Open Access Article
Mátyás
Hunyadi
*a,
Zoltán
Gácsi
a,
István
Csarnovics
b,
Lóránt
Csige
a,
Attila
Csik
a,
Lajos
Daróczi
c,
Róbert
Huszánk
a and
Zoltán
Szűcs
a
aInstitute for Nuclear Research, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, Bem tér 18/c, 4026 Debrecen, Hungary. E-mail: hunyadi.matyas@atomki.mta.hu; Fax: +36 52 416 181; Tel: +36 52 509 270
bDepartment of Experimental Physics, Debrecen University, Bem tér 18/a, 4026 Debrecen, Hungary
cDepartment of Solid State Physics, Debrecen University, Bem tér 18/b, 4026 Debrecen, Hungary
First published on 30th May 2017
An unprecedented rate enhancement was observed in the wet-chemical synthesis of tellurium nanowires under crowded conditions of inert macromolecules. The synthesis was carried out at 105 °C using solutions of sodium tellurite (Na2TeO3) as a precursor, hydrazine (N2H4) as a reducing agent, and polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) as both a stabilizing and crowding agent. The PVP concentration was systematically varied between the dilute and crowding regimes up to 166 g l−1. The growth of the nanowires was monitored by measuring their size-dependent optical properties in the UV-Vis spectrum characterizing the size and morphology evolution of the nanowires and a coexisting phase of amorphous tellurium nanoparticles. The observed growth characteristics were interpreted in terms of non-specific structural organization of the crowded media due to the entropic-driven effects of space compartmentalization.
Nanoparticles (NPs) are routinely synthesized in dilute systems utilizing phase transition in supersaturated solutions of low-molecular weight species as their monomeric building blocks. In practice, the challenging task is to find an appropriate model system for NP synthesis to study crowding effects in the growth process, since macroscopic observables depend on the morphological and size parameters of the NPs in a rather complex way.13 In contrast, the time evolution of observables such as excitonic absorbance can be explicit expressions of reaction rates in the case of one-dimensional particles such as nanowires, provided the total area of growth surfaces is constant and seed formation terminates before the growth period.
Our choice for a model system was the well-established hydrothermal procedure of synthesizing Te nanocrystals in supersaturated solutions of Te atoms or their elemental molecules. These building-block particles (monomers) were produced under mild alkaline conditions via chemical reduction of the sodium tellurite precursor (Na2TeO3) by the reducing agent hydrazine (N2H4) or its protonated form hydrazinium cation (N2H5+), which then turn into inert products in an irreversible process:14,15
| TeO32− + N2H4 → Te↓ + N2↑ + 2OH− + H2O E° = 0.59 eV |
| TeO32− + N2H5+ → Te↓ + N2↑ + OH− + 2H2O E° = 1.057 eV |
Te nanocrystals preferentially grow into one-dimensional nanowires (NWs) with unlimited length and narrow size-distribution in diameter under well-controlled physical conditions.16,17 Their crystalline form has a trigonal structure (t-Te), which consists of helical chains of covalently bound atoms, and is bundled together by weak secondary interactions.18 The unique feature of the longitudinal growth tendency is a consequence of the crystal structure and selective surface stabilization implemented by various additives, which effectively constrain the pathways of crystal growth by preventing undesired polymorphism or aggregation as a result of steric stabilization of crystal facets.19 As a result, the high-energy surface of t-Te [001] with dangling covalent bonds remains accessible for growth. In our case, PVP was used as a capping and structure-directing agent,20,21 which can also act as a suitable crowding agent due to its inertness and high solubility in water.22
Similarly to NPs of other semiconducting materials on the scale of quantum-size confinement, excitons of valence to conduction band transitions (VB–CB) appear in tellurium in the UV-Vis spectrum.18 These excitons form two absorption peaks at 270–280 nm (VB2–CB1) and 500–650 nm (VB3–CB1), the positions of which shift to longer wavelengths with increasing nanowire dimensions, and can be used to monitor the ripening process.23,24
In this work, we report an unprecedented observation of the enhanced growth of Te NWs, which emerged at around the crossover between the semi-dilute and crowding regimes of the PVP concentration. The ripening process of the NWs and a coexisting phase of amorphous Te NPs were monitored by systematically measuring their size-dependent optical properties as a function of time in the UV-Vis spectrum, including excitonic and background parameters. We outline a potential explanation to elucidate the observed rate-enhancement effect on the basis of a simplified association–dissociation reaction scheme and entropic-driven spatial organization of the crowded media.
000) were purchased from Alfa-Aesar and Sigma-Aldrich companies. The pH of the PVP solutions in the present study ranged between 4.5 and 7. Water from a Milli-Q ultrapure system was used for the preparation of the solutions.
In a seeded-growth procedure (procedure B) synthesis batches were prepared by mixing 1 ml of identical aliquots from an NW suspension previously synthesized in procedure A and 2 ml of PVP solutions with varying concentrations. The NW suspension was prepared in a 100 ml flask containing 10 ml of each stock solution using cPVP = 1.67 g l−1, under vigorous stirring for 60 min at 105 °C. The batch concentration of PVP was set in five steps in the range of cPVP = 3.89–166 g l−1. The NW suspension and the PVP stock solution were mixed at room temperature, and the pH was set to a common value of 9.1 by adding 10–50 μl of 0.4 M HCl solution. The prepared mixture was filled into the cuvette, and heated up to 105 °C following the protocol of procedure A measurements.
In the reaction-order measurements based on the protocol of procedure B, the volume of the injected suspension was systematically varied from 0.25 to 2 ml, keeping the PVP concentration fixed at 33.8 g l−1.
The particle-size distributions were generated by unbiased sampling from the TEM images. The centroid and width parameters of the distributions were found rather insensitive to the sample-to-sample variation due to the relatively large standard deviation which is the consequence of the limited number of particle specimens visually observed.
The absorbance-weighted centre of the visible excitonic peak shifted from approximately 500 nm to 600–650 nm during the 60 min course of the synthesis. The analysis of TEM images, partly shown in Fig. 2b–e, and related energy-dispersive X-ray (EDX) data supported the presence of 1-dimensional Te nanostructures in the forms of nanorods and nanowires. The images also revealed a coexisting phase of spherical-like particles with diameters of 5–15 nm as shown in Fig. 2d, which were identified as amorphous Te NPs similarly to previous experiments.15,23 The continuous development of nanorods to nanowires and their longitudinal growth were observed in TEM images (Fig. 2b and c) and in the corresponding length distributions (Fig. 2f). Moreover, the diameter of the NWs remained constant along the growth axis due to the stabilizing effect of PVP, and its distribution typically peaked at 6 ± 1 nm. Based on these observations, the wavelength-averaged absorbance of the excitonic peak is assumed to be a linear function of the cumulated NW length, and its time-derivative can give direct information on growth rates.
During the induction period preceding the visible formation of the crystalline phase, a structureless spectrum appears as a monotonously decreasing function of wavelength as seen in Fig. 2a. This spectrum is characteristic of optical extinction caused by scattering on particles with sizes smaller than the wavelength of the incident light. Evaluating the TEM images, as exemplified in Fig. 2d, spherical particles are sufficiently small to use Rayleigh approximation on their spectra (Rayleigh-scattering absorbance), which gives a satisfactory fit with a λ−4 function to the background under the emerging excitonic structure.25 The excitonic peak then gradually becomes visible due to the developing crystalline phase, and the excess yield above the Rayleigh-scattering absorbance is referred to as NW absorbance. It is apparent that NW absorbance can be further decomposed to the localized structure of the excitonic peak and a background nearly independent of the wavelength. The latter component was also fitted in every time step and found to be linearly proportional to the averaged absorbance of the excitonic peak in the growth period. Based on self-consistent calculations on t-Te crystals, the imaginary part of the transversal and longitudinal components of the frequency-dependent permittivity considerably differ for the VB3–CB1 transitions.27 While the former yields a relatively sharp peak around 2 eV corresponding to the observed excitonic structure, the latter results in a broader structure over the entire visible spectrum extending to the near-infrared. Rayleigh scattering on the NWs as a non-excitonic extinction process may also be present in the background, although its contribution to the integrated yield is potentially less dominant partly due to the isotropic distribution of the optical axis of the NWs and the polarization of the incident light, as well as to the reduced dielectric contrast at the diffuse capping layer on the crystal–polymer interface.
The relevant quantities of the spectral components (the centre of the excitonic peak, and nanowire and Rayleigh-scattering absorbance) are presented in Fig. 3 as a function of synthesis time and parametrised by the systematically varied PVP concentration. Three stages of the ripening process can be recognized in the evolution curves. The first section lasting for 5–10 min, including the heat-up period when the temperature was increased to 105 °C, is the induction period, which is characterised only by the formation of amorphous NPs. The second section in the interval of 5–15 min is the seeding period, when the excitonic peak turns up and rapidly shifts to a longer wavelength. This behaviour was pointed out in previous experiments, which revealed a correlation between the nanorod length and the centre of the excitonic peak;23 however, its radial dependence is presumably irrelevant during the synthesis, since the nanorod diameter does not change after crystalline seeds are formed. In parallel, the Rayleigh-scattering absorbance steeply increases before it reaches a maximum value. After the length of the growing nanorods exceeds the size of the Bohr-exciton of bulk t-Te, the length dependence vanishes and the centre of the exciton converges to 610–630 nm. At this stage of evolution, the NW absorbance realizes a linear time dependence, while the Rayleigh-scattering absorbance turns to a declining section. Taking into account the typical power-law dependence of the Rayleigh-scattering cross section on the particle diameter (σR ∝ d6), the declining behaviour may be attributed to the dissolution of the NPs.25
The most striking and common feature of all evolution data is the monotonously accelerated ripening of both the NW and Rayleigh-scattering absorbances with increasing PVP concentration (Fig. 3). The drastic enhancement of growth rates took place only above ≈20 g l−1 typically falling in the crossover region between semi-dilute and crowding concentrations, while at lower concentrations no significant effect of PVP was found. It is an obvious question as to whether the faster processes connected with higher monomer consumption rates are caused by higher concentrations of crystalline seeds or by higher longitudinal growth rates of the NWs. Upon comparing the size parameters of the NWs synthesized at semi-dilute and crowding concentrations of PVP, as shown in Fig. 4a and b, the substantial difference in length suggests that crowding promotes longitudinal growth, while significant change in the average radii was not found. Consequently, crystal-seed concentrations might have only a minor or negligible role in the observed effect.
The size distribution and concentration of premature particles sensitively depend on the uncertainties of the initial parameters due to the stochastic nature of nucleation. Furthermore, as the pH of the initial batch mixtures was measured in the range of 10.0–10.6 depending on the amount of PVP applied, it may affect the relative concentration of hydrazine and its protonated form (hydrazinium cation), which potentially results in increased growth rates considering the difference in the electromotive force of the respective reduction processes. To eliminate the role of these effects and uncertainties, we extended procedure A to a seeded-growth synthesis (procedure B) with controlled concentration parameters and pH adjusted to 9.10 ± 0.05 by the addition of 0.4 M HCl solution. NW suspension prepared for 60 min under semi-dilute conditions was injected in identical amounts to PVP solutions ranging from semi-dilute to crowding concentrations, and ripened for another 60 min period at 105°. The NWs and their length distributions at the end of the procedure-B synthesis are illustrated in Fig. 5 for semi-dilute and crowding PVP concentrations. During the course of the synthesis, the pH decreased by an amount of 0.1–0.2 with respect to the adjusted value. Considering that the concentrations of NWs and NPs, as well as of any remaining reactant, are equal in each synthesis batch, the procedure is capable of verifying that crowding affects the crystal-growth dynamics instead of the nuclei formation. After a short heat-up period, the time evolution of the NW absorbance in Fig. 6a quickly turns to a monotonously increasing section, the slope of which demonstrates a significant enhancement with increasing PVP concentration similarly to the systematics measured in procedure A. The negative deviation from a linear approximation is probably caused by the gradual exhaustion of the monomers. The declining section of the Rayleigh-scattering absorbance evolution was also approximated with a linear model for procedure-A data, while the slopes deduced from the procedure-B data could not be determined with acceptable confidence, because the mean size of the amorphous NPs fell below the threshold of optical sensitivity. The time derivative of the nanowire absorbance is summarized in Fig. 6b as a function of PVP concentration at a fixed pH. To quantify the sample-to-sample reproducibility of growth data, the statistical analysis of five independent series of procedure-B synthesis was performed, and errors comprising both systematic and statistical uncertainties of data reduction were determined and are shown in Fig. 6b.
The amount of the injected suspension in procedure B was also varied at fixed PVP concentrations to determine the reaction-rate exponent for the crystal growth, which was found to be 2.09 ± 0.05 by fitting the slope parameter in the linear-growth section. This reveals that the overall process can be viewed as a purely binary reaction between the NWs and the monomers (Fig. 6c).
For a deeper understanding of the molecular mechanisms behind the observed rate-enhancement effect of MMC, a plausible reaction scheme is outlined based on both thermodynamic and structural considerations of the association–dissociation dynamics (Fig. 7).
Initially, the decomposition of precursors by chemical reduction leads to the instantaneous supersaturation of zero-valent species, functioning as monomers for spontaneously forming nuclei. The formation of such new-phase particles then suddenly pulls down the concentration of the monomers, which then terminates the nucleation; the solution becomes undersaturated, and eventually makes the particles subcritical.28,29 In accordance with the Ostwald-step rule, nuclei with a preferentially metastable, often disordered state are formed, which are structurally closest to their parent state.30 Later, particles may acquire a partial crystalline structure as a transitional state (e.g. crystal facets or edges) and form seeds for subsequent crystal growth, which possibly remain supercritical due to their lower solubility and higher surface energy with respect to the amorphous NPs. The crystal seeds then undergo a process, in which the dissolution of the disordered domain and the epitaxial growth of the crystal facets take place in parallel. The process can be viewed as a special case of Ostwald ripening, where the size-controlled process described by the Gibbs–Thomson equation is replaced by structural control, sometimes referred to as intraparticle growth.28
The ascending section of the Rayleigh-scattering absorbance as shown in Fig. 3c in procedure A is considered as a sign of Ostwald ripening of the amorphous population taking into account that only the fraction of the largest particles is visible in the spectra. After the first crystalline seeds start growing, the amorphous population undergoes a dissolution process, the rate of which correlates with the rate of NW growth in the linear section at all PVP concentrations applied. This behaviour of evolution is demonstrated in Fig. 3d, where points of the Rayleigh-scattering absorbance follow very similar tracks and converge to practically the same position of the excitonic centre in the linear-growth section.
Evaluating the reaction-order measurement on procedure B, a partial order of approximately one can be assigned to the concentration of the monomers, which is the only dynamic quantity that determines the NW growth. When realizing a balance between the source and consumption rates of monomers during the linear-growth period, the monomer saturation takes a constant, non-vanishing value. In this steady state, the monomer-association process is assumed to be the rate-limiting step, on which the influence of the crowded environment must be examined on the basis of the dynamic control over the geometrically constrained space.
Note that crowded media of inert obstacles naturally lead to an obstructed diffusion,31 which suppresses the rates of kinematically controlled processes. The obstructed diffusion may have a selective effect on reaction pathways with different reaction orders. In the simplest case, the associative processes are disfavoured against the dissociative ones; consequently, the effective solubility of the particles must increase. Since the consumption rate of the monomers governed by the associative-rate constant of NW growth is then also suppressed, the monomer concentration increases toward the solubility region of the amorphous population. Potentially, this would lead to the Ostwald ripening of the NPs; however, this scenario would confront with the observations of shrinking NP size-distribution in Fig. 4c. Although this effect may still be present in the limit of kinematic control, it might have only a minor role in the overall growth process.
In thermodynamic control, the role of kinematic obstruction must principally be different due to the structural organization of the media, which might elucidate the accelerated NW growth. In fact, the associative reactions are sequential processes of distant transport and local random walk of the reactants. The former process is quantified by the so-called first-passage time; in our case, this is the time needed for a mobile reactant to first encounter the NW end. However, this process is slowed down in a crowded environment, which can be overbalanced by increased recollision rates.32,33 This case can be realized if reactants are temporally trapped in compartments that force them to explore the local environment on a time scale much longer than defined by the recollision frequency.
The formation of compartments is ascertained by the entanglement of polymeric chains at the surface of the new-phase particles due to the partially overlapping excluded volumes of the crowder and capping molecules. This interaction is of entropic nature and creates a depletion zone expelling the crowder molecules. In contrast, the depletion zones trap the monomers by maintaining a dynamic balance between their diffusion along the concentration gradient toward the bulk solution and the driving force by the entropic gain of their localization in the depletion zone.
The caging of monomers inside the compartments constrains their random distribution in the phase space; hence, their configurational entropy is reduced with respect to the unconstrained case of dilute solutions. The chemical potential of the monomers in the solution phase should also increase accordingly,34 which leads to higher transition probabilities through the activation barrier; therefore, less free energy is required to reach the transition states. The outlined approach can reasonably be phrased as structural catalysis induced by the compartmentalized space of MMC.
We outlined a possible explanation for the crowding-induced enhancement of nanowire growth on the basis of the association–dissociation reaction scheme and the non-specific structural organization of the crowded media. Associative processes may be governed by the complex kinematics due to space compartmentalization localized to the active surfaces of the new-phase particles, ultimately leading to a catalysed process in the limit of thermodynamic control.
Motivated by the presented methodology, the effect of MMC on the synthesis of tellurium nanowires as a specific model system for investigating phase transitions and phase behaviour in a more general sense is proposed to be tested by further experimental and simulation studies, which potentially give rise to a more fundamental understanding of crowded systems.
| This journal is © the Owner Societies 2017 |