Open Access Article
Hayato
Tsurugi
*,
Akio
Hayakawa
,
Shun
Kando
,
Yoshitaka
Sugino
and
Kazushi
Mashima
*
Department of Chemistry, Graduate School of Engineering Science, Osaka University, CREST, Toyonaka, Osaka 560-8531, Japan. E-mail: tsurugi@chem.es.osaka-u.ac.jp; mashima@chem.es.osaka-u.ac.jp
First published on 31st March 2015
We developed a hydrodehalogenation reaction of polyhaloalkanes catalyzed by paddlewheel dimolybdenum complexes in combination with 1-methyl-3,6-bis(trimethylsilyl)-1,4-cyclohexadiene (MBTCD) as a non-toxic H-atom source as well as a salt-free reductant. A mixed-ligated dimolybdenum complex Mo2(OAc)2[CH(NAr)2]2 (3a, Ar = 4-MeOC6H4) having two acetates and two amidinates exhibited high catalytic activity in the presence of nBu4NCl, in which [nBu4N]2[Mo2{CH(NAr)2}2Cl4] (9a), derived by treating 3a with ClSiMe3 and nBu4NCl, was generated as a catalytically-active species in the hydrodehalogenation. All reaction processes, oxidation and reduction of the dimolybdenum complex, were clarified by control experiments, and the oxidized product, [nBu4N][Mo2{CH(NAr)2}2Cl4] (10a), was characterized by EPR and X-ray diffraction studies. Kinetic analysis of the hydrodehalogenation reaction as well as a deuterium-labelling experiment using MBTCD-d8 suggested that the H-abstraction was the rate-determining step for the catalytic reaction.
CR1R2)], metal-alkoxide, and -nitride species, [M2L4(Z)] (Z = OR, N).3c–3e,4–6 In all cases, because four supporting ligands tightly coordinate to the adjacent two metal centers while maintaining the dinuclear paddlewheel skeleton and the metal–metal bond, the architecture of the four supporting ligands was tunable to control redox behavior and catalytic performance of the paddlewheel complexes. In sharp contrast, few studies have examined the catalytic application of paddlewheel complexes of the early transition metals. As an example, Mo2(OAc)4 was used for an aza-Diels–Alder reaction of acyl hydrazones and dienes;7 however, the original paddlewheel structure was not maintained during the reaction. We and others have continued to investigate the stoichiometric and catalytic application of quadruply bonded M2 complexes of group 6 metals for organic radical generation by designing bridging ligands,8–10 and have achieved catalytic radical addition and polymerization reactions.9 During these transformations, the metal–metal bond responds to the one-electron redox processes without decomposition of the dinuclear structure. The structural stability of the dinuclear motif owes to both the surrounding four ligands and the metal–metal multiple bonds. In a further catalytic application of the M2 complexes, we used a cyclohexadiene derivative instead of α-olefins as a substrate for the organic radicals generated from polyhaloalkanes, leading to the formation of hydrodehalogenated products. Although hydrodehalogenation is one of the key reactions for decomposing environmentally unfriendly polyhaloalkanes, precious metal catalysts are often used.11 Herein, we report that paddlewheel Mo2 complexes, as shown in Fig. 1, act as catalysts for hydrodehalogenation reactions of polyhaloalkanes upon combination with 1-methyl-3,6-bis(trimethylsilyl)-1,4-cyclohexadiene (MBTCD)12 as an H-atom donor, and reveal the mechanism and actual active species in this catalytic process.
| Run | Cat. | Solvent | Additive | Yielda (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| a Determined using 1H NMR measurements. Yield in parentheses was the isolated yield. b n Bu4NCl (10 mol%) was added to the reaction mixture. | ||||
| 1 | 1 | CD3CN | — | 4 |
| 2 | 2 | CD3CN | — | 47 |
| 3 | 3a | CD3CN | — | 64 |
| 4 | 3b | CD3CN | — | 9 |
| 5 | 3c | CD3CN | — | 1 |
| 6 | 4 | CD3CN | — | 31 |
| 7 | 5 | CD3CN | — | <1 |
| 8 | 3a | THF-d8 | — | 59 |
| 9 | 3a | C6D6 | — | 42 |
| 10b | 3a | CD3CN | n Bu4NCl | 84 (73) |
| 11 | 7a | CD3CN | — | 71 |
| 12b | 7a | CD3CN | n Bu4NCl | 85 |
| 13b | 8a | CD3CN | n Bu4NCl | 32 |
| 14 | 9a | CD3CN | — | 85 |
To reveal the additive effects of nBu4NCl to 3a, we conducted control experiments. We observed the formation of trimethylsilyltoluene and ClSiMe3 as the reaction byproducts derived from MBTCD, along with Me3SiOAc, which was the reaction product of the acetate ligand and ClSiMe3. Because the ligand replacement reaction of an acetate ligand by ClSiMe3 was reported by Cotton et al.,14 we examined the reaction of 3a with excess ClSiMe3 in CD3CN (Scheme 1). In the 1H NMR spectrum, new resonances assignable to the Mo2 complex 6a appeared within 30 minutes at room temperature, and, after 41 h, all of 3a was converted to 7a, which was isolated as a purple powder.15 Subsequent heating of a solution of 7a at 80 °C resulted in the formation of a dimeric molybdenum cluster, [Mo2{CH(NAr)2}2(μ-Cl)2]2 (8a),16 which was previously isolated and structurally characterized. The dimeric complex 8a exhibited low catalytic activity even in the presence of nBu4NCl, probably due to the low solubility of 8a in the reaction media (run 13). In contrast, treatment of complex 3a with ClSiMe3 in the presence of nBu4NCl in toluene at 80 °C afforded a dianionic Mo2 species, [nBu4N]2[Mo2{CH(NAr)2}2Cl4] (9a), in which two amidinates and four chloride ligands coordinated to the Mo2 core, based on single crystal X-ray diffraction analysis (Fig. 2(a)).15,17 Notably, no conversion of 9a to the Cl-bridged dimer 8a was observed, even upon prolonged heating of 9a in CH3CN. The catalytic activity of 9a was equal to that of 3a/nBu4NCl (runs 10 and 14). By monitoring the reaction progress using 1H NMR spectroscopy, we found the induction period for the 3a/nBu4NCl catalyst. Complexes 3a or 7a were slowly catalyzing the hydrodehalogenation reaction. Interestingly, complex 9a initiated the catalytic hydrodehalogenation reaction without any induction period (Fig. 3), indicating that the dianionic complex 9a was the identity of the catalytically active species.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 ORTEP drawing of the molecular structure for dimolybdenum complexes (a) 9a and (b) 10a. Hydrogen atoms and the cationic part are omitted for clarity. | ||
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 Reaction profile for the hydrodehalogenation catalyzed by Mo2 complexes (3 mol%) with MBTCD (1.2 equiv.) at 60 °C. | ||
Because of the inactivity of MBTCD toward [Mo2]4+ complexes, the catalytic reaction of 9a (3a/nBu4NCl) was assumed to be initiated by the first reductive cleavage of a carbon–halogen bond, which produced a carbon radical and an [Mo2]5+ species. Thus, we next performed an oxidation reaction of 9a with CCl4 at room temperature, and the oxidized [Mo2]5+ species, [nBu4N][Mo2{CH(NAr)2}2Cl4] (10a), was isolated in 88% yield (Scheme 2, path a). During the reaction, nBu4NCl was eliminated, and the ligand system of the Mo2 core remained intact. A single crystal X-ray diffraction study of 10a confirmed the elongation of the Mo–Mo bond by ∼0.04 Å from 9a, and the distance of the Mo–Mo bond is typical for [Mo2]5+ species (Fig. 2(b)).8a,15,18 The formation of [Mo2]5+ was further confirmed using EPR spectroscopic analysis, in which resonances typical of [Mo2]5+ species were detected (g = 1.955). The high catalytic activity of 9a was ascribed to the relatively negative Eox([Mo2]4+/5+) value: the Eox ([Mo2]4+/5+) value of 9a was −0.29 V, which shifted to a more negative value compared to that of 7a (−0.14 V) and 8a (−0.08 V). The other aspect of the high catalytic activity of 9a is the stability of the Mo2(L)2Cl4 structure and solubility during the redox processes. In fact, complex 7a reacted with CCl4 to form a [Mo2]6+ species, [Mo2{CH(NAr)2}2Cl4(CH3CN)2] (11a), as poorly soluble dark-red microcrystals that precipitated from the reaction mixture (eqn (1)).15
![]() | (1) |
When the oxidized species 10a was treated with MBTCD in the absence of nBu4NCl or without MBTCD in the presence of nBu4NCl to reduce 10a, no reaction was observed, even after heating. On the other hand, in the presence of MBTCD, nBu4NCl, and AIBN as a carbon radical source, we observed the formation of 9a together with ClSiMe3, trimethylsilyltoluene, and isobutyronitrile, after heating at 80 °C for 1.5 h (Scheme 2, path b). This indicated that the AIBN-derived carbon radical abstracted one hydrogen atom from MBTCD to generate isobutyronitrile and a radical derivative of MBTCD, which subsequently reduced 10a to give 9a, along with ClSiMe3 and trimethylsilyltoluene.
By using the complex 9a as a catalyst for the hydrodehalogenation of 1,1,1,3-tetrachloropropane, we checked the initial reaction rate dependence for the catalyst, 1,1,1,3-tetrachloropropane, and MBTCD. A first-order rate dependence on the catalyst and MBTCD concentration was observed, whereas the reaction was not dependent on the concentration of 1,1,1,3-tetrachloropropane (Fig. 4(a)–(c)). During the catalytic reaction as described in Table 1, we did not find any byproducts such as radical homo-coupling and disproportionated products, suggesting that the reaction of 9a and 1,1,1,3-tetrachloropropane is in fast equilibrium with 10a before reacting with MBTCD. Zero-order in 1,1,1,3-tetrachloropropane might indicate the saturation of the reactive intermediate composed of 10a and the carbon radical in the coordination sphere, which is consistent with the large negative entropy value (vide infra). In addition, MBTCD-d8 was applied to the catalytic reaction: the KIE value was 1.71, suggesting that the H-abstraction from MBTCD by the organic radical was involved in the rate-determining step. Furthermore, the rate of the catalytic reaction over a temperature ranging from 50 to 65 °C was monitored by 1H NMR spectroscopy. Eyring kinetic analyses of the reaction profile afforded the activation parameters of ΔH‡ = 25.7 ± 0.9 kJ mol−1, ΔS‡ = −56.5 ± 0.7 e.u., and ΔG‡(298 K) = 96.2 ± 1.8 kJ mol−1 (Fig. 4(d)). A large negative ΔS‡ value indicated an ordered transition state for the H-abstraction step: we presume that the organic radical derived from 1,1,1,3-tetrachloropropane stays in the coordination sphere of 10a after C–Cl reductive cleavage, while the radical abstracts the H-atom from MBTCD.
Based on the above observations for the kinetic study and redox reactions of the Mo2 complexes, we propose a plausible catalytic cycle as shown in Scheme 3. In the initial stage, the dinuclear metal cluster 9a is in equilibrium with [Mo2]5+ species 10a in the presence of alkyl halides, which is often observed for the carbon radical generation by low-valent metal species with alkyl halides.19 Because of the zero-order dependence on the substrate concentration and no observation of the radical homo-coupling and disproportionated compounds, this equilibrium is very fast, and the reactive intermediate, 10a and the carbon radical in the coordination sphere, is generated. Next, the carbon radical abstracts a hydrogen atom from MBTCD, which is a rate-determining step in this catalytic cycle, to form hydrodehalogenated products and a radical derivative of MBTCD. Finally, the [Mo2]5+ cluster is reduced by the MBTCD-derived radical to regenerate the [Mo2]4+ species 9a together with ClSiMe3 and trimethylsilyltoluene.
![]() | ||
| Scheme 3 Plausible mechanism for hydrodehalogenation reactions of alkyl halides catalyzed by the Mo2 complex 9a. | ||
Under optimized conditions for the catalytic hydrodehalogenation reaction using 3a/nBu4NCl in CH3CN at 80 °C as described in Table 1, the substrate scope was surveyed for haloalkanes having a trichloromethyl or a bromomethyl group, and the results are summarized in Table 2. Tetrachloroalkanes having a longer alkyl chain, ether, and ester groups were effectively dehalogenated to give the corresponding trichloroalkanes in 66%–82% yields (runs 1–3). In addition, α-halocarbonyl ester derivatives and benzyl bromide derivatives were applicable for the hydrodehalogenation reaction in the presence of 2 equiv. of MBTCD to afford the corresponding products in good yields (runs 4–7).
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experimental details for the synthesis and characterization of Mo2 complexes, kinetic analysis of the reactions, 1H NMR spectra of the catalytic reactions, identification of the products, CV of selected Mo2 complexes, and crystal data for 7a (CCDC 1046579), 9a (CCDC 1046580), 10a (CCDC 1046581), and 11a (CCDC 1046582). CCDC 1046579–1046582. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: 10.1039/c5sc00721f |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |