Christoph J.
Sahle
*ab,
Simon
Kujawski
c,
Arndt
Remhof
d,
Yigang
Yan
d,
Nicholas P.
Stadie
d,
Ali
Al-Zein
a,
Metin
Tolan
c,
Simo
Huotari
b,
Michael
Krisch
a and
Christian
Sternemann
c
aESRF-The European Synchrotron, Grenoble Cedex 9, France. E-mail: christoph.sahle@esrf.fr
bDepartment of Physics, University of Helsinki, POB 64, FI-00014, Helsinki, Finland
cFakultät Physik/DELTA, Technische Universität Dortmund, Dortmund, Germany. E-mail: christian.sternemann@tu-dortmund.de
dMaterials for Energy Conversion, Empa, Ch-8600 Dübendorf, Switzerland
First published on 6th January 2016
We present an in situ study of the thermal decomposition of Mg(BH4)2 in a hydrogen atmosphere of up to 4 bar and up to 500 °C using X-ray Raman scattering spectroscopy at the boron K-edge and the magnesium L2,3-edges. The combination of the fingerprinting analysis of both edges yields detailed quantitative information on the reaction products during decomposition, an issue of crucial importance in determining whether Mg(BH4)2 can be used as a next-generation hydrogen storage material. This work reveals the formation of reaction intermediate(s) at 300 °C, accompanied by a significant hydrogen release without the occurrence of stable boron compounds such as amorphous boron or MgB12H12. At temperatures between 300 °C and 400 °C, further hydrogen release proceeds via the formation of higher boranes and crystalline MgH2. Above 400 °C, decomposition into the constituting elements takes place. Therefore, at moderate temperatures, Mg(BH4)2 is shown to be a promising high-density hydrogen storage material with great potential for reversible energy storage applications.
Promising alternatives for hydrogen storage include liquid organic hydrogen carriers,5 metal organic frameworks,6 carbon nanostructures,7–9 and metal borohydrides.10 Hydrogen storage in the solid state, especially in metal borohydrides, is desirable, since these materials can offer simultaneous high gravimetric and volumetric hydrogen densities.11 For metal borohydrides – such as LiBH4, NaBH4, Mg(BH4)2, and Ca(BH4)2 – to function as hydrogen storage materials, reversible desorption, i.e. cyclability, is necessary. However, the reversibility of the decomposition reactions of borohydrides can be hindered by unwanted reaction intermediates, such as for example the [B12H12]2−-phases in LiBH4 and NaBH4. These phases are kinetically stable and thus hinder the reversibility.11 Although it was found that decomposition proceeds in multiple steps and is even partially reversible, the details of the decomposition mechanisms and possible formation of stable boron phases in the intermediate steps is still debated. The amorphous nature of some of the final and intermediate compounds makes the investigation of the important details of the de- and re-hydrogenation mechanisms difficult. Furthermore, these details strongly depend on the experimental conditions and thus need to be investigated in situ.
Mg(BH4)2 is one of the most promising metal borohydride hydrogen storage materials due to its moderate enthalpy of decomposition and has been studied widely in the recent years.12–18 Hydrogen desorption was investigated with a particular focus on the possible formation of closoboranes under different thermal conditions and in different gaseous media such as hydrogen, argon, and helium or under dynamic vacuum conditions resulting in a variety of suggested decomposition pathways.15,19–23 The formation of MgB12H12, even in the early stages of decomposition, is often inferred by solid-state-nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) or evidenced indirectly via solution NMR.
The presence of [B12H12]2− would not support the use of Mg(BH4)2 for applications in cycleable hydrogen storage devices due to the kinetically unfavorable re-hydrogenation. Hence, full decomposition into MgB2 is necessary for cycling,15 which calls for reaction conditions with temperatures that are not suited for portable storage media. However, it was recently shown that Mg(BH4)2 decomposes under dynamic vacuum conditions up to 400 °C without the formation of MgB12H12.23 Here, [B12H12]2− was observed as a part of the polymeric intermediate MgBxHy between 265 °C and 300 °C, which first converts into amorphous B, Mg, and MgH2 at 400 °C and then converts completely into MgB2 at 500 °C.23 Other reports proposed a gradual B–H condensation process from [BH4]− to higher boranes in the decomposition of Mg(BH4)2.15,24 Furthermore, there are also studies suggesting the formation of MgB12H12 species during the dehydrogenation.19,20 However, the reaction conditions and, especially, the gaseous atmospheres under which those various investigations took place were not the same and, importantly, may not be applicable to practical applications. To improve reversibility and possibly modify the reaction pathways, these must be understood. Different borohydrides decompose along different pathways without a general rule. For some compounds there seems to be an emerging agreement, but the hydrogen release reactions of Mg(BH4)2 are still under discussion. So far, there are only a few inconclusive in situ X-ray diffraction (XRD)18,25,26 and infrared spectroscopy studies26 reported in the literature and a dependence on the presence of impurities remains an open question.18,25 Hence, experimental in situ studies using complementary methods are highly desireable. We apply X-ray Raman scattering (XRS) spectroscopy at both, the boron K- and magnesium L2,3-core levels, to analyze the in situ decomposition of Mg(BH4)2 under hydrogen atmosphere (up to 4 bar) at temperatures up to 500 °C. XRS provides the unique and powerful capability to investigate these amorphous and/or nanocrystalline products in situ and under well-defined thermodynamic conditions. We find that after the transition from the low temperature α/γ-Mg(BH4)2 phase to the high temperature β-phase, significant amounts of intermediate compound(s) form, which, at higher temperatures, decompose into mostly B, MgH2, and Mg. We quantify the amount of different phases present during the decomposition and discuss possible strategies to identify the intermediate phase(s) that occur(s) at lower temperatures.
In this work, XRS spectra were collected at beamline ID20 of the European Synchrotron Radiation Facility. The beam size on the sample was 150 μm × 250 μm (V × H). The spectrometer employed 36 Si(660) analyzer crystals with a mean scattering angle of 50° (used in the case of the B K-edge), and 24 analyzers with a mean scattering angle of 120° (for the Mg L2,3-edges). This results in momentum transfers of 4.2 ± 0.5 Å−1 (probing mostly p-DOS) and 8.5 ± 0.5 Å−1 (probing a mixture of s-, p-, and d-DOS), respectively. The choice of these different momentum transfers for the two different edges is dictated by the energy-loss position of the dominating Compton profile, which varies as a function of momentum transfer. The core onset extraction from the data is feasible if the peak of the Compton profile is far enough from the energy region of interest; hence in XRS different edges must often be measured with different momentum transfers. The overall energy resolution was 0.6 eV.
We purchased Mg(BH4)2 and all reference materials, i.e. amorphous B, H3BO3, MgB2, MgH2, and MgO, from Sigma-Aldrich and used them without further processing except for the nanoscale MgB12H12/carbon sample, which we prepared by a gas–solid reaction of carbon-supported Mg(BH4)2 with a B2H6/H2 atmosphere, as previously discussed.40
We used a custom high-temperature/high-pressure sample cell for the in situ measurements, as described in detail elsewhere.41 In short, we pressed the native Mg(BH4)2 powder into a circular, resistively heated sample holder (see inset in Fig. 1(b)) and covered the sample using Be foil (0.1 mm thickness) to prevent sample spillage during annealing. The reaction chamber was closed by a half-spherical Be dome (wall thickness 1.7 mm), which allowed a field of view of 2π for the incident and scattered X-rays. With this cell, we performed measurements at ambient conditions (room temperature/pressure) as well as at temperatures between 200 °C and 500 °C in steps of 100 °C. At each temperature, we measured several XRS spectra first of the of B K-edge and then the Mg L2,3-edge, checked them for consistency, and averaged signals from several analyzer crystals and different scans. Only the spectra of the boron K-edge measured at 300 °C exhibited a slight time dependence, which we will discuss later. The desired core edges were extracted from the overall spectrum by removing the contribution from valence electrons using parameterized PearsonVII functions. Details of the data analysis can be found elsewhere.42,43 We normalized all XRS curves to the area below the spectra in the energy loss range from 185–212 eV (45–65 eV) for the B (Mg) edge. In this way, the dependence on the stoichiometry of the sample is not considered; i.e., MgB12H12 has 12 B atoms per formula unit whereas H3BO3 only has one B atom per formula unit, and the fit parameters describe the contribution of a single B atom within each compound to the scattering signal. However, since the formula units are known, the stoichiometries can simply be derived, as shown in parentheses in Table 1 alongside the fit parameters. For Mg, the stoichiometric- and fit-values are equivalent since each compound only has one Mg atom per formula unit.
T [°C] | MgB12H12 | B | β-Mg(BH4)2 |
---|---|---|---|
300 | 0.12 ± 0.02 (0.02 ± 0.05)* | 0.23 ± 0.02 (0.41 ± 0.06)* | 0.64 ± 0.02 (0.57 ± 0.05) |
400 | 0.95 ± 0.02 (0.61 ± 0.08) | 0.05 ± 0.02 (0.39 ± 0.14) | — |
500 | 0.71 ± 0.08 (0.17 ± 0.04) | 0.29 ± 0.04 (0.83 ± 0.10) | — |
The approximately corresponding pressure–temperature relation measured during the in situ XRS experiment is shown in Fig. 1(b). In this case, the sample was heated to the indicated temperature and we waited until the vapor pressure reached an approximate equilibrium. The p–T-regimes during which we recorded XRS spectra are indicated by gray shaded areas in Fig. 1. The pressure increase during heating is a combined effect from both, gas law expansion and H2 release from Mg(BH4)2. During the measurements at above-ambient temperature, we observed continued hydrogen desorption and thus expect further decomposition on much longer time scales. Hence, the measured spectra depict an averaged snapshot of the sample composition in a non-equilibrium state on a timescale of 2 hours rather than the final reaction products at a certain temperature. At each temperature, directly before the XRS measurement, we collected tomographic images of the sample (the details of this technique are reported elsewhere44), shown as insets in Fig. 1(b). In the last steps of decomposition, we observed macroscopic cracks in the sample (just before 400 °C and at 500 °C). At these temperatures, the sample pellet's integrity is likely to be compromised due to large volume changes during the formation of Mg and MgO, as discussed later, as well as possible heat and gas evolution.
Fig. 2 shows the in situ spectra of the B K-edge and the Mg L2,3-edges. The minor differences between the spectra at room temperature and at 200 °C are due to the structural phase transition of α/γ-Mg(BH4)2 to β-Mg(BH4)2, which occurs between 180 °C and 190 °C.13,45,46 There is an associated small release of H2 already at 200 °C, which may be due to the presence of impurities.18 At temperatures above 200 °C, β-Mg(BH4)2 starts to decompose, which is manifested by more dramatic changes in both the B K-edge and the Mg L2,3-edges (prominent changes are marked by arrows in Fig. 2(a) and (b)).
The in situ XRS spectra can be compared to XRS spectra of reference compounds measured at room temperature to analyze the dehydrogenation reaction pathway of Mg(BH4)2. Here, we use a multi-component analysis method to quantify the phases present at each stage during thermal decomposition. We considered various prominent candidates for decomposition and intermediate products: B, a MgB12H12/carbon compound, MgB2, and metallic Mg, as well as H3BO3 and MgO to detect possible sample oxidation. These reference spectra are shown in Fig. 2(c) and (d). The XRS spectrum of metallic Mg was previously reported34 and all other spectra were measured in this work. The presence of numerous unique features in each reference spectrum allow each to be used as fingerprints to identify the main decomposition products of native Mg(BH4)2 by a multi-component fitting method. The MgB12H12/carbon-reference is representative of a wide variety of higher Mg boranes (MgxByHz) with a similar local chemical environment of B and Mg.
The multi-component fit of the B K-edge was performed by considering contributions from B and MgB12H12, except for the initial decomposition at 300 °C where, in addition, we also considered the β-Mg(BH4)2 phase (spectrum measured at 200 °C). Occurence of β-Mg(BH4)2 for higher temperatures and occurence of MgB2 in the whole temperature range could be excluded due to the analysis of the Mg L-edge as discussed later. The possibility of the oxidation of boron during annealing was excluded due to the lack of any feature at 194 eV (compare e.g. Miedema et al.38) and hence H3BO3 was not a component in the fit. The Mg L2,3-edges were fitted with contributions from all six Mg-containing references: MgB12H12, metallic Mg, MgH2, MgB2, MgO, and the β-Mg(BH4)2 phase. The best fit results are shown in Fig. 3 and the resulting best fit parameters are given in Tables 1 and 2.
T [°C] | MgB12H12 | MgH2 | Metallic Mg | MgO | β-Mg(BH4)2 |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
300 | (0.32 ± 0.05)* | 0.28 ± 0.05 | 0.01 + 0.04 | 0.00 + 0.04 | 0.35 ± 0.02 |
400 | 0.29 ± 0.05 | 0.50 ± 0.01 | 0.15 ± 0.03 | 0.16 ± 0.04 | 0.00 + 0.04 |
500 | 0.23 ± 0.05 | 0.35 ± 0.02 | 0.21 ± 0.01 | 0.27 ± 0.02 | 0.00 + 0.04 |
We find a good agreement between the measured spectrum at 400 °C and a fit involving our MgB12H12 reference sample and small amounts of B. At 500 °C, the spectral weight of B increases significantly at the expense of the MgB12H12 contribution, suggesting that some of the MgB12H12-like phase decomposes into elemental B and Mg during the observed H2 release. MgB12H12 has been found to decompose at temperatures above 400 °C into B and Mg.40 At all temperatures explored in this work, the occurrence of MgB2 could be ruled out due to its prominent pre-edge feature at 187 eV. This is in contrast to earlier studies employing vacuum conditions.14,23 We note that the present results characterize the non-equilibrium composition of the sample upon annealing for times on the order of 2 h and might not describe the final composition after long-term annealing at the same temperatures. Consequently, the results obtained here should be used to identify decomposition reaction pathways including amorphous reaction products, but not necessarily to identify equilibrium states.
The MgB12H12 carbon-nanocomposite reference material, has been used in this work to identify contributions from MgB12H12-like species, including MgB12H12 (as suggested in other work15), B12H12 dimers, or larger borane polymers interconnected by Mg atoms as they may show similar Mg and B fingerprints due to their similar chemical environment.40 However, assuming MgB12H12 to be a decomposition product according to the fit of the B K-edge at 400 °C and 500 °C, results in a larger Mg:
B ratio than expected from the 1
:
2 stoichiometry of the starting material which will be discussed after evaluation of the Mg L-edges.
This intermediate phase then decomposes into a MgB12H12-like phase (as discussed above), MgH2, metallic Mg, and small amounts of B (as inferred from the B K-edge fit) between 300 °C and 400 °C. In addition, a contribution from MgO was observed at high temperatures as indicated by the spectral feature at 57 eV energy loss. Most probably, part of the metallic Mg decomposition product was oxidized by residual oxygen in the reaction chamber. Elemental Mg is clearly present in the sample at this temperature because of the small pre-edge shoulder at around 51 eV in the Mg L2,3-edges. Between 400 °C and 500 °C, the spectral weights of MgB12H12 and MgH2 decrease, whereas those of metallic Mg and – correspondingly – of MgO increase. We infer from this that MgB12H12-like species as well as MgH2 decompose into elemental Mg and B accompanied by hydrogen release (also reported elsewhere40). The increasing contribution of Mg is coupled to an increase in MgO content. The decrease of MgB12H12 and MgH2 content directly converts to an increase of Mg and MgO content within the errors of the fit. Deviations of the fits from the measured spectra may be due to the fact that we used a nanocomposite MgB12H12 sample as a reference. Comparing the fit results obtained for the Mg L2,3- and B K-edges, similar amounts of decomposed MgB12H12 (or MgB12H12-like phases) are found. It should be noted, that at 500 °C contributions from MgB12H12-like species and MgH2 are still present in the sample, suggesting that the decomposition reaction is slow and not fully completed. Furthermore, the stoichiometric analysis of all Mg- and B-containing phases based on the fits of both edges yields an Mg:
B ratio of approximately 1
:
4 if MgB12H12 is assumed to be the decomposition product. This ratio deviates significantly from the 1
:
2 ratio of the native Mg(BH4)2, which implies that instead of MgB12H12, a polymer or other intermediate is present with a stoichiometry of 1
:
6 (Mg
:
B) that exhibits a similar local Mg and B environment compared to MgB12H12.
The present study shows that the intermediate formed in the main decomposition step of Mg(BH4)2 (between 200 °C and 300 °C) is not MgB12H12 and supports earlier studies,23 namely that an intermediate with MgxByHz stoichiometry forms first, together with MgH2. This intermediate might be Mg(B3H8)2 as identified in these earlier studies23,24 which would be consistent with the estimated stoichiometry using our fit results. At higher temperatures, MgH2 decomposes into Mg and H2, while the intermediate MgxByHz may react under the release of hydrogen to growing agglomerates containing B12H12-like units until, finally, all hydrogen is released. Between 300 °C and 400 °C a significant amount of hydrogen release can be achieved without the occurrence of unwanted byproducts such as MgB12H12 and elemental B. It is unknown from this work whether the reaction, if stopped at 300 °C, would proceed further given more time.
In order to identify the intermediate products in the early stages of the decomposition by XRS, it would be desirable to measure the reference spectra of possible intermediate products discussed elsewhere in the literature (e.g.ref. 47 and 48) and incorporate them into the multi-component fitting analysis. However, many of these possible intermediate structures were predicted via theoretical modeling and are difficult to synthesize or are unstable in freestanding form. Nevertheless, experimental XRS spectra may provide a unique benchmark for calculated XRS spectra both at the Mg L2,3- and B K-edges of the proposed intermediates.
This journal is © the Owner Societies 2016 |