L. Ourry,
F. Mammeri*,
D. Toulemon,
T. Gaudisson,
M. Delamar and
S. Ammar
Université Paris Diderot, Sorbonne Paris Cité, ITODYS CNRS UMR 7086, 5 rue Thomas Mann, 75205 Paris Cedex 13, France. E-mail: fayna.mammeri@univ-paris-diderot.fr
First published on 6th May 2016
We report herein the synthesis and characterization of exchange-biased CoxFe3−xO4@CoO@PMMA nanohybrids in which the inorganic core comprised a highly crystallized polyol-made ferrimagnetic cobalt iron spinel oxide nanoparticles perfectly epitaxied to an very thin antiferromagnetic polycrystalline cobalt monoxide CoO shell, whereas the organic coating comprised a layer of dense poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) chains. PMMA brushes were grown by atom transfer radical polymerization (ATRP). The polymerization was monitored by combining infrared absorption (FTIR) and X-ray photoelectron (XPS) spectroscopy. The resulting nanohybrids are considered as potential building blocks for flexible magnetic recording devices. Their magnetic properties were then investigated by low temperature field cooling (FC) and zero field cooling (ZFC) magnetometry experiments. The obtained results agree fairly with a direct dependency of the coercivity and the remanence with the polymer chain length and then with the interparticle distance, emphasizing the role of material processing in the design of tailored flexible polymer based hybrid materials.
Focusing on magnetic recording applications, high storage memory applications require dense but well-separated magnetic nanoparticles (NPs). Thus, in an optimized geometry, in the hypothesis of particles of a few nanometer in size, each one storing one bit of data, densities of 150 Gbit cm−2 in range can be reached. The ability of such NPs to react with any magnetic stimulation is of course dependent on their intrinsic properties (composition, size, and shape) but also on their spatial arrangement.5,6 For such a purpose, two issues have to be addressed. First, the intrinsic magnetic anisotropy of NPs, which should be high enough to assure the thermal stability of the magnetization at the operating temperatures, and second, the mutual influence between NPs that should be low enough to decrease the dipolar interaction (DI) effects.
In this context, several studies have been achieved to build exchange-biased NPs composed of ferro or ferrimagnetic (F) cores coated by nanocrystalline antiferromagnetic (AF) layers, leading to coupled F–AF interfaces. Thanks to the exchange-bias (EB), these nanostructures exhibit an enhanced magnetic anisotropy, an improved thermal magnetization stability and a significantly higher blocking temperature (TB).7–11 Surprisingly, despite an impressive number of studies on this topic,12–18 few of them focused on the interplay between the exchange bias (EB) and dipolar interactions (DI), while DI are known to be able to greatly affect the magnetic responses of any magnetic NPs in any type of assembly, particularly 2D8 and 1D19 ones.
Moreover, while some research groups have worked towards tuning the NP–NP distance to vary and control the dipolar interactions (DI), functionalizing NPs with dendrimers or fatty acids of different lengths,20,21 or coating them by a more or less thin silica shell,22,23 they have mainly focused on iron oxide particles, which are not the best magnetic systems for magnetic recording applications. They have shown that the NP–NP distance necessary to observe non-interacting particles is dependent on the nature of the spacer for similar NP sizes and have also shown that magnetic NP surface modification is a great challenge regarding the strong tendency of these nanomagnets to agglomerate. In the case of polymer spacers, it was established that optimization of the hybrid interface is required before building any efficient magnetic assembly. The hybrid interface, also called the interphase, is the area in which the chemical bonding between both the polymer chain and the magnetic particle is established. Therefore, despite polymer coatings having attracted increasing interest,24 it has been necessary to wait for the development of fundamental processes of living radical polymerization (e.g. atom transfer radical polymerization ATRP, reversible addition–fragmentation chain transfer RAFT or nitroxide-mediated polymerization)25 before producing robust polymer-particle links and then achieve polymer brushes of controlled molecular weight and polydispersity index, within a satisfying grafting density.
Clearly, for magnetic recording applications (as for others), prior to NP organization, (i) NPs have to be well defined in composition and morphology to obtain the best properties and (ii) the NPs must be judiciously functionalized to ensure their compatibility with the polymer matrix and (iii) the process used to assemble the resulting hybrids has to be optimized to fit the properties to the desired application.6,26–28
To satisfy these requirements, we decided to (i) produce exchange-biased, almost isotropic in shape, about 10 nm sized and perfectly epitaxied CoxFe3−xO4@CoO core@shell NPs using the polyol process,29 (ii) grow, directly at their surface, poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) chains using the ATRP grafting from technique and (iii) study their magnetic properties by comparison to those of bare NPs with a special emphasis on the interparticle distance effects.
FTIR (ν in cm−1, KBr technique): 2933 (C–H), 2309 (P–O–H), 1733 (CO), 1272 (P
O), 1160 (C–O of carbonyl), 1074 and 990 (C–O and P–O bond, respectively).
1H NMR (400 MHz, δ in ppm, CDCl3): 6.20 (2H), 4.24 (2H), 3.81 (2H), 1.88 (6H).
31P NMR (400 MHz, δ in ppm, CDCl3): 0.67 ppm.
![]() | ||
Scheme 1 General approach to coupling the polyol process and ATRP to design new processable exchange-biased nanoparticles for magnetic recording applications. |
The efficiency of the grafting process by the ATRP initiator has been checked by analysis of the surface state using XPS. The survey spectrum of the brominated NPs (NP-Br) was found to be similar to that of the as-prepared core–shell NPs (Fig. 1a and b), exhibiting all the peaks associated to O 1s (529.7 eV), Fe 2p3/2 (711.4 eV) and Co 2p3/2 (780.9 eV) and new peaks assigned to P 2p in a phosphonate compound (133.2 eV) and Br at 182.7 eV (3p3/2) and at ∼69 eV (3d5/2) as a shoulder of the peak assigned to Co 3p3/2 (60.5 eV). The peaks at 781.3 eV and 796.9 eV correspond to the characteristic doublet related to Co and are assigned to Co 2p3/2 and Co 2p1/2; two shake-up satellite peaks at 786.6 eV and at 803.1 eV were observed, corresponding to Co 2p3/2 and Co 2p1/2. The presence of these two peaks and highly intense satellites is consistent with the presence of Co2+ cations in the high-spin state. The Fe 2p high-resolution spectrum exhibited a main peak at 711.5 eV and a satellite at 723.8 eV, which are characteristic of the presence of a majority of Fe3+ cations. Thus, we can conclude that the successful grafting of 2-phosphonooxy-2-bromo-2-methylpropanoate on the core–shell nanoparticles was achieved whose crystallographic structure was preserved during the functionalization process. The chemical composition of as-produced NP and NP-Br are gathered in Table 1.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 XPS survey spectra of (a) bare CoxFe3−xO4–CoO NPs (NP), (b) NP-Br, (c) NP-bPMMA1, and (d) NP-bPMMA3. |
Sample | Elemental atomic composition (%) | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Fe | Co | O | C | P | Br | |
NP (CoxFe3−xO4–CoO) | 14.5 | 24.3 | 40.2 | 21.0 | — | — |
NP-Br | 6.6 | 15.5 | 46.2 | 29.9 | 1.4 | 0.4 |
NP-bPMMA1 | 1.3 | 3.8 | 30.2 | 64.1 | 0.6 | — |
NP-bPMMA3 | 0.8 | 2.9 | 28.6 | 67.3 | 0.4 | — |
The C 1s peak before the functionalization process demonstrated the presence of organic matter (polyol and acetate molecules) on the core–shell NP surface. This is a consequence of the polyol process, during which the solvent molecules also play the role in ligand complexation on the NP surface to control the growth step.
The XPS spectrum of NP-bPMMA1 is depicted in Fig. 1c. The Co 2p and Fe 2p peaks were strongly attenuated after 1 hour of polymerization, revealing the presence of a non-negligible polymer coating (Fig. 2c). After 3 hours of reaction (NP-bPMMA3), the Co 2p and Fe 2p peaks have almost disappeared, suggesting a higher content of organic matter (Fig. 2d).
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 The high-resolution Fe 2p (left) and Co 2p (right) scan of (a) bare CoxFe3−xO4–CoO NPs (NP), (b) NP-Br, (c) NP-bPMMA1, and (d) NP-bPMMA3. |
The decomposition of the C 1s peak specific to PMMA was difficult to achieve because many sources of organic matter (PMMA, initiator, little residual polyol and acetates) are present on the surface of NPs and that of O 1s for PMMA was difficult too because of the presence of oxides constituting the core–shell NPs.
The cobalt atomic percentage was found to be higher than that of iron for all the nanoparticles, either bare or functionalized. This trend can be explained by considering the mean free paths in both oxides, according to eqn (1) and (2) given by Dench and Seah for oxide materials:32
λ(k) = 0.55 × Ek0.5 × ak1.5 | (1) |
Considering Ek being the kinetic energy of ejected core electrons (eV) and ak the dimension of atom k; Ek is tabulated while ak is calculated using eqn (2):
![]() | (2) |
With A the molecular weight of the oxide (g mol−1), ρ its density (kg m−3), n is the number of atoms per molecular unit and NA, Avogadro number.
The mean free paths were found to be 1.5 nm for iron in CoO and 1.4 nm for cobalt in CoO. However, as the thickness of the CoO shell is about 1 nm, electrons can penetrate the whole Co-rich shell but pass through only 0.5 nm of the Fe-rich core. The difference in depth analysis explains that both the core and shell are not characterised in a similar way because XPS provides only surface information. Moreover, one can notice that there is not as much phosphorus as bromine. Indeed, the C–Br bond is relatively sensitive to X-ray and tends to be altered, whereas the P–O bond is quite stable; this leads to a higher P atomic percentage than that of Br.
As a first approximation, the PMMA thickness could be estimated considering the C 1s and Co 2p peaks and their relative intensities (see ESI†) assuming the carbon and cobalt signals were mainly due to the CoO shell (the cobalt content into the spinel lattice is weak30) and the PMMA brushes (the molecular weight of the phosphonate initiator being negligible front to the polymer brushes), respectively. It was found to be 1.3 ± 0.1 nm for NP-bPMMA1 and 2.7 ± 0.2 nm for NP-bPMMA3. However, one has to remember that under ultra-vacuum conditions (like in the XPS analysis chamber), polymer chains have a strong propensity to collapse; therefore, the calculated thickness have to be considered for a polymer in a random coil conformation, meaning that XPS measurements do not allow the determination of the exact chain length. However, we can conclude that increasing the polymerization time leads to the formation of a greater amount of polymer on the NP surface.
The XPS data were found to be in good agreement with the qualitative FTIR spectroscopy results (see ESI†) because the spectrum of NP-Br exhibits νP−O (1009 cm−1) and νPO bands (1278 cm−1) corresponding to phosphonate and an intense peak at 1733 cm−1 corresponding to νC
O in the bromoester. After ATRP, the C–C skeleton at 750 cm−1, C–O–C bands (1149 and 1192 cm−1) and very intense νC
O at 1727 cm−1 (characteristics of PMMA) can be observed, whereas all peaks previously assigned to the initiator disappeared, which can be explained by the formation of a layer of PMMA of significant thickness.
To determine the molecular weight Mw and polydispersity index Ip = Mw/Mn of the grafted PMMA thus formed, the hybrid NPs were subjected to degrafting using concentrated hydrochloric acid, in the presence of chloroform, followed by precipitation in methanol and drying. The degrafted polymer chains were then analysed by SEC and the obtained results were correlated to those inferred from the TGA (see ESI†), assuming the observed total weight losses were due to polymer brushes decomposition.
In practice, we deduced from the weight loss observed at 150 °C, during the TG analysis of NP-Br, the grafting density of the initiator molecules as 2.8 molecules nm−2. For that we assumed that the mass loss at this temperature is mainly attributed to the degrafting of the initiator molecules and we determined from BET measurements the specific area of the as-prepared core@shell NPs as 119 m2 g−1. Note that the obtained grafting density value agrees with that reported in previous study.31
Second, we supposed that the polymer chains on NP-bPMMA1 and NP-bPMMA3 are almost homogeneous in length. This hypothesis was supported by the fact that the TGA of the produced hybrids showed a unique and drastic weight loss at 300 °C: 33 and 43 wt% for NP-bPMMA1 and NP-bPMMA3, respectively. Assuming that all “Br” initiator ends can initiate a polymerization, we could estimate the mean degree of polymerization to be about 6 and 8 units, respectively. All the results allowed us to calculate not only the chain length (Mw(calc)), but also the monomer conversion ratio and the grafting efficiency (see ESI†). The results are presented in Table 2.
Sample | Weight loss (%) | Conversion (%) | Mw(calc) (g mol−1) | Mw(corr) (g mol−1) |
---|---|---|---|---|
NP-bPMMA1 | 33 | 0.62 | 674 | 1241 |
NP-bPMMA3 | 43 | 0.78 | 833 | 1561 |
From Table 2, we can conclude that the conversion is very low in comparison with previous studies performed with a quite similar initiator.31 We believe that this discrepancy between our results and the former ones was due to the dilution of the NPs and monomers in the reaction medium. Indeed, to avoid NP aggregation during the functionalization process and to improve the control the radical polymerization with a polydispersity index close to 1 during the chain grow process, we worked with very low concentrated starting systems.
Finally, we deduced from SEC experiments the polymer chain density (eqn (3)) and the grafting efficiency after the chains had been degrafted:
![]() | (3) |
Then, the initiator efficiency could then be calculated as follows (eqn (4)):
![]() | (4) |
From the SEC measurements, we know that only half of the initiator molecules are active. On the basis of this information we propose a methodology to calculate the molecular weight (Mw) of the grown polymer chains from the TGA measurements (Table 2). Indeed, the degrafting step is quite hard to realize and requires more matter than TGA for doing the analysis. Therefore, we use eqn (14) in the ESI,† considering only half the quantity of initiators (2.3 × 10−5 mol instead of 4.3 × 10−5 mol). The results are compiled in Table 2 (Mw(corr)).
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 5 K-magnetization versus magnetic field variation for the bare core–shell NP and their related hybrids, NP-bPMMA1 and NP-bPMMA3. |
Then, for all the samples, we could calculate the coercive field, HC, following eqn (5):34
HC (FC) = (−HC− + HC+)/2 | (5) |
HC+ (Oe) | HC− (Oe) | HC (Oe) | Ms (emu g−1) | |
---|---|---|---|---|
NP (CoxFe3−xO4–CoO) | 9743 | −12![]() |
9648 | 65 |
NP-Br | 7387 | −10![]() |
9897 | 60 |
NP-bPMMA1 (1 h) | 11![]() |
−13![]() |
11![]() |
46 |
NP-bPMMA3 (3 h) | 10![]() |
−13![]() |
11![]() |
33 |
One can notice the decrease in the magnetization as the amount of diamagnetic polymer content increases. Designing the saturation magnetization of free polymers (assumed to be zero), bare core@shell NPs and their related PMMA-hybrids as Msat (polymer), Msat (NP) and Msat (NP–polymer), the PMMA weight content, x, can be deduced by eqn (6), neglecting in a first approximation the initiator weight content:
x × Msat(polymer) + (1 − x) × Msat(NP) = Msat(NP–polymer) | (6) |
We found x = 31 and 45 wt% for NP-bPMMA1 and NP-bPMMA3, respectively, close to those determined by TGA and shows once again that the percentage weight grafted from the NP surface is significant.
Focusing on the coercivity of the produced hybrids, it is found that the coercive field measured at low temperature on bare NP, NP-Br and NP-bPMMA1 increases progressively in agreement with the inter-magnetic core distance with a slight decrease in the exchange field HE defined by eqn (7):34
HE (FC) = (+HC− + HC+)/2 | (7) |
Interestingly, this tendency is not respected between NP-bPMMA1 and NP-bPMMA3 whereas more polymers are present on the surface of the NPs in NP-bPMMA3, its coercive field appears to be smaller than that of the less polymer rich NP-bPMMA1 sample. One may suspect that the polymer chains collapse around the inorganic cores when the polymerization degree increases, leading to a shorter NP–NP distance (Scheme 2).
These multifunctional magnetic nanoparticles, exhibiting exchange bias for more thermal stability, as well as a better miscibility in PMMA, are interesting for fundamental studies on the collective magnetic properties of extended arrays of nanoparticles.35 They also would allow us to prepare flexible functional hybrid PMMA-NPs films with enhanced properties.36
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c6ra06963k |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2016 |