Xiang Liua,
Yuan Lib,
Lan Jia*a,
Song Chen*a and
Yinghua Shenc
aKey Laboratory of Interface Science and Engineering in Advanced Materials, Ministry of Education, College of Material Science and Engineering, Taiyuan University of Technology, Taiyuan, 030024, China. E-mail: liuxiang030024@126.com; jialan@tyut.edu.com; chensong@tyut.edu.cn
bHangzhou AmpleSun Solar Technology Co. Ltd, No. 12 Street, Export Processing Zone, Xiasha Economical Developing Area, Hangzhou, 310018, P. R. China. E-mail: liyuan_zj@163.com
cCollege of Chemistry Science and Engineering, Taiyuan University of Technology, Taiyuan, 030024, China. E-mail: shenyinghua@tyut.edu.cn
First published on 19th September 2016
A facile and ultrasensitive fluorometric assay for trypsin detection was successfully established on the basis of surfactant/protamine/fluorescent hydrophobic dye assemblies. The supramolecular micellar-type assemblies were obtained by mixing the positively charged protein protamine as the substrate of trypsin with the anionic surfactant sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) at a level lower than its critical micelle concentration (CMC), and their apolar interiors could sequester several types of the representative hydrophobic fluorescent dyes such as Nile red, pyrene, and coumarin 6. It was found that the supramolecular assemblies exhibited a high specificity towards trypsin and its stability had a significant effect on the fluorescent intensity of the sequestered dyes. The addition of trypsin into the assembly system led to the dissociation of the assemblies and the decrease of the fluorescent intensity of the dye, which was exploited for trypsin detection and inhibitor screening. A detection level down to 0.044 ng mL−1 was obtained for trypsin. Moreover, the emission wavelength and detection range could be tuned by simply varying the type of fluorescent dye.
Numerous methods for trypsin detection are available, including enzyme linked immunosorbent assay,6 MS,7 gel electrophoresis,8 radioimmunoassay,9 electrochemical assay,10 quartz crystal microbalance (QCM) sensing,11 surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS),12 and optical detection using nanomaterials13–15 and organic fluorescent probes.16–18 Among them, the fluorescent approach has attracted more attention because of its low-cost, operational simplicity, high sensitivity, and real-time detection. This technique is somewhat limited by the fluorogenic substrates, usually the labeled molecular beacons or peptides, which were expensive and difficult to synthesize.
Self-assembling and self-organizing methodologies have been extensively used to construct the fluorescent chemosensors.19 Following these strategies, the subunits can be separately designed and synthesized, and then easily combine to produce the sensing system. The assay of trypsin activity has been achieved by integrating different substrates with signal-enhancing reporters (e.g., aggregation-induced emission (AIE) molecules,20,21 conjugated polymers,22–24 quantum dots25,26 or fluorescent dye derivatives16–18) through non-covalent interaction. These popular methods are simple, flexible and sensitive; however, the preparation of these fluorescent reporters still involved laborious synthesis procedures.
Supramolecular assemblies from surfactants are of interest because of their container properties in aqueous solutions.27 Depending on the micellar form template provided by surfactant, the fluorescent reporter and the substrate do not interact directly and the communication between them is ensured only by their spatial closeness.19 The metal ions27,28 and proteins pattern sensing29,30 have been realized based on the surfactants–ligands and surfactants–polymers assemblies, respectively. However, there are few reports related to enzyme assaying.
In the present study, a facile fluorometric system was constructed for trypsin activity assay and inhibitor screening. The design rationale is illustrated in Scheme 1. The positively charged protamine was designed not only as the substrate of trypsin, but also as the building block of the supramolecular assemblies. Protamine would form micellar-type assemblies with anionic surfactant sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) at a level lower than the critical micelle concentration (CMC). The combination should provide supramolecular assemblies with apolar interiors that could sequester hydrophobic dye (Nile red, pyrene, or coumarin 6) molecules. The hydrophobic dye was used as the reporter and converted binding events into fluorescent signals.
![]() | ||
Scheme 1 Scheme of the SDS/protamine/dye assembly and the disassembly induced by trypsin-catalyzed hydrolysis. |
The hydrolysis of protamine into short peptides was facilitated by trypsin addition; consequently, the SDS/protamine/dye assemblies disassembled, and the fluorescence intensity reduced obviously as the hydrophobic dye was released. In the presence of inhibitors, protamine hydrolysis would be retarded and a slight fluorescence intensity decrease would be observed. Thus, the assembly system could also be used to screen the inhibitors of trypsin.
This supramolecular assembly fluorescence system shows several advantages: first, the realization and optimization of florescent sensing system are quite easy to realize. Second, the present design strategy exhibits a wide applicability to various targets. The system could be applied to fabricate new sensors that target different molecules by replacing the receptor units with the appropriate surfactant. Third, a variety of fluorophores could be used to work as the fluorescent reporter. Thus, the emission and the detection wavelengths of the sensing system are tunable.
For trypsin activity assay, different amounts of trypsin (1 × 10−8 to 0.05 mg mL−1) were added to the solutions of supramolecular assemblies and the fluorescence intensities of the mixture were measured every minute during hydrolysis (up to 30 min).
Other proteins, including BSA, papain, pepsin and lysozyme, were also tested under the same conditions to investigate the selectivity of the system towards trypsin.
Inhibition efficiency was estimated as follows:
Inhibition efficiency = (Fi − Fn)/(F0 − Fn) × 100 |
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Plot of the I630 of NR emission spectra as a function of the logarithm concentration of SDS in Tris–HCl buffer (10 mM, pH = 8.0). |
The critical aggregation concentration (CAC) of surfactants decreases when polyelectrolytes act as counterions.29,30 Protamine is a highly cationic protein that possesses a high content of basic amino acids, about 50% of which are arginine residues. This attribute renders protamine an attractive and widely used substrate for trypsin-like serine proteases,10,14,20 cleaving polypeptide mainly at the carboxyl side of lysine or arginine. In the present study, protamine was used as the substrate of trypsin, which could form assemblies with SDS. The fluorescence property of protamine itself with NR was investigated. The peak intensities of the protamine solutions remained about the same with increasing protamine concentration (Fig. 2). This result indicates that protamine would not form assemblies or aggregation by itself.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Plot of the I630 as a function of logarithm concentrations of protamine in SDS–protamine and protamine solutions. The inset is the TEM image of the assemblies. |
To obtain the assemblies of SDS–protamine and avoid the formation of SDS micelles, the concentration of SDS was set to lower than its CMC (e.g., 0.3 mM). Interaction between protamine and SDS were demonstrated by fluorescence enhancement and TEM images. When protamine was added to the SDS–NR solution, the fluorescence emission gradually increased with increasing protamine concentration. This result indicates that the supramolecular assemblies of SDS–protamine may be produced through electrostatic interaction (Fig. 2). TEM images show the presence of spherical nanoparticles with a diameter of ∼70 nm in the SDS–protamine solution (inset in Fig. 2). This result confirms the formation of micellar-type assemblies. To obtain stable assemblies, the critical concentration of protamine was determined to be 0.06 mg mL−1 from the second inflection point. The supramolecular assembly system composed of 0.3 mM SDS, 60 μg mL−1 protamine and 1 μM NR was selected for the following examination.
Protamine could be enzymatically cleaved into fragments with decreased charge and molecular weight. Hence, protein length may be a key factor contributing to supramolecular assembly formation. Oligo–polyarginines (such as Arg5,32 Arg6,13 or Arg8 (ref. 33)) could also be used as the substrate of trypsin. In this study, the coassembly behavior of SDS and the arginine-rich peptide Arg8 also was tested.
In contrast to the peak intensity of 0.3 mM SDS–NR, the peak intensity of the SDS/Arg8/NR solution enhanced by about 10 fold when the concentration of Arg8 exceeded 0.2 mg mL−1, whereas that of the SDS/protamine/NR solution enhanced by about 16 fold with the same concentration of protamine (Fig. S3†). Compared with the SDS/protamine/NR system, the SDS/Arg8/NR system showed less fluorescence increases. In addition, the critical concentration of Arg8 was increased to 0.2 mg mL−1, which corresponded to 0.3 mM SDS.
The peptide Arg8 was less efficient than protamine in promoting the formation of supramolecular assemblies possibly because of the shorter chain of the former than the later peptide. However, Arg8 demonstrated a remarkable fluorescence enhancement effect. Whether Arg8 could be used as a receptor unit needs further verification.
To clarify the contribution of electrostatic interaction between protein and SDS/protamine/NR to fluoresce quenching, control experiments were conducted. The fluorescence emission spectra of NR and SDS/NR responding to various protein with different pI values, including BSA (pI 4.7–5.3), lysozyme (pI 11), pepsin (pI 1), papain (pI 8.75), protamine (pI 10–12) and trypsin (pI 10.5), were investigated. All of the fluorescence intensities were quite low in protein/NR systems (Fig. S4a†) except that BSA induced certain fluorescence enhancement, this might be ascribed to the fact that the hydrophobic pocket of BSA could sequester NR and thus the fluorescence intensity increased.30 Positively charged lysozyme induced obvious enhancement as protamine (Fig. S4b†), which might due to the electrostatic interaction as these two proteins had similar pI values, and papain induced slightly increment with lower pI value. However, trypsin induced no changes in the fluorescence emission of SDS–NR. Hence, electrostatic binding was not the sole driving force for the formation of assembly, the structure of protein might also play important role.
We hypothesized that the emission quenching originated from trypsin-trigged disassembly, which were studied by ζ-potential and TEM. The ζ-potential decreased from negative (−15.7 mV) to nearly neutral (−3.91 mV) as the protamine concentration increased (Table S1†). After enzyme treatment, the ζ-potential was found to be −16.6 mV, close to the value of SDS, suggesting the dissociation of SDS/protamine/NR assembly. In addition, trypsin cleavage-induced disassembly was also confirmed by TEM images, wherein no self-assembly particles were observed after trypsin digestion (Fig. S5†).
As shown in Fig. 3b, the quenching efficiency of the assemblies at 630 nm obviously increased with increasing trypsin concentration until a plateau was reached after 1 μg mL−1. The inset is a calibration curve that corresponds with the analysis of trypsin. A linear relationship between quenching efficiency and trypsin concentration was observed over the enzyme concentration of 0.01–0.1 ng mL−1. The limit of detection (LOD) was calculated to be 0.044 ng mL−1 (S/N = 3). A comparison between the proposed method and other reported methods for trypsin determination in detection limit and linear range was summed up in Table 1. It could be seen from Table 1 that the sensitivity of this proposed method was the lowest among the best trypsin assays reported.12,14,17,18,34
Method | Linear range | Detection limit | Reference |
---|---|---|---|
Electrochemistry | 5–150 ng mL−1 | 1.8 ng mL−1 | 10 |
SERS | 0.1–10![]() |
0.1 ng mL−1 | 12 |
Colorimetric | — | 1.6 ng mL−1 | 14 |
Fluorimetry | 0.1–1000 ng mL−1 | 0.048 ng mL−1 | 15 |
Fluorimetry | — | 0.5 μg mL−1 | 16 |
Fluorimetry | 0–60 mU mL−1 | 0.5 mU mL−1 | 17 |
Fluorimetry | 0.005–2 nM | 0.006 nM | 18 |
Fluorimetry | 1.25–375 nM | 0.42 nM | 25 |
Fluorimetry | 0.01–100 μg mL−1 | 2 ng m−1 (86 pM) | 34 |
Fluorimetry | 0.01–0.1 ng mL−1 | 0.044 ng mL−1 | This work |
Protamine could form assemblies with different kinds of reporters, such as organic fluorescent probes (pyrene derivative,16 benzoperylene,17 perylene18), nanoclusters (DNA hosted Cu nanoclusters15) and quantum dots,26 via electrostatic interactions to monitor the trypsin activity. Compared with these reports, our system achieved a lower or comparable detection limit without synthetic process.
The fluorescent response was examined using Arg8. Interestingly, no significant fluorescence quenching (∼10%) was observed when 0.05 mg mL−1 trypsin was added to the SDS–Arg8 solution (Fig. S6†). The SDS/Arg8/NR system was not practical for trypsin activity sensing. In some studies, oligo–polyarginines (such as Arg5,32 Arg6 (ref. 13) or Arg8 (ref. 33)) were utilized to assay trypsin enzymatic activity as the substrate of trypsin with conjugated polymers or AIE molecules. Moreover, the five-mer peptide (i.e., Arg5) was reported to be of critical length for trypsin-catalyzed hydrolysis with anionic conjugated polyelectrolyte (PPESO3).23 In our system, however, although Arg8 was highly positive and could electrostatically interact with SDS, the short peptide chain rendered Arg8 inefficient at sensing trypsin. These results indicate the polymer-analogue structure of the protamine is indispensible in our sensing system.
To demonstrate the potential of the SDS/protamine/NR system in monitoring trypsin activity in real time, we studied the fluorescence quenching of the assembly system at 630 nm as a function of trypsin concentration (Fig. 4). A gradual fluorescence decrease dependent on trypsin concentration was observed.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Real-time fluorescence intensity changes of SDS/protamine/NR assemblies at different trypsin concentrations. |
Fluorescent sensing systems with tunable detection wavelengths might be desirable for specific use.35 Commonly used fluorescence probes pyrene and coumarin 6 (ref. 13 and 14) were selected as the reporter unit for this study. Consistent with the use of NR as the probe, both of the fluorescence intensities of the assemblies with pyrene and coumarin 6 gradually decreased with increasing trypsin concentration (Fig. S7†). The emission maxima for coumarin 6 and pyrene were 502 nm and 391 nm, respectively. Compared with that of NR, the linear range of determination of trypsin widened with pyrene and coumarin 6 from 0.01 ng mL−1 to 0.5 ng mL−1 for both dyes (Fig. 5). Pyrene and coumarin 6 could achieve good detection sensitivity, as evidenced by the respective LODs of 0.09 ng mL−1 and 0.48 ng mL−1, which were higher than that of NR.
These results demonstrate that the modular nature of the assemblies enabled the tuning of the emission wavelength and detection range by simply varying the type of reporter in the disassembly-based sensing. With this strategy, the preparation and optimization of the fluorescent system were easily realized. All three components of the assemblies could be naturally changed, and an optimum combination for specific use exists. For example, pyrene and coumarin 6 were inferior to NR as the fluorescent reporter, and Arg8 was a less efficient substrate than protamine. The surfactant also played a significant role; further work is now under way along these lines.
The quenching efficiencies of the supramolecular assemblies in the presence of other proteins, such as papain, pepsin, lysozyme and BSA, were recorded to investigate the selectivity of this fluorometric trypsin assay. The concentration of each enzyme was maintained at 0.05 mg mL−1, and each solution was incubated for 30 min under the same conditions as those for trypsin. The peak emission intensity of the supramolecular assemblies at 630 nm was reduced largely only after trypsin addition (Fig. 7). The intensities were only slightly reduced or increased in the presence of other proteins. The sensing system exhibited a high specificity toward trypsin.
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 Quenching efficiency of formed assemblies at 630 nm with different proteins. The concentration of each protein was 0.05 mg mL−1. |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: The fluorescence enhancement of SDS–protamine and SDS–Arg8 with increasing concentrations of protamine and Arg8 respectively; fluorescence emission spectra of SDS–Arg8–NR and SDS–Arg8–NR + trypsin; fluorescence emission spectra of different hydrophobic dyes in SDS/protamine assemblies. See DOI: 10.1039/c6ra19220c |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2016 |