Amir
Gheisi
a,
Andreas
Sternig
a,
Günther J.
Redhammer
b and
Oliver
Diwald
*b
aInstitute of Particle Technology, Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg, Germany
bDepartment of Materials Science and Physics, Paris-Lodron University Salzburg, Austria. E-mail: oliver.diwald@sbg.ac.at
First published on 21st September 2015
Thin films of water covering highly dispersed metal oxides can give rise to the spontaneous and spatially controllable growth of hydroxide fibers in ambient air. Knowledge about the underlying formation mechanisms is key to the rational development of metal oxide nanomaterials and associated microstructures. We used SiCl4 as a water free chlorine ion source for the surface functionalization of MgO nanocubes and explored their subsequent transformation into magnesium oxychloride Mg3(OH)5Cl·4H2O fibers upon contact with water vapor. Specifically we show how the temperature of the functionalization process and material dispersion control the reaction pathway that can lead to very different products like Mg(OH)2, MgCl2·6H2O, or Mg3(OH)5Cl·4H2O and delineate a reaction mechanism. Lessons to be learned from this unique route to form hydroxide fibers under ambient conditions can be applied to a variety of microstructural evolution processes that involve metastable solids and superficial water acting both as a reactant and as a reaction medium for the hydration of metal oxide particles.
Most growth processes yielding oxide nanoparticles occur under non-equilibrium conditions.3,4 Resulting solids are metastable, highly dispersed and, as such, subject to their interface and the chemical composition of the surrounding gas or liquid phase. Under ambient conditions and in humid environments thin-film water is ubiquitous2,5,6 and nanomaterials become instantaneously covered by water films with thicknesses ranging between one molecular layer to few nanometers.7 While the water-mineral oxide chemistry has received much attention in earth and environmental science6,8 as well as in surface and materials science7,9–11 significantly less attention has been paid to interfacial water in the field of nanomaterials chemistry. This is surprising if one considers that thin water films can serve as a reaction medium for the growth and assembly of oxide nanostructures.12,13
We recently discovered the spontaneous formation of magnesium oxychloride (Mg3(OH)5Cl·4H2O) fibers which grow out of MgO-based nanoparticle agglomerates.14 This process occurs under ambient conditions and starts from MgO nanocubes the surfaces of which were previously contacted with chlorine. Prior to fiber growth both the synthesis and the functionalization procedure of the metal oxide nanoparticles exclusively involved the solid–gas interface and were performed under dry conditions. The critical impact of materials and process parameters during functionalization, such as the required degree of dispersion or the temperature of adsorption and surface functionalization has remained unknown to date. In this study, we identified their decisive impact on the entire transformation process to gain insights into the underlying growth mechanism and, ultimately, to control microstructure development. Moreover, the challenge of achieving compositional homogeneity over the entire nanoparticle ensemble is at the focus of this study. The detailed exploration of the here presented solid–liquid–gas interface reaction involves surface functionalized non-equilibrium solids and thin liquid water films serving as reaction medium and solvent. The study provides important insights for the synthesis and functionalization of oxide nanomaterials. Moreover, it also connects to key steps in the interface chemistry of mineral binders and ceramics which is determining for their later performance.
XRD confirms for both types of MgO powders the exclusive presence of crystalline particles with periclase structure (Fig. S2, ESI†). The average crystallite sizes, as determined from peak broadening using the Scherrer equation,21,22 correspond to 6 ± 1 nm and 35 ± 1 nm for CVS MgO and commercial MgO, respectively. While the measured specific surface area of CVS MgO, which corresponds to SBET = 300 ± 20 m2 g−1, is perfectly consistent with the XRD derived specific surface area, the situation is different for commercially available MgO: in comparison to a XRD derived value of SXRD = 50 m2 g−1 we determined via N2 sorption analysis a value of SBET = 12 ± 1 m2 g−1 which is lower by a factor of five. This discrepancy points to polycrystalline grains exhibiting a large fraction of intergranular solid interface area that is not susceptible to N2 adsorption. Both CVS and commercial MgO were processed equally prior to functionalization and growth studies described in this work.
For a typical functionalization approach we exposed approximately 200 mg of MgO nanocube powder within a first cycle for 5 minutes to SiCl4 vapor (with a vapor pressure of 300 mbar at room temperature) and after subsequent pumping subjected the powder to O2 atmosphere (p = 700 mbar) for another period of 5 minutes. Gaseous reactants that did not adsorb on the particle surface are removed upon subsequent pumping to a base pressure of p < 10−4 mbar and new reactant molecules are supplied to the powder sample in the course of each subsequent cycle. The results presented in this study were obtained on MgO nanocube powders which were subjected to 6-cycles of room (RTA) or low temperature (LTA) adsorption. The 6th cycle is completed by sample evacuation to the base pressure of p < 10−4 mbar at 298 K.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 Optical appearance and structural properties of chlorine functionalized MgO nanocube samples with different levels of compositional homogeneity. Exposure of an originally white and opalescent MgO nanocube powder (a) to SiCl4/O2 at T = 77 K produces a homogeneous white and compact powder (b). The inhomogeneous appearance of the sample in (c) arises from an identical sample treatment that was performed at T = 298 K and is due to the coexistence of two fractions: (c1) agglomerates of unreacted MgO nanocubes and (c2) parts of a more compact and deeply white powder with a XRD pattern which is specific to MgCl2·6H2O grains (please find Rietveld analysis of the pattern in Fig. S3, ESI†). The energy profile in the bottom panel underlines that adsorption at 77 K inhibits the strongly exothermic reactive transformation of MgO into MgCl2·6H2O leads to MgO nanocubes with surface adsorbed SixClyOz (b).14 | ||
For specimens isolated from the more compact regions of the powder sample (Fig. 3c2), phase analysis revealed magnesium dichlorhydrate MgCl2·6H2O (Bischofite) as the predominant phase (69%) together with forsterite (28%) and periclase (3%) as minor fractions (Fig. S3, ESI†). The sample heterogeneity emerges directly after the SiCl4/O2 adsorption step, i.e. before the vacuum of the reaction cell (Fig. 1) was broken for sample transfer and further materials characterization. Apparently, water from the ambient, which is unavoidable in our current XRD set up, leads to the transformation of a so far unknown precursor phase into MgCl2·6H2O (Fig. 2c2).
Earlier powder XRD and solid state 29Si MAS NMR studies revealed that the LTA sample consists of MgO nanocubes that are covered with surface adsorbed chlorosiloxane species SixClyOz.14 Despite their pronounced reactivity in the ambient, the chemical composition as well the nano-/microstructure of this metastable composite can be retained over weeks of storage in vacuum. As a major finding, the adsorption temperature represents the determining factor for the here described functionalization approach. In case of the room temperature adsorption (RTA) experiment the corresponding thermal energy in conjunction with the heat of reaction released allows the system to overcome the activation barrier ΔEA (Fig. 2d) towards formation of MgCl2·6H2O (see XRD pattern and TEM image in Fig. 2c2) and forsterite (Fig. S3, ESI†).
The MgO particles are arranged in particle agglomerates (Fig. 3a). Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) measurements do not reveal any characteristic morphological features in the μm size range on these agglomerates. Room temperature exposure of bare MgO particle surfaces to water vapor produces thin lamellar features (e.g. see arrow in the upper right panel of Fig. 3) which are characteristic for Mg(OH)2 nanosheets, the crystallographic phase analysis of which is presented below. (A detailed microstructural and morphological description of these hydroxides can be found in ref. 19.) A completely new microstructural situation, however, originates from water contact of chlorosiloxane covered MgO nanocube agglomerates for exposure times t ≥ 3 days24 (lower panel in Fig. 3): assemblies of needle-like shaped crystals, which have grown radially out of the individual agglomerates are observed. We also checked for related microstructural transformation behavior on commercially available nanocrystalline low surface area MgO material (SBET = 12 m2 g−1) which, prior to water vapor exposure, had been subjected to functionalization cycles identical to those applied to CVS MgO nanocubes (Table S1 in ESI†). In this case XRD patterns (Fig. S4a, ESI†) and SEM images (Fig. S4b, ESI†) point to the exclusive formation of Mg(OH)2 and the absence of fiber growth or other additional crystallographic phases.
The different microstructures observed for pure and surface functionalized MgO nanocube ensembles after water vapor exposure (Fig. 3) are in line with crystallographic structure changes (Fig. 4).
![]() | ||
| Fig. 4 Left panel: (a) powder XRD pattern of a MgO powder after storage in water-saturated air (p(H2O) = 32 mbar), (b) a chlorinated CVS MgO powder after storage in vacuum (p < 10−4 mbar) and (c) a chlorinated CVS MgO powder after storage in water-saturated air (p(H2O) = 32 mbar). The measured XRD patterns are consistent with (a) the brucite phase Mg(OH)2 (black lines, JCPDS card # 44-1482) and (b) periclase MgO (blue lines, JCPDS card # 45-0946). Rietveld refinement of the pattern in (c) (Fig. S5 in ESI†) indicates a quantitative materials conversion into the F5 phase of magnesium oxychloride (Mg3(OH)5·Cl·4H2O). The right panel shows a graphical representation of the corresponding crystal structure as adopted from ref. 25. | ||
Water vapor converts MgO nanocubes into Mg(OH)2 (Fig. 4a). However, the interaction between chlorosiloxane covered MgO nanocubes and H2O vapor gives rise to the F5 phase Mg3(OH)5Cl·4H2O as concluded from the XRD powder pattern (Fig. 4c and S5 in ESI†).14,26 A graphical representation of this structure is provided in Fig. 4d. Importantly, in the course of all the experiments performed we have never obtained any evidence for magnesium oxychloride carbonatation which would result from CO2 uptake from the gas phase.27
For complementation of materials characterization we analyzed the LTA samples at the different stages of their transformation with TEM (Fig. 5). The granular contrast in Fig. 5a and b indicates a high degree of crystallinity of the particles after low temperature contact with SiCl4/O2 (Fig. 1b). Displaying sharp edges and corners their cubic habitus is essentially retained. Furthermore, consistent with the crystallite domain size the particle sizes, as determined by TEM analysis, remain in the range below 10 nm.19 Irrespective from the retained primary particle properties, the agglomerates have become more compact (upper micrographs of Fig. 5a and b) in comparison to MgO nanocube powders before functionalization (Fig. S1a, ESI†).19,28
From microscopy and XRD data in conjunction with the NMR evidence of siloxane formation on MgO surfaces14 we infer that SiCl4/O2 adsorption (Fig. 1b) does not affect the primary particle properties but decreases their average distance and, by that, increases the powder density. This explains the changes in the scattering properties and, thus, the altered macroscopic optical appearance as revealed by the digital images in Fig. 2b. The larger Mg3(OH)5Cl·4H2O fibers (Fig. 5) are arranged as bundles (inset in Fig. 5c) with diameters in the range between 100 and 300 nm. After 14 days of H2O exposure we did not evidence residues of MgO nanocubes which previously had served as Mg2+ ion source for magnesium oxychloride fiber growth.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 6 Scheme illustrating the mechanism of fiber growth. Contact with water vapor leads to the instantaneous formation of condensed water films which sustain ion transport necessary to add new Mg3(OH)5Cl·4H2O units to the top of the growing crystalline fibers. As concluded from the characteristic and well-characterized morphology of oxychloride fibers25 the [010] direction is proposed to be the growth direction with the (101) plane being subject to fast material addition and growth. | ||
We used SiCl4 as a water free chlorine ion source23 and co-adsorbed these molecules with O2 at low temperatures. Upon subsequent sample warming to room temperature and under dynamic vacuum conditions, the MgO particle surfaces transform a fraction of activated SiCl4/O2 molecules into chlorosiloxane species that remain on the MgO nanocube surfaces. Comparison of the two types of nanocrystalline MgO samples, i.e. the CVS MgO nanocube powder (Fig. S1a and c, ESI†) and commercially available MgO (Fig. S1b and d, ESI†), shows clearly that the degree of dispersion is key to the transformation process (Fig. 3 and 6). On CVS MgO, where reactive SiCl4/O2 adsorption (Fig. 1b) can occur, the estimated number of monolayer equivalents corresponds to approximately 1 and is by a factor of 28 lower as compared to commercially available nanocrystalline MgO (Table S1, ESI†). In the latter case the materials' dispersion is apparently too low to enable effective intermixture between SiCl4/O2 derived adsorbates, on the one hand, and activating MgO surface sites, on the other. As a consequence, SixClyOz production is negligible. The evacuation step at the end of each functionalization cycle (Fig. 1b) is performed during warm up and leads to the removal of all physisorbed and weakly bound SiCl4/O2 molecules. Since the concentration of surface activated chlorsiloxanes SixClyOz is insufficient to engage the reaction path towards magnesium oxychloride fiber formation, the exposure of this low surface area material towards H2O leads to the quantitative transformation of MgO into brucite (Fig. S4, ESI†). An additional explanation relates to the complex reaction network which requires Mg–O dissolution to enrich the liquid water film with Mg2+ ions. Size dependent dissolution effects19 as well as microstructural parameters which hamper mass transfer may eliminate the chance for magnesium oxychloride growth in case of the commercially available starting material. Silicon originating from SiCl4 is neither part of the crystalline product nor does it contribute to any other crystalline phase as concluded from the XRD measurements. We expect that after fiber growth amorphous SiOx remains in the base region of the fiber assemblies.
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Supporting powder X-ray diffraction data with the results of Rietveld refinements and additional electron microscopy images together with a table of estimated surface coverages of SiCl4 and O2 on the different types of nanocrystalline MgO samples. See DOI: 10.1039/c5ra18202f |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |