Yingjie Zhua,
Jianfeng Wua,
Haiyue Gaoa,
Guokun Liub,
Zhongqun Tianc,
Jianlin Fenga,
Lei Guo*a and
Jianwei Xie*a
aState Key Laboratory of Toxicology and Medical Countermeasures, Laboratory of Toxicant Analysis, Institute of Pharmacology and Toxicology, Academy of Military Medical Sciences, Beijing 100850, China. E-mail: guolei@bmi.ac.cn; xiejw@bmi.ac.cn; xiejwbmi@163.com; Fax: +86-10-68225893; Tel: +86-10-66931650 Tel: +86-10-68225893
bCollege of the Environment and Ecology, Xiamen University, Xiamen 361005, China
cState Key Laboratory of Physical Chemistry of Solid Surfaces, College of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Xiamen University, Xiamen 361005, China
First published on 15th June 2016
An on-site direct detection method for paraquat in biologic fluids was developed on the basis of iodide-facilitated pinhole shell-isolated nanoparticle-enhanced Raman spectroscopy. A full removal of matrix interference on the nanoparticle surface from the complicated biologic samples, and a selective attraction of paraquat to “hotspot” via a highly electrostatic adsorption on the iodide-modified nanoparticle surface are accomplished in this method. Four distinguished characteristics were provided as (1) high sensitivity with a limit of detection of 1 μg L−1 for paraquat; (2) free of pretreatment with a direct measurement in plasma or urine finished within 1 minute; (3) on-site detection using a portable Raman spectrometer; and (4) high antifouling stability during measurement with the pinhole shell-isolated nanoparticle structure. This method was further showed its great clinical diagnosis applicability on a rapid, accurate detection of the plasma and urine samples from a paraquat poisoned patient.
In the past decades, various methods including high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC),4,5 gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS),6 and liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS)7 have been established for the clinical diagnosis aim. These chromatographic separation-based methods provided high sensitivity and selectivity, with limits of detection (LODs) ranging from 10 to 100 μg L−1 in biologic samples, but so sophisticated and time-consuming, and cannot meet the demand of rapid test. Enzyme linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) and colorimetric methods have been established for on-site detection of paraquat.8,9 For example, an ELISA method offered a limit of quantification (LOQ) of 2 μg L−1 for paraquat in urine,8 while the pretreatment procedure is tedious, and the cross-reactivity of antibodies towards small organic molecules is a big problem and inclined to false-positive results in practical use. Colorimetric method is fast but with a limited sensitivity and low specificity due to poor discrimination between paraquat and its analogue diquat.9
In recent years, surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SERS) is emerged as a powerful on-site technique for its unique characteristics of rapid detection, high sensitivity and fingerprint identification.10,11 Benefited from the enhanced Raman scattering of analytes through a localized surface plasmonic resonance provided by nanostructural noble metals, the sensitivity of SERS can even reach a single molecule detection level.12 Several SERS detections on paraquat for pesticide residue determination have been tested. For instance, Gao et al. reported a LOD at nM level (sub μg L−1) of paraquat in aqueous samples with a microfluidic-based SERS method, and proposed an on-site screening potential in the water contamination.13 Tang et al. discriminated tricyclazole, paraquat and flusilazole in water at sub mg L−1 level by SERS.14 However, while SERS is involved in the condition of biologic fluids, severe interferences from biological matrix with great amount of nitrogen- and sulfur-containing compounds overwhelmed the characteristic Raman shifts of paraquat in the same range of 600 to 1700 cm−1.15 Therefore, no SERS detection on paraquat in biologic fluids has been reported until now.
To address this issue, here we describe a facile SERS based paraquat measurement in biologic fluids by coupling the advantages from pinhole shell-isolated nanoparticle-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SHINERS) and iodide addition, and a quantitative determination is achieved. The pinhole structured ultrathin SiO2 shell (1–2 nm) isolated Au core nanoparticles (pinSHINs) not only left the active adsorption sites on the Au surface for target molecules, but also provided a far more stability than bare gold nanoparticles (bare AuNPs) during measurement. With the introduction of iodide as the cleaning agent and specific linker between pinSHINs and paraquat, the nonspecific adsorption interference from biologic matrices was effectively eliminated, which makes the impossible possible: a direct detection of paraquat in plasma or urine was successfully achieved without tedious pretreatment using a portable Raman spectrometer. The mechanism of the iodide-facilitated effect was discussed accordingly. A LOD of 1 μg L−1 for either plasma or urine samples was obtained, and a good selectivity towards diquat, the analogue of paraquat was achieved. This method was further applied in authentic plasma and urine samples from a paraquat poisoned patient, and results were displayed with good sensitivity, selectivity and reliability.
Blank human urine was collected from five healthy volunteers, and then mixed and stored at 4 °C. Blank human plasma, paraquat poisoned plasma and urine samples were provided by the 307 hospital of Chinese People's Liberation Army with a permission of the poisoned patient. Blank human plasma was stored at −80 °C. Paraquat poisoned samples were stored at 4 °C. All procedures were approved by the Ethics Committee of the 307 hospital of Chinese People's Liberation Army.
Caution: Paraquat, diquat and sodium cyanide are extremely toxic agents. Handling of these agents should be carried out in a well-ventilated fume hood with high attention. Gloves and stringent protective measures should be adopted.
The spiked biosamples were prepared by the addition of the standard solution into plasma or urine and then serially diluted, and the final concentrations of paraquat in such biologic fluids were ranged from 0.5 to 200 μg L−1. No pretreatment was needed for either spiked samples or poisoned samples before SERS detection. A serial dilution by saline solution was adopted for the real poisoned samples when the SERS intensity was beyond the linear range.
However, when we performed same measurement towards spiked human plasma or urine samples, we cannot detect paraquat even at a 50 μg L−1 level (Fig. 1A). The interference from abundant salts, proteins and other components existed in the human plasma or urine matrix may be the main reason. Considering that SERS response of molecules is highly related to their distances to the metal surface,20,21 and that biomolecules such as proteins, nitrogen- and sulfur-containing compounds in plasma and urine are inclined to be adsorbed onto the surface of NPs, as shown as the matrix peaks around 620, 730 and 1350 cm−1 (Fig. 1A), we believed that the paraquat molecules were hampered to reach the surface of NPs by a thick layer of other adsorbed molecules so as to hardly show any efficient SERS response. How could we achieve specific measurement of paraquat in complex biologic fluids?
Up to now, no reports have been published about SERS detection of paraquat in biofluids. In a related pesticide detection field, Clauson et al. employed a liquid–liquid extraction to isolate urea and salts, and achieved a SERS detection of acephate, an organophosphate pesticide in urine.22 The direct and selective detection of analytes in complicated matrix without any pretreatment is still a critical challenge in the on-site detection field. Considering that paraquat is a quaternary ammonium which shows as its cation format in a neutral pH but reveals weaker interaction with Au surface than the matrix interferences, we can introduce a kind of anion, which has a moderate interaction with the surface of Au to directly eliminate interferences, and act as a “bridge” between paraquat and the substrate of pinSHINs, so as to attract paraquat to SERS active sites by electrostatic interaction, and achieve a facile, real-time detection. Herein, we examined different common anions, and found that iodide is the most effective kind (Fig. 1B and S2†). The SERS signals of interferences could be effectively suppressed while that of paraquat was greatly enhanced by iodide adsorption (Fig. 1C). This might be due to the excellent advantage of iodide by coupling its constant electrostatic attraction for positively charged N+ quaternary ammonium compounds and its strong adsorption onto the surfaces of Au that expels most interfering substances.23–25 As some of the anions are basic and S2− is the most basic with a pH of 11.7 when added to the sample at the concentration of 100 mM, we tested the influence of pH and found that it didn't have an obvious effect on the SERS signal of paraquat in the range from 6.0 to 12.0 (Fig. S2A†).
When we replaced KI with NaI or MgI2, we did not found any obvious signal difference, indicating the most contribution was derived from the I− anion. Among all anions we tested (F−, Cl−, Br−, I−, S−, IO3−, CN−, SCN−, SO42−, SO32−, NO3−, NO2−, HPO42−, CO32−, and HCO3−), we emphasized the effect of S2− and CN− as well as I− due to their well-known affinity with Au. As shown in Fig. 1B, regarding the reference band of 1643 cm−1, S2− showed similar, while CN− showed much weaker effect compared with I−. The SERS spectra were listed in Fig. S2.† To explain the different phenomenon, we also examined the zeta potentials (Table 1). Towards all three anions, the pinSHINs@I− or S2− or CN− has similar zeta potentials without paraquat. When the surface was further covered by paraquat, the zeta potentials of pinSHINs@I−, S2−, CN−@paraquat increased by 4–8 mV, following an descending order of pinSHINs@I−@paraquat, pinSHINs@S2−@paraquat, pinSHINs@CN−@paraquat. It is indicated that more paraquat cations were tethered to the layer of I−, larger SERS response was revealed. We have also observed same trend when we used bare AuNPs instead of pinSHINs.
Kind of NPs | NPs | NPs@paraquat | NPs@I− | NPs@I−@paraquat | NPs@S2− | NPs@S2−@paraquat | NPs@CN− | NPs@CN−@paraquat | NPs@I−@diquat | NPs@I@4,4′-bipyridine | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Zeta potential (mV) | pinSHINs | −28 | −27 | −31 | −23 | −33 | −26 | −35 | −31 | −25 | −31 |
Bare AuNPs | −38 | −33 | −37 | −21 | −37 | −28 | −33 | −32 | −24 | −35 |
We then investigated the effect of KI concentration on the SERS response. Here we used human plasma containing 50 μg L−1 of paraquat as an example of matrix. When the concentration of KI was below 0.1 mM, the SERS signal of paraquat was overall suppressed by the matrix. As the concentration of KI further increased from 0.1 to 100 mM, the signal of paraquat gradually appeared and increased while the SERS signal of blank plasma gradually decreased, indicating that sufficient amount of I− covered the surface of pinSHINs and the matrix around the NPs were efficiently replaced (Fig. S3†). When the concentration of KI was beyond 100 mM, the pinSHINs were excessively aggregated to a status of agglomeration, leading to a decreased SERS intensity of paraquat. We also observed same trends in urine for the SERS signal versus concentration of KI (Fig. S4†). Herein 100 mM of KI was chosen as an optimized concentration in this work.
To confirm this assumption, we further tested two analogues of paraquat, i.e., diquat and 4,4′-bipyridine in our work. Diquat is also a quaternary ammonium herbicide, and 4,4′-bipyridine is a tertiary amine intermediate in the production of paraquat, containing a pair of N-donor sites to the Au acceptors at the surface.27 As shown in Fig. 2A, SERS signals of paraquat and diquat (50 μg L−1) in the presence of ten-fold 4,4′-bipyridine were covered by 4,4′-bipyridine (855 cm−1, 1016 cm−1, 1293 cm−1, 1609 cm−1) in water. However, when 100 mM of KI was added into the mixture, the SERS responses of paraquat and diquat (1383 cm−1, 1524 cm−1, 1570 cm−1)28 were greatly enhanced while that of 4,4′-bipyridine almost disappeared, and paraquat and diquat can then be discriminated very well. In Fig. 2B, with the addition of KI, the SERS signals of paraquat or diquat can be greatly enhanced in plasma and urine while that of 4,4′-bipyridine could not, indicating that the electrostatic interaction between I− and positively charged paraquat or diquat is great helpful.
To further illustrate the crucial role of such a layer-by-layer attraction, we performed zeta potential tests towards pinSHINs@I−@paraquat or the other compound like diquat or 4,4′-bipyridine. As shown in Table 1, compared with 4,4′-bipyridine, only remarkable increases of the original negative zeta potential occurred when quaternary ammonium paraquat and diquat were added to pinSHINs@I− (from −31 mV to −23 mV for paraquat, and to −25 mV for diquat). It indicates that the layer of the cationic paraquat and diquat could be tethered to the layer of I−, while the neutral 4,4′-bipyridine could not. Same trends were observed in the case of bare AuNPs at a subtle differed values, indicating that the layer of I− is tightly adsorbed onto the surface of bare AuNPs, while the ultrathin silica shell did not disturb the Au–I interaction but shield some adsorbed amount of I−. Furthermore, from the UV-vis spectra of different NPs presented in Fig. 3, we observed a new peak at 762 nm when pinSHINs@I−@paraquat formed, indicating that the interaction between I− and paraquat could induce the aggregation of pinSHINs. All the results indicated that electrostatic interaction between I− and paraquat (as well as diquat) played a dominant role in enhancing their SERS responses when we used I− to replace the matrix from Au surface.
For SERS measurement in practical application, the stability of the substrate is an important issue. In a time-dependent experiment, the plasma or urine samples containing 50 μg L−1 of paraquat were added into the pinSHINs, maintained at room temperature for a certain time, and measured by SERS. The pinSHINs substrate has a quite good stability that the SERS signal of paraquat was steadily hold at least 12 hours in plasma and 20 minutes in urine (Fig. S5A and B†). For comparison, we used bare AuNPs as a substrate instead of pinSHINs, although a slightly improved sensitivity at 0.5 μg L−1 was provided, we found a worse stability of bare AuNPs in biologic fluids. The SERS signal of paraquat on bare AuNPs decreased rapidly in less than 5 min in urine, and decreased more than half after 6 h in plasma (Fig. S5C and D†). We contribute the prolonged detection window on pinSHINs to the protection from the ultrathin silica shell around Au core.31
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 SERS spectra of the urine (a) and plasma (b) of the paraquat poisoned patient and of saline solution (c). Both urine and plasma samples were diluted 100 times by saline solution. |
Other various complicated matrices including plasma and bronchoalveolar lavage fluid (BALF) of poisoned rats, spiked milk and orange juice samples were also tested and all good results were obtained (see Fig. S7, S8 and Table S2†), showing its general and wide applicability.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c6ra06954a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2016 |