Lorenzo
Rovigatti
*,
Barbara
Capone
and
Christos N.
Likos
Faculty of Physics, University of Vienna, Boltzmanngasse 5, A-1090 Vienna, Austria. E-mail: lorenzo.rovigatti@univie.ac.at
First published on 5th October 2015
The fabrication of versatile building blocks that reliably self-assemble into desired ordered and disordered phases is amongst the hottest topics in contemporary materials science. To this end, microscopic units of varying complexity, aimed at assembling the target phases, have been thought, designed, investigated and built. Such a path usually requires laborious fabrication techniques, especially when specific functionalisation of the building blocks is required. Telechelic star polymers, i.e., star polymers made of a number of f di-block copolymers consisting of solvophobic and solvophilic monomers grafted on a central anchoring point, spontaneously self-assemble into soft patchy particles featuring attractive spots (patches) on the surface. Here we show that the tunability of such a system can be widely extended by controlling the physical and chemical parameters of the solution. Indeed, under fixed external conditions the self-assembly behaviour depends only on the number of arms and on the ratio of solvophobic to solvophilic monomers. However, changes in temperature and/or solvent quality make it possible to reliably change the number and size of the attractive patches. This allows the steering of the mesoscopic self-assembly behaviour without modifying the microscopic constituents. Interestingly, we also demonstrate that diverse combinations of the parameters can generate stars with the same number of patches but different radial and angular stiffness. This mechanism could provide a neat way of further fine-tuning the elastic properties of the supramolecular network without changing its topology.
Polymeric molecular building blocks present several advantages. In terms of synthesis, no cumbersome preparation techniques are required.30,31 From a theoretical point of view, the self-assembling nature of the particles makes them inherently soft and floppy, providing additional control over the target structure and its properties.32,33 However, such a subtle dependence of the bulk properties on the single-star conformation calls for a precise determination of the latter. In this work, we carry out extensive simulations of single, large telechelic star polymers for a wide range of parameters, characterising the self-assembly process and the resulting conformation as functionality, diblock copolymer length and solvent quality vary. We show that by tuning the chemical and physical parameters in solution, it is possible to influence and control the number and size of the attractive patches that each particle forms. Interestingly, we also demonstrate that different combinations of the parameters can generate stars with the same number of patches but different radial and angular stiffness. This mechanism could provide a neat way of tuning the elastic properties of the supramolecular network without changing its topology.
![]() | (1) |
All the repulsive interactions acting between both bonded and non-bonded A–A and A–B pairs are modelled through a generalised Lennard–Jones (LJ) potential,
![]() | (2) |
![]() | (3) |
Therefore, the λ parameter plays the role of an inverse temperature for the B–B interaction. The value of λ at which purely solvophobic chains have a Gaussian statistics, equivalent to the so-called θ-temperature, is λθ ≈ 0.92. For performance reasons we truncate and shift this potential at rc = 1.5.
We run Brownian dynamics simulations at fixed temperature kT/ε = 0.5.35 Single TSPs with functionality f ranging between 3 and 18 and values of α ranging between 0.3 and 0.8 are investigated. In this work we characterise how chemical and physical parameters can influence single star properties, self-assembling behaviour, localisation and flexibility of the patches, both angular and radial, focussing on monomer-resolved stars so as to access a broad temperature range and investigate a large number of (f, α) combinations.
Recent studies33 showed that soft patchy particles assemble into different gel-like structures depending on the softness of both angular and radial positions of the patches with respect to the equilibrium position; at the same time, studies on coarse-grained telechelic star polymers27 showed that the single star self-aggregating scenario is preserved upon increasing density in solution, for stars with various different (f, α) combinations. It hence becomes important to completely characterise, on the full monomer scale, how a change of chemical (solvent quality e.g. λ−1 – temperature effect), and physical parameters (such as (f, α) combinations) can lead to the formation of particles with a given number of patches, and how the radial and angular flexibility of those functionalised domains can be tuned and controlled by parameters external to the macromolecules. We hence carry out extensive characterisation of the stars and of their self-assembling behaviour as a function of λ, f and α.
The first parameter that we use to classify the stars is the number of patches Np that the macromolecules self-assemble, defined as the number of clusters formed by multiple arms. If the interaction energy between at least two monomers of different arms is negative, i.e., if they experience a net attraction, then the two arms belong to the same cluster, and hence to the same patch. According to this definition, Np ≈ 0 in the good solvent limit (λ → 0), since the attractive nature of the entropic-solvophilic monomers does not play any significant role in the self-aggregating behaviour that is instead driven by the enthalpic-solvophobic part of the molecule.
We start off by making a characterisation of the stars based on the number of self-assembled functionalised regions. We then move deeper into the description of the soft molecular building blocks by quantifying how the patch population sp, defined as the number of arms that form a patch, is influenced by the choice of the parameters. Stars with different compositions can assemble into soft-patchy nano building blocks decorated by the same number of functionalised regions. Their radial and angular flexibility will crucially depend on the number of arms that are participating in the formation of a patch and on the size of the patch itself. Hence we perform a radial–angular flexibility analysis by characterising the geometry of the assembled TSP. We compute the average distance between the centre of mass of a patch and the position of the anchoring point, rp, and the average angle between two patches, θp, defined as the angle between two vectors pointing towards each pair of patches, starting from the anchoring point. The quantities rp and θp are two very important parameters to consider when looking to hierarchically self-assemble specific structures. For example, particles with an excess of radial and angular flexibility might lose the capability to crystallise.36
The overall conformation and shape of the stars is another key characteristic, and we will elucidate its dependence on f, α and λ. The latter analysis is done by computing the shape anisotropy δ, the prolateness S and the acylindricity c.37–39 These quantities are derived from the gyration tensor:
![]() | (4) |
![]() | (5) |
![]() | (6) |
![]() | (7) |
Finally, here and in what follows we use the expression soft particle to refer to building blocks that are partially or completely interpenetrable and exhibit an intrinsic floppiness, in contrast to the usual “hard” colloids. An overview of wide classes of soft particles can be found in ref. 40.
Fig. 1 shows representative snapshots of a star with f = 15 and α = 0.5 for different values of the attraction coupling constant λ. The picture sketches the self-assembly process that takes place as λ increases for a fixed (f, α) combination. When the B-monomers, coloured in green, are in a good solvent (i.e. for small values of λ), the star is open and the inter-chain attraction is negligible. In this regime stars resemble the usual athermal star polymers.41 Upon worsening the solvent-quality, the solvophobic monomers start to collapse on themselves forming patches. A further increase of the attraction leads to a coarsening of the patches, which decrease in number but grow in size, as shown in the rightmost snapshot of Fig. 1. Similar figures are used in the plots throughout the paper to increase readability and to show how stars with different parameters look like.
We note that the functionalities investigated here yield small numbers of patches, ranging from one to four. We will put particular emphasis on stars that exhibit one to three patches since these can be used to generate low-density disordered (gel) phases.10,14,42 However, other combinations of (f, α) can be used to select higher-valency particles that can be used to assemble denser, and possibly ordered, phases.19,27 Additional control could be provided by confining the system, effectively reducing its dimensionality to generate two-dimensional or quasi two-dimensional phases with distinct symmetries and properties.43,44
Fig. 2 shows Np as a function of λ for all investigated f and α = 0.3, 0.5 and 0.7. For the lowest values of λ investigated here, all the curves are increasing functions of the coupling constant, signalling the onset of the self-assembly process. A comparison between different α suggests that this onset occurs at lower values of λ as α increases. For the lowest value of α considered here, all the curves except for f = 18 are monotonic with both λ and f. However, for high values of α and λ the curves exhibit a clear non-monotonicity. Indeed, when the attraction between solvophobic monomers exceeds a certain threshold, the arms start feeling a strong mutual attraction, collapsing on themselves and forming fewer, although larger, patches. Upon further increasing λ (λ > 1.15) these high-α systems fall off equilibrium and Np eventually plateaus. A visual inspection of the configurations shows that monomers in the largest patches eventually crystallise.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Number of patches Np as a function of λ for (top) α = 0.3, (middle) α = 0.5 and (bottom) α = 0.7. |
Depending on the number and size of the patches, these low-valence TSPs will assemble into different large-scale structures. A single patch can yield micelles or interconnected (wormlike) micelles, depending on the patch size.25 As the number of patches increases so does the connectivity, meaning that the inter-star bonds become more common, eventually leading to network formation. The overall properties of this network will depend not only on the number and size of the patches, as it is the case for patchy colloids,6 but also on the radial and angular stiffness of the stars themselves.33
We now move on to the average patch population sp, which is defined as the average number of arms per patch. Fig. 3 shows sp for α = 0.3 and 0.5. At low λ-values all curves approach 2, which is the minimum value according to our definition of a patch. For all the investigated state points sp is, within the statistical error, monotonic with λ. The observed growth of Np at intermediate values of λ is thus accompanied by an increase of sp, which then plateaus as the systems undergo a dynamical arrest for λ > 1.15. At this stage all the arms are involved in a patch, thereby sp → f/Np.
The formation of specific macroscopic phases with the desired properties and symmetry often requires building blocks with a well-defined valence and patch size.10,47 We thus have to be sure that all the relevant quantities yield not only the right average values but also small fluctuations. We estimate the conformation fluctuations by looking at the patch population distribution P(sp), shown in Fig. 4. At small λ all the distributions are peaked at sp = 2. As λ increases P(sp) starts developing longer and longer tails, making the distribution very wide and almost flat. For even stronger attractions, P(sp) becomes non-monotonic and more and more peaked; this non-monotonicity is characteristic of systems forming aggregates with a preferential size. Indeed, systems undergoing self-assembly processes, such as micelle-formation, have cluster-size distributions which exhibit similar behaviour.48 The particular value λc at which the self-assembly of the patches occurs, i.e. at which most of the arms are part of a patch, depends on α but not, or very weakly, on f, and it roughly coincides with the λ-value at which the number of patches and the average sp reach the first plateau as shown in Fig. 2 and 3. Indeed, λc decreases from ≈1.15 for α = 0.3 to ≈1.00 for α = 0.7, while its dependence on f is negligible.
The results obtained with toy models have shown that the phase behaviour of patchy systems, and in particular the symmetry of the ordered or partially ordered phases, is determined not only by the number of patches, but also by their size and geometrical arrangement.49,50 In addition, internal flexibility has been proven to play a fundamental role in the thermodynamics of these systems.36 It is thus very important to characterise the patch arrangement. We start off by introducing a vector rpi that connects the centre of mass of the i-th patch to the star centre. We then define for each pair of patches i and j an angle θp = arccos(rpi·rpj). Fig. 5 shows the distribution of the cosine of this angle, P(cosθp), for different values of α, f and λ. All the curves are clearly peaked around values that directly reflect the number of patches of the nanoparticle: for two and three patches the arrangement is planar and hence the average angle is slightly smaller than π and 2π/3, respectively. For f = 12, α = 0.5 we also observe a coexistence between the two conformations: the number of patches of the nanoparticle continuously changes between two and three, giving rise, for intermediate values of λ, to a double-peaked P(cos
θp). For higher values of α or f this transition happens in a narrower range of λ-values and we do not observe any double-peaked distribution for the investigated parameters. The effect of the functionality on the distribution of the angle is also interesting: as f increases the distributions become more and more peaked, due to the higher local density of monomers close to the anchoring point.
The functionality f plays a similar role in determining the distribution of the radial patch–anchor distance rp, P(rp), which is linked to the stiffness of the particle. Fig. 6 shows P(rp) for fixed α = 0.7, λ = 1.10 and three different functionalities, f = 12, 15 and 18, chosen so as to yield the same number of patches, Np = 2. As f increases we observe a monotonic growth of the average patch–anchor distance and a narrowing of the distribution. The net effect of f is thus to stiffen and elongate the nanoparticle.
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 Distribution of the distance between a patch and the TSP centre, P(rp), for f = 12, 15 and 18, λ = 1.10 and α = 0.7. |
As a consequence of the above single-particle properties, two networks built with stars with different functionalities but the same number of patches would differ in the spacing between neighbours and in the overall stiffness. Indeed, both are increasing functions of f, due to the narrowing of the angle and radial distributions. On the contrary, the topology, being primarily determined by the number and arrangement of the patches, would be less affected by f. We thus provide an additional degree of control on these hierarchically self-assembled materials: the mechanical and elastic properties of bulk materials can be tuned to a certain degree without varying their topology. In other words, stars with different functionalities can be exploited to obtain phases which are similar from the structural point of view but behave differently, e.g. under shear.
Fig. 7 shows the dependence of the shape parameters on f, α and λ. We start off by considering the prolateness parameter S which, as noted in section 2, has the same qualitative behaviour as the asphericity δ, which is thus not shown here. S is always positive, indicating that the stars are always prolate, regardless of f, α and λ, as also observed for chain- and ring-polymers.51 Comparing Fig. 7 with Fig. 3 shows that the steep increase of S at high values of f and λ is associated with the presence of two patches which, as also shown in Fig. 1, result in dumbbell-like, very prolate conformations. By contrast, stars with smaller functionalities end up in almost spherical single-patch states having S ≈ 0. As a consequence, at high values of λ there is a clustering of the curves with different f, depending solely on the number of patches and not on the functionality. We note that the f = 18, α = 0.7 case, which form 4 patches at intermediate λ-values (see Fig. 2), exhibits a very small prolateness, demonstrating that S is sensibly different from 0 only for Np ≤ 3. We deduce that the number of patches controls the overall shape of the star, while f affects size, stiffness and deformability of the assembled nanoparticles, as shown in the previous section.
The last investigated parameter, the acylindricity c, is always small and decreases for large values of λ. This demonstrates that stars are mostly symmetrical around the main axis. In agreement with the trends observed for the other shape parameters, this tendency is enhanced when stars assemble into dumbbells due to the presence of two large patches. Indeed, at high f and λ, c ≈ 0.
Here we showed that the self-assembly of a very promising class of polymeric building blocks, namely telechelic star polymers, can be controlled with great precision by changing the functionality or the solvophobic-to-solvophilic ratio, as well as by a careful tuning of the temperature. We have studied how the number and size of attractive spots on the surface, herein referred to as patches, vary under changing conditions, showing that, at low temperature, these quantities exhibit single-peaked, narrow distributions, thereby providing a robust route for the generation of microscopic building blocks with specific, well-defined properties. We have also studied the flexibility and stiffness of the stars, demonstrating that those depend not only on the number of patches, but also on the functionality. This opens up the possibility of selecting the elastic properties of the resulting macroscopic phases without changing their topology and average structure.
Reliable thermosensitive flexible patch formation and tunable dependence on the number of patches on temperature for a given molecular unit is a key ingredient that allows one to obtain different mesoscopic self-assembling behaviours from the same molecular species. As a consequence, different, possibly ordered, structures, as well as diverse viscoelastic properties can be obtained with the same microscopic constituents.27 The results reported here should be considered together with the notion that the conformation of single stars is preserved in low-density bulk phases.27 Indeed, in this case a direct link between the conformation of the building blocks and the final structure and phase behaviour of the resulting macroscopic material can be established, for example by means of coarser-grained models,33 or theoretical treatments.52 The investigation of such hierarchical self-assembly processes will provide an excellent testing ground for the development of new multiscale methods and also guidance for experiments for the synthesis of smart materials of the next generation.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2016 |