You you Yaoa and
Jing Liu*ab
aDepartment of Biomedical Engineering, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, PR China. E-mail: yaoyy14@mails.tsinghua.edu.cn; jliubme@mail.tsinghua.edu.cn; Tel: +86 010 62798963
bTechnical Institute of Physics and Chemistry, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100084, PR China
First published on 6th June 2016
Miniaturized-vehicles are witnessing an increasing demand in many areas such as lab-on-chip, flexible fabrication, micro fluidics and small object manipulation. Lots of effort has therefore been made to build a small-scale, controllable, robust and adaptable carrying vehicle. To explore an alternative way, an innovative vehicle driven by liquid metal droplet “wheels” is presented with a geometric size in the millimeter scale. Unlike former trials, this vehicle is a movable structure composed of soft wheels and a rigid body. Such a hybrid construction adapts to multiple electrolytes especially NaOH solution. Under variable conditions of electrical voltages and channels, the present vehicle can be controlled precisely to achieve progression, steering and more complex locomotion. With a boat-like core body, the vehicle can take burdens up to 0.4 gram at a speed of about 25 mm s−1. More sophisticated vehicles with integrated manipulators and power supplies could still be built based on the current attempt. This kind of vehicle design realizes complex and accurate control as well as driving of a miniaturized robotic structure. The present finding may shed light on the construction of further complex miniaturized machines or robots in the future.
Based on these motors, functional devices or carrying vehicles can be further developed. An intuitive idea is to attach target objects onto motors through electroplate or incubate techniques. Researchers in biomedical and pharmaceutical areas tend to work on this way since it can delivery drugs or modified bio-molecules with micro-scale maneuverability. In most cases, vehicles and burdens are closely integrated with no distinct interfaces, while the whole systems are powered by catalytic chemical reaction which can lead to consumption of metal electrodes. A relatively larger vessel was also devised. Diller and Sitti proposed magnetic robotic small-grippers of a customized U-shape which is manufactured by rubber molding.3 External magnetic field is needed in this particular example which can control the position, orientation and opening/closing state of grippers. In view of associating and aligning these different types of small-vehicles, we can further depict a vision of micro-factory concept.2,3 Differing from its counterpart in real industry, micro-factories have much smaller transporters, manipulators and grippers. Comprised of basic elements such as power supply, transportation, manufacture and assembly, miniaturized-factory can perform significant roles in many fields such as medicine test, cell culture, lab-on-chip and so on.
In this article we proposed a new kind of millimeter scale boat like vehicles driven by soft liquid metal wheels immersed in aqueous solutions and powered by exterior electric fields. Eutectic gallium-indium (EGaIn) liquid metal is a metal material which has a room temperature melting point and is basically composed of gallium and indium elements. Previous works have shown that liquid metal droplets can swim, swirl and deform in electrolytes based on Marangoni effect and surface tension asymmetry.14–16 Regarding liquid metal droplets as variable motors,17,18 they can be exploited as soft and compliant wheels of the miniaturized vehicles. Such assembly will accommodate the design of complex body structures as the power source can be switched from external electric field to interior button cells. In our approach, 3D printing technology is implemented to fabricate the rigid body of the vehicle. Carrying capability can be up to 0.4 gram with overall dimensions of 10 to 20 mm. Both fabrication and actuation methods can be improved in order to build vehicles of different sizes to meet varied tasks.
According to previous research,14 when an external electricfield is applied onto the electrolyte, liquid metal droplet dipping in the solution can be driven by asymmetry of surface tension. On the basis of Lippmann's equation, one has
![]() | (1) |
Fig. 1(c) exhibits the locomotion trajectory with a fixed time interval of 0.2 s, from which it can be noticed that the vehicle orientation would veer accordingly (orientation is labeled by red arrows along with trajectory, which is shown in the up down zoom-in view of vehicle, Fig. 1(b)). Instantaneous speed ranges from 0 to 77 mm s−1, which is spotted in upper right of Fig. 1(c). The distortion of the trajectory can be interpreted by slight unevenness of viscous friction between different legs and aqueous solution, frictional resistance between legs and Petri dish, along with irregular glass bottom. The shape of the trajectory varies within repeated experiments.
When droplets attach and wet copper rods surface, after applying an exterior electric potential, aforementioned liquid metal locomotion can be delivered to the rods through a dragging force. For our liquid metal vehicle, with four rods and four liquid metal droplets, the whole structure can be uniformly propelled by such locomotion.
To investigate the critical characteristics of vehicle locomotion and propulsion, a series of comparative experiments are conducted. First incremental voltages are applied starting from 15 V to 23 V with a step of 4 volts. While the electrolyte is 0.5 mol l−1 NaOH solution and the electrodes are placed at two extreme ends of PMMA channel. Power supply is a constant voltage source which can provide a highest voltage up to 30 V. To better demonstrate the locomotive velocity and direction, a black letter Y signature is drawn at the upper surface of transparent plastic sheet.
Before applying the step voltage, non-wheel structure is gently placed on the surface of water solution with a tweezer. The structure would be floated by solution surface tension just like gerridae standing on water surface. At the edge of sheet an obtuse contact angle (θ) can be observed, as is illustrated in Fig. 2(a). When the structure is immersed in aqueous solution, a syringe is used to inject liquid metal towards four copper rods, respectively. Liquid metal would wet the surface of copper and adhered to it stably. After four times of injection, the four-wheel liquid metal vehicle would be assembled completely and capable to voyage (Fig. 2(b)).
Fig. 2(c) demonstrated the continuous motion process of four wheel vehicle when applied with a 19 V electric potential. Center point of signature Y is utilized as the reference point to calculate horizontal displacement and velocity. There are three different forces affecting the vehicle structure,20 which are electric potential induced liquid metal propelling force, viscous friction between the structure and the basic solution, as well as friction between soft liquid metal wheels and PMMA substrate, respectively. For every single wheel, its propelling force is determined by liquid metal volume and adjacent electric field intensity. Considering that the precise size of each wheel cannot be strictly equivalent, and the electric field intensity is not uniformly distributed, the propelling forces of different wheels are thus unequal. Meantime, due to machining error, the friction between liquid metal wheel and PMMA channel bottom also varies according to the positions of contacting points. Taking above factors into account, the locomotive speeds of different wheels would be different, thus the vehicle would rotate and oscillate within open top channel. For instance, the upper two wheels have a higher speed compared with their lower counterparts, shown in Fig. 2(c). As a result, the letter Y signature yaws clockwise along with the plastic body and then becomes restricted by channel side wall. Such deflection happens occasionally and is dominated by the precise volumes of injected liquid metal wheels.
To depict the locomotive characteristics of liquid metal wheeled vehicle, displacements and instantaneous velocities are charted in Fig. 3(a and b) with applied voltages of 15 V, 19 V, 23 V, respectively. The positions and velocities are recorded every 0.08 s. From Fig. 3(a), we can see that the displacement of vehicle ascends gradually in any case. Whereas the red line (19 V) and blue line (23 V) are much closer to each other when compared to the black line (15 V). When the conducted voltage is lower than 15 V, the vehicle moves too slow to accomplish the entire distance of about 60 mm. It is obvious that the average speeds are not linearly related to voltage increases. To confirm such a dependency and eliminate the impact from stochastic factors, experiments are repeated with different voltage steps of 5 V and 3 V, respectively. The experimental process with 5 V voltage step is shown in ESI Movie S2.† There exists a quite similar phenomenon that displacement increase rates of 20 V and 25 V are much closer than the counterpart rates with 15 V (Fig. 4(a and b)). When applying a smaller voltage interval of 3 V, such regularity still remains (Fig. 4(c and d)). To further elucidate the phenomenon, instantaneous velocity diagram is shown in Fig. 3(b), from which it can be clearly noticed that the speeds of 15 V and 19 V are much closer and would intersect with each other at several points.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 (a) Displacements of the locomotion with different applied electrical potentials. (b) Instantaneous speeds of locomotion under different voltage conditions. |
Displacement and instantaneous velocity diagrams with voltage intervals of 5 V and 3 V are shown in Fig. 4(b and d). As a comparative result, displacements and instantaneous speeds data of a single liquid metal droplet locomotion are also illustrated in Fig. 4(e and f), from which the volume of droplet is 0.1 ml and the voltage increment is 3 V.
Here is a tentative further explanation of the phenomenon.21,22 The relation between propelling force and locomotive velocity, as well as the fluidic resistance force, needs to be clarified. First we need to evaluate the Reynolds number of solid vehicle structure swimming in the pool, which is the ratio of liquid inertia force and viscous force. It can be calculated by expression
![]() | (2) |
The Reynolds number of the system is much larger than 1. Utilizing the equation , which is carried out by Rayleigh, we can notice that the fluidic resistance FD is proportional to the flow velocity square V2 (ρ is the solution density, CD is the drag coefficient and A is the reference area). This indicates that when the speed increases, the resistance would ascend much faster. In view of that the propelling force is roughly linearly proportional to the voltage, then we can reach a conclusion that the speed would raise slower as the applied voltage increases. For a single liquid metal droplet, such interpretation is still appropriate (Fig. 4(e and f)).
From the instantaneous speed data, it can be noticed that the speed value oscillates up and down along the time axis. This is mainly due to the uneven surface of channel bottom which is CNC milled and has scratches distributed among the groove bottom. It can be proven by the fact that speed diagrams have quite close oscillating pattern and period if squeezing the speed lines horizontally according to the travelled distance, which means vibration happens at fixed positions of the channel. Meanwhile, the unbalance of body structure and fluidic perturbation would also contribute to the fluctuation of instantaneous speed values.
For each liquid metal soft wheel, its propelling force varies with the distances between the wheel and the electrodes, thus a controllable steering can be achieved by placing copper electrodes at asymmetrical positions of vehicle in a free space, as shown in Fig. 5(a). The four-wheel liquid metal vehicle stays still in a large glass Petri dish; the filled solution is 0.5 mol l−1 NaOH alkaline solution while the diameter of Petri dish is 10 cm.
The orientation of vehicle is defined as the pointing direction of the lower part of character “Y”. If one wishes to turn the direction of vehicle, for example, right hand rotation, he or she can put the anodic electrode at the right side of the front part of vehicle, while the cathode at the left side of the front part of vehicle. Obviously the front part is closer to copper electrodes and therefore has a stronger electric field intensity. Accordingly, the front two wheels would display a higher rightward directional propulsion and then the whole vehicle would rotate clockwise. Apparently left hand rotation can also be achieved in a similar way via exchanging the anode and cathode. Another way to approach directional rotation is to place electrodes closer to the rear part of the liquid metal vehicle, while in this case, anode needs to be put at the right side of rear part of vehicle to turn it left, and left side of rear part to turn it right, contrarily. From Fig. 5(a), we can calculate that the entire average angular speed is ∼0.73 rad s−1.
Besides, analogizing to the real manned sedan, liquid metal vehicle can move backwardly, as is shown in Fig. 5(b). The anodic electrode is placed at the tail side of vehicle and the cathode in front of the vehicle. With a 19 V voltage implementation, the vehicle would back down with an average speed of ∼18.8 mm s−1. The displacement and speed here depends on the travelled distance along the downward coordinate (black arrow), while the distance numbers are labelled above red stripes with different shades.
With an overview of above experiments, it is feasible to achieve a more complex and comprehensive locomotion through combining all these individual manipulations. Compared with manned car in daily life, the presented liquid metal vehicle is much more flexible and compliant. For instance, the vehicle can move omni-directionally and spin around if the electrodes are appropriately placed. Besides the soft liquid metal wheels can play a role of bumper when the vehicle collides with other rigid objects, hence the solid structure of vehicle would be protected. When the vehicle runs along the edge of the Petri dish, liquid wheel would contact the glass wall and add a recoil force to the vehicle, in which, the liquid metal would act as guide pulley and driving wheel simultaneously.
To demonstrate the cargo carrying capability of the vehicle and the relationship between the masses of loads and the velocities of locomotion, further experiment is conducted in which the vehicle carried different volumes of liquid metal droplet, in particular, empty, 0.03 ml and 0.05 ml EGaIn liquid metal (see ESI Movie S3†). Motion processes are recorded accordingly. Displacements and instantaneous speeds are shown in Fig. 7(a and b).
Applied voltage is 15 V while the concentration of NaOH is about 0.8 mol l−1. From the diagrams, we can notice that the vehicle has a highest average velocity (∼40 mm s−1) when taking a 0.03 ml droplet cargo. After a few more repetitive experiments, it is found that the order of velocities is not consistent, which means that the effect of accidental disturbance from turbulence and friction overwhelms the influence of carried loads. If more experiments are conducted with other variables being precisely controlled, the exact relation between the mass of cargo and motion velocity could be further identified.
Anyhow it can be proven that such a boat-like structure design does own the carrying ability up to hundreds of milligrams. So long as the vehicle would not sink, more cargos can still be loaded. The size of the vehicle could be enlarged to increase its carrying capability. More complex tasks could be done if several customized vehicles cooperate with each other. Furthermore, if equipping the vehicle with grippers or manipulators, a desktop level miniaturized factory could be accomplished.
Another way to improve the vehicle is to mount the vehicle with untethered power source such as button cell, and employ chips and circuits to control the motion of wheels individually. As liquid metal wheel is affected by local electric field, putting electrodes close to wheels separately can reduce reciprocal interference and control the wheels precisely.
Such a small vehicle can be utilized in many practical fields like small-scale transporter, miniaturized valve, as well as micro factory.25,26 Since the vehicle is controlled by electric potential, which is very easy to modulate, it can have a higher control precision compared with some flagellum propelled swimmers. Another advantage of the current design is that the body structure can be arbitrarily customized so long as it can float upon liquid surface. Such flexibility can bring it more consolidated capabilities, along with its carrying capability. The propulsion force can be adjusted by increasing the number of wheels or voltage magnitude. To improve the present design, micro controllers and built-in power source can be implemented. It is expected that this work can inspire future researches in related areas to build more powerful and flexible miniaturized-robots,27,28 as well as helping to advance the fields of microfluidic systems, programmable intelligent machines and so on in the years to come.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: More supplementary movies of the locomotion of the liquid metal vehicle. See DOI: 10.1039/c6ra10629c |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2016 |