Open Access Article
Stefan
Seidel‡
a,
Tobias
Dierkes‡
b,
Thomas
Jüstel
*b,
Christopher
Benndorf
ac,
Hellmut
Eckert
*cd and
Rainer
Pöttgen
*a
aInstitut für Anorganische und Analytische Chemie, Universität Münster, Corrensstrasse 30, D-48149 Münster, Germany. E-mail: pottgen@uni-muenster.de; Fax: +49 251-83-36002
bFachbereich Chemieingenieurwesen, Fachhochschule Münster, Stegerwaldstraße 39, 48565 Steinfurt, Germany. E-mail: tj@fh-muenster.de
cInstitut für Physikalische Chemie, Universität Münster, Corrensstrasse 30, D-48149 Münster, Germany
dInstitute of Physics in Sao Carlos, University of Sao Paulo, Sao Carlos, SP 13560-590, Brazil. E-mail: eckerth@uni-muenster.de
First published on 1st July 2016
X-ray pure samples of SrBa8[BN2]6 and EuBa8[BN2]6 were synthesized from appropriate amounts of binary nitrides (Sr3N2, Ba3N2 and BN in sealed niobium ampoules and EuN, Ba3N2 and BN in BN crucibles, respectively) at temperatures up to 1370 K. The structure of SrBa8[BN2]6 was refined from single crystal X-ray diffractometer data: Fd
m, a = 1595.1(1) pm, wR(F2) = 0.0515, 387 F2 values and 21 variables. EuBa8[BN2]6 has a lattice parameter of 1595.00(9) pm. Both nitridoborates adopt a new 2 × 2 × 2 superstructure variant of the LiCa4[BN2]3 type, realized through ordering of vacancies and Sr2+ and Eu2+ cations, respectively. The structures of SrBa8[BN2]6 and LiCa4[BN2]3 are related by a group–subgroup scheme. The Sr2+/vacancy ordering leads to an asymmetric coordination (1 × Sr2+ and 8 × Ba2+ in a distorted, mono-capped square prism) for the [BN2]3− units with B–N distances of 132 and 136 pm. Vibrational spectra of SrBa8[BN2]6 and EuBa8[BN2]6 confirm the discrete linear [BN2]3− units and 11B solid state MAS NMR spectra are compatible with single crystallographic sites for the boron atoms. In EuBa8[BN2]6 the spectra are profoundly influenced by interactions of the 11B nuclei with the unpaired electrons of the paramagnetic Eu2+ ions.
Phase analytical studies later on led to a series of nitridoborate halides M2[BN2]X (M = Ca, Sr, Eu; X = F, Cl, Br, I) and Ba8[BN2]5F.13–16 Depending on the metal and halide matrix, the [BN2]3− units show small distortions, i.e. two slightly different B–N distances within the unit and/or N–B–N angles slightly deviating from 180°. Extension of the crystal chemistry is also possible through the ordered replacement of the alkaline earth metal position by alkali or divalent rare earth metals. Many such nitridoborates, AM4[BN2]3 (A = Li, Na; M = Ca, Sr, Ba, Eu),17–21 have been characterized structurally. They are electron-precise nitridoborates with linear [BN2]3− units. Both series of quaternary nitridoborates have been studied intensively with respect to their IR and Raman spectra.16,22,23 Distortions (deviations from linearity) of the [BN2]3− units are readily visible in the IR spectra and the separate bands for the 10B/11B isotopologues are resolved. A comparison of the spectra of different compounds reveals a clear correlation between the force constant and the effective partial charge of the [BN2]3− anion.
Most recent studies on [BN2]3− containing nitridoborates have concerned their luminescence properties. Polycrystalline samples of Mg3[BN2]N,24 Mg8–xMx[BN2]2N4 (M = Al, Si; x = 1, 2)25 and Mg3Ga[BN2]N26 were studied with and without Eu2+ doping. These compounds show broad emission bands with orange-red to deep-red photoluminescence. In view of these interesting results we extended our work to the doping of compounds with the composition MBa8[BN2]6 (M = Sr, Eu). The structures of both nitridoborates show a 50% occupancy of the strontium/europium site in order to account for an electron precise composition.27 X-ray powder patterns of our first samples always showed additional reflections that could not be indexed on the basis of the body-centered cell, indicating superstructure formation. Herein we report on a single crystal study, revealing complete strontium/vacancy ordering within a 2 × 2 × 2 superstructure cell.
EuN, Ba3N2 and BN were used in stoichiometric ratios for the synthesis of polycrystalline EuBa8[BN2]6. EuN was synthesized from europium metal (Treibacher, 99.9%), firstly preparing the hydride at 620 K for 2 h in a mixture of argon and hydrogen (Westfalen AG, Ar/W35), followed by subsequent nitridation under N2 (Westfalen AG, 5.0) at 770 K for 4 h. The starting materials were thoroughly ground in an agate mortar. The mixture was then transferred into BN crucibles, capped with a lid and calcined at 1270 K for 4 h under nitrogen. Both gases were purified using an “oxisorb”-cartridge (Spectron), which reduces the oxygen/moisture level to below five and thirty parts per billion, respectively. Further in situ gas purification was carried out using two crucibles filled with Mischmetal placed in front of and behind the reaction vessel. EuBa8[BN2]6 was obtained as a dark purple to black polycrystalline powder, similar to LiEu4[BN2]3,21 while the respective Sr compound was almost colorless. Although these two compounds are electron precise, the [Xe]4f7 configuration of Eu2+ along with low-lying 4f–5d transitions leads to complete absorption in the visible range. Two broad absorption bands are characteristic of the interconfigurational transition from [Xe]4f7 to [Xe]4f65d1(t2g) and [Xe]4f65d1(eg) of Eu2+ in cubic crystals.29,30
Due to the moisture-sensitive nature of the precursors and the final products, all handling was carried out in a nitrogen filled glovebox from GS Glovebox Systemtechnik with H2O levels well below 50 ppm.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 Experimental (top) and calculated (middle and bottom) X-ray powder patterns of SrBa8[BN2]6. The hkl indices of the superstructure reflections are marked in the experimental pattern. | ||
Irregularly shaped crystal fragments of SrBa8[BN2]6 were glued to thin silica fibers using beeswax. The sample was previously coated with paraffin oil (dried over sodium granules) for protection from hydrolysis. Subsequently the quality of the selected fragments was tested using Laue photographs on a Buerger camera (white molybdenum radiation, the image plate technique, Fujifilm, BAS-1800). Suitable crystals of SrBa8[BN2]6 were stored in Schlenk tubes under an argon atmosphere prior to the data collection. Intensity data of the selected crystal were collected at room temperature under a constant nitrogen gas flow using a Stoe StadiVari diffractometer equipped with a Mo microfocus source (λ = 71.073 pm) and a Pilatus 100 K detector with a hybrid-pixel-sensor. A spherical absorption correction was applied to the data set. All relevant crystallographic data and details of the data collection and evaluation are given in Table 1.
m, Z = 8
| Formula | SrBa8[BN2]6 |
|---|---|
| Molar mass/g mol−1 | 1419.3 |
| Lattice parameter/pm (powder data) | a = 1595.1(1) |
| Cell volume/nm3 | V = 4.0585 |
| Density calc./g cm−3 | 4.65 |
| Crystal size/μm | 30 × 40 × 40 |
| Detector distance/mm | 60 |
| Exposure time/s | 43 |
| Integr. param. A, B, EMS | 7.0; −6.0; 0.030 |
| h k l range | ±23; ±23, ±23 |
| θ min, θmax/° | 2.21/32.34 |
| Linear absorption coeff./mm−1 | 17.9 |
| No. of reflections | 23 114 |
| R int | 0.0198 |
| No. of independent reflections | 387 |
| Reflections used [I ≥ 3σ(I)] | 284 |
| F(000), e | 4800 |
| R factors R(F)/wR(F2) [I ≥ 3σ(I)] | 0.0237/0.0453 |
| R factors R(F)/wR(F2) [all data] | 0.0450/0.0515 |
| Data/parameters | 387/21 |
| Goodness-of-fit on F2 | 0.96 |
| Extinction coefficient | — |
| Diff. Fourier residues/e− Å−3 | −1.54/1.93 |
m. The starting atomic parameters for the structure refinement were obtained using the charge-flipping algorithm Superflip.32 The structure was subsequently refined with anisotropic displacement parameters for all atoms on F2 using Jana2006.33 As a check for the correct composition and site assignment, the occupancy parameters for all atoms were refined in separate least-squares cycles. All sites were fully occupied within three standard deviations. The setting of the structure was finally adjusted to that required for the group–subgroup scheme (vide infra). The final difference Fourier syntheses revealed no significant residues. The refined atomic positions, displacement parameters and interatomic distances are given in Tables 2–4.
| Atom | Wyckoff position | X | y | z | U eq |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sr | 8a | 1/8 | 1/8 | 1/8 | 134(2) |
| Ba1 | 32e | 0.25833(2) | x | x | 230(1) |
| Ba2 | 16c | 0 | 0 | 0 | 251(1) |
| Ba3 | 16d | 1/2 | 1/2 | 1/2 | 244(1) |
| B | 48f | 0.3671(6) | 1/8 | 1/8 | 240(30) |
| N1 | 48f | 0.0344(5) | 3/8 | 3/8 | 243(15) |
| N2 | 48f | 0.2025(5) | 3/8 | 3/8 | 257(15) |
| Atom | U 11 | U 22 | U 33 | U 12 | U 13 | U 23 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sr | 134(4) | U 11 | U 11 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Ba1 | 230(2) | U 11 | U 11 | −23(1) | U 12 | U 12 |
| Ba2 | 250(2) | U 11 | U 11 | −61(2) | U 12 | U 12 |
| Ba3 | 244(2) | U 11 | U 11 | −22(2) | U 12 | U 12 |
| B | 360(70) | 180(30) | U 22 | 0 | 0 | 140(30) |
| N1 | 170(30) | 280(20) | U 22 | 0 | 0 | 20(30) |
| N2 | 170(30) | 300(20) | U 22 | 0 | 0 | −10(30) |
| Sr: | 6 | N1 | 254.3(8) | N1: | 1 | B | 132(1) |
| Ba1: | 3 | N2 | 277.8(3) | 1 | Sr | 254.3(8) | |
| 3 | N1 | 303.6(1) | 2 | Ba2 | 287.3(2) | ||
| Ba2: | 6 | N1 | 287.3(2) | 2 | Ba1 | 303.6(1) | |
| Ba3: | 6 | N2 | 292.0(2) | N2: | 1 | B | 136(1) |
| B: | 1 | N1 | 132(1) | 2 | Ba1 | 277.8(3) | |
| 1 | N2 | 136(1) | 2 | Ba3 | 292.0(2) |
Further details of the structure refinement may be obtained from the Fachinformationszentrum Karlsruhe, D-76344 Eggenstein-Leopoldshafen (Germany), by quoting Registry No. CSD-431340.
The reason for superstructure formation lies in the electron-precise formulation. When sodium in the alkali metal compound NaBa4[BN2]3
18 is substituted by strontium, charge balance requires half of the strontium sites to remain unoccupied. A view of the SrBa8[BN2]6 unit cell is presented in Fig. 2. The strontium-vacancy ordering is not simply realized through decentering of the body-centred cell (as is the case for the well-known example bcc vs. CsCl type36). The eight subcell strontium sites (50% occupied) around each strontium atom are ordered 4 + 4 in the superstructure, with both strontium and vacancies in a tetrahedral arrangement. This results in a doubling of the subcell in all three directions.
The resulting near-neighbor coordination for the strontium atoms and the [BN2]3− units is presented in Fig. 3. The strontium atoms have end-on octahedral coordination by [BN2]3− units with Sr–N distances of 254 pm, similar to the shorter Sr–N distances in the structures of Sr4N3 (255–258 pm),37 SrN (258–265 pm)38 and Sr2Si5N8 (254–272 pm).39
The most pronounced influence of the strontium-vacancy ordering is readily seen in the near-neighbor coordination of the [BN2]3− units. In alkali metal compounds like NaBa4[BN2]3,18 each [BN2]3− unit has a cation coordination in the form of a bi-capped square prism. Since only half of these sites are filled in the present strontium compound, only the N1 atoms have a strontium neighbor. Consequently we observe a lower number of cations coordinating with the N2 atoms, leading to drastically shortened N2–Ba distances of 278 and 292 pm as compared to the N1–Ba distances of 287 and 304 pm. The barium displacements are readily evident from Fig. 2. The cation ordering leads to asymmetric (but linear) [BN2]3− units with interatomic distances of 132 pm for B–N1 and 136 pm for B–N2.
We have further analyzed the superstructure model of SrBa8[BN2]6 through calculations of the bond valence sums (BVS)40 and the Chardi algorithm.41,42 The refined numerical values are listed atom by atom in Table 5. The BVS data result from empirical parameters43,44 and show strong overbonding for the strontium atoms and strong underbonding for the Ba3 atoms. The charges are much better reproduced with the point-charge approach in Chardi, nicely underlining the electron-precise description. This holds also for the covalently bonded [BN2]3− units.
The SrBa8[BN2]6 structure is related with the LiCa4[BN2]3 subcell type through a group–subgroup relation, which is presented in the Bärnighausen formalism45–47 in Fig. 4. The symmetry reduction proceeds in two steps. First we observe a decentering of the body-centred lattice through a klassengleiche transition of index 2 (k2) from Im
m to Pn
m. Although this symmetry reduction leads to splitting of the 8c calcium site, there is still no possibility of ordering of the strontium atoms for the title compound. Subsequently, a second klassengleiche transition of index 2 (k2) from Pn
m to Fd
m upon doubling of the unit cell in all three directions proceeds and the splitting of the 2a site into two eightfold sites in the superstructure allows for strontium-vacancy ordering. The klassengleiche transitions lead to the superstructure reflections observed in the powder patterns. The symmetry reductions also lead to free x parameters for the Ba1 and B atoms as well as two different x parameters for N1 and N2.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Group–subgroup scheme in the Bärnighausen formalism45–47 for the structures of LiCa4[BN2]3 and SrBa8[BN2]6. The indices for the klassengleiche (k) symmetry reductions, the unit cell transformations, and the evolution of the atomic parameters are given. No representative is known for the intermediate space group Pn m. The alkali and alkaline earth sites for that intermediate are symbolized by A and AE, respectively. | ||
Ordering of cation vacancies has also been determined for the β-Ca3[BN2]2 structure,7 but with a different symmetry reduction. This superstructure variant crystallizes with the orthorhombic space group Cmce. The smaller calcium atoms and the different pattern of vacancy ordering lead to significant tilts and bending of the [BN2]3− units. For comparison, projections of the SrBa8[BN2]6 and β-Ca3[BN2]2 structures are presented in Fig. 5.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 5 Projections of the SrBa8[BN2]6 and β-Ca3[BN2]2 structures. Heights of the strontium atoms in SrBa8[BN2]6 are indicated. Both superstructures are a consequence of vacancy ordering. For further details of the vacancy ordering in β-Ca3[BN2]2, we refer the reader to ref. 7. | ||
:
20. The assumption of asymmetric [BN2]3− units as confirmed by the crystallographic data is underlined by the presence of the symmetric ν1 stretching mode in the FTIR spectrum. Further confirmation of the broken linear symmetry, due to different B–N bond lengths, is given by the doublet splitting of the ν3 deformation modes.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 6 IR spectra of SrBa8[BN2]6 and EuBa8[BN2]6. Relevant modes are indicated. For numerical values see Table 6. The modes marked with asterisks result from slow decomposition of the samples. | ||
| υ 1 | υ 2 (11B) | υ 2 (10B) | υ 3a (11B) | υ 3b (11B) | υ 3a (10B) | υ 3b (10B) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SrBa8[BN2]6 | 1028 | 1625 | 1687 | 585 | 595 | 607 | 615 |
| EuBa8[BN2]6 | 1025 | 1622 | 1684 | 583 | 593 | 606 | 613 |
The Raman spectrum of SrBa8[BN2]6 is presented in Fig. 7. EuBa8[BN2]6 was also tested; however, similarly to LiEu4[BN2]3
23 it decomposed during laser exposure. The symmetric B–N stretching splits into two bands in the Raman spectrum at 1024 and 1030 cm−1, similar to the situation in Ca3[BN2]I48 that also shows two different B–N bond lengths of 139.3 and 136.9 pm.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 8 11B MAS NMR spectrum of SrBa8[BN2]6 with simulation (red line) recorded at an external magnetic flux density of B0 = 4.7 T and a spinning frequency of 12 kHz. | ||
| δ iso | C Q | η CQ | B 0 | LB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SrBa8[BN2]6 | 26.6 | 3.30 | 0.02 | 4.7 | 2.0 |
| EuBa8[BN2]6 | 26.6 | 3.10 | 0.03 | 4.7 | 15.2 |
| 24.3 | 3.10 | 0.03 | 11.7 | 7.0 |
Footnotes |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/C6DT02029A |
| ‡ These authors contributed equally to this work. |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2016 |