Zhiyu Xia,
Kangle Jia,
Xuefeng Li* and
Jinfeng Dong*
College of Chemistry and Molecular Sciences, Wuhan University, Wuhan 430072, PR China. E-mail: lixuefeng@whu.edu.cn; jfdong@whu.edu.cn
First published on 3rd May 2016
A new class of light-responsive fluids based on reversible transitions between wormlike micelles and rodlike micelles is developed. The system is composed of a synthesized light-responsive surfactant, 4-decylazobenzene-4-(oxyethyl)-dihydroxyethylmethylammonium bromide (C10AZODEMAB), and a salicylic acid derivative, 5-methyl salicylic acid (5 mS). 5 mS is highly efficient in inducing the micellar growth of C10AZODEMAB at a constant concentration, i.e., [C10AZODEMAB] = 30 mmol L−1. Viscoelastic fluids are formed in a wide concentration region of 5 mS, and show UV light-induced shining behaviors. More importantly, they can return to their original states after visible light irradiation. Cryogen transmission electronic microscopy (cryo-TEM) and rheology measurements confirm that the light-induced rheological responses are attributed to the reversible transitions between wormlike micelles and rodlike micelles. UV-Vis and 1H NMR spectra are employed to study the molecular interactions between C10AZODEMAB and 5 mS before and after light irradiation systematically, which evidence the critical role of light-induced isomerization between trans-C10AZODEMAB and cis-C10AZODEMAB during the transition process well.
In general, there are mainly two routes in designing responsive fluids based on surfactants as mentioned previously.14 One is relying on the synthetic chemistry through introducing some special responsive moieties into molecules, and the other is through the formation of surfactant/hydrotrope binary systems. The latter route is more extensively studied for its simplicity by comparing with the former one, where stimuli-responsive transitions between aggregates with different morphologies and even phase transitions are realized by employing the binary systems.1–8 Here, the stimuli-responsive component can be either additives or surfactants. However, hydrotropes with responsive groups are often employed because functional hydrotropes with desired structures are commercially available. For example, the azobenzene dyes and coumaric acid derivatives are often employed to develop light-responsive fluids.15–17
Raghavan et al. reported that 5-methyl salicylic acid (5 mS) is highly efficient in inducing spherical micelle to vesicle transition via wormlike micelle in the cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB) aqueous solutions.18 More importantly, there present temperature-induced vesicle to wormlike micelle transitions in the CTAB/5 mS binary systems owing to the solubility variation of 5 mS at different temperatures. Similar transitions were also observed in the dodecyltrimethylammonium bromide (DTAB) and polymer amphiphile Pluronic P85 systems in the presence of 5 mS.19,20 According to the same principle, we have recently studied a new category of responsive fluids based on 1-[2-(4-decylphenylazo-phenoxy)-ethyl]-3-methylimidazolium bromide (C10AZOC2IMB) and a salicylic acid derivative, 4-(trifluoromethyl) salicylic acid (4FS), which shows pH-, temperature-, and light-induced thickening behaviors.21 However, long and entangled wormlike micelles can be formed only in narrow molar ratio regions of [hydrotrope]/[surfactant] in those systems,18–21 resulting in difficulties in preparation and the potential applications as well. Thereby, how to develop stimuli-responsive systems based on surfactants and salicylic acid derivatives with a wide wormlike micelle formation region is of particular interest and is also the major motivation of this work.
Recent works show that surfactants with hydroxyethyl moieties in the headgroups favor wormlike micelles formation since the presence of hydroxyl moiety endows possibility to form hydrogen bonds between molecules.22–24 Without doubt, the hydroxyethyl containing surfactants provide an alternative way to enlarge the wormlike micelle formation region in the surfactant/hydrotrope binary systems. In this work, a new light-responsive surfactant, 4-decylazobenzene-4-(oxyethyl)-dihydroxyethylmethylammonium bromide (C10AZODEMAB), is synthesized. Based on C10AZODEMAB and 5 mS binary mixtures, a new family of light-rheological responsive fluids is developed that has a wide wormlike micelle formation region. The light-induced rheological responses are illustrated by the rheology and cryogen transmission electron microscopy (cryo-TEM) results. Furthermore, the interaction between C10AZODEMAB and 5 mS is studied systematically at the molecular level by the spectra methods including both UV-Vis and 1H NMR techniques. The present work not only enriches the diversity of light-responsive fluids but also provides important information about molecular interactions between surfactants and hydrotropes, which is fundamental importance in colloids and interfaces.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 [5 mS] dependent zero-shear viscosity of C10AZODEMAB/5 mS binary systems before and after UV light irradiation. |
It was reported previously that 5 mS was highly efficient in inducing micellar growth and could even induce vesicles formation in both surfactant and polymer systems,18–20 whereas only wormlike micelles are observed in this work. Since the hydrophilicity of dihydroxyethylmethylammonium headgroup is weaker in comparing with the trimethylammonium headgroup surfactants such as CTAB as suggested from the cmc values.12,25 That's to say, the presence of hydroxyethyl moiety strengths the hydrophobicity of C10AZODEMAB headgroup in some ways. Simultaneously, it should enlarge the headgroup area of C10AZODEMAB due to the stronger steric hindrance of dihydroxyethylmethylammonium headgroup. From the viewpoint of the molecular packing parameter P,12 C10AZODEMAB should have a relatively smaller P value and reduce the efficiency of 5 mS in increasing P, resulting in the P values of C10AZODEMAB/5 mS binary systems mainly locating in the region of 1/3–1/2. Thus, only wormlike micelles are formed. It is noticed that nearly all samples show significantly UV light-induced thinning behaviors as shown in Fig. 1. The zero-shear viscosities of the C10AZODEMAB/5 mS binary systems drop about 100 times after UV light irradiation for 3 hours (ESI Fig. S3†) when [5 mS] is above 10 mmol L−1, suggesting the formation of micelles with the shorter lengths, i.e., rodlike micelles. In other words, the UV light-induced wormlike micelle to rodlike micelle transitions might happen in the C10AZODEMAB/5 mS binary systems.
In order to clarify the importance of light on the rheological responses of C10AZODEMAB/5 mS binary systems, a typical composition of 30 mmol L−1 C10AZODEMAB and 34 mmol L−1 5 mS is employed, which shows the highest zero-shear viscosity about 10 Pa s in the wormlike micelle formation region. On a macro level, the sample is a very thick fluid with the strong tendency to trap bubbles, however, it becomes a thin one after UV light irradiation (the insert images in Fig. 2a). Fig. 2a shows the steady-shear rheological responses of the systems before and after light irradiation. It is clear that the sample shows the typical shear-thinning behavior regardless of UV light irradiation or not, whereas its zero-shear viscosity drops about 100 times after UV light irradiation. In addition, the system shows perfectly reversible rheological response that the viscosity returns to its original state after visible light irradiation for 3 hours. The dynamic rheological responses (Fig. 2b) show that the original sample behaves as an elastic fluid because the elastic module G′ is commonly larger than the viscous modulus G′′ in the whole measured frequency region.18 However, it transforms into a pure viscous one after UV light irradiation that the elastic module G′ is always below the viscous modulus G′′ instead.
Generally speaking, the light-responsive variation is often attributed to the microstructural changes of the self-organized assemblies. In order to evaluate the morphology changes of aggregates, cryo-TEM is employed. It is clear that very long and entangled wormlike micelles are observed in the original sample (assigned by black arrows in Fig. 3a), whereas short rodlike micelles are observed instead after UV light irradiation (assigned by white arrows in Fig. 3b). The cryo-TEM results confirm the light-induced wormlike micelle to rodlike micelle transitions evidently, and the formation of micelles with the shorter lengths supports the UV light-induced thinning behaviors perfectly. Since the light-induced reversible trans–cis isomerization of azobenzene surfactant C10AZODEMAB is essential during the transition, the isomerization is also monitored by the UV-Vis spectra (ESI Fig. S4†). It is observed that the absorbance spectra of 30 mmol L−1 C10AZODEMAB/34 mmol L−1 5 mS changes a lot after UV light irradiation for 3 hours, and then the spectrum returns to its original shape with a slight variation in intensity through a 3 hours visible light irradiation. Based on the maximum absorbance intensity at 336 nm, the recovered trans-content is estimated to about 89.4% after one UV light and visible light irradiation cycle,26 indicating the existing of light-induced reversible transitions.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Cryo-TEM images of 30 mmol L−1 C10AZODEMAB/34 mmol L−1 5 mS before (a) and after (b) UV light irradiation. |
Fig. 4c shows the 1H NMR spectra of 10 mmol L−1 C10AZODEMAB before and after UV light irradiation. The trans-azobenzene moiety shows two double peaks at 6.81 ppm and 7.54 ppm as assigned as H1 and H′1, H2 and H′2, respectively. There is about 91% trans-C10AZODEMAB in the original bulk phase as calculated from the 1H NMR spectrum. After UV light irradiation, two peaks, in terms of the singlet at 6.55 ppm assigned as H′2 and the triplet at 6.70 ppm assigned as H1, H′1 and H2, respectively, are observed. It's clear that the cis-C10AZODEMAB becomes dominant after UV light irradiation, whereas there is still about 20% trans-isomers remained.
1H NMR is powerful in explaining the intermolecular interactions between surfactants and additives because the chemical shifts reflect the variation in micro-environment of molecules.28–30 Fig. 6a and b show five typical 1H NMR spectra of 5 mS/C10AZODEMAB binary systems before and after UV light irradiation, respectively. Significant changes are observed upon increasing [5 mS]. First of all, significant broadening and compress of the proton signal resonance are observed from either 5 mS or C10AZODEMAB, suggesting the occurrence of 5 mS-induced micellar growth,26,31 i.e. the spherical micelle to wormlike micelle transition. Furthermore, the chemical shifts of protons located in the headgroup and azobenzene moiety of C10AZODEMAB shift toward upfield evidently as well as Ha and Hb of 5 mS, indicating the micro-environmental changes of protons during the process. It should be mentioned that the signals from the protons Hc and Hd of 5 mS is invisible because of the overlap from the trans-azobenzene moiety. However, all the spin–spin splitting of the peaks of 5 mS can be distinguished well after UV-light irradiation when [5 mS] is below 7 mmol L−1 (Fig. 6b). The viscosity (Fig. 2) and cryo-TEM (Fig. 3) results confirm that trans-C10AZODEMAB favors very long and entangled wormlike micelles in the presence of 5 mS, whereas cis-C10AZODEMAB/5 mS binary systems prefer to form rodlike micelles. Therefore, the prominently weakened broadening of the resonance shown in Fig. 6b could be attributed to the formation of micelles with the smaller size, i.e., rodlike micelles.
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 [5 mS] dependent 1H NMR spectra of 5 mS/C10AZODEMAB binary systems with [C10AZODEMAB] = 10 mmol L−1 before (a) and after (b) UV-light irradiation for 3 h, respectively. |
To further understand the role of 5 mS, the dependence of chemical shifts of 5 mS and C10AZODEMAB protons on [5 mS] is shown in Fig. 7. Before UV irradiation, nearly all chemical shifts of the protons Ha and Hb of 5 mS (Fig. 7a) and the protons around the headgroup such as H6, H7, H8 and H10 of trans-C10AZODEMAB (Fig. 7c) shift toward upfield, indicating the strong interactions between 5 mS and trans-C10AZODEMAB. For trans-C10AZODEMAB, the chemical shifts shifting toward upfield suggests that 5 mS is penetrated into palisade layer of trans-C10AZODEMAB micelles.26,31 The largest chemical shift changes (Δδ = δbinary mixture − δpure) of H6, H7, H8 and H10 of C0AZOC2DEMAB are 0.26, 0.13, 0.11 and 0.12 ppm before UV irradiation, whereas those are 0.25, 0.22, 0.15 and 0.16 ppm after UV irradiation (Fig. 7d). For one thing, 5 mS affects the proton H6 of C10AZODEMAB more remarkable, indicating the interactions between 5 mS and H6 is the strongest regardless of UV irradiation or not. On the other hand, the interactions between 5 mS and C10AZODEMAB especially that between 5 mS and H7 are strengthened after UV irradiation, indicating that the distance between 5 mS and H7, H8 or H10 is shortened, and thereby more remarkable Δδ occurs. That's to say, 5 mS should become closer to the charged interface of C10AZODEMAB headgroup after UV light irradiation.26,31
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 Dependence of the typical protons chemical shifts of 5 mS and C10AZODEMAB on [5 mS] before (a) and (c), and after (b) and (d) UV light irradiation for 5 mS and C10AZODEMAB, respectively. |
For 5 mS, the chemical shifts shifting upfield upon increasing [5 mS] before UV light irradiation (Fig. 7a) imply that Ha and Hb of 5 mS shift to the nonpolar part of C10AZODEMAB micelles.26,31 In other word, the aromatic ring of 5 mS is penetrated into the nonpolar core of C10AZODEMAB micelles. Similar tendency is also observed in the C10AZODEMAB/5 mS binary systems after UV light irradiation (Fig. 7b) except the proton Hd of 5 mS that shifts toward downfield, indicating Hd should be very close to the charged interface.30 Since the chemical shifts of Hc and Hd of 5 mS cannot be visible because of the overlap from the trans-azobenzene moiety, we compared the chemical shifts of Ha and Hb of 5 mS at [5 mS] = 1 and 9 mmol L−1 before and after UV irradiation, respectively. It is observed that the values of chemical shift changes (Δδ = δ[5 mS]=1 − δ[5 mS]=9) of Ha and Hb are 0.13 and 0.08 ppm before UV light irradiation (Fig. 7a), respectively. Those of Ha and Hb are 0.14 and 0.06 ppm after UV light irradiation (Fig. 7b), respectively. It is clear that the change in Δδ of Ha is far larger than that of Hb regardless of UV irradiation or not, indicating Ha should be located in a more nonpolar environment than that of Hb, and the tendency strengthened after UV light irradiation. However, no significant micro-environmental change happens on Ha and Hb upon light irradiation because light irradiation shows little effect on Δδ. Since the cationic–π interactions between aromatic chemical of 5 mS and the polar headgroup of C10AZODEMAB is dominant (Fig. 5), therefore, the most reasonable molecular arrangement of 5 mS and C10AZODEMAB in micelles might be represented by the following figure (Fig. 8).
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c6ra05529j |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2016 |