Albert S. Lee‡
a,
Jin Hong Lee‡ab,
Soon Man Hongac,
Jong-Chan Leeb,
Seung Sang Hwang*ac and
Chong Min Koo*ac
aMaterials Architecturing Research Centre, Korea Institute of Science and Technology, Hwarangno 14-gil 5, Seong-Buk Gu, Seoul 136-791, Korea.. E-mail: koo@kist.re.kr, sshwang@kist.re.kr
bDepartment of Chemical and Biological Engineering, Institute of Chemical Process, Seoul National University, 599 Gwanak-ro, Gwanak-gu, Seoul 151-744, Korea
cNanomaterials Science and Engineering, University of Science and Technology, 217 Gajungro, 176 Gajung-dong, Yuseong-Gu, Daejeon, Korea 305-333
First published on 28th October 2015
A series of PEO-functionalized, ladder-like structured polysilsesquioxane copolymers were synthesized and utilized for the fabrication of PEGylated hybrid ionogels through chemical crosslinking of the ionic liquid, 1 M LiTFSI in N-butyl-N-methylpyrrolidinium bis(trifluoromethylsulfonyl)imide. Through systematic variance of the copolymer concentration of methacryloxypropyl- and PEG groups, we were able to demonstrate enhanced ionic conductivity and lithium ion dissociation as the PEO content increased. Through an in-depth spectroscopic investigation of the ion conduction behavior of these PEGylated hybrid ionogels and comparison with hybrid ionogels without PEG groups, we were able to demonstrate how the enhancement in lithium ion battery performance for PEGylated hybrid iongels could be achieved at identical crosslinker concentrations.
In order to alleviate the above safety concerns, ionogels have recently garnered great interest in the academic community. Ionogels are defined as ion conducting liquids solidified through physical or chemical crosslinks, usually through the use of crosslinkable polymeric gelators.7–9 Through tuning of both the content and composition of the solidifying gelator, various ionogels have been fabricated, and their utility for practical electrochemical performance confirmed.10–12 However, even these ionogels crosslinked with organic gelator materials lacked the necessary thermal and mechanical properties, leading to excess use of crosslinking material, invariably depreciating ion mobility and electrochemical performance.13,14
The hybridization of the crosslinking matrix network to attain hybrid ionogels has also been a booming field of interest to alleviate the above concerns of low thermal, mechanical, and ion transport properties. The gelation of ionic conducting solutions with various inorganic–organic hybrid materials such as ORMOCERs,15 inorganic oxides,16–18 and polysilsesquioxanes10 have been extensively investigated. However, many of these approaches have entailed the use of organic moiety for only crosslinking function. Additionally, inorganic-oxides, such as nano-sized silica and alumina, have shown great promise due to their ability to gel ionic conducting solutions through the aggregation of inorganic networks, following the Derjaguin–Landau–Verwey–Overbeek (DLVO) theory.19 Pioneering works by the Archer group11,12,20,21 have investigated hybrid ionogels gelled through silane surface-modified metal oxides. Through surface modification of ionic liquid groups, oligo-ethylene oxide groups, and single ion conducting groups, all functioning to improve the electrical properties of the hybrid ionogels, these hybrid ionogels have been pioneering in improving the thermal stability, mechanical properties and ion mobility. However, these hybrid ionogels still suffer from the fact that they can only be dispersed, not homogenously dissolved in ion conducting solutions,18,22 and that the degree of control over mechanical properties is low compared with chemically crosslinked hybrid ionogels.
In our previous study, we investigated hybrid gel polymer electrolytes and hybrid ionogels fabricated with a methacryloxypropyl-functionalized ladder-structured polysilsesquioxane homopolymer. Ladder-structured polysilsesquioxanes,10,23 which are comprised of an inorganic Si–O–Si ladder backbone, with radial organic functional groups, exhibited high solubility in various ion conducting solutions, and thus we were able to tune the mechanical properties such that liquid-like ionic conductivity was able to be attained without sacrificing gel robustness.
In this study, we sought out to investigate the effect of free-dangling oligomeric polyethyleneoxide groups copolymerized with methacryloxypropyl- groups at various comonomer ratios on the ion conduction behavior of chemically crosslinked hybrid ionogels. We stipulated that through introduction of the free-dangling oligomeric polyethyleneoxide groups into the inorganic ladder-structured backbone at the molecular level, the inorganic backbone would function as support for mechanical robustness, while the PEO groups would contribute to enhanced ion conduction behavior through an in-depth spectroscopic analysis of these PEGylated hybrid ionogels compared to our previously studied hybrid ionogels.
:
polyethyleneoxide mol ratios, 25
:
75, 50
:
50, 75
:
25, were synthesized by simply varying the initial feed comonomer ratio and the samples were named LPEOMASQ25, LPEOMASQ50, and LPEOMASQ75, accordingly to the PEO-copolymer composition percentage.
1H NMR (CDCl3) (δ, ppm): 0.35–0.45 (m, Si(CH2CH2CH2OCOCCH2CH3), SiCH2CH2CH2O(CH2CH2O)6–9CH3, 4H), 1.8–1.9 (m, Si(CH2CH2CH2OCOCCH2CH3, SiCH2CH2CH2O(CH2CH2O)6–9CH3, 4H), 1.95–2.05 (m, Si(CH2CH2CH2OCOCCH2CH3, 3H), 3.15–3.3 (m, Si(CH2CH2CH2OCOCCH2CH3, SiCH2CH2CH2O(CH2CH2O)6–9CH3, 4H), 3.7–3.8 (m, SiCH2CH2CH2O(CH2CH2O)6–9CH3, 30H), 4.08–4.16 (m, SiCH2CH2CH2O(CH2CH2O)6–9CH3, 3H), 5.3–6.1 (m, Si(CH2CH2CH2OCOCCH2CH3, 2H).
29Si NMR (ppm): −68 to −70 ppm,
| Mw = 24.3 k. |
:
75, 50
:
50, 75
:
25, of 2-[methoxy(polyethyleneoxy)propyl]trimethoxysilane and 3-methacryloxypropyltrimethoxysilane were hydrolyzed and condensed in situ. (Scheme 1a) Obtained hybrid polymers were named as such: LPEOMASQ25, LPEOMASQ50, LPEOMASQ75 according the PEO comonomer percentage. Through design of the comonomers, crosslinkable ladder-structured polysilsesquioxanes with free-dangling PEO groups were introduced at the molecular level. These LPEOMASQ compounds then were utilized to crosslink ionic liquid solutions of 1 M LiTFSI in BMPTFSI at a low concentration of 5 wt%.
The characterization of the LPEOMASQ compounds were conducted with 1H NMR, 29Si NMR, and FTIR, as shown in Fig. 1. 1H NMR of the LPEOMASQ compounds showed that the methacryloxypropyl groups and PEG groups were introduced according to their initial comonomer ratio as indicated by the increasing large signal at 3.7 ppm, attributed to the ethylene oxide proton, as the PEG-ratio increased from LPEOMASQ25 to LPEOMASQ75. Moreover, no discernible peaks were found at 5.0 ppm, attributed to the uncondensed silanol Si–OH end groups.26 Also, 29Si NMR results revealed the presence of two large signals centered at −67 and −69 ppm, attributed to the fully condensed T3 Si–O–Si structure of Si-methacryloxypropyl- (Si-MMA) and 2-[methoxy(polyethyleneoxy)propyl] (Si–C3-PEG) groups, respectively.27 As shown, the relative intensity of the T3 for Si–C3-PEG at −69 ppm (assigned as X) increased as the PEG-ratio increased from LPEOMASQ25 to LPEOMASQ75, and the relative integrative ratio between the T3 for Si–C3-PEG at −69 ppm (assigned as X) and T3 for Si-methacryloxypropyl at −67 ppm (assigned as Y) reflected the initial comonomer feed ratio. Also noteworthy is the lack of signals near −58 ppm, which are the characteristics chemical shifts for the uncondensed T2 alkyl-silicons, as this provides additional evidence for the fully condensed, ladder-like structure of the LPEOMASQ compounds. FTIR spectra revealed the presence of C
O, and C
C, and Si–O–Si bands centered at 1745 cm−1, 1638 cm−1, and 1050 cm−1, 1100 cm−1, respectively.
The hybrid ionogels were prepared via a thermally curing process. The unsaturated vinyl groups of the methacryloxypropyl-moieties in ladder-like poly(methacryloxypropyl-co-polyethyleneoxide)silsesquioxane (LPEOMASQ) were cross-linked in an ionic liquid solution of 1 M LiTFSI in BMPTFSI to form a polymeric network structure, resulting in an mechanically stable and homogeneous ionogels as shown in Fig. 2. As shown, the disappearance of peaks assigned to the C
C bonds at 1638 cm−1 was determined by FT-IR after thermal treatment. To eliminate mitigating factors of crosslinker concentration, we fabricated the PEGlyated hybrid ionogels with equal concentrations (5 wt%) of LPEOMASQs. Furthermore, the dynamic viscoelastic properties of the thermally cured hybrid ionogels as a function of frequency are presented in Fig. 2b. For all ionogel samples, the response of dynamic modulus was seen to be nearly independent of the applied frequency and the elastic modulus G′ was greater than storage modulus G′′, indicating predominantly solid-like viscoelastic behavior.34–36 Moreover, the effect of increasing PEO content was to plasticize the hybrid ionogel, as LPEOMASQ75 5 wt% exhibited the lowest modulus and LPMASQ 5 wt%, which has no PEO groups, giving the highest modulus values across all frequencies. This was in due part to the free-dangling oligomeric PEO groups, which at room temperature existed in the melt-phase given the liquid state of the neat PEGylated LPSQs. Moreover, given that all of the LPEOMASQ gels exhibited solid-like behaviour, even the low MMA content of LPEOMASQ25 contained enough crosslinking functionality for obtaining mechanically robust hybrid gels.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 (a) FTIR spectra of LPEOMASQ75 5 wt% before and after crosslinking and (b) rheological properties of the IL and hybrid ionogels. | ||
| σ(T) = ∑n × q × μ |
As such, we conducted solid-state 7Li NMR single-pulse experiments comparing the neat ionic liquid and the various hybrid ionogels as shown in Fig. 3b, to probe the ability of ion dissociation and conduction of lithium ions. As shown, while the neat IL showed a very sharp peak attributed to the lithium cation derived from the lithium salt dissolved in IL, the 7Li NMR linewidth for the hybrid ionogels revealed a noticeable degree of decrease, or sharpening effect, as the PEO comonomer content increased from LPMASQ (0%) (chemical structure shown in ESI, Fig. S1†) to LPEOMASQ13 (75%). This point was further explored by the temperature dependent solid state 7Li NMR spectra comparing LPMASQ and LPEOMASQ75 (Fig. 2c), which showed the rapid sharpening of the Li+ peak starting around 35 °C (Fig. 3d), correlating to the melt-phase state of the ionic liquid confined in the hybrid matrix.9 It was clear from these NMR results that the effect of free-dangling PEGs on the lithium salt was pronounced in effectively dissociating the TFSI anion from lithium cation. This was a noteworthy result, as the effect was only previously demonstrated with zwitterionic compounds and single-ion conducting compounds, which functioned to immobilize the anion completely.31 Further distinguishing from these previously results, is the low concentration of crosslinker (5 wt%) required to fully gel the liquid solution, due to the hybrid inorganic backbone delivering mechanical robustness further showcasing the inherent high and effective ion conduction behavior of these hybrid PEGylated ionogels for practical commercial performance.
Moreover, solid-state 19F NMR single-pulse experiments with the PEGylated hybrid ionogels (Fig. 4a) showed similar peak sharpening effect as the fluorines derived from the TFSI anions were more dissociated for those hybrid gels containing greater concentration of PEO groups. To better understand the observed intermolecular interaction, we characterized the extent of ion pair formation using Raman analysis. It has previously reported that the strong Raman bands at 742 cm−1 and 748 cm−1 correspond to the free, or dissociated TFSI− ions and the bonded, or associated Li+ TFSI− ion pairs, respectively.32,33 As shown Fig. 4b, we observed changes in Li+ coordination with PEO concentration that may possibly contribute to an increase in ionic mobility. It can be clearly seen that there was a weak interaction in LPEOMASQ ionogels over the non-PEO containing LPMSASQ ionogel counterpart. When considering the minimal contribution of the highly sterically hindered ester groups of the crosslinked MMA junctions to ionic conductivity in our hybrid ionogels, and that the PEO-groups are only functionalized to the silicon backbone on one end, or free-dangling, we attributed the increase in ionic mobility and ionic conductivity to the melt-phase, liquid-like, free-dangling PEO groups.
Before evaluating the electrochemical performances of the ionogels, we assessed the electrochemical stability using linear sweep voltammometry (LSV) measurements. As shown in ESI Fig. S2,† no abrupt rise in oxidative current related to the electrochemical decomposition of the electrolyte was detected below 5.0 V in the anodic sweep, demonstrating that the prepared ionogels were electrochemically stable up to 5.0 V, which could be utilized in high-voltage lithium batteries. Additionally, the thermal stability of ionogels was investigated. As depicted in ESI Fig. S3,† these ionogels exhibited excellent thermal stability with no obvious weight loss observed at temperatures exceeding 350 °C. Moreover, this high thermal stability of indistinguishable decomposition of residual silanol groups, thus full condensation of the Si–O–Si backbone, rendered the high electrochemical stability of the PEGylated hybrid ionogels.
The cycling performance of the cells was evaluated further through measuring the discharge capacities, where the cells were charged at a current density of 0.1C and discharged 0.1C. Fig. 5b presents the charge/discharge capacity and coulombic efficiency as a function of cycle number. As shown, the cycling behaviors of the cells containing LPEOMASQ hybrid ionogels were more stable in the following cycles. In the initial stages of cycling, reversible discharge capacities reached 148.2 mA h g−1, which was close to the cells fabricated with the liquid 1 M LiTFSI BMPTFSI (ESI, Fig. S4†). The retained discharge capacity was 136.6 mA h g−1 after 50 cycles and the coulombic efficiency of the system was observed to be nearly 99%. In addition, as depicted in Fig. 5b inset, a well-defined voltage plateau around 3.4 V (vs. Li/Li+) associated to the lithium insertion/extraction into cathode materials was a highly maintained and repeatable process,39 confirming the sufficient mobility of lithium ions and electrochemical stability of these PEGylated hybrid ionogels. Therefore, we clearly demonstrated that the incorporation of polyethyleneoxide groups in the network structure could help facile ion transport of hybrid ionogels, resulting in improved electrochemical performance.
Footnotes |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: FTIR spectra, picture of vial, structure of LPMASQ, LSV, TGA, charge–discharge profiles with BMPTFSI cells. See DOI: 10.1039/c5ra18856c |
| ‡ These authors contributed equally. |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |