R. Vijayalakshmi,
S. Radhakrishnan*,
Pooja Shitole,
S. J. Pawar,
V. S. Mishra,
R. K. Garg,
M. B. Talawar and
A. K. Sikder*
High Energy Materials Research Laboratory, Pune-411 021, India. E-mail: ak_sikder@yahoo.com; sradha78@yahoo.com; Fax: +91 20 25869031; Tel: +91 20 25912218
First published on 12th November 2015
3-Nitro-1,2,4-triazol-5-one (NTO) is an unique candidate among military high explosives and is explored as a potential bomb filler with TNT in melt cast formulations. In the present study, we attempted to replace sensitive RDX with NTO with spherical morphology to develop a less hazardous, thermally stable shock insensitive composition. A bimodal mixture (150 and 25 μm in 70/30 ratio) of spherical NTO powders with superior flowability was chosen for the formulations and achieved 60% solid loading. The temperature sensitivity of the formulations was assessed by calculating the activation energy for the flow. The velocity of detonation and shock sensitivity of the composition were also determined. The study demonstrated that the spherical-NTO/TNT (60:
40) was found to be 2.5 times more shock and 2 times more friction insensitive than composition B which consisted of RDX/TNT (60
:
40). The activation energy for thermal decomposition was determined to assess the thermal hazards and a vacuum stability test was carried out to ensure the storage life of the composition.
3-Nitro-1,2,4-triazol-5-one (NTO) is a unique candidate among military high explosives for effective insensitive munitions and a potential bomb filler in the admixture with TNT under investigation.3 Various NTO based melt-cast formulations such as Picatinny Arsenal Explosives (PAX), Ordnance System Explosives (OSX) and Insensitive Munitions Explosives (IMX)-101 (containing DNAN, NTO and NQ) and IMX-104 (containing 40% DNAN or TNT, 40% NTO and 20% RDX) etc., have been reported using TNT or DNAN as a binder.4 Among these, the IMX-104 composition involves the part replacement of RDX and the VOD was determined to be 7190 ± 200 m s−1 and 7410 ± 100 m s−1 for DNAN and TNT respectively. Accordingly the impact sensitivity of the TNT based composition is higher than the DNAN based composition. Further, the biodegradation and phytoremediation of IMX-101 formulations were also investigated by Richard et al.5,6 It is also inferred from the toxicological studies that NTO is non-toxic compared to RDX and TNT, and Table S1 of ESI† lists the LD50 values of the studied explosives. Cliff and Smith et al. developed a RDX-free ARX-4002 melt-cast formulation consisting of NTO/TNT (50:
50). The lower amount of solid explosive (NTO) in the reported formulation may be due to the usage of non-spherical NTO and also the solid loading can be significantly increased by the use of spherical NTO.7 Large scale preparation of NTO involves the crystallisation of NTO from water and this yields irregular rods and jagged crystals.8,9 This irregular and undesired crystal morphology leads to high viscosity, poor processability and hence reduced solid loading. Our previous studies reported the crystallisation process for the preparation of spherical-NTO (SNTO) of various particle sizes and the characterisation of the prepared powders. It was demonstrated that the use of spherical-NTO improves the mix fluidity of the composite explosives significantly and hence the solid explosive loading.10,11 Further, it was also revealed that spherical crystals of explosives can improve their insensitivity towards a sudden shock, performance, processability and packing density compared to non-spherical crystals.12–14
The present study is aimed to develop less hazardous shock insensitive melt-cast explosive formulations based on NTO by complete replacement of RDX (60%) in composition B. In order to achieve higher solid loading, spherical NTO with good flow characteristics was identified and employed in the formulations. An anchor blade mixer was used for processing and the explosive charges were made using suitable moulds. Performance and hazard assessments like shock, friction and impact sensitivities were carried out using these charges. The study also reports the activation energy of the thermal decomposition of SNTO/TNT and RDX/TNT (60:
40) melt-cast formulations using Ozawa and Kissinger methods to determine the thermal hazards of compositions. A thermogravimetric study and vacuum stability tests have been carried out to asses the storage stability of the compositions.
Calorimetric studies were undertaken on a Perkin Elmer DSC-7 instrument at four different heating rates 2, 5, 10 and 15 °C min−1 under nitrogen atmosphere with 1 mg of sample. The Ozawa and Kissinger method was employed to calculate the activation energy (Ea) of the thermal decomposition reactions.15–18 Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) was carried out using a simultaneous thermal analyzer (TA instruments SDTQ600) at 5 °C min−1 under a nitrogen atmosphere using an open platinum cup. Morphological characterization was carried out using an Optical Microscope (RAX-vision Y-coo series). The extent of sphericity is expressed by means of circularity which was determined by the following formula: (4πarea)/(perimeter2).
Particle size distribution was measured with a Sympatech particle size analyzer in dry mode by applying a laser diffraction method and volume mean dia, D[4,3] is reported in the present study. The true density was determined by measuring the changes in pressure with helium gas displacement using a gas pycnometer of Thermo Scientific Instruments. USP-II standard procedure was adopted to measure the tapped bulk density with the defined set of the tapping procedure using Veego Industries, India Tap density apparatus. Flowability properties like Carr’s index (CI) and Hausner ratio (HR) were also calculated from the above measurements. All viscosity measurements were made using a Brookfield viscometer (RV-DVII + Pro) equipped with a small sample adapter (SC4-27) where shear rate and stress can be measured. The sample was placed in a chamber which was heated through a circulator. All measurements were made at 81, 83, 86 and 90 °C and at the shear rates varied from 17 to 59.5 s−1.
In order to determine the chemical and thermal stability under extreme conditions and also to verify the compatibility among the explosives in the melt-cast compositions, a vacuum stability tester (Tirupati scientific industry, Calcutta) was used. A dried and weighed sample (5 g) of both RDX/TNT (60:
40) and SNTO/TNT (60
:
40) was heated at 120 °C for 48 hours, the volume of the gases (mL g−1) evolved was recorded and the experiments were repeated for consistency.
The shock sensitivity was determined with the standard card gap test, using a cellulose acetate sheet as an attenuator and a CE pellet (tetryl) as a donor charge. The sheet thickness of cellulose acetate was varied until No-Go was observed on the witness plate while carrying out experiments with the RDX and SNTO charges. The shock sensitivity of the melt cast explosive composition is expressed in terms of the minimum pressure of the shock wave which can initiate detonation. The critical pressure (P in kbar) developed across the cellulose acetate sheets which can detonate the explosive composition with 50% probability was determined from the following equation:
P (kbar) = 105e−(0.0358x) |
It is important to control the size distribution of particles in attaining high density and also to achieve the maximum packing density in the formulations which further increases the amount of solids per unit volume.19,20 Further, the size along with the shape of the particle plays a key role in obtaining the flowability of the powders. Our earlier studies on spherical NTO powders demonstrate the flowability parameters such as Carr’s Index (Compressibility Index) and Hausner ratio (HR) which are the simple measurements used to describe the complete flow properties of a material.21–24 To attain the specific density many combinations of distribution are preferable. In order to achieve efficient packing various ratios of coarse (150 μm) to fine (25 μm) powders were screened and based on the high density and flowability, a 70:
30 ratio (coarse to fine) was chosen, analysed for particle size and further used for the formulation studies (Fig. 4). The optimized bimodal mixture obtained maximum tapped bulk density i.e.1.09 g cc−1 with a Carr’s index less than 15 and Hausner ratio less than 2 (Fig. 5). True density is a fundamental parameter contributing to the characterization of a product, directly proportional to the performance of an explosive and also helps to identify different polymorphs of a particular molecule.25 The true densities of virgin explosives were determined and are presented in Fig. 5. The combination of the bimodal mixture of SNTO (70
:
30) resulted to give 1.892 g cc−1 which is in between that of SNTO 150 μm (100%) and SNTO 25 μm (100%) indicating that efficient packing has occurred.
Composition | True density (g cc−1) |
---|---|
RDX (100%) | 1.798 |
TNT (100%) | 1.616 |
RDX/TNT (60![]() ![]() |
1.717 |
SNTO/TNT (60![]() ![]() |
1.741 |
The rheological behaviour of a material is greatly affected by the temperature and the precise control of temperature is of major importance in viscosity measurements. It is also vital for safety during handling and production. Our previous study reported the temperature dependent flow phenomenon of melt-cast formulations which can be described by the Arrhenius equation of ideally viscous materials.26 It was observed that, the SNTO/TNT (60:
40) composition exhibited temperature independent behaviour (Fig. 6) (no significant variation in viscosity). A viscous flow phenomenon involves a thermally activated rate process and in order to move molecules to an adjacent vacant site they must overcome an energy barrier. By applying the Arrhenius relationship, the activation energy for flow has been obtained. Fig. 7 compares the activation energy for the flow of the compositions. The RDX/TNT based composition requires about a three times higher activation energy for flow than SNTO/TNT (60/40). This clearly indicates the role of chemical composition and the nature of the material in the activation energy for flow and also indicates the relative temperature susceptibility of the different compositions. From this study, it can be inferred that the SNTO/TNT composition was found to be insensitive to temperature and hence, processing can be done nearly at the melting temperature of TNT. In contrast to SNTO, the dependency is high in the case of the RDX based benchmark composition, which demands a higher processing temperature.
Sedimentation of a solid in any liquid matrix plays a crucial role especially in melt-cast compositions. The sedimentation rate of the solid explosive was studied for both compositions at 86 °C under a shear rate of 59.5 s−1 for a period of 1 h. Viscosity was noted at an interval of 5 min and a plot of time versus viscosity is shown in Fig. 8. The study reveals that the rate of increase of viscosity is high for the RDX based composition and it may be due to the non-uniform distribution of RDX. The increase in viscosity is low in the case of SNTO/TNT (60:
40) and it is mainly due to the stronger interaction of NTO and molten TNT which kept the dispersion more stable and hence gave a lower sedimentation rate.
Composition | Theo. max density (g cm−3) | Experimental density (g cm−3) | VOD (m s−1) | Sensitivity to various stimuli | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Tmax (°C) | Shock (kbar) | Friction (kg) | Impact h50 (cm) | ||||
SNTO/TNT (60/40) | 1.79 | 1.65 | 7100 | 266 | 51.3 | 36 | 72 |
RDX/TNT (60/40) | 1.74 | 1.68 | 7900 | 241 | 18.7 | 14.8 | 99 |
The activation energy for the decomposition of the compositions was computed using the Ozawa and Kissinger method.15–18 Arrhenius plots of these compositions are shown in Fig. 9a and b and 10a and b and the calculated data are given in Tables 4 and 5. The activation energies of these compositions are 185 and 259 kJ mol−1 for the RDX and SNTO based compositions respectively. These values did not significantly vary through calculating them from the above methods. The higher activation energy of the SNTO/TNT composition indicates a high thermal stability and that it is relatively safe at elevated temperatures compared to composition B. This increased thermal stability may be attributed to the existence of the hydrogen bonding stabilised layered structure of NTO.
![]() | ||
Fig. 9 (a and b) Activation energy of decomposition (RDX/TNT 60![]() ![]() |
![]() | ||
Fig. 10 (a and b) Activation energy of decomposition (SNTO/TNT 60![]() ![]() |
Heating rate (β) (°C min−1) | Tm (K) | Tm2 | 1/Tm (K) | log![]() |
ln![]() |
ln![]() |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2 | 500.52 | 2.50 × 105 | 1.99 × 10−3 | 0.3010 | 0.6932 | −11.7381 |
5 | 505.62 | 2.55 × 105 | 1.97 × 10−3 | 0.6990 | 1.6094 | −10.8421 |
10 | 514.17 | 2.64 × 105 | 1.94 × 10−3 | 1 | 2.3026 | −10.1825 |
15 | 522.31 | 2.72 × 105 | 1.91 × 10−3 | 1.1761 | 2.7081 | −9.8085 |
Heating rate β (°C min−1) | T (°C) | Tm (K) | Tm2 | 1/Tm (K) | log![]() |
ln![]() |
ln(β/Tm2) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2 | 254.02 | 527.02 | 2.77 × 105 | 1.89 × 10−3 | 0.3010 | 0.6932 | −11.8413 |
5 | 261.93 | 534.93 | 2.86 × 105 | 1.86 × 10−3 | 0.6990 | 1.6095 | −10.9548 |
10 | 266.47 | 539.47 | 2.91 × 105 | 1.85 × 10−3 | 1 | 2.3026 | −10.2786 |
15 | 272.21 | 545.21 | 2.97 × 105 | 1.83 × 10−3 | 1.1761 | 2.7081 | −9.8943 |
The thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) of the melt-cast compositions is given in Fig. 11. The RDX/TNT (60:
40) composition starts to show weight loss within a temperature range of 94.8 to 241.7 °C in two steps. The loss in weight for the composition in the first step is found to be 28.8% in the temperature range of 94.8 to 178.4 °C which corresponds to the loss of TNT, while the 58.9% loss in weight observed in the second step corresponds to RDX in the temperature range of 178.4 to 241.7 °C. The SNTO/TNT (60
:
40) composition was also decomposed in two steps as shown in Fig. 11. It starts to show weight loss within a temperature range of 104.5 to 264.2 °C. The first step shows a 38.9% weight loss in the temperature range of 104.5 to 185.6 °C which corresponds to TNT, whereas the 63% loss in weight observed in the temperature range of 185.6 to 264.2 °C corresponds to NTO. This study clearly examines that the weight mixtures of SNTO/TNT and RDX/TNT from the temperature ranges 104.5 to 264.2 °C and 94.8 to 241.7 °C indicated that each species enhanced the decomposition of the other. This shows that the NTO containing formulations are found to be thermally stable as brought out by the thermal decomposition studies and this composition is less susceptible to storage temperature compared to RDX/TNT compositions. Both the calorimetric and weight loss studies brought out that the SNTO/TNT (60
:
40) composition shows good thermal and storage stability.
Thus the SNTO/TNT (60:
40) melt-cast compositions exhibit better thermal and storage stability even under extreme conditions. The vacuum stability results were also corroborated with the TGA and DSC analyses.
Overall, a melt-cast composition with spherical-NTO possessing 60% solid loading was developed and exhibited to be 2.5 times more shock insensitive and 2 times more friction insensitive compared to the RDX based composition B. The insensitivity of the spherical NTO based compositions may be attributed to the layered crystal structure of NTO unlike RDX.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c5ra19010j |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |