Genbai Chua,
Feng Lua,
Jianting Xina,
Tao Xia,
Min Shui*a,
Weihua Hea,
Yuqiu Gu*a,
Ying Xiongb,
Kemei Chengb and
Tao Xub
aScience and Technology on Plasma Physics Laboratory, Research Center of Laser Fusion, China Academy of Engineering Physics, Mianyang 621900, P. R. China. E-mail: shm@caep.cn; yqgu@caep.cn
bInstitute of Chemical Materials, China Academy of Engineering Physics, Mianyang 621900, P. R. China
First published on 1st June 2016
Insights into the excited-state dynamics and electron transfer processes of nitro explosives offer an efficient tool for unravelling ultrafast and complex detonation physics. In this work, the excited state dynamics and electron transfer processes of 1,3,5-triamino-2,4,6-trinitrobenzene (TATB) were studied using femtosecond transient absorption spectroscopy and time-dependent density functional theory. The de-excitation of TATB after excitation at 400 nm involves an equilibrium between the vibrationally hot S1 (S*1) and S1 states, with lifetimes of 0.64 and 6 ps, respectively. After vertical excitation, the electron density is transferred from the C-ring and NH2 group to NO2 groups. The excitation energy activates the nitro groups, and energy is redistributed via their nuclear motion. The relaxation of the initial S*1 state shows an apparent structural change occurring at one activated nitro group, which becomes further twisted from the planar benzene ring and relaxes to the S1–T1 conical intersection. The T1 state is populated via the minimal intersystem crossing through the S1–T1 intersection. The nitro group charge transfer process is then explored following the ultrafast structural change. This study advances our understanding of photo-initiated reactions as well as the ignition of energetic materials.
Energetic materials (EMs) are organic compounds with substantial amounts of stored chemical energy that can be released under extreme conditions, such as exposure to photons, shock, or rapid heating.13,14 EMs, which include fuels and explosives, are widely utilized in many fields; however, their useful energy conversion features have associated problems of safety, reliability, and application.15 On the molecular level, very little is known about the dynamic responses of these materials. For example, electronic excitation plays a crucial role in the energy conversion processes of EMs. Insights into the excited-state dynamics of these materials and their electron transfer behaviours would potentially allow us to unravel these inherent mechanisms, and would also have implications for the behaviour of other nitro derivatives.
Among EMs, nitro explosives constitute the major class. The introduction of a nitro group into a molecule greatly changes its photo-physical behaviour, and can impact the molecular stability and impact sensitivity.16,17 The electronically excited state of a nitro-containing species undergoes ultrafast intersystem crossing and exhibits a high quantum yield of the triplet state. For example, de-excitation of the nitrostilbene derivative, 2,2′,4,4′,6,6′-hexanitrostilbene (HNS), was revealed to involve a major change from the S1 to the T1 state with a lifetime of 6 ps.18 It is essential to understand the photo-induced behaviour of nitro-containing species. As a type of nitro explosive, 1,3,5-triamino-2,4,6-trinitrobenzene (TATB) is of particular interest because, although it is relatively stable to external stimuli such as heat, impact, and shock,19–21 it is a photo-sensitive EM that exhibits colour changes under light irradiation.22 A study of the evolution of the excited states and photo-induced electron transfer of TATB is crucial to understanding the importance of nitro groups and EMs ignition.
In this work, we present an experimental and theoretical investigation of the excited-state dynamics and electron transfer processes of TATB. The initial S*1 state of TATB and its evolution into the S1 state with lifetimes of 0.64 and 6 ps, respectively, were observed using femtosecond transient absorption spectroscopy at an excitation wavelength of 400 nm. The structural relaxation that occurs as the S*1 state evolves to the S1 state, with the apparent structural change occurring at a nitro group, was investigated using the time-dependent density functional theory (TD-DFT) method at the B3LYP/6-311++G(d,p) level. An S1–T1 conical intersection was suggested to enhance the efficiency of intersystem crossing. The electron distribution was also evaluated in order to explain the structural change. Ultrafast nitro group charge transfer (Qnitro), which occurs subsequent to the structural changes, was also explored. The study advances our understanding of ultrafast electron transfer in EMs.
The typical equipment used to obtain transient absorption spectra has been described previously.11,23 Briefly, a laser system generates fundamental femtosecond pulses at 800 nm, with a pulse duration of 35 fs, energy per pulse of 1 mJ, and repetition rate of 1 kHz. As the pump beam, the third harmonics (266 nm) of the fundamental pulses were attenuated to ∼5 μJ. The white-light-continuum (WLC) pulses from a CaF2 crystal were used as the probe beam, with a spectral range of 440–640 nm. The pump-probe pulses were organized as follows: the pump-pulse beam was lead and collimated onto the sample cell (1 mm optical pathlength). The probe-pulse beam passed through an optical delay line, and then was split into two parts by a metallic beam splitter. One part was collimated and overlapped with the pump-pulse in the sample cell. The other was collimated into the sample cell at a different spot as a reference signal, to improve sensitivity. The polarization plane of the probe pulses was rotated by a λ/2 plate, and a magic angle (54.7°) configuration between the pump and probe pulses was adopted in all the measurements. Given the speed of light (3 × 108 m s−1), the delay time was varied up to 500 ps with a minimum interval of 2.08 fs. The probe-pulse beam was dispersed by a grating inside the spectrometer (Princeton, SpectraPro 2500i) and detected by a two-dimensional CCD detector (PI-MAX, 1024 × 256 pixel array). On the CCD surface, two image signal stripes were formed, one from the probe and the other from the reference. Each of these signals was sent to a computer through a 16-bit analog-to-digital converter (ADC). The data acquisition and experiment control were performed via the LabView program. A low noise level (<2 mOD) could be achieved by averaging approximately 1600 pulses. The instrumental response of the system was determined to be ∼180 fs by cross-section measurements between the pump and probe pulses. The chirp of the WLC was measured at the position of the sample cell by using the optical Kerr effect of the solvent; this value was used to correct the dispersion of the relative delay time in the time-resolved data. The stimulated emission, ground state bleach, and dark response were eliminated by logical collections, by the use of two shutters. The absorption of excited states, transient products, and long-lived molecular states such as triplet state would acquire ΔA > 0, while the bleaching of the ground state absorption and stimulated emission are obtained for ΔA < 0. Therefore, the spectral changes could be sometimes complicated and required special methods to accurately analyse the time-resolved data.
The TD-DFT method at the B3LYP/6-311++g(d,p) level was employed to calculate the vertical excitation energies and optimize the structures in the ground (S0) and first singlet excited (S1) states.24 The first triplet excited (T1) state was also obtained at this level by changing the spin multiplicity. The natural population analysis (NPA) charge was utilized in this study. The absorption spectra were obtained at the wb97xd/cc-pVTZ level. The Kohn–Sham orbitals, orbital energies, and density-of-states (DOS) spectra were also obtained at this level, to avoid the effects of a diffuse basis function. All the calculations were performed using Gaussian 09 software.25 Although TD-DFT was not as accurate as multi-configuration methods such as the complete-active-space self-consistent field (CASSCF) method, TD-DFT provided reliable results for the related states of this molecule, according to our tests, because it had no multi-configuration effects. It should be pointed out that the TD-B3LYP method is not well suited for searching for an intersection point, and the CASSCF method is too expensive for performing such calculations. The molecular orbitals, electron distributions, and DOS spectra were obtained using a wave function analyser (Multi-wfn).26
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 The structure of TATB in the S0 state (TA-S0), and the highest occupied molecular orbitals (HOMOs) and the lowest unoccupied molecular orbitals (LUMOs). |
The total, partial, and overlap density-of-states (TDOS, PDOS, and OPDOS) for TATB are shown in Fig. 2. In the TDOS map, each discrete vertical line corresponds to a molecular orbital (MO). The curve for the TDOS was simulated based on the distribution of MO energy levels. From the PDOS, it is clear that the nitro groups contribute the most to the valence MOs. In the range from −10.0 to −7.5 eV, there are comparable contributions from the C-ring and NH2 groups. However, the contributions are reduced to a low level in the range from −3.0 to 0.0 eV. The OPDOS is negative in the −3.0–0.0 eV range, which indicates the anti-bonding orbitals between the NO2 groups and other moieties. The DOS curves also show that the low-lying excitation process can be assigned as an n → π* transition.
In the experimentally obtained steady-state absorption spectrum of TATB in DMSO, there is a wide band centred at 357 nm, which extends to the 450 nm range28 (Fig. 3). The extension of the experimental absorption results from the “hot band” effect that occurs at room temperature and weak interactions in solution, such as intramolecular and intermolecular H bonds. The band is centred at 301 nm in the calculated spectrum, which is lower than that observed experimentally. This may be explained by an overestimation of the excitation energy by the TD-DFT method. However, this discrepancy does not affect the general discussion in this work. From the orbital information above, the peak can be assigned as an n → π* transition (S1 state),which is Franck–Condon-state-accessible from the vibrational ground state configuration. At 400 nm, the strong absorption efficiency indicates the vertical excitation from the contribution of MO pairs of the low-lying transition dipole moment. Thus, from the calculations in this paper, the ultraviolet excitation at 400 nm (3.10 eV) suggests that TATB molecules are vertically excited to the S1 surface from the vibrational ground state.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 (a) Evolution-associated difference spectra (EADS) resulting from a global analysis of the transient absorption experiments on TATB. Dynamics traces recorded at (b) 600 and (c) 450 nm. |
Dynamics traces recorded at 600 nm (upper panel) and 450 nm (lower panel) are presented in Fig. 4b and c, respectively. Here, the lifetimes were fitted with a convolution of a Gaussian-type instrumental response function and an exponential decay rate. The obtained lifetimes for the S*1 and S1 states are 0.64 and 6.0 ps, respectively, from the best fits of the two curves. The former value is in agreement with those observed for the S*1 → S1 transitions of HNS18 (0.8 ps), carotenoids11 (0.9 ps), and trans-4-aminoazobeneze23 (0.7 ps). The S1 state lifetime accords well with that observed for the S1 → T1 transition of HNS18 (6 ps) and the S1 → S* transition of o-nitroaniline29 (6.4 ps).
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 (Upper) LUMO-4 and LUMO-6 of TA-S0, together with (Lower) the geometrical structure, LUMO-1, LUMO-4, and LUMO-6 of TA-S1. |
The initial excitation energy, after making the NO2 groups active, is redistributed via the nuclear motion of the active nitro group (i.e. relaxation). Relative to TA-S0, the C(5)–N(10) bond and two N(10)–O(11,12) bonds of TA-S1 are lengthened by about 0.04 Å, respectively. Also, the energy of TA-S1 in the S1 state is 3.42 eV, a reduction of 0.25 eV. The apparent change is suggested to be due primarily the vibrational cooling of the vs. (NO2) mode. The electron density is mainly distributed in LUMO-1 of the active nitro group in TA-S1, which is much different from that of TA-S0; this further indicates an electron has been transferred into the active nitro group in the relaxation process. Thus, it is still feasible that the electron can be re-excited to LUMO-6 from LUMO-1, based on the electron distribution in Fig. 5. However, the re-excitation of LUMO-1 to LUMO-4 is infeasible because of the electron transfer in the relaxation process. Referring to the EADS in Fig. 4, the feasible re-excitation corresponds to the blue shift of the peak at 470 to 450 nm, while the infeasible re-excitation corresponds to the disappearance of the absorption peak at 600 nm.
The bond of the active NO2 group, which exhibits π* character, becomes further twisted from the planar benzene ring. After optimization, TA-S′1 in the S1 state exhibits a dihedral C(4)C(5)N(10)O(12) twist of 69.7° and a dihedral C(6)C(5)N(10)O(11) twist of 104°. The electron density is mainly distributed in the NO2 group with the deviated structure in Fig. 6, as LUMO-1 of TA-S′1. The energy of the LUMO is reduced to −2.36 eV, and the energy of TA-S′1 in the S1 state is greatly reduced to 2.25 eV. In the meantime, the energy of TA-S′1 in the T1 state is calculated as 2.43 eV, slightly higher than that in the S1 state. This means that the TA-S′1 structure is close to the point of the S1–T1 conical intersection, which is suggested to enhance the efficiency of intersystem crossing and greatly reduce the lifetime of the transition.30 Thus, the T1 state can be easily populated via a minimal intersystem crossing from the S1 state. The TA-T1 structure was also optimized, and displayed the electron distribution in the deviated NO2 group, in good agreement with the foregoing discussion. The dihedral C(4)C(5)N(10)O(12) twists to 46.9° and the dihedral C(6)C(5)N(10)O(11) twists to 84.2°, such that O(11) is nearly perpendicular to the benzene ring. The energy of TA-T1 in the T1 state is 2.30 eV, much lower than that on the S1 surface.
To summarize, the NO2 groups in TATB are activated after vertical excitation to the S1 state, which show their π* bond character. Then, they are relaxed via the vibrational cooling of one active nitro group, leading to TA-S1 in the S1 state. The nitro group is further twisted from the planar benzene ring so as to approach the S1–T1 conical intersection. The T1 state is then populated via minimal intersystem crossing. Overall, the electron distribution spectra provide a new insight into the de-excitation process.
Structure | State | Energy | Qnitro | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Site 1 | Site 2 | Site 3 | Average | |||
TA-S0 | S0 | 0.00 | 0.397 | 0.397 | 0.397 | 0.397 |
S1 | 3.67 | 0.459 | 0.459 | 0.459 | 0.459 | |
TA-S1 | S0 | 0.40 | 0.389 | 0.392 | 0.392 | 0.391 |
S1 | 3.42 | 0.727 | 0.339 | 0.339 | 0.468 | |
TA-S′1 | S1 | 2.25 | 0.887 | 0.363 | 0.364 | 0.538 |
T1 | 2.43 | 0.645 | 0.375 | 0.372 | 0.464 | |
TA-T1 | T1 | 2.30 | 0.598 | 0.380 | 0.381 | 0.453 |
The initial Qnitro values at the three sites are 0.397, 0.397, and 0.397 (−e), respectively. After excitation, they increase to 0.459, 0.459, and 0.459 (−e), respectively, indicating charge transfer from the benzene ring to the three nitro groups. In the relaxation process of the initial excited state, Qnitro is transferred from the other two sites to Site 1. The overall Qnitro does not change significantly in the redistribution process, but Qnitro at Site 1 increases to as high as 0.727 (−e). It is noted that the Qnitro distribution at the three sites of TA-S1 in the S1 state is different from that in the S0 state, mainly at Site 1. This result comports with the deviation of the NO2 group taking place on the S1 rather than the S0 surface. Subsequently, the Qnitro transfer process involves mainly the decrease of Qnitro at Site 1 via deviation of the NO2 group. The Qnitro at Site 1 decreases to 0.645 (−e) in the T1 state of TA-S′1, rather than 0.887 (−e) in the S1 state. Furthermore, the Qnitro at Site 1 decreases to 0.598 (−e) in succession without significant change at the other two sites.
Overall, the ultrafast Qnitro transfer process involves (a) an initial increase after excitation, then (b) redistribution from the first two sites to Site 1, and (c) a decrease at Site 1 via the deviation of the NO2 group. The Qnitro transfer process is also in accord with the NO2 group deviation on the S1 surface rather than on the S0 surface. This study of the dynamic response of EMs upon excitation shows potential application for the exploration of EMs under other extreme conditions.
The nitro group plays an important role in the initial reactions of nitro explosives. The excitation and relaxation processes that take place with other explosives such as RDX, HMX, CL20, and PETN have also been investigated.34 These exhibit similar behaviours, and their impact sensitivity was found to be related to the excitation energy of the relaxed structure. Consequently, other characteristics also influence the impact sensitivity of these EMs, including their crystal, surface, and interfacial structures. These characteristics should clearly be considered in future work.
Importantly, there are several differences between nitro derivatives and nitro explosives. Nitro explosives usually have a symmetrical structure with many nitro groups. The influence of the nitro group son the photo-physical behaviour of the materials is distinct and clear. Nitro derivatives have fewer nitro groups than nitro explosives. In the low-lying unoccupied orbitals, the nitro group can be conjugated with other groups, such as aromatic rings and NH2. Such nitro groups exhibit distinct photo-physical behaviours depending on their geometrical arrangement and electron distribution.24,35,36
Thus, the introduction of a nitro group into a molecule greatly changes the photo-physical behaviour of the derivative, and studies of the excited-state dynamics and electron transfer processes can effectively serve to unravel the ultrafast and inherently complex changes that occur.
The initial S*1 state was observed at an excitation of 400 nm, with two peaks centred at 470 and 600 nm. This state evolved into the S1 state, with a peak at 450 nm from EADS. The lifetimes of the two states were found to be 0.64 and 6 ps, respectively. The electron density was transferred from the C-ring and NH2 groups to the NO2 groups after vertical excitation. The excitation energy activated the nitro groups and was then redistributed via their nuclear motion. The structural relaxation of the initial S*1 state revealed that the electron density was mainly distributed in the activated nitro group. Then, the active nitro group was further deviated from coplanarity with the benzene ring and relaxed to the S1–T1 conical intersection point. The T1 state was suggested to be populated via minimal intersystem crossing through the S1–T1 intersection. The electron distribution spectra provided a new insight into the de-excitation process. This study advances our understanding of photon-initiated reactions and EM ignition processes.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c6ra11584e |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2016 |