium-borate phase. In borate glasses, the Na ions are bound to the BO4− groups. The results of the chemical durability investigation of these glasses indicate that most of the iron ions are allocated at the sodium-borate phase. It is obvious that both sodium and iron ions contribute to the electrical conductivity in iron-containing alkali borosilicate glasses. The electronic conductivity is considered as the polaron hopping between the iron ions. All the glasses under investigation contain the same concentration of sodium ions; therefore the number of carriers is the same. The increase in the dc conductivity and the activation energy with increasing Fe content is related to the presence of Fe and its influence on the structure of the investigated glasses. The addition of iron ions to the sodium borosilicate network reduced the amount of four-coordinated boron (BO4/2) and increased the amount of three-coordinated boron (BO3/2).18 The structural reorganization of iron-SBS glasses is probably caused by the competition between FeO4 and BO4 with a compensation of the negative charge by the Na+ ions. At the same time, the number of non-bridging oxygen atoms increases, which produces a weakening of the SBS glass structure. Such structural changes can have an important influence on the mobility of Na+. The Na+ mobility increases in the presence of non-bridging oxygen atoms.38 These changes can cause an increase in dc conductivity. On the other hand, addition of iron oxide causes the formation of [FeO4/2]−Na+ units.39 The increase of the Fe content causes the increase of these units, where the Na+ ions are linked stronger than those in the sodium-borate [BO4]−Na+ units. In our opinion, this is the most probable reason why the dc activation energy increases. It can be expected that for a constant concentration of Na+ in the investigated glasses, the number of [FeO4/2]−Na+ units increases with increasing Fe2O3/B2O3 ratio.
It is known that in ionic conducting glasses, the activation energy is attributed to the Na+ ion transport. It is determined by the average height of potential barriers. The main electronic transport in these glasses is hopping through localized states. These localized states can correspond to the gap states which are attributed with structural defects. The value of dc activation energy of 0.88 eV for SBS-Fe3 glasses is similar to that of about 0.85 eV for dc conductivity obtained for iron-free glasses (SBS sample). This suggests that the conduction mechanism in the investigated glasses is ionic, and the dc activation energies are described by the sodium ion transport through the glass network.
The total conductivity is given by the empirical form that is expressed as σt(ω) = σDC(ω) + σAC(ω), where σt(ω), σDC(ω) and σAC(ω) have typical meanings. For the investigated glasses, the values of ac conductivity σAC were obtained by subtracting the dc conductivity from the total conductivity. The glass systems presented in this paper, have not been considered till now that occurs more because of very difficult glass network, the full structure of these systems is not accessible now. One of the probable scenarios of reduction of Eac with increasing Fe concentration is that the doping of Fe in the SBS glass network leads to an increase in the number of glass network defects. As the iron content is increased, the number of defects increases. The reduction of the ac activation energy can be related to the trapping on the defects. As the iron content is increased, the number of defects also increases. The frequency dependence of σAC(ω) at various temperatures is shown in Fig. 7 for SBS-Fe10 glass.
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 Frequency dependences of the ac conductivity, σAC, for the glass containing 10 mol% of Fe2O3 (SBS-Fe10) at selected temperatures. |
The observed changes are typical for an amorphous material and usually follow the power law relation σAC = A·ωs, where s represents the temperature-dependent degree of an interaction between the mobile ions and generally varies between 0 and 1. The exponent s was calculated for selected temperatures from experimental data by means of linear data fitting.
The fitted value of the exponent s is shown in Fig. 8 for several temperatures. The relative errors are smaller than the given tolerance. It can be seen that s increases with decreasing temperature from approximately 0.51 to approximately 0.68. The temperature behaviour of the s exponent can be useful to clarify the conductivity mechanism in the material. It is known that the decrease of s with increasing temperature is related to the charge transport between the localized states attributed to hopping over the potential barriers.37–40 For all glasses under study, the s exponent obeys such a temperature-dependent behaviour.
For all glasses, the peaks shift toward higher frequencies with increasing temperature, while the shapes of the curves are asymmetric, exhibiting non-Debye behaviour in the high-frequency region. The broadness of the M′′ curves remains constant for all samples, which may imply the same activation energy for all distribution components. An extra small peak in the glass with the highest content of Fe is observed. As far as we know, in this system it is difficult to enhance the Fe-SBS glasses with higher iron concentrations. Until we obtain glasses with a higher iron content, we can only assume that the extra-smaller peak observed in SBS-Fe10 is related to the Fe content. Fig. 10 shows the temperature dependence of the relaxation frequency obtained from the peak position of M′′.
![]() | ||
Fig. 10 Frequency dependences of the M′′ peak on 1000/T for Na2O–B2O3–SiO2–Fe2O3. The data are connected as a guide to the eye. |
The relaxation time can be determined as the inverse of the maximum modulus frequency τσ = 1/(2·π·fM). The relative errors are smaller than the given tolerance. For all glasses investigated in the present work the activation energy can be described using the Arrhenius equation fM = fM0·exp(−EM/kB·T), where EM is the activation energy of the electrical relaxation, kB is the Boltzmann constant and fM0 is the characteristic frequency. The activation energy EM is almost identical to the activation energy of the conduction process EDC, and this suggests that both the relaxation and conduction processes may be attributed to the same type of entities. The values of relaxation times τσ for the glasses measured at 400 K are shown in Table 3. The relaxation time can be attributed to the time of jumps between two nearest interstitial sites. The values of activation energies EM, ascribing the motion of Na+, calculated from the fitting data, are presented in Fig. 10 and are shown in Table 3.
This journal is © the Owner Societies 2017 |