Danhua Xiea and
Jianxi Zhao*b
aDepartment of Chemistry, Fujian Province University Key Laboratory of Green Energy and Environment Catalysis, Ningde Normal University, Ningde, Fujian 352100, P. R. China
bInstitute of Colloid and Interface Chemistry, College of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Fuzhou University, Fuzhou, Fujian 350108, P. R. China. E-mail: jxzhao.colloid@fzu.edu.cn
First published on 4th March 2016
The cloud point (CP) behaviour of a carboxylate gemini surfactant, O,O′-bis(sodium 2-dodecylcarboxylate)-p-dibenzenediol (referred to as C12ϕ2C12), in aqueous solution has been examined in the presence of tetra-propyl-ammonium bromide (Pr4NBr), an organic salt with less hydrophobicity than that of commonly used species. The aggregates of C12ϕ2C12 in the solution were investigated by dynamic light scattering (DLS), steady-state fluorescence and rheological measurements. Compared with traditional single chain surfactants, C12ϕ2C12 showed the CP phenomena at very low surfactant concentrations. In the presence of Pr4NBr, C12ϕ2C12 in aqueous solution formed several types of aggregates with different sizes. As the temperature was raised to the CP, the micelles rapidly associated, resulting in a cloud-like appearance of the solution. The mechanism has been attributed to C12ϕ2C12, which can provide an attractive force for the micelle–micelle contact. Namely, with increasing temperature, some of the C12ϕ2C12 molecules within the micelles changed their configuration from cis- to trans-form, leading to some tails of C12ϕ2C12 in aggregates stretching towards the solution. When such micelles approached each other, these projecting tails interacted hydrophobically, and this resulted in the association of the micelles.
CP phenomenon also occurs in ionic surfactant systems but the mechanism is more complex than that in non-ionic systems since electrostatic repulsion is ever-present between the charged micelles, which together with their hydration hindrance may greatly exceed the attraction between the micelles induced by van der Waals forces.2,3 Therefore, the generation of the CP phenomenon in ionic surfactant systems always requires the addition of a salt to screen the charge of the micelles. Another role of the salt is to pull the micelles together (providing attractive force). Symmetrical quaternary ammonium bromides such as tetra-n-butyl ammonium/phosphonium and tetra-n-amyl ammonium bromides are often applied for this purpose. For example, for the sodium dodecylsulfate (SDS) system, the alkyl quaternary ammonium ion, R4N+, orients its alkyl chains in two directions due to geometrical restrictions: one towards the water phase, the other protruding towards the micellar core.4 The alkyl chains pointing towards the water phase may interact with the alkyl chains of other counter-ions attached to another micelle, leading to a micelle–micelle contact. To achieve this purpose, the alkyl chain of any quaternary ammonium counter-ion is required to attain a certain length. Accordingly, tetra-n-propyl ammonium bromide is rarely used to investigate CP phenomena in ionic surfactant systems as it bears shorter alkyl chains than tetra-n-butyl ammonium or tetra-n-amyl ammonium salts.
In the case of anionic surfactants, Yu and Xu5 reported the first instance of cloud point behaviour for tetrabutylammonium tetradecyl sulfate surfactant. Following their pioneering work, sodium dodecylsulfate (SDS),6–10 sodium dodecylbenzene sulfonate (SDBS)11 and sodium oleate (NaOA)12 were also investigated. The CP phenomenon was observed in the presence of the hydrophobic salt, Bu4NBr, tetra-n-butylphosphonium bromide (Bu4PBr), tetra-n-amylammonium bromide (Am4NBr), or triethylammonium chloride (Et3NHCl), in which Et3NHCl was only suitable for NaOA and had no common significance.
Gemini surfactants consist of two hydrophilic head groups, two hydrophobic chains and a spacer linked at or near the head groups.13 Compared with traditional single head and single chain surfactants, this special molecular structure may bring out some novel solution properties including the CP behaviour. Firstly, the head groups of gemini surfactants can strongly associate with counterions,14–16 which is a prerequisite for yielding the CP as pointed out by Kalur and Raghavan.12 Secondly, the spacer presented not only determines the molecular geometry but also provides the possibility of introducing some functional group(s) within the head region.17 A complementary attractive force can be induced between the aggregates by these functional groups which may make CP behaviour occur relatively easily. Although gemini surfactants exhibit the possibility of producing CP behaviour, no reports relative to this subject are currently available.
Recently, we have been interested in the gemini surfactant O,O′-bis(sodium 2-dodecylcarboxylate)-p-dibenzenediol, referred to as C12ϕ2C12. The molecular structure of C12ϕ2C12 is shown in Scheme 1. C12ϕ2C12 forms network-like aggregates at a very low concentration.18 With increasing concentration, these aggregates transform into rod-like (even thread-like) micelles without any additives.19 Such unusual aggregation behaviour is caused by the presence of long and rigid dibenzene spacer. In this paper, we further report the CP behaviour of C12ϕ2C12 in the presence of tetra-n-alkylammonium bromide, an organic salt which is rarely used to induce CP behaviour of ionic surfactants because of its lower hydrophobicity.
![]() | ||
Scheme 1 Chemical structure of the anionic gemini surfactant C12ϕ2C12 containing a dibenzene spacer. |
![]() | (1) |
The CP phenomena of the present systems are slightly different with that reported in ref. 12. The physical appearance of one of C12ϕ2C12/Pr4NBr system below and above their CP points is shown in Fig. 1. Below CP, all solutions are homogenous and transparent as pure water. When the temperature was increased to their corresponding CP, the solutions show cloud-like appearance instead of obvious phase separation. This appearance didn't show further change after these solutions are stored at 80 °C for 1 week (80 °C is the temperature that above their CP).
Fig. 2 shows the CP curves of C12ϕ2C12 in the presence of Pr4NBr. Compared with the SDS system as studied by Kumar et al.,7 the present plots presented two obvious features. One was the variation extent. For the C12ϕ2C12 system, the CP rose rapidly at low surfactant concentrations and then tended to a plateau with increasing surfactant concentration. In contrast, the increase of CP with rising SDS concentration was slow over the low concentration range and became faster at higher concentrations, during which no plateau was observed over the range of the added Bu4NBr concentrations. This feature in Fig. 2 may relate to the strong association of C12ϕ2C12 with organic counter-ions since each gemini molecule carried the charged head-groups to a greater extent than was the case in traditional surfactants.14–16 This led to more effective neutralisation for the surface charge of C12ϕ2C12 aggregates in comparison with the SDS case, particularly at low surfactant concentrations where the counter-ions were more excessive at a fixed concentration of Pr4NBr. This satisfied the prerequisite of generating CP behaviour as emphasised by Kalur and Raghavan,12 and may be the reason for the induction of a rapid rise of the CP curve at low surfactant concentrations as shown in Fig. 2.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Variation of CP with concentration of C12ϕ2C12 in the presence of Pr4NBr: □, 300; ○, 400; ▵, 450; ▿, 500; ◊, 800 mmol L−1. |
Another feature in Fig. 2 was the response concentration of C12ϕ2C12 to the CP, which was much lower than that of SDS in the presence of identical concentrations of Bu4NBr. For SDS, 50 mmol L−1 was the lowest concentration examined,7 whereas in the present work, the smallest concentration of C12ϕ2C12 was only 3 mmol L−1, nearly 20 times lower than SDS. This was due to the strong ability of geminis to aggregate as mentioned previously. In a salt-free system, the cmc that characterised the ability of surfactant aggregation was in the order of μmol L−1 for C12ϕ2C12 (ref. 18) and 8 mmol L−1 for SDS as measured by surface tension. The former was almost four orders of magnitude lower than the latter. In the presence of salt, the aggregation ability of C12ϕ2C12 could be significantly enhanced. The existence of micelles in the solution was a premise to yield the CP phenomenon and therefore, it was expected that the CP of C12ϕ2C12 occurred at low surfactant concentrations.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Intensity-fraction distributions measured at a 90° angle and at 25 °C for (a) 10 and (b) 50 mmol L−1 C12ϕ2C12 with and without different concentrations of Pr4NBr, dealt from CONTIN model. |
For those bimodal distributions, a more precise approach was to fit the data using a double exponential (Dblexp) model,22 which was described in the ESI (Fig. S1, ESI†). Fig. 4a shows a plot of the scattering intensity (I) of small aggregates derived from the Dblexp model as a function of Pr4NBr concentration, in which the critical salt concentration (CP,LS) as shown by arrow, was obtained to be 15.2 mmol L−1. In addition, we carried out a solubilization test using a hydrophobic probe, 1,6-diphenyl-1,3,5-hexatriene (DPH). Fig. 4b shows the variation of DPH anisotropy (r) with Pr4NBr concentration, in which r rapidly increased after the critical salt concentration CP,DPH. This indicated that DPH was solubilised, demonstrating the existence of core–shell micelles in the solution.23,24 The CP,DPH (15.0 mmol L−1) was consistent with the CP,LS (15.2 mmol L−1), suggesting the small aggregates had a core–shell structure. Therefore, the addition of Pr4NBr induced part of the network-like aggregates to transform into the core–shell micelles. With further increasing concentration of Pr4NBr, the micelles should gradually grow as general,26 which was reflected in their increased sizes (Fig. 3a).
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Variation of (a) scattering intensity I of small micelles for 10 mmol L−1 C12ϕ2C12 derived from Dblexp model and (b) anisotropy r of DPH with Pr4NBr concentration at 25 °C. |
Similarly, we can also decide that at 50 mmol L−1 C12ϕ2C12, the micelles with core–shell structure have already existed in the salt-free system as indicated by the DLS (Fig. 3b, bottom) where the scattering intensity distribution at smaller sizes has appeared. With the addition of Pr4NBr, as seen in Fig. 3b, the aggregates with small and large sizes grew continuously, resulting in a more and more viscous solution. At Pr4NBr concentrations of 400 and 450 mmol L−1, the systems (Fig. 5a) clearly exhibited shear thinning behaviour of viscosity above the critical shear rate c, which demonstrated the existence of threadlike (wormlike) micelles in the solution.27 The dynamic viscoelastic spectra (Fig. 5b) shows that these solutions have Maxwell fluid behaviour, in which the fitting results (solid lines) closely followed the Maxwell model with a single stress relaxation time (τR) in the range of low and medium frequencies according to the following equations:28–30
![]() | (2) |
![]() | (3) |
In conclusion, at ambient temperatures, the added Pr4NBr partly screened the charges of C12ϕ2C12 head group and reduced the hindrance of aggregation. This led to the transformation of the network-like aggregates into the core–shell micelles with continuously increasing salt concentration. If the core–shell micelles already existed in the solution, as the case at high surfactant concentrations, the addition of Pr4NBr acted to further promote their growth into thread-like micelles.
What was the attractive force driving the micelles to associate? This was a key point to reveal the CP mechanism. As described in Introduction, for anionic surfactant systems, quaternary ammonium counter-ion with a certain length of alkyl chain was always required to generate the CP phenomenon,4 which can screen the charge of the micelles, and also provide an attractive force to pull the micelles together. In the present system, however, the CP was observed in the presence of Pr4NBr. Even though Pr4NBr might neutralise the charge at the micelle surface, it was difficult to effectively achieve the interactions with other counterions attached to another micelle due to the short propyl chains. Evidently, another actor certainly substituted for Pr4NBr to play this role in the micelle association. This actor should be C12ϕ2C12!
As discussed above, C12ϕ2C12 had a tendency to produce trans configurations due to its long, rigid spacer. This tendency can be enhanced with increasing temperature and thus some alkyl tails of the molecules within the micelles might extend towards the solution. When two C12ϕ2C12 micelles approached, those projecting tails associated hydrophobically. Since these projecting tails of C12ϕ2C12 were long sufficiently, such non-covalent tail interactions pulled one micelle to the other. A schematic representation is shown in Fig. 8, which describes the mechanism of the CP in the present system. This was similar with the effect suggested by Menger and Peresypkin,37 in which vesicles formed by zwitter-ionic geminis were linked in this way to generate strings of vesicles. In fact, the vesicle associations were observed in the case of C12ϕ2C12 with the addition of CnNBr (n = 8, 10, 12).38 The present novel behaviour of C12ϕ2C12 benefited from the geometry of its long rigid spacer. This example well exhibits the exquisite property of gemini-type molecular structures in the self-assembly which is intrinsically complex.
![]() | ||
Fig. 8 Schematic representation of bridging between neighbour gemini micelles by the extending alkyl tails of C12ϕ2C12. |
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: PDF file describing details of the intensity-fraction distributions measured at 90° angle for C12ϕ2C12 without and with Pr4NBr at different temperatures dealt from Dblexp model. See DOI: 10.1039/c5ra18043k |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2016 |