Open Access Article
Sergey S.
Kharintsev
*ab,
Alexandr I.
Fishman
a,
Semion K.
Saikin
cd and
Sergei G.
Kazarian
e
aDepartment of Optics and Nanophotonics, Institute of Physics, Kazan Federal University, Kremlevskaya, 16, Kazan, 420008, Russia. E-mail: skharint@gmail.com; Sergey.Kharintsev@kpfu.ru; Tel: +7(843)2337741
bInstitute of Perspective Technologies, Tatarstan Academy of Sciences, Baumana, 20, Kazan, 420111, Russia
cDepartment of Chemistry and Chemical Biology, Harvard University, 12 Oxford Street, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA
dDepartment of Theoretical Physics, Institute of Physics, Kazan Federal University, Kremlevskaya, 16, Kazan, 420008, Russia
eDepartment of Chemical Engineering, Imperial College, London, SW7 2AZ, UK
First published on 7th November 2016
Azobenzene-functionalized polymer films are functional materials, where the (planar vs. homeotropic) orientation of azo-dyes can be used for storing data. In order to characterize the nanoscale 3D orientation of the pigments in sub-10 nm thick polymer films we use two complementary techniques: polarization-controlled tip-enhanced Raman scattering (TERS) microscopy and contact scanning capacity microscopy. We demonstrate that the homeotropic and planar orientations of the azo-dyes are produced by applying a local dc electrical field and a resonant longitudinal optical near-field, respectively. For a non-destructive probe of the azo-dye orientation we apply a non-resonant optical near-field and compare the intensities of the Raman-active vibrational modes. We show that near-field Raman dichroism, a characteristic similar to the absorption dichroism used in far-field optics, can be a quantitative indicator of the 3D molecular orientation of the azo-dye at the nanoscale. This study directly benefits the further development of photochromic near-field optical memory that can lead to ultrahigh density information storage.
Controlling the transverse and longitudinal diffraction-free optical anisotropy in photo-responsive organic solid materials is an ongoing challenge.6 Considerable progress in polarization-controlled diffraction-limited optical microscopy has been achieved due to the longitudinal z-polarization of focused laser beams.7–11 The simplest case is related to highly squeezed (NA > 1) linearly polarized light, for which the z-component of an electric field exceeds the transverse component by four times at NA = 1.49.12 In practice, this approach is of little use because of mixed polarization; the focused light contains both (xy) transverse and (z) longitudinal polarization which are spatially mismatched. The polarization of light may be designed with focusing of higher order laser modes,12 phase discontinuity of light,13 and tunable orbital angular momentum.14 Nowadays, axially symmetric radially and azimuthally polarized (RP and AP) light have found wide applications in the analysis of molecular orientation and symmetry.6,15
Evaluation and control of the near-field polarization state are directly linked to the properties of optical nano-antennas (often referred to as tips) such as their shape, size, and orientation relative to the polarization direction of the incident light. A de-focused imaging technique16 and a polarization-dependent analysis17,18 provide the possibility to explicitly determine the direction of dipole oscillation at the tip apex. However, the tip apex polarizability tensor is commonly anisotropic since often it has an elongated shape. This is the main reason why the tip orientation tremendously affects the tip–light coupling.19 It means that an upright tip, that is perfectly smooth and cone-shaped, illuminated with longitudinal light, provides a maximal contribution to the field enhancement, whereas its tilt relative to the light polarization direction inevitably reduces the strength of the coupling.19 Generally speaking, the conical tips are not suitable for performing polarization-controlled near-field optical microscopy. For this purpose, a spherical nanoparticle-shaped tip apex with isotropic polarizability might be helpful to control the near-field polarization with the incident light in a wide angular range.18 Unfortunately, the reproducibility of the sphere-like gold tip apexes prepared with electrochemical etching is still low.20 An alternative approach is to bend the tip, as depicted in Fig. 1(a), in such a way that the in-plane and out-of-plane ‘pure’ polarizations, perpendicular to each other, contribute to the field enhancement equally. The bent conical gold tip is coupled with the RP and AP light in an optimal way, as demonstrated in ref. 17.
In this paper, we study the planar and homeotropic states of a sub-10 nm thick epoxy-based side-chain azo-polymer film using tip-enhanced Raman scattering (TERS) microscopy6,21 and contact scanning capacitance microscopy (c-SCM).22 The enhancement of the TERS intensities depends dramatically on the near-field polarization, as was established earlier for both a radial breathing mode and a graphite mode of single-walled carbon nanotubes.7,8,11 Inspired by this finding, we introduce near-field Raman dichroism for quantitative analysis of the molecular orientations of the polar azo-moieties in a glassy environment. In our approach, the out-of-plane orientation of the azo-dyes is set with a bias voltage (bv) gold tip, whereas the in-plane alignment is readily achieved with the resonant longitudinal near-field due to orientation angular burning (OAB).23–28 Non-destructive monitoring of the planar and homeotropic alignments can be probed with transverse and longitudinal non-resonant optical near-fields equally. In addition, we provide evidence for the planar and homeotropic states being robust and stable through probing the local permittivity of the azo-polymer thin film with the s-SCM tool.
200).29,30 This material is a promising non-linear optical medium for the second harmonics generation, showing a higher quadratic susceptibility of ∼62 pm V−1.29 A chemical structure of this molecule is shown in Fig. 1(b). One should emphasize that no spacers are used to attach the azo-moiety to the backbone. Therefore, the bulk amorphous polymer cannot exhibit liquid crystalline behavior. A decrease of the thickness of the CFAO thin film down to several nanometers can lead to the rapid arrangement of the azo-chromophores due to their higher mobility. A schematic illustration of the chromophore orientation is given in Fig. 1(c) where the azo-dyes are randomly oriented either in or out of the thin film plane exposed to both longitudinally and transversely polarized light. As follows from Fig. 1(c) the planar and homeotropic states are achieved using resonant LP and TP light due to the OAB effect, respectively. In order to differentiate the two orientational states their non-resonant counterparts are used. Alternatively, the out-of-plane arrangement may be induced by a local dc electrical field that is applied in the z-direction. In this case, the film becomes non-centrosymmetric, showing non-zero quadratic susceptibility.
A sub-10 nm thick CFAO film is prepared with spin-casting of the bulk polymer diluted by cyclohexanone in a volume proportion 1
:
100 (Fig. 2(a)), 1
:
150 (Fig. 2(b)), and 1
:
200 (Fig. 2(c)). As a result, we observe a spongy micro-structured thin film with the thickness estimated as the difference between the peaks in the heights histogram, as shown in the insets in Fig. 2. The mean thickness of such films is in the order of 2.3 ± 0.3 nm. A solid thin film can be fabricated with a higher concentration of the polymer, however, its thickness gets inevitably larger. A structure of mesopores containing a polymeric bump at their core is caused by wettability of the polymer with the glass substrate. As follows from the figure, a decrease of the concentration of the polymer leads to an increase of the pore size. Due to the sub-wavelength spatial resolution, appropriate height constant valleys can be found on the ragged film to study orientation effects.
At lower concentrations, for example 1
:
400 or smaller, the pores are degenerated into randomly dispersed polymeric droplets. A dark depletion area is indicative of a CFAO monolayer. To confirm this, we make a straight scratch with a softer AFM cantilever (0.01 N m−1) in contact mode, as shown in Fig. 2(c). Seeing it again in semi-contact mode reveals a ∼0.8 nm sized pitch on the cross-section (Fig. 2(d)) taken along the white dashed straight line in Fig. 2(c). Thus, the thickness of the ragged film is estimated to be approximately 3.5 ± 0.3 nm. In particular, this finding allows the suggestion that the azo-dyes almost certainly lie in the thin film plane to minimize the surface free Gibbs energy. Adhesion forces have been measured with approach/withdrawal curves (Fig. 2(d)) at the points indicated with a circle (on the polymer bulk, 30 nN), a triangle (on the depletion area, 7.2 nN), and a square (on the pitch, 4.5 nN). These results confirm the assumption of the existence of the polymer depletion areas.
The orientation of the azo-chromophores is recognized by means of non-resonant polarization-controlled TERS (PC-TERS) microscopy of a ∼4.7 ± 0.3 nm thick CFAO film. An AFM image of the film is given in Fig. 3(a). This figure clearly shows four depletion areas with polymeric bumps at their centers. These bumps are very helpful for assigning an optical response to the topography of the sample. Raman spectra with and without a bent gold tip illuminated with non-resonant 632.8 nm LP and TP light, taken at an arbitrary spot marked with a star, are shown in Fig. 3(b). The intensity of the light at the CFAO film and the exposure time were ∼1 kW cm−2 and 10 s, respectively. Five-fold and twenty-fold enhancements were reached for longitudinal and transverse excitation. The two characteristic vibrational modes at 1110 cm−1 and 1147 cm−1 correspond to the Ph-NO2 stretch and Ph-NN stretch.31 A peak at 1130 cm−1 is negligible, which is commonly responsible for photodegradation of the CFAO thin film in air, as earlier reported.6 PC-TERS maps at the 1147 cm−1 peak for both RP and AP incident light are shown in Fig. 3(c) and (d). A weak Raman contrast with the LP excitation compared to that with the TP excitation is a convincing outcome for the in-plane arrangement of the azo-dyes. Bumps at the center of the depletion areas are unavailable because of the mismatched tip–light coupling upon altering the polarization. With the transverse excitation, the distribution of the intensity over the extent of the thin film is slightly inhomogeneous. Bright Raman responses coming from the bumps are shifted from the centers of the depletion zones due to the above-mentioned reason. It is important to notice that photo-isomerization comes into play when resonant PC-TERS microscopy is in use. Therefore, this instrument is not suitable for reading optical information stored with the chromophore due to the OAB effect.
Along with photo-isomerization, the temperature-dependent mobility of polymeric chains plays a crucial role in the alignment of the azo-dyes.32–34 At the above glass temperature, the azo-polymer thin film can be easily oriented with a corona discharge-based dc electrical poling.30 In this case, the pigments are partly aligned out-of-plane towards the z-direction. A specific spectroscopic fingerprint of the ordered state is the appearance of the absorption dichroism in the visible region (for electronic excitations S1(nπ*) and S2(ππ*)) which can be defined as:
![]() | (1) |
|n> is a transition dipole moment between the electronic states |m> and |n>. Unlike the traditional formulas for linear or circular dichroism, longitudinal (out-of-plane) absorbance Iab∥ and transverse (in-plane) absorbance Iab⊥ are used in eqn (1).
The absorption dichroism, defined with eqn (1), serves as a quantitative indicator of the transverse and longitudinal orientation. For the isotropic state we have 2Iab∥ = Iab⊥ and therefore, Dab = 0. In the limiting cases, upon TP and LP light illumination, the dichroism should become −1 and 1, respectively. The change in the sign of this magnitude could be used to encode optical information. However, a direct measurement of the electronic absorption spectra Iab∥ and Iab⊥ results inevitably in the disturbance of the ordered state due to photo-isomerization. Non-resonant Raman spectroscopy and infrared spectroscopy are preferable to delicately probe the induced orientation in a non-destructive fashion. In far-field Raman spectroscopy, a depolarization ratio ρ is normally used to distinguish the molecular symmetry and vibrational modes. However, this magnitude is used for linearly polarized light only. In analogy with eqn (1) we introduce the following expression for near-field Raman dichroism at a vibrational mode ν:
![]() | (2) |
![]() | (3) |
![]() | (4) |
![]() | (5) |
and
present a frequency-dependent molecule polarizability without and with a gold tip, g is an enhancement factor, and
is an oscillating optical field. μind is dependent on the properties of the gold tip and its orientation in respect to the molecule frame. Obviously, at g ≫ 1 a significant contribution to the Raman tensor is made with the tip-dependent molecule polarizability. Since the form of this tensor is in general not known, an understanding of no photo-bleaching at high intensity optical fields is still unavailable. It follows from the behavior of intensities peaked at 1340 cm−1 and 1400 cm−1 (NN symmetric stretch), which increase with the voltage rather than drop.22
![]() | ||
| Fig. 4 (a) TERS spectra of the CFAO thin film at different voltages, and (b) dependence of near-field dichroism on applied voltage for two characteristic vibrational modes. | ||
Thus, the longitudinal and transverse optical anisotropy of the CFAO polymer thin film exposed to optical and electrical fields at the nanoscale can be quantitatively characterized with the near-field Raman dichroism DR(V). Fig. 4(b) demonstrates a dependence of this magnitude versus the applied voltage for two characteristic vibrational modes. It also follows from the figure that the Raman dichroism for both peaks is saturated for voltages of above 5 V. It means that most of the azo-dyes are oriented out-of-plane and further increasing the voltage does not affect the homeotropic state. Furthermore, when the voltage is returned to zero, the Raman spectrum is reversibly restored under resonant illumination. In the dark, the oriented state retains its form for as long as several hours. This state can be safely unravelled with non-resonant near-fields. Closing this section, we conclude that control of the near-field polarization in TERS microscopy is of great advantage, as it allows one to probe the highly directional intrinsic properties of the azo-dyes within a glassy environment at the nanoscale. In the context of optical near-field memory this instrument may provide not only ultrahigh density data storage but contributes to error correction and polarization multiplexing.1
Fig. 5(a) shows the sketch of the experimental setup for measuring the capacitance of the CFAO thin film. In our experiment, we intend to qualitatively estimate the capacitance C(V) + const, which is very sensitive to the surface topography. Fig. 5(b), (e), (j), (c), (f), and (h) show the topography and capacitance of the CFAO thin films at different bias voltages (Vdc = Vtip − Vsample). In assumption of a plane capacitor, the permittivity may be evaluated as a product of the topography and capacitance maps, as given in Fig. 5(d), (g), and (k). At zero bias, we observe the inhomogeneous distribution of the pigments in the thicker polymer. In the case of Vdc = −10 V a permittivity contrast is noticeably enhanced. It means that all azo-chromophores are anchored along the electric field direction with negatively charged NO2 ends that are oriented upward. In other words, longitudinal optical anisotropy takes place. Fig. 5(l) shows the heights histogram before (red curve) and after (blue curve) applying the dc electric field. We observe that the mean height of the polymeric structure increases by a magnitude of ∼0.7 nm, that is, approximately one chromophore in length. This state, generated with the dc electric field in the ultrathin film at room temperature, is stored for several hours. One should notice that the orientation polarization of the azo-dyes within thicker films drops enough rapidly. For example, a 100 nm thick polymer film holds the homeotropic state for 1–2 min only.6 Cross-sections taken along dashed straight lines provide evidence that the azo-chromophores are more easily oriented in the vicinity of interfacial features rather than in thicker fragments of the polymer. In particular, a crater-like peculiarity is formed on the surface of the polymeric fragment (Fig. 5(m)).
In the case of Vdc = +10 V the permittivity contrast vanishes. This is explained by the in-plane arrangement of the azo-chromophores, since they cannot follow the electrical field because of the substrate. It gives rise to the transverse anisotropy, by which all chromophores are randomly dispersed in the film plane. Thus, changing the polarity of the applied voltage allows us to handle the oriented states between the planar and homeotropic arrangement of the azo-dyes.
The surface charge that occurs is followed by out-of-plane alignment of the azo-moieties with negatively charged ends going upward. One should bear in mind that the positively charged end group is at load, whereas the other one is free to move (Fig. 1(c)). The induced potential is dependent on the dipole moment of the azo-dyes and their concentration. Therefore, changes in the net surface potential Δφ, according to the Helmholtz equation,35,36 read as:
![]() | (6) |
Several important properties of the polar polymer thin film, such as the order and dipole depolarization, can be derived from eqn (6).35 Each azo-dye can be considered as an individual local dipole that contributes into the surface potential enhancement. If the azo-dyes concentration is low then the dipoles are located far from each other. Such a system tends to a disordered state and the surface potential vanishes in time. Increasing the azo-dye density in a glassy environment can lead to the depolarization effect and the resulting dipole moment becomes negligible. However, in an ordered polymer ultrathin film with a high concentration of the pigments a cooperative molecular effect35 comes into play due to a dipole–dipole interaction.
000 rpm for 3 min. In order to eliminate remaining solvent the thin film was annealed at the glass temperature of 130 °C and 10 mbar for 2 h.
:
0.3
:
0.2, by means of dc-pulsed voltage electrochemical etching with a self-tuneable duty cycle and working potentials of Vb = 1.5 V and Vup = 1.9 V.38 With that, ∼20 nm curvature radius gold tips were obtained (inset in Fig. 1(a)). Once prepared, the probes were thoroughly rinsed with distilled water and dried with nitrogen. After that, they were under mechanical load to become bent and glued to a conductive long tab of a horizontally oriented tuning fork (TF103_NTF, NT-MDT) operating at a resonance frequency of ∼192 kHz, as shown in Fig. 1(a). Approaching the gold tip to a thin film was safely performed with the help of a normal force feedback scheme with a scanning head (SNLG103NTF, NT-MDT) at a set-point value as small as ∼95%.
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2016 |