Nupur Saxena*,
Pragati Kumar and
Vinay Gupta
Department of Physics & Astrophysics, University of Delhi, Delhi-110 007, India. E-mail: n1saxena@gmail.com; Fax: +91 11 27667036; Tel: +91 11 27667036
First published on 6th August 2015
A wide range (20–560 K) temperature sensor is devised for the first time from CdS:
SiO2 nanocomposite thin films grown by pulsed laser deposition. Highly intense, stable, and broad red emission observed from the CdS
:
SiO2 nanocomposite is employed to obtain a luminescence thermometer. Nearly monodisperse and small sized CdS nanocrystals (∼3 nm) in a SiO2 matrix, as viewed by transmission electron microscopy, may be accountable for the absence of band edge emission even at 20 K. The sensor exhibits almost linear behavior in all cryogenic, physiological, and high temperature ranges. The average sensitivity and resolution of the sensor reported here were ≈10−2 K−1 and 10−4 K, respectively, with a maximum relative sensitivity of ∼8.4% K−1 at 120 K.
Optical temperature sensors are important in many thermometry applications because they provide immunity to electrical noise and exhibit better sensitivity, selectivity, and fast response. A variety of devices have been reported utilizing various methods, such as optical fiber sensing,1 surface plasmon resonance (change in dielectric constant and refractive index),2 photoluminescence (change in intensity, peak position, and lifetime),3–7 and shift in optical absorption edge,8 to realize optical thermometers in different ranges. In particular, photoluminescence (PL) based temperature sensors are widely applicable because of their low-cost, simple preparation, easy instrumentation, noninvasive operation, and nondestructive technique for the detection of temperature even for living or cancer cells.4 The PL intensity or luminescence intensity ratio (LIR) is a parameter that can offer versatility for sensing in different environments compared to other techniques.9 This ability to glean the temperature is demonstrated by certain luminescent materials including II–VI semiconductor quantum dots (QDs),6,7,10–14 carbon dots,15 lanthanide based complexes,1,3,16–18 and metal–organic-frameworks (MOFs).5,19 Among these, II–VI semiconductors (especially Cd-containing QDs) and their nanocomposites are used outstandingly. In the report by Walker et al., a luminescence intensity based thermometer was realized by CdSe QDs with a ZnS overlayer [(CdSe)ZnS] in poly(lauryl methacrylate) (PLMA) matrix in the temperature range from 100 to 315 K and a relative sensitivity of 1.3% per °C was observed.6 P. A. S. Jorge et al. devised a (CdSe)ZnS core–shell-doped bulk glass temperature sensor (287–316 K) with a resolution of 0.3 °C for intensity based sensing, and a wavelength shift sensitivity of 0.2 nm °C−1 was observed.7 Local temperature sensing (297.4–316.6 K) using single QDs of (CdSe)ZnS coated with a layer of organic polymer and conjugated with streptavidin was reported by S. Li and co-workers, which exhibited sensitivity of ∼0.1 nm °C−1 using a PL spectral shift.10 A CdSe(ZnS):
SiO2 nanocomposite based high temperature sensor (295–525 K) was demonstrated. The optical thermometer worked on the principle of the variation of the emission wavelength with temperature and exhibited a sensitivity of ∼0.11 nm °C−1. The core–shell structure of CdSe(ZnS) QDs with ECdSe = 2.04 eV and EZnS = 2.72 eV encapsulated with SiO2 was employed to obtain a high yield and intense emission in the visible range.11 Maestro et al. demonstrated the potential use of CdSe QDs as fluorescent nanothermometers for two-photon fluorescence microscopy. This nanothermometer displayed not only an enhancement in spatial resolution for multiphoton excitation processes but also considerably higher temperature sensitivity for two-photon (near-infrared) excitation as compared to that under one-photon (visible) excitation. In addition, the peak emission wavelength was also found to be temperature sensitive.12 A temperature sensor (296–353 K) based on ultrathin film system of mercaptosuccinic acid modified CdTe QDs and positively charged layered double hydroxide nanosheets with high response sensitivity (1.47% per °C) was reported by R. Liang et al. recently.13 However, mostly Cd-containing QDs based temperature sensors suffer from limited temperature variation, poor sensitivity and thermal stability. Therefore, it is a challenge to devise new types of QDs based temperature sensors with a wide temperature range, thermal stability, reproducibility, and better sensitivity.
In this article, we report a simple and low-cost CdS:
SiO2 nanocomposite system that is chemically pure, thermally stable and offers a broad red luminescence, which opens new channels for futuristic photonic, optoelectronic and sensing devices. In particular, this study is about the fabrication of a versatile range temperature sensor based on emission from this system. CdS is a direct band gap (for bulk CdS Eg = 2.42 eV) II–VIth semiconductor that exhibits tunable optical properties and emission, which covers the full range of visible spectrum. Due to this property, CdS QDs are extensively used in diverse applications, including photodetection,20 light-emitting diodes,21 solar cells,22 lasers,23 waveguides,24 bio-imaging,25 and photoelectrochemical sensors.26 An optically transparent matrix such as SiO2 provides multifold recompenses like stabilization of emission, prevention from contamination and oxidation, which can extensively affect the emission.11 The encapsulation of CdS with SiO2 in the form of a nanocomposite provides thermal resistance, transparency, stability, and multifold enhancement in emission intensity to this system. The intense room temperature luminescence from the CdS
:
SiO2 nanocomposite motivates for future research towards diverse applications of this system. A wide range luminescence based thermometer obtained out of it is just a step for harnessing the extraordinary emission properties of this composite system.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Room temperature photoluminescence of as-grown CdS![]() ![]() |
Thermal annealing of the nanocomposite causes enhancements in the emission intensity with a maximum shift of ∼15 nm in peak position towards higher wavelength. The enhancement in intensity by annealing may be resulted by the alteration of interface conditions of CdS QDs and SiO2 matrix in the nanocomposite, i.e. coalescence of very tiny particles, thereby improving the crystallinity and formation of a large amount of surface defects such as cadmium and sulphur vacancies due to ionic displacements during recrystallization.34,35 The communal effects accountable for the observed intense RE in nanocomposites are the interaction of CdS nanoparticles with the SiO2 matrix at their interfaces and thermal annealing. In the present study, the temperature sensing is performed only on the nanocomposite annealed at 500 °C because it offers the highest emission intensity.
BFTEM studies envisage the formation of almost mono-disperse CdS nanoparticles with a size of ∼3 nm in SiO2 matrix after annealing at 500 °C, as shown in Fig. 2. The average inter-particle separation is ∼12 nm, which is crucial to obtain highly intense and pure emission. The inset shows the corresponding particle size distribution histogram, which indicates that the size of the CdS nanoparticles ranges from 1.5 to 6 nm. The lognormal fitting to the histogram suggests the average particle size to be 3.0 ± 0.2 nm, indicating almost monodispersity in the nanocomposite system. Selected area electron diffraction (SAED) pattern confirms the hexagonal phase of CdS with d-spacings of 3.54 Å, 3.34 Å and 3.12 Å, corresponding to the (100), (002) and (101) crystal orientations, respectively (inset Fig. 2).
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 TEM image of CdS![]() ![]() |
The stability of PL intensity at room temperature for the present sensor was also studied with respect to time, and is shown in Fig. 3. It is clear that the intensity remains almost unchanged over the course of time. For better visualization, the upper part of the spectra is shown in a magnified view. It is illustrated that the rate of intensity reduction for first six months is relatively larger than later, and it almost saturates after two years (inset, Fig. 3). It is significant to note that even after two or more years, the PL intensity is preserved at 95% of its initial value.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Room temperature photoluminescence of the CdS![]() ![]() |
The evolution of RE intensity with lowering of temperature is shown in Fig. 4a. The emission intensity enhances gradually, as the temperature is decreased to 20 K. This enhancement in intensity is usually due to the thermal deactivation of non-radiative transitions.36 The spectra do not show evolution of any new peak even at 20 K, implying that the only possible traps that contribute to emission are either sulfur vacancies or cadmium vacancies
or both. The shift in the peak position is marginal, being maximum up to 15 nm at 20 K stating a high stability in the trap emission in the lower temperature range. It is observed that at room temperature, the emission intensity is sufficiently high to study the temperature dependency of the emission spectra above room temperature. The stagnation of the PL intensity is observed with increasing temperature and is shown in Fig. 4b. The peak shift is relatively larger (∼35 nm) in this case as compared to the lower temperature side, but still trivial. Therefore, the emission is considerably stable in both the temperature regions. The data is obtained in reversible and repetitive manner to check the repeatability and reliability. This PL behavior gears-up to be utilized as a probe for temperature.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Temperature-dependent PL of the CdS![]() ![]() |
Fig. 5 depicts the linear behavior of the temperature sensor studied as a function of inverse temperature according to the linear function , deduced from the variation of integrated intensity with respect to temperature according to the following equation:30
![]() | (1) |
The sensor response is also studied in terms of the full width at half maximum (FWHM) of the PL spectrum and is plotted as a function of temperature, which is shown in Fig. 6. Intensity gives a direct interpretation of temperature, whereas FWHM is analytical. The collective effect of homogeneous and inhomogeneous broadening results in the increase in FWHM of the PL spectrum with increasing temperature. The underlying reasons for such broadening are: (i) broad distribution of intraband states caused by different trapping sites, (ii) distribution in trapped e–h distances (iii) carrier–phonon interactions due to scattering of excitons with acoustic and longitudinal optical (LO) phonons and (iv) nanocrystallites size distribution induced inhomogeneous broadening. Broadening of the PL spectrum is mainly originated by (iii) and (iv) sources. The third one causes homogeneous broadening, whereas the fourth is responsible for inhomogeneous broadening in the PL spectrum due to thermal treatment. The solid curve is obtained using a modified Toyozawa's equation,37 which is stated as follows:
![]() | (2) |
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 FWHM dependency on temperature. The solid curve represents fitting to the experimental data according to eqn (2). |
Temperature sensing in the cryogenic, physiological, and high temperature range has been studied with various materials. Nevertheless, there is rarely any report on such a wide range temperature sensor using inorganic compounds and simple fabrication processes. The efficiency of the temperature sensor reported here can be attributed to high sensitivity and resolution. The sensitivity of the sensor is related to the slope of the linear fit and defines the rate of change of intensity/FWHM with respect to the change in temperature. The average sensitivity of the sensor in two temperature ranges is calculated using the relation ΔI/ΔT, where ΔI is the change in lnP/FWHM, corresponding to the change in temperature ΔT.38 The resolution of the sensor is deduced from the detector resolution and the calculated sensitivity. The sensitivity of the sensor deduced from intensity studies is plotted with temperature and is shown in Fig. 7. The sensitivity decreases with increasing the temperature due to the drastic change in emission intensity in the lower temperature regime and stability at higher temperatures. The calculated sensitivity and resolution in the two temperature ranges are given in inset of Fig. 7. The average sensitivity and resolution of the sensor were calculated to be ∼0.06 K−1 and 0.0002 K, respectively, from the intensity, while ∼0.389 meV K−1 from the FWHM measurements. The relative sensitivity of the sensor,38 i.e.
![]() | (3) |
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 Variation of absolute and relative sensitivities as a function of temperature. Inset: table of sensor parameters in two temperature regimes. |
A brief review on the luminescence-based thermometers is presented in Table 1 for comparison. It includes studies on diverse range of materials to realize nanothermometers with high sensitivity. In most of the studies, the luminescence intensity ratio in rare earth doped compounds/complexes or alternatively PL intensity/spectral shift in Cd-containing QDs are studied with respect to temperature. In particular, for Cd-containing QDs temperature sensors, the sensitivity is not very satisfactory with the maximum being 1.47% °C−1 for CdTe quantum dots-layered double hydroxide ultrathin films13 with a limited range of temperature response. Some sensors are useful at cryogenic temperatures, some at physiological, while others are good for the high temperature range. Nevertheless, such a wide range temperature sensor that covers all the temperature zones has not yet been reported. The sensitivity and resolution of the present sensor is considerably better in all temperature regimes, according to the intensity study. The study of luminescence intensity with temperature for the present sensor is a direct and significant method as compared to others because a single peak is observed in the PL spectrum. The advantage here is that the temperature can be sensed directly by the observation of lowering or evolution of the PL spectrum intensity. Usually in most temperature sensors, like rare earth doped complexes, there are two sharp peaks for which the intensity ratio varies with temperature, and a direct linear or natural log based linear relation can be obtained for temperature sensor. Instead, for the CdS:
SiO2 nanocomposite temperature sensor, there is no need to observe the ratio of PL peaks, which is not easy to perceive. We have also performed FWHM studies as a function of temperature and found that the sensor works with better sensitivity for luminescence intensity. The highest value of relative sensitivity (∼8.4% K−1) is maximum, which is 1.2 times greater than the maximum achieved sensitivity to date18 for luminescence based molecular thermometers. The present temperature sensor is a good choice in the cryogenic region for better sensitivity, whereas in high temperature zones it offers better resolution.
Sensing material | Temperature sensing method | Temp. range | Absolute/relative sensitivity | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|
Rare-earth element doped γ-Fe2O3@TEOS/APTES NPs | Luminescence intensity ratio | 10 K–350 K | 0.5% K−1 | 1 |
Eu3+ doped TiO2 NPs | Fluorescence intensity ratio and life time | 307 K–533 K | 0.17–2.43% K−1 | 3 |
Mixed-lanthanide MOF | Luminescence intensity ratio | 10 K–300 K | — | 5 |
(CdSe)ZnS QDs in PLMA | Luminescence intensity | 100 K–315 K | 1.3% °C−1 | 6 |
(CdSe)ZnS QDs doped bulk glass | PL spectral shift | 287 K–316 K | 0.2 nm °C−1 | 7 |
Single QDs of (CdSe)ZnS | PL spectral shift | 297.4 K–316.6 K | 0.1 nm °C−1 | 10 |
CdSe(ZnS) nanocomposite | PL spectral shift | 295 K–525 K | 0.11 nm °C−1 | 11 |
CdSe QDs | Luminescence intensity and spectral shift | 303 K–333 K | 0.16 nm °C−1 | 12 |
CdTe quantum dots-layered double hydroxide ultrathin films | Luminescence intensity | 296 K–353 K | 1.47% °C−1 | 13 |
(ZnCd)S![]() ![]() |
Luminescence decay time | 263 K–423 K | — | 14 |
Carbon dots | Luminescence intensity | 288 K–333 K | — | 15 |
Tb3+ doped crystalline oxide powders | Luminescence intensity ratio | 303 K–773 K | 2.8 × 10−4 to 9 × 10−4 °C−1 | 16 |
Er3+ doped BaTiO3 NCs | Fluorescence intensity ratio | 322 K–466 K | ≤0.0052 K−1 | 17 |
Eu3+ doped Y2MoO6 | Luminescence intensity | 20 K–500 K | 7% K−1 | 18 |
EuxTb(1−x)MOF | Luminescence intensity ratio | 100 K–450 K | 1.325% K−1 | 19 |
CdS![]() ![]() |
Luminescence intensity & FWHM | 20 K–560 K | Intensity: 0.06 K−1/8.4% K−1 FWHM: 0.388 meV K−1 | Present work |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |