Jae-Gyoung Gwona,
Hye-Jung Choa,
Sang-Jin Chuna,
Soo Leeb,
Qinglin Wuc and
Sun-Young Lee*a
aNational Institute of Forest Science, Department of Forest Products, Seoul, 02455, Korea. E-mail: nararawood@korea.kr
bChangwon National University, Department of Chemical Engineering, Changwon, 51140, Korea
cLouisiana State University Agricultural Center, School of Renewable Natural Resources, Baton Rouge, LA 70803, USA
First published on 14th January 2016
Although cellulose nanocrystals (CNCs) have been highlighted as a potential nano-reinforcement in polymer composites, the hydrophilic surface nature of CNCs limits their usage in the composite area due to the poor dispersibility of the CNCs in nonpolar solvent systems. A chemical modification of the CNCs was performed using toluene diisocyanate (TDI) to overcome the limitation in the solvent systems. CNCs and TDI-modified CNCs (mCNCs) reinforced poly(lactic) acid (PLA) films were prepared using the solvent casting method. After the modification, the mCNCs were well dispersed in chloroform with hydrophobic nature. In addition, AFM images and UV-Vis spectroscopy provide clear evidence for a good distribution of mCNCs in the PLA matrix. Thermal and mechanical behaviors of the PLA nanocomposite films with the CNCs and mCNCs were explored based on interfacial forces existing between the surface of the CNCs and the PLA matrix as well as the dispersibility of the CNCs with the increase of their loading levels.
The development of biodegradable films with high performance in their mechanical properties is one of the most important challenges of the packaging industry today due to eco-friendly decomposition of the films in a sustainable manner.10 Poly(lactic acid) (PLA) as a commercially available biopolymer has been highlighted as a good candidate for packaging materials because of its biodegradability. Moreover, PLA is one of the few biopolymers available today which have similar properties to the petroleum-based commodity thermoplastics.11 Therefore, it can be expected to notably fortify the properties of the PLA films reinforced with the nanocelluloses such as biodegradability and biocompatibility, high stiffness, and low density compared to pure PLA film,12 and this enhancement in the properties makes PLA films have extensive applications.
However, there are some limitations in preparation of PLA films reinforced the nanocelluloses. The PLA film is mostly prepared by organic solvent (chloroform) casting method, but the nanocelluloses have strong hydrophilic nature due to abundant hydroxyl groups on its surface (three hydroxyl groups per glucose unit). Hence, a good dispersed suspension of the nanocelluloses in the nonpolar solvent is not easy to obtain. The poor dispersion in the solvent system can lead severe aggregation of the nanoparticles. Although the hydrophilicity of the nanocelluloses is possible to act as a good nano-biofiller in an aqueous polymer suspension,13 its surface characteristic limits their usage as nano-reinforcement for the composite processes in hydrophobic organic solvent systems. Therefore, it is essential to tune the surface of the nanocelluloses for overcoming the drawbacks representing in the organic solvent systems.
Recently extensive studies have been carried out on techniques for modulating the surface characteristic of the nanocelluloses. Chemical modification of the nanocellulose is generally achieved via the formation of covalent bond, and the modification is categorized into five strategies excepted for the pre-treatment methods: (i) urethanization,14–17 which forms urethane linkage by reaction with isocyanate group; (ii) silylation,12,18–22 which introduce silanol groups onto the surface through forming ether (–O–) or urethane (–NHCOO–) linkage; (iii) amidation,23 which forms amide linkage (–NHCO–) by the reaction of carboxylated site with amine group; (iv) acetylation,24 which forms ester linkage (–COO–) by reaction with acetic anhydride; (v) polymer grafting (‘onto’ or ‘from’).25–27
Urethanization leading an addition reaction causes no by-products, which require elimination during the modification like silylation leading condensation reaction. Also, isocyanate functionality (–NCO) has high reaction activity, and hence can react with various functionalities such as amino (–NH2), hydroxyl (–OH), and carboxylic acid (–COOH) groups. The high reactivity of the isocyanate group can render its chemistry to complicate, but it is possible to design various experimental approaches for desired chemical reactions. Despite above interesting advantages of urethanization, the surface tuning of the nanocellulose through urethanization strategy has received little attention compared to other surface tuning methods.
In the present work, our aims are to modify surface of cellulose nanocrystal (CNC) by using urethanization technique and to successfully disperse CNCs in PLA matrix for PLA nanocomposites. Toluene diisocyanate (TDI) was used for improving dispersibility of the CNCs in nonpolar organic solvents and compatibility of the CNCs with PLA. Particularly, TDI can lead many interactions with PLA compared with polyolefin such as polypropylene and polyethylene. The toluene moiety in TDI can interact with methyl group in PLA chain, and also its isocyanate group can react with hydroxyl group and carboxyl group at the chain ends (more details discussed later). Therefore, it can be expected that a continuous phase can be formed between PLA matrix and CNCs through TDI modification of CNCs. To the best our knowledge, TDI has not been reported in the surface modification area of the nanocellulose. Effects of the TDI on the dispersibility and the compatibility in the preparation of the PLA nanocomposites films were explored with various angles such as chemical, mechanical and optical properties. Meanwhile, a solvent exchange technique was adapted to obtain never-dried CNCs having no strong hydrogen bonds between the nanoparticles during the CNC manufacturing process.
:
2,6-TDI = 80
:
20, Alfa Aesar) was adapted for chemical modification of the CNCs. Sulfuric acid for acid hydrolysis of the cellulose powder was obtained from Junsei Chemical Co., Ltd. and was diluted to 64 wt% prior to use. Deionized water (DI-water, resistivity > 18 MΩ) was used for acid hydrolysis. Acetone (Ac), N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF), dichloromethane (DCM), and chloroform (CF) (HPLC grade, from Daejung Chemicals Co., Ltd.) were used for the solvent exchange as received.
620g with 10 °C for 10 min) and redispersion (at 10
000 rpm for 30 s) were performed four times each exchange step to the desired solvent by using a high speed refrigerated centrifuge (Mega 17R, Hanil Science Industrial) and a homogenizer (Ultra Turrax® T25, IKA®), respectively. DMF and CF were our target solvents for the chemical modification and PLA film casting, respectively.
DMF suspension (100 ml) including CNCs of 1 g was added into a three-neck flat-bottomed flask with a reflux condenser under nitrogen condition, and the flask was immersed in silicon oil bath preheated up to 70 °C. After 30 min for obtaining stable DMF suspension at 70 °C, TDI was added into the suspension in drops with an equivalents ratio of 2
:
1 for isocyanate groups in TDI and whole hydroxyl groups in CNCs. TDI grafting reaction was carried out for 24 h, and DMF exchanged to CF. Subsequently, CNC suspension in CF was sonicated by using sonicator (VCX 130, Sonics & Materials Inc.) to achieve homogeneous suspension for 15 min four times in an ice bath.
C
O stretching (Fig. 2b); (iii) 1800–1200 cm−1 corresponding to C
O stretching in amide group (Fig. 2c); (iv) 3000–3600 cm−1 corresponding to intermolecular hydrogen bonded O–H stretching (Fig. 2d).
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 FTIR-ATR spectra of CNCs and mCNCs: (a) full range of IR spectroscopy, (b) NCO region, (c) amide region, and (d) intermolecular hydrogen bonded OH region. | ||
As shown in Fig. 2a, the absorption band at 1100 cm−1 attributed to secondary alcohol is strongly increased after TDI modification of the CNCs compared with at near 1070 cm−1 corresponding to primary alcohol. From the result, it is suggested that reactivity of isocyanates prefers primary hydroxyl groups to secondary ones. This is because the relative reactivity of isocyanates against primary hydroxyl group is about three times as high as secondary hydroxyl group under condition of non-catalyst.34 In chemical modification of the CNCs using bifunctional TDI, our aim was to induce a chemical bond between the terminal carboxyl groups at end positions of PLA backbone and isocyanate groups on surface of mCNCs as well as physical interactions such as hydrogen bond and van der Waals forces, when incorporated with PLA resin. Fig. 2b shows distinctive change of band intensity between pristine CNCs and mCNCs at 2272 cm−1 corresponding to NCO stretching. The result can suggest the existence of the free second NCO group of the TDI after the modification of the CNCs because of reduction in reactivity of the second NCO group. It could be due to electron releasing effect of urethane group derived from the reaction between the hydroxyl group of the CNCs and the first NCO group of the TDI.34,35 Fig. 2c demonstrates clear evidence for mCNCs chemically linked with TDI. Several absorbance peaks are confirmed in the amide region: (i) at 1710 and 1537 cm−1 associated with C
O stretching in urethane group, and (ii) 1600 cm−1 associated with C
C stretching in aromatic ring. In addition, intermolecular hydrogen bonding interaction between the mCNCs can be reduced due to TDI attachment onto surface of the mCNCs, as shown in Fig. 2d.
Fig. 3 shows an effect of the surface modification on dispersion of the CNCs in CF. Significantly fast aggregation between CNC nanoparticles is occurred in CF despite just after sonication, on the other hand the suspension of mCNCs remains stable after time. The stability of mCNC nanoparticles in the hydrophobic organic solvent can be attributed to improving compatibility between the solvent and mCNC surface nature, which is induced by TDI.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 CNC and mCNC suspensions in chloroform: (a) after 15 min sonification and (b) after 15 min sonification and 5 min standing. | ||
![]() | ||
| Fig. 4 Transparency of PLA films with CNCs (a–c) and mCNCs (d–f) test using background images as a function of nanocellulose loading level. | ||
UV-Vis analysis was performed for the more precise analysis on the optical property. Fig. 5 represents transmittance of PLA films with pristine CNCs (a) and mCNCs (b) in ultraviolet (UV) (100–400 nm) and visible light (400–700 nm) regions as a function of the nanocellulose content. The transparency of polymer films is generally gauged through measuring transmittance of visible light in the wavelength range of 540–560 nm according to ASTM-D1746-03 due to the eye sensitivity.36 As can be expected from Fig. 4, the PLA films with the mCNCs maintain higher transmittance than the CNC cases at the same content level in the range of 540–560 nm. Also, the PLA films with mCNCs reduce UV-B light in the range of 280–315 nm which is responsible for the photochemical degradation of packaged goods despite having higher transparency than the CNC case. Therefore, the transparent PLA film as a barrier against UV light can be obtained by incorporating TDI modified CNC due to homogeneity of the mCNCs in the PLA matrix.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 5 Transmittance of PLA films with CNCs (a) and mCNCs (b) in ultraviolet and visible light regions as a function of the nanocelluloses content. | ||
Qing et al.37 reported that the enhancement in the light transmittance of a film was attributed to increase in the surface smoothness (low roughness) of the film due to the reduction of surface light scattering. Thus, AFM measurement was performed to explore the surface roughness of PLA film with nanocellulose. Fig. 6 shows 3-D plotted AFM images representing the difference of the surface topography between the PLA films with CNCs (Fig. 6a: CNC1 and Fig. 6b: CNC5) and mCNCs (Fig. 6c: mCNC1 and Fig. 6d: mCNC5). The PLA films with mCNC have more even surface than CNC case, and the surface evenness reduces with increasing the loading level of the nanocellulose. To better understand the surface smoothness of the films, Rq (RMS roughness, root mean square roughness) values were calculated from the AFM images. Fig. 7a represents Rq values of PLA nanocomposites as a function of the nanocellulose content. Surface roughness increases with the nanocellulose loading level. Also, the Rq of the PLA films with the CNCs increases significantly in comparison with the mCNC cases. The Rq trend is good agreement with the trend of transmittance in the visible light. The increase of Rq can indicate the agglomeration occurrence of the nanoparticle in PLA matrix. The severe agglomeration of the CNCs in PLA matrix can be occurred due to the difference in the compatibility between the nanoparticle and PLA solution, and hence it is mandatory for the pristine CNCs case to have the Rq trend. On the contrary of the CNC case, the PLA films with mCNC have very low Rq values resulted from its good dispersibility in PLA matrix but show a similar Rq trend with CNC case as increasing nanocellulose loading level. The little agglomeration of the mCNC could be formed due to closed distance between mCNC particles with increasing mCNC loading level.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 6 Surface topography of PLA film with nanocelluloses in the area of 15 × 15 μm: (a) CNC1, (b) CNC5, (c) mCNC1, and (d) mCNC5. Height scale bar: 200 nm. | ||
Another noticeable thing is that the Rq values of PLA film with mCNC 1 and 3 are lower than that of the pure PLA film. Fig. 7b shows schematic illustration for demonstrating roughness changes of the pure PLA and PLA nanocomposite films. The polymer chains are experienced a stress relaxation caused by the chain entanglement when the solvent evaporation is occurred.38 The rate of solvent evaporation at each local evaporation point can be irregular and it may cause difference in the chain density. However, well-dispersed nanocrystals in PLA matrix reduce the difference in the density through decreasing the chain mobility.39 Therefore, the addition of mCNCs in the PLA matrix can make the surface of the PLA nanocomposite the smoother than the pure PLA film attributed to the improved dimensional stability of PLA network chain structure.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 8 TGA results of CNCs and mCNCs: (a) weight loss, and (b) derivative weight as a function of temperature. | ||
Fig. 9 shows thermal gravimetric analysis of PLA nanocomposites with CNCs and mCNCs compared with neat PLA film. It is noticeable that the PLA film incorporated with the mCNCs shows lower thermal stability than the neat PLA film and PLA nanocomposite with pristine CNCs, although the thermal stability of the CNCs themselves was improved by introducing TDI onto its surface. The dispersibility improvement of the mCNCs in the PLA matrix results in its high surface area compared with the agglomerated CNCs, and hence the mCNCs can reduce thermal stability of the PLA film with the mCNCs due to the increase of the heat transfer rate in the PLA film, as explained above. Therefore, the addition of a flame retardant may be necessary to achieve the high thermal stability of the PLA nanocomposite reinforced with the mCNCs.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 9 TGA results of PLA films with CNC and mCNCs: (a) weight loss, and (b) derivative weight as a function of temperature. | ||
![]() | ||
| Fig. 10 Effects of CNCs and mCNCs on tensile properties ((a): strength, and (b): elongation modulus) of PLA nanocomposites. | ||
On the basis of the FTIR results, TDI moieties attached onto mCNC surface by urethane linkage possibly have various interactions with the PLA backbone. Scheme 2 shows the schematic illustrations of the interactions existing at the interfaces between mCNC and the PLA backbone. A toluene moiety of the mCNC and a methyl group of the PLA backbone can form van der Waals force, and various hydrogen bonds (N⋯H and O⋯H) can be occurred. Also, it can be possible to generate a chemical crosslinking through forming amide group by the reaction between isocyanates of TDI and terminal hydroxyl or carboxyl groups of the PLA backbone. Therefore, these interactions as well as the distribution of the mCNC can be helpful for improving mechanical properties of the PLA matrix.
![]() | ||
| Scheme 2 Schematic illustration of the dispersibility of mCNC in PLA matrix and interfacial interactions between mCNC and PLA backbone. | ||
In the case of tensile modulus (Fig. 10b), both CNC and mCNC cases show no considerable changes with increasing the nanocellulose content level. Also, the PLA films filled with the mCNCs have higher tensile modulus (elongation modulus) than the pristine CNC cases. The increase of the tensile modulus can be associated with the increased stiffness of the composite materials.43 The stiff CNCs can act as hard domain as forming homogenous phase in the soft amorphous PLA matrix through the TDI chemical modification. This is because TDI modification of the CNCs leads enhancement of the compatibility between the CNCs and PLA matrix, as explained above. Hence, the good dispersion of the mCNC can improve stiffness of the soft PLA matrix. However, the function as stiff hard domain might be offset by little agglomeration of the mCNCs as increasing mCNC loading level. Therefore, the PLA film with the mCNCs has higher modulus than the pure PLA film and the PLA film with the CNCs, but the increase of the mCNC content has nearly influence on improving the modulus of the PLA film with the mCNCs.
Fig. 11 shows the elongation of the PLA nanocomposites as a function of the nanocellulose loading level. It has similar trends with the tensile strength and modulus in comparison between PLA films with CNCs and mCNCs. This trend can be due to formation of a continuous structure of mCNC in PLA matrix by enhancing compatibility between them, as explained above.
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2016 |