Zeyu Lua,
Dongshuai Hou*b,
Lingshi Menga,
Guoxing Suna,
Cong Lua and
Zongjin Lia
aDepartment of Civil and Environmental Engineering, The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, Hong Kong, China
bDepartment of Civil Engineering, Qingdao Technological University, Cooperative Innovation Center of Engineering Construction and Safety in Shandong Blue Economic Zone, Qingdao, China. E-mail: monkeyphildhou@gmail.com; Fax: +86-852-2358-1534; Tel: +86-852-9162-6614
First published on 9th November 2015
This study presents the enhanced mechanical properties of cement paste reinforced by graphene oxide (GO)/carbon nanotubes (CNTs) composites. The UV-vis spectroscopy and optical microscopy results show that the dispersion of CNTs in the GO solution is much better than in an aqueous solution due to the higher electrostatic repulsion, which allows a completely new approach of dispersing CNTs rather than by incorporating a dispersant. More importantly, the GO/CNTs composite plays an important role in improving the compressive and flexural strength of cement paste by 21.13% and 24.21%, which is much higher than cement paste reinforced by CNTs (6.40% and 10.14%) or GO (11.05% and 16.20%). The improved mechanical properties of cement paste are attributed to better dispersed CNTs and enhanced interactions among CNTs by the GO incorporation. Finally, the space interlocking mechanism of the GO/CNTs/cement paste composite with enhanced mechanical properties is proposed.
CNTs, including single wall (SWCNTs) or multi walls (MWCNTs), are one-dimensional carbon nanomaterial that may be viewed as rolled up from a single planar sheet of graphene. The unique mechanical properties make it as an attractive candidate for reinforcement of composite materials. Many attempts have been made to incorporate CNTs as reinforcement in cementitious materials and to investigate the mechanical behavior. However, the prerequisite for CNTs reinforcement is the uniform dispersion of CNTs. Three major methods for dispersing CNTs are the addition of surfactants, mechanical ultrasonication and functionalization of CNTs. Shah et al.2 investigated the effects of ultrasonic energy and surfactant concentration on the dispersion of MWCNTs at an amount of 0.08 wt% of cement, and found that the appropriate dispersion of CNTs could be achieved using sonication and a surfactant-to-CNTs weight ratio of 4. Konsta-Gdoutos et al.3 demonstrated that the flexural strength of the cement paste with the addition of MWCNTs at a concentration of 0.08% was improved by 35% with the help of surfactants and ultrasonication. Parveen et al.4 determined that 0.1 wt% of SWCNTs improved the flexural modulus, flexural strength and compressive strengths of mortar by 72%, 7% and 19%, through a short dispersion route using Pluronic F-127 as a novel dispersing agent. Duan et al.5 demonstrated that the flexural strength, Young's modulus and fracture toughness of the cement paste were significantly improved using 0.55 wt% CNTs with a pre-treatment of 50 J mL−1 ultrasonication energy. Although the addition of surfactants contributes to better dispersion of CNTs in cementitious materials, it has a weak interface between CNTs and cement matrix. Moreover, ultrasonication dispersion of CNTs before mixing with the cement matrix makes it more expensive, complicated and time-consuming, and excessive ultrasonication has damaging effects on the properties of CNTs. Furthermore, defect free CNTs are incapable of forming good adhesion with the cement matrix. Even if better dispersion of the CNTs can be obtained with the help of surfactants, the sliding of the CNTs still readily occurs due to the weak bonding between the CNTs and matrix, which leads to the poor reinforcing effect on the mechanical behavior of cementitious materials. Therefore, chemical functionalization of CNTs has been widely investigated and developed because of the improved chemical bonding between CNTs and the cementitious matrix. Cwirzen et al.6 investigated the surface decoration of MWCNTs on the mechanical properties of cement paste and indicated that the compressive strength can be improved to nearly 50% with only a small addition (0.045–0.15 wt%) of MWCNTs. Li et al.7 showed that the use of chemically functionalized CNTs at a concentration of 0.5% by weight of cement led to an increase in the compressive and flexural strength of cement mortar of 19% and 25%, respectively. However, the reinforcing efficiency of chemical functionalization of CNTs on the mechanical properties of cementitious materials greatly depends on the following two points: (1) dispersion of the functionalized CNTs. Although functionalized CNTs shows better dispersion in an aqueous solution than pure CNTs, because of the hydrophilic functional groups, it still can be improved to increase the dispersion of CNTs to generate better mechanical properties in the cementitious materials. The increasing concentration of functionalized CNTs may lead to further mechanical improvement of cementitious materials, but the agglomeration more readily occurs with excessive CNTs content, so how to improve the dispersion of functionalized CNTs with a fixed concentration is important. (2) Damage of the functionalized CNTs. The mechanical properties of the functionalized CNTs are not as good as pure CNTs due to structure damage. There is a trade-off between the improved chemical interactions of functionalized CNTs/cement matrix and the decreased mechanical properties of the functionalized CNTs itself. Therefore, a question that has arisen is ‘whether there is a way that not only improves the dispersion of functionalized CNTs but also has a positive effect on the mechanical properties of cementitious materials that can compensate for the mechanical loss of the functionalized CNTs’.
Differing from CNTs, GO is an excellent hydrophilic material with oxygen-containing functional groups such as hydroxyl, carbonyl and carboxyl. Therefore, the dispersion of GO in an aqueous solution is excellent and therefore it is much easier to mix with cement compared with CNTs. Duan et al.8 demonstrated that introduction of 0.05 wt% GO can increase the compressive strength and flexural strength of GO/cement composite by 33% and 59%, respectively. Saafi et al.9 reported that 0.35 wt% GO can improve the flexural strength, Young's modulus and flexural toughness of geopolymeric cement by 134%, 376% and 56%, respectively. The improved mechanical properties of cementitious composites were mainly attributed to the high specific surface area and excellent mechanical properties of GO.10
Although CNTs and GO make great contributions to the mechanical enhancement of cementitious materials, the co-effects of GO/CNTs composites on the mechanical behavior of cementitious materials have not been investigated. In addition, what might happen if the negative charged CNTs and GO are combined, and the question as to whether the dispersion of CNTs in a GO solution can be improved due to the electrostatic repulsion still needs to be settled.11 In the present study, the carboxylic functionalized CNTs were first dispersed in a GO and an aqueous solution and the dispersion efficiency of the functionalized CNTs in both solutions was characterized by UV-vis spectroscopy and optical microscopy. Then, the mechanical behavior and microstructure of cement paste reinforced with 0.05 wt% functionalized CNTs, 0.05 wt% GO and 0.025 wt% functionalized CNTs/0.025 wt% GO composite were investigated by mechanical testing and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) coupled with the energy dispersive X-ray (EDX) spectroscopy technique. The chemical interactions between functionalized CNTs and GO were investigated by Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy. Finally, the space interlocking mechanism of the cement paste reinforced with GO/functionalized CNTs composite with enhanced mechanical properties is proposed.
Diameter (nm) | Length (μm) | Aspect ratio | Specific surface area (m2 g−1) | Electric conductivity (s cm−1) |
---|---|---|---|---|
40–80 | 5–15 | 800 | 40–300 | (15–30) × 10−3 |
For the mechanical property tests, a three-point bending test was conducted following the procedure prescribed by ASTM C78/C78 M-10. Three specimens with dimensions of 150 mm × 30 mm × 10 mm were measured with a span of 90 mm and a stroke control at a loading rate of 0.1 mm min−1. Two linear variable differential transformers (LVDTs) were set up on each side of the specimen to measure the mid-point deflection. The compressive strength test was conducted by testing three cubes of size 40 mm × 40 mm × 40 mm. The samples were placed in a materials testing system and loaded at the speed of 1 kN s−1. FTIR testing was conducted to investigate the chemical interactions between the CNTs and GO. The microstructures of GO/cement paste composite and GO/CNTs/cement paste composite were evaluated by SEM with EDX.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Scheme showing the dispersion of (a) unfunctionalized CNTs and (b) functionalized CNTs in the aqueous solution and (c) functionalized CNTs in the GO solution. |
To better investigate the dispersion of CNTs in aqueous and GO solutions, a typical optical microscope observation for the CNTs/aqueous and CNTs/GO solutions was carried out and the results are presented in Fig. 5. Although CNTs are dispersed by a pre-ultrasonication for 15 min, some agglomerates of the CNTs in the aqueous solution are still observed due to the large surface tension and energy, as observed in Fig. 5a. In contrast, the bundled CNTs disappear and a better dispersion of CNTs can be achieved in the GO solution, as observed in Fig. 5b. The microscope results are consistent with the UV-vis spectroscopy results, indicating the dispersion of CNTs in GO solutions is much better than in aqueous solutions.
Specimen | Compressive strength (MPa) | Flexural strength (MPa) | Young's modulus (GPa) |
---|---|---|---|
Cement paste | 25.60 | 13.64 | 12.12 |
0.05 wt% CNTs/cement | 27.24 | 15.06 | 12.63 |
0.05 wt% GO/cement | 28.43 | 15.85 | 14.31 |
0.025 wt% GO/0.025 wt% CNTs/cement | 31.01 | 16.93 | 15.42 |
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 SEM images and EDX results of GO/cement paste: (a) highlighted part is without GO; (b) highlighted part is with GO. |
More importantly, the GO/CNTs/cement paste composite shows the highest compressive strength (31.01 MPa), flexural strength (16.93 MPa) and Young's modulus (15.42 GPa), which is improved by 21.13%, 24.21% and 27.23%, respectively, compared with cement paste, as shown in Fig. 6 and Table 2. The reinforcement by the GO/CNTs composite is much higher that by GO or CNTs individually. Therefore, the GO/CNTs composite plays a more important role in reinforcing the mechanical strength of cement paste, which is attributed to the better dispersion of CNTs in the GO solution, as discussed and shown in Fig. 3 and 5. Better dispersion of CNTs, in turn, contributes more to the mechanical enhancement of the cement paste.
To verify the improved dispersion of CNTs with the help of GO in the cement paste matrix, the microstructures of the CNTs/cement paste composite and the GO/CNTs/cement paste composite were compared and investigated, as shown in Fig. 8. Some agglomeration of the CNTs in the cement paste can be observed in Fig. 8a, otherwise the mechanical improvement should be higher than the present results. However, the agglomeration of CNTs significantly disappears in the GO/CNTs/cement paste composite, as shown in Fig. 8b. Most of the CNTs tend to be uniformly distributed in the pores or voids of the matrix, rather than intertwining with each other. Therefore, it is reasonable to deduce that the better dispersion of CNTs, resulting from the GO incorporation, is the basis for the stronger reinforcement of CNTs on the cement paste. More importantly, as observed in Fig. 8b and c, some GO sheets exist in the middle of the CNTs, which is like a bridge linking the dispersed CNTs together by chemical bonding. It is considered that the space interlocking of CNTs by GO incorporation also contributes to the mechanical improvement of cement paste.
![]() | ||
Fig. 8 SEM images of (a) CNTs/cement paste composite and (b) GO/CNTs/cement paste composite with low magnification and (c) high magnification. |
FTIR analysis was conducted to investigate the chemical interaction between CNTs and GO sheets, as shown in Fig. 9. The characteristic peaks of GO at 1723, 1621, 1403, 1222 and 1058 cm−1 indicate carboxyl or carbonyl CO stretching, H–O–H bending band of the absorbed H2O molecules, carboxyl O–H stretching, phenolic C–OH stretching and alkoxy C–O stretching.19 In addition, the characteristic peaks of CNTs at 2361, 1716, 1565, and 1182 cm−1 indicate the O–H stretch from strongly hydrogen-bonded –COOH, C
O (carboxylic acid moieties), carboxylate anion stretching and C–O stretching, which shows the CNTs are decorated with carboxyl groups. However, the higher intensity and large width of these bands have the stronger interactions in the GO/CNTs composite. Particularly, the higher absorption at 1720 cm−1, corresponding to the stretching vibration of the C
O ester groups formed between the carboxylic acid groups of the CNTs and the alcohol groups of GO indicates that the CNTs have indeed been covalently attached to the GO.
A number of studies have demonstrated the significant reinforcement mechanism of the cement matrix by CNTs or GO. Li et al.7 reported that chemical reactions occurred between the carboxylic acid of CNTs and the calcium silicate hydrate (C–S–H) or Ca(OH)2 of the cement matrix. The strong covalent force on the interface between the CNTs and matrix can improve the load-transfer efficiency from the cement matrix to the CNTs. Duan et al.8 pointed out that GO sheets containing carboxylic acid groups can also form strong interfacial adhesion between the GO and the cement matrix, which has a similar reinforcement mechanism to CNTs. As a result, due to the excellent mechanical behavior of the functionalized CNTs and GO with better interaction with the cement matrix, the mechanical properties of the cement composite reinforced by GO or CNTs are clearly improved. In this study, it is the first time that the space interlocking mechanism of the GO/CNTs/cement paste composite with enhanced mechanical properties has been proposed, as shown in Fig. 10. The significant mechanical improvement of the GO/CNTs/cement paste composite is mainly attributed to two effects. First, the better dispersion of CNTs ensures that more CNTs contribute to the mechanical enhancement of cement paste. Second, the two separate phases, (C–S–H) and Ca(OH)2, in the cement hydration product are likely linked by the GO and CNTs together. GO sheets can not only interlock the cement matrix together, but also bridge the CNTs by chemical bonding. More load can thus be transferred and shared by the GO and CNTs simultaneously. Finally, the improved chemical bonding among the CNTs by GO incorporation can result in a space interlocking structure, the [CNTs–GO–CNTs] structure, which helps to improve the load-transfer efficiency from the cement matrix to the GO/CNTs composites. As a result, the mechanical properties of the GO/CNTs/cement paste composite are significantly improved.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |