D.
Pontiroli
a,
D.
D'Alessio
a,
M.
Gaboardi
a,
G.
Magnani
a,
C.
Milanese
b,
S. G.
Duyker
cd,
V. K.
Peterson
c,
N.
Sharma
e and
M.
Riccò
*a
aDipartimento di Fisica e Scienze della Terra, Università di Parma, Viale delle Scienze 7/a, 43124 Parma, Italy. E-mail: mauro.ricco@fis.unipr.it
bPavia H2 Lab, C.S.G.I & Dipartimento di Chimica, Sezione di Chimica Fisica, Università degli Studi di Pavia, V.le Taramelli 16, 27100 Pavia, Italy
cThe Bragg Institute, Australian Nuclear Science and Technology Organisation, Locked Bag 2001, Kirrawee DC, NSW 2232, Australia
dSchool of Chemistry, The University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia
eSchool of Chemistry, University of New South Wales (UNSW), Sydney, Australia
First published on 9th September 2015
Ammonia has been proposed as an indirect hydrogen carrier, as solid-state ammonia-storage could be easier than directly absorbing hydrogen in materials. Here we investigate the structural evolution of hyper-ammoniated lithium fullerides (ND3)yLi6C60 during ammonia desorption, using in-situ high intensity neutron powder diffraction. In (ND3)yLi6C60, ammonia molecules are stored in their neutral state inside the inter-fullerene interstices and are coordinated to the intercalated Li ions, forming Li–ND3 clusters. Li6C60 is found to absorb up to 36.8 wt% ND3, which corresponds to approximately 14 ammonia molecules per C60. The ammonia release, studied either in-situ or ex-situ by means of manometric analyses and differential scanning calorimetry, takes place in two main steps, at 350–410 K and 500–540 K, respectively. This corresponds to two clear 1st order structural phase transitions and the absorption process is partially reversible. These findings suggest that the system could be a good candidate for ammonia-storage applications.
In this context, the feasibility to use ammonia as a hydrogen carrier represents an interesting alternative, since ammonia is easy to synthesize and allows high H2 storage capacity (up to 18 wt% in liquid NH3).4 Currently, ammonia is mainly produced by reacting atmospheric nitrogen with the hydrogen contained in natural gas, through the Haber process;5 but other sources, such as coal or coke gasification, are available, which, in combination with CO2 sequestration, could in principle offer a long-term ammonia production at zero emission.4 In contrast to hydrogen, even though liquid NH3 is more toxic than common hydrocarbons, infrastructure for handling and transporting bulk ammonia are already well-established and developed. Nevertheless, especially for mobile applications, hazards associated with ammonia use should be further reduced ideally being a safer solution than gasoline. These hazards can in principle be lowered by storing ammonia in solid systems, such as metal ammines, which are able to reversibly absorb/desorb ammonia gas, provided at elevated temperatures.6 Use of NH3 as a fuel can be direct, for instance by feeding ammonia straight into solid oxide fuel cells (SOFC),7 or indirect, through the catalytic decomposition of ammonia8 at high temperatures (300–500 °C) and using hydrogen as an energy source.
Notably, some common solid ammonia containing systems find direct use as hydrogen-storage materials, for example, ammonia borane (NH3BH3 with 19.6 wt% H2),9 or the ammonia complexes of borohydrides (LiBH4·nNH3 with 18 wt% H2, Mg(BH4)2·nNH3 with 16 wt% H2).10,11 This is because in these compounds the thermal decomposition usually causes the recombination of the N–H and B–H groups (followed by H2 emission), rather than the release of pure ammonia. It is worth noting that this recombination makes the H2-storage irreversible in these systems. The situation is different in the case of metal ammine complexes M(NH3)nXm, where M is a metal cation (e.g. Mg, Ca, Ni) and X is an anion (e.g. Cl, SO4). Metal ammine complexes6,12 were reported to reversibly store up to 10 wt% NH3, although the complete ammonia release occurs at temperatures too high for practical applications, i.e. up to 650 K. More recently, the complex Li2B12H12 was found to catch seven NH3 molecules and to completely release them below 473 K, corresponding to 43.4 wt% NH3 stored under mild conditions.13 Another noteworthy compound is LiBH4, forming four stable ammoniated species.14 In particular, the mono-ammoniated phase of lithium borohydride contains 44 wt% ammonia and was reported to release ammonia at the accessible thermal decomposition temperature of just 313 K, although it presents a minor equilibrium NH3 vapour pressure (8.4 mbar) at room temperature.15 Different approaches, based on the NH3 physisorption in highly porous materials, like covalent organic frameworks (COFs), led to lower storage performance, up to 25.5 wt% ammonia stored at 1 bar.16
Recently, alkali intercalated fullerides (AIFs) have attracted some interest in the field of solid energy storage, for their ability to reversibly absorb hydrogen with favourable binding energies.17–19 In the case of hydrogen, the storage mechanism occurs through the chemical bond of H atoms on the C60 molecule (formation of the hydrofullerene C60Hx), which is mediated20 by the catalytic activity of the intercalated alkali (lithium, sodium) clusters21–24 and can be optimized by the presence of catalysers.25,26
The ability of AIFs to react with ammonia is another well-known phenomenon.27,28 Typically, NH3 molecules can be co-intercalated in the AIF lattice interstices directly during the synthesis stage, from the reaction of C60 with the alkali metal (e.g. Li, Na, K) in ammonia solution,29 or by exposing the prepared AIF to ammonia vapours.30 Ammonia acts as a neutral spacer for the fulleride lattice and coordinates with the alkali ions.31,32 The induced lattice expansion dramatically affects the electronic and magnetic properties of the metallic highly-correlated AIF phases, which generally lie on the verge of a metal-to-insulator transition.33 However, despite the intense research activity on these compounds, so far there have been no investigations on these systems for ammonia-storage purposes.
In this work, the ND3 desorption as a function of the temperature of the ammoniated phases of lithium fulleride (ND3)yLi6C60 is investigated using neutron powder diffraction (NPD). The structural evolution of the compound was, in addition to the NPD data, followed by the in-situ monitoring of ammonia release via a Sievert apparatus directly connected to the sample-holder. Ex-situ manometric measurements and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) analyses were also performed, in order to precisely determine the thermodynamic properties of this system.
NPD experiments were performed on the three obtained hyper-ammoniated lithium fullerides (ND3)yLixC60 at the high-flux powder diffractometer WOMBAT,34 at the Bragg Institute of the Australian Nuclear Science and Technology Organisation (ANSTO, Sydney, Australia), using an incident wavelength of λ = 2.9654(2) Å, determined using the La11B6 NIST standard reference material 660b. The high neutron flux intensity on this instrument meant that the typical accumulation time of each pattern was on the order of 1 min. Samples were loaded in vanadium cells equipped with a gas delivery tube and isolation valve. Sample loading was performed in a He glove-box with <0.1 ppm H2O and O2. The gas delivery tube was then connected with a Hiden Isochema IMI gas-delivery system, able to perform in-situ Sievert analysis of the ND3 desorption process. During the experiment, ND3 desorption was induced by gradually increasing the temperature of samples, which was varied in the range of 15–500 K using a cryofurnace on the sample position. The temperature was controlled via a k-type thermocouple at the base of the sample cell, with a second thermocouple attached to the cell above the sample level for monitoring purposes.
Samples synthesized at the same conditions starting from natural ammonia (Aldrich, 99.99+% purity) were investigated in parallel with ex-situ manometric/DSC analysis at the Pavia H2 lab, by heating the sample from room temperature up to 653 K under 0.3 bar of He at 5 K min−1 in a high pressure cell of a Sensys DSC (Setaram) connected with a PCTPro-2000 manometric instrument (Hy Energy-Setaram). This was undertaken in order to better determine the thermodynamic parameters of the NH3 release process.
For the sake of clarity, selected diffraction patterns of the four regions are plotted in separate panels displayed in Fig. 2. Below room temperature, the diffraction pattern consists of a set of broad peaks, superimposed to few narrower ones. Although not indexed, the broad peaks were ascribed to the hyper-expanded ammoniated fulleride phase containing up to 14 ammonia molecules per C60 (phase 0), while the latter were indexed to the tetragonal phase of LiND2 (S.G. I4, a = b = 5.03(1) Å, c = 10.26(3) Å)35 which is present as the minority phase in the sample (<2 wt%).
At around 350 K, the first phase transition occurs, indicated by a slight rearrangement of the fulleride cell parameters, which is probably associated with a small amount of ammonia released by the sample. The reflections were successfully indexed to a hexagonal cell, containing about 12 ND3 molecules per C60 (phase 1-hcp, a = 10.86(1) Å, c = 18.57(1) Å, γ = 120°, Vcell = 1794(5) Å3 − VC60 = 948(2) Å3).
A more dramatic structural transition is found at 410 K, when the powder pattern starts to change, with new peaks arising in the region at 30 < 2θ < 50°. At the same time, the total counts rapidly decrease, indicating a significant loss of the sample mass. At 470 K this second phase transition is complete and all the observed reflections are indexed to a bcc phase, isostructural to the already known Mott–Hubbard insulating phase of (NH3)6Li3C60 (phase 2-bcc, S.G. Im, a = 11.92(1) Å, Vcell = 1742(6) Å3 − VC60 = 871(3) Å3).29,32
It is worth noting that at this stage (above 470 K) the peaks referred to LiND2 are no longer present, even if the melting point and the decomposition temperature of the LiND2 phase are expected at a much higher temperatures (648 and 973 K respectively). This fact, which was not observed in the other investigated samples (see ESI, Fig. 2S†), could be due to a chemical reaction occurring between the segregated Li amide and the fulleride, similarly to what observed in case of hydrides.18
The bcc phase appears stable for a wide range of temperatures, against a continuous loss of mass probed by the neutron total counts; during this stage the estimated amount of ammonia ranges between 7 and 5 ND3 molecules per C60.
Finally, at 500 K a third structural phase transition is observed, which suddenly brings to a fcc rearrangement of the fullerene packing, similarly to what is observed in pristine Li6C60 (phase 3-fcc, S.G. Fmm, a = 14.02(1) Å, Vcell = 2758(5) Å3 − VC60 = 689(3) Å3).17,25 This phase is compatible with an ammonia-free structure. The comparison between the mass before and after the experiment, in fact, reveals a loss of about 26.7 wt%, which corresponds to the complete desorption of ammonia from the sample. A more precise determination of the parameters describing the ammonia release process is discussed below, through the analysis of manometric/DSC data collected ex-situ (see also Table 1).
Phase | Symmetry | ND3 cont. (wt%) | In-situ tr. T (K) | Ex-situ tr. T (K) |
---|---|---|---|---|
Phase 0 | Not indexed | 36.8(3) | — | — |
Phase 1 | hcp | ∼32 | ∼350 K | — |
Phase 2 | bcc | 13–18 | ∼410 K | 350(5) K |
Phase 3 | fcc | — | ∼500 K | 535(5) K |
Similar neutron powder diffraction measurements were performed on (ND3)yLixC60 samples with x = 3 and 12 and data were shown in Fig. 2S of the ESI.† However, in these cases the ammonia-storage performance was revealed to be worse if compared with Li6C60. In particular, for (ND3)yLi3C60, the amount of co-intercalated ammonia turned out to be significantly lower, on the order of 10 wt%. This is most likely due to the lack of formation of a hyper-expanded ammoniated phase in this case. Moreover, the complete desorption of ammonia was not reached during the in-situ thermal treatment – even at 500 K the sample still shows the bcc arrangement.
On the other hand, in the case of (ND3)yLi12C60 the behaviour is similar to (ND3)yLi6C60, even if a rather large amount of LiND2 is present. The increase in the LiND2 content at this composition is due to the partial reaction of Li with ND3 during the ammoniation process. The peaks ascribed to LiND2 remain during the whole thermal treatment (see Fig. 2S†) and allowed us to estimate the amide amount in the sample at about 12 wt%. Such an amount clearly affects the effective stoichiometry of the Li fulleride, which after corrections, turns out to be Li6.7(5)C60, where part of the Li is involved in the formation of the amide phase. Notably, this fact also suggests an upper limit for the Li stoichiometry of the ammoniated (ND3)yLixC60 phases, with x around 6.
The observed transition temperatures are slightly different with respect to those observed in the in-situ NPD experiment, but such discrepancy can be easily rationalized by taking into account the different sample environment, which in this case allowed a more precise control of the thermodynamic parameters. The amount of ammonia released in the two processes is roughly the same and corresponds to about six NH3 molecules per C60. Therefore, these findings confirm the results of the in-situ manometric analysis. DCS data indicate that the two desorption processes are endothermic, as expected.
The peak at 350 K appears broader than the one at 535 K, probably due to the more complex release mechanism of the first process, which actually involves two structural phase transitions (from phase 0 to phase 1 and from phase 1 to phase 2). From the peak area an estimate of the binding-energy of the released ammonia molecules was calculated. This ranges between 24 and 28 kJ mol−1 NH3, a value significantly lower than the binding energy of Li–NH3 clusters reported in the literature (see also discussion below).36
In particular, the lithium intercalated fulleride (NH3)6Li3C60 is known to be stable under ambient conditions and possesses a super-expanded insulating bcc lattice, which leads to the on-ball localization of the three electrons donated by Li to C60.32 In such a system, two ammonia molecules are coordinated to each Li (see Fig. 2 left) and occupy the 24 g Wyckoff positions with half fractional occupancy. On the other hand, Li ions are in quasi-linear coordination with these sites, occupying at 25% occupancy the 24 g position (0.38, 0.41, 0), with the Li–N distance of ∼2.15 Å, falling in the typical range observed in Li–NH3 clusters.29,39,40 Such an arrangement indicates a relatively high degree of disorder, suggesting that more Li could in principle be accommodated in the lattice. In fact, in this work we observe a similar bcc structure in the (ND3)yLi6C60 phase, with y = 5–7 (phase 2), as shown in Fig. 2. This system revealed to be stable in the temperature range 400–500 K during the desorption experiment and retains about half of the total amount of ammonia that can be stored in this system.
The hyper-expanded (ND3)yLi6C60 (see Fig. 3c), with y = 12, 14 (phases 0 and 1), shows a different structure, that to our knowledge has been never observed so far, and it is stable up to 350–400 K. Although a detailed structural analysis was not possible, due to the low crystallinity of this phase, for y = 12 we managed to index all the observed reflections to a hcp cell (see Fig. 2 left and Fig. 1S†). The hcp–bcc transformation observed during the desorption process, when about half of the ammonia is released through an endothermic process, is not easily explained in terms of group–subgroup relationships, while it can be rationalized in the framework of the Burgers model.41 Moreover, the hcp–bcc phase coexistence observed around 410 K suggests that this is a 1st order phase transition.
Above 500 K, the bcc structure undergoes a further phase transition to cubic fcc (phase 3), which results as an ammonia-free phase (see Fig. 2 and 1S†). During the NPD experiment, this transition was reached by evacuating the sample space; for this reason, the manometric/DSC measurements provided a slightly higher bcc–fcc transition temperature, of about 535 K.
It is worth noting here that this value is still far lower than the decomposition temperature reported by Durand and co-workers for (NH3)6Li3C60,29 which appeared stable up to 673 K. A higher thermal stability for (ND3)yLi3C60 was also evidenced by our NPD data, as for this phase the complete ammonia release was not reached under the accessible thermodynamic conditions (see in Fig. 2S†). This suggests that the Li–NH3 binding energy in these systems should be somewhat driven by the Li stoichiometry, as it is known that, on increasing the Li content, its ionization progressively decreases and, as an example, in Li12C60 the charge transferred to C60 is of only 6 electrons.22 Specifically, over the past years, the stability of the Li(NH3)n (n = 1–5) complexes was thoroughly investigated42–44 in order to understand the unusual optical properties of alkali metals solvated in liquid ammonia;45 in particular, the Li–N dissociation energies seem to strongly depend either on the number of ammonia molecules coordinated to the alkali atom, or to the charge state of the Li(NH3)n cluster.36 In our systems, depending on the amount of co-intercalated ammonia molecules, we expect the formation of Li(NH3)n clusters with n = 1–2, for which the calculated dissociation enthalpy range between 61.4 kJ mol−1 (n = 1) and 46.1 kJ mol−1 (n = 2) for the cluster in the neutral state, and between 169 kJ mol−1 (n = 1) and 125.8 kJ mol−1 (n = 2) for the cations Li(NH3)n+.36 Although a direct comparison with these data is not trivial, the DSC data collected on (NH3)yLi6C60 (see Fig. 3b) suggest that the co-intercalation of the Li-ammonia clusters in the fullerene matrix is effective in bringing the Li–NH3 binding energies towards lower values, probably due to the partial negative charge redistribution on the C60 LUMO.
In order to check the reversibility of the ammoniation process, the completely discharged Li6C60 sample underwent a second treatment in liquid NH3, under the same conditions employed for the first process. By comparing the weight of the sample before and after the process, an increase of 14.8 wt% was again found and this corresponds to the nominal stoichiometry (NH3)6.64Li6C60. Therefore, the ammonia-storage appears partially reversible in this system. Laboratory XPD data indicated an improvement of the crystallinity in the ammoniated phase after the second treatment, although a fraction of Li amide (peak at 2θ = 43° in Fig. 1S†)46 also appears. This fact may be due to a partial Li segregation, as a metal, upon the NH3 discharge, followed by the reaction of the bare alkali with ammonia during the second uptake. This process is expected to limit the reversibility of the ammonia absorption of this system. Further investigations are however required in order to better evaluate the robustness of this system upon cycling.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c5ta05226b |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |