Anu Renjith and
V. Lakshminarayanan*
Raman Research Institute, C.V. Raman Avenue, Sadasivanagar, Bangalore-80, India. E-mail: narayan@rri.res.in
First published on 9th October 2015
A novel ionically conducting colloidal suspension was prepared from a quaternary ammonium salt and ethylene glycol. The prepared colloidal medium was thoroughly characterized in terms of its ionic conductivity, rheological and thermal properties. The colloid exhibited sharp reversible sol ↔ gel transitions at 50–55 °C. The phase transitions were associated with drastic changes in viscosity (10−2 to 102 Pa s) and ionic conductivity (0.5–12.67 mS cm−1). The sharp transition at ambient temperature helps to preserve the dispersed state of different nanoparticles obtained via sonication in the medium. The soft solid nature of the colloid can be considered to mimick a biological environment and was evaluated as a soft electrolytic medium for monitoring enzyme kinetics.
At present, soft solids are prepared by the quasi-solidification of ionic liquids and organic solvents. This is brought about by the addition of polymers,3 inorganic nanoparticles,4 and low molecular weight gelators.5,6 The polymeric analogues of ionic gels are being extensively prepared for various applications. The reversible thermal transitions observed in these polymer based ionic gels are attributed to the reversible cross linking of the polymer with temperature. By appropriate choice of a block polymer, He et al. could prepare a thermally reversible gel by the self assembly of poly (N-isopropyl acrylamide-b-ethylene oxide-b-N-isopropyl acrylamide) in an ionic liquid medium of 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium bis (trifluoromethylsulfonyl)-imide ([EMIM][TFSI]).7 Susan et al. prepared polymer based soft solids by in situ polymerization of vinyl monomers in ionic liquids.8 The high cost and moisture sensitivity of the ionic liquid based gels pose limitations for its use in practical applications.
Gels can also be formed by various secondary interactions such as van der Waals forces, hydrogen bonding, π–π interactions occurring within the components. These gels are prepared by the addition of a low concentration of an organogelator to the bulk solvent medium. The organogelator is capable of gelating the bulk solvent medium by promoting the formation of three dimensional network structures based on secondary interactions.9 The organic solvent molecules get trapped within the three dimensional structures causing gelation. These type of gels possess thermal reversibility much better than their polymeric counterpart as the three dimensional network structures are formed by non-covalent interactions unlike that in polymers.6 Smith et al. prepared room temperature gels of tetrafluoroborate based ionic liquid in DMSO solvent by the addition of an organogelator N-carbobenzyloxy-L-isoleucylaminooctadecane.10 Thermo reversible gels have also been prepared from long chain tertiary amines and other related tertiary and quaternary ammonium halide salts (Cn = 12, 18) in organic solvents.11
The soft solid properties of ionic gels together with the inherent ionic conductivity show immense potential in areas of electrochemical capacitors, DSSC, Li ion batteries.12,13 The sol–gel matrices have also been studied as a matrix for protein storage, enzymatic studies, enzyme catalyzed organic reactions and enzyme kinetics.14,15 It has been shown that the structure of the protein in its native state is very well preserved in a gel matrix compared to that in the molecular solvents. The gel matrix when associated with sufficient ionic conductivity are considered ideal medium for electrochemical studies of enzymatic processes. The colloidal suspension reported here, is found to exhibit these physical properties, and hence was explored as a media for the electrochemical monitoring of enzyme kinetics.
The aggregation of nanoparticles in solvent matrices is an important issue that can adversely affect their use in potential applications. The problem can be circumvented using a suitable dispersing medium.16 The nanoparticle dispersions have been prepared earlier in molecular solvents through proper control of surface potentials and surface forces of nanoparticles, yet highly loaded nanoparticle suspensions were found to be difficult to achieve. Through our studies, we demonstrate here that the colloidal suspension can be used for dispersing nanoparticles.
Urease from Canavalia ensiformis (Sigma Aldrich) was used as enzyme while urea was used as the substrate.
Pt foils (0.5 mm thickness) purchased from Advent research materials were used as electrodes for the ionic conductivity measurements.
:
8 and heated at 80 °C under magnetic stirring till a homogeneous colorless solution was obtained. The solution attains a soft solid state as the temperature decreases below 50 °C.
For the cryo-SEM experiments, the samples are transferred to a PP3000T cryo unit (Quorum Technologies) and freeze fractured with a cold knife. The fractured and cut samples are sublimated at −130 °C for 5 minutes and then sputtered with platinum inside the unit. Imaging of the samples were performed using Zeiss Ultra Plus cryo-SEM setup at a temperature of −160 °C. The transition temperature of the material developed was determined by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) using Perkin-Elmer, Model Pyris-1 at a heating rate of 5 °C min−1. The texture of the colloidal suspension was observed using a polarising optical microscope (POM) (Olympus BX50) equipped with a heating stage (Mettler FP82HT) and a central processor (Mettler FP90).
The electrochemical characterization of the developed medium was performed by electrochemical impedance spectroscopy using Zahner electrochemical workstation in a frequency range of 0.1 to 105 Hz. The kinetics of enzyme–substrate reaction was monitored by a Lock in amplifier (model SR830 DSP, Stanford research systems) using Labview 2012, Stanford research-830 constant frequency.
The quaternary ammonium cation used in our studies is symmetric with an alkyl chain of Cn = 4. This bulky cation is devoid of any polar functional groups. It is thus least expected for the cation to have any significant secondary interactions with the other components i.e., [BF4]− and ethylene glycol (EG). However, recent reports on eutectic solvents prepared from tetra butyl ammonium chloride (TBA+Cl−) and EG as well as tetrabutyl ammonium bromide (TBA+Br−) and EG show that a strong hydrogen bonding interaction between the Cl/Br anion and EG is sufficient for the formation of a room temperature liquid.18 Thus, together with a symmetric tetrabutyl ammonium cation, a poorly interacting anion also needs to be selected so as to ensure the formation of a soft solid. Abbott et al. studied depressions in freezing point of mixtures containing hydrogen bond donor (HBD) and choline salts with different anions such as Cl−, [BF4]−, [NO3]− and F−.2,17 The studies showed that the mixtures containing [BF4]− were associated with least depression in freezing point and this was correlated with weak hydrogen bonding interactions between the anion and HBD. From our experiments, we have also observed that TBACl and TBABr form corresponding liquids with EG while TBABF4 and TBAPF6 form soft solid with EG. The studies on [C4mim][BF4] assisted gelation of DMSO also reported the crucial role of tetraflouroborate anion in gelating the solvent.10
The effect of solvent on the physical state of the salt on mixing was also studied by the inverted vial experiment. The quaternary ammonium salt [TBA]+[BF4]− was fixed and EG (ε – 37) was replaced with other molecular solvents such as acetonitrile (ε − 37.5), glycerol (ε – 42.5) and ethanol (ε – 24). [TBA]+[BF4]− dissolved completely in acetonitrile and ethanol while it gelated in glycerol. The results suggest that a structured/associated solvent has greater influence on the physical state of the mixture rather than its dielectric constant.
Based on all these observations, the components were chosen as [TBA]+[BF4]− and EG (Scheme 1). A weak hydrogen bonding interaction between hydroxyl protons of EG and BF4− has been earlier confirmed in literature by fluorescence spectroscopy and NMR.19 Thus the symmetric tetrabutyl ammonium cation and the weak hydrogen bonding interactions of BF4− and EG would render a delicate balance of the polar–non polar characteristics to the medium and thus promote the formation of a stable colloidal suspension of [TBA]+[BF4]− in EG.
:
EG. A ratio of 1
:
8 was optimized as the composition exhibited a fine balance in rigidity and fluidity. Photographs of the suspension in an inverted vial are shown in Fig. 1a. The mechanical strength of the composition corresponding to 1
:
8 was sufficiently high enough that a colloidal volume corresponding to 1.5 ml could hold a Teflon coated magnetic pellet (0.76 g) in an inverted vial as shown in Fig. 1a(ii).
The sol–gel transition of the colloidal suspension was monitored by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) given in Fig. 1b. The gel → sol conversion was observed at 60 °C while the reverse transition corresponding to sol → gel occurred at 51 °C. The gelation and melting processes are accompanied by exothermic and endothermic peaks respectively as usually observed for any freezing or melting process. However, the sharp calorimetric peaks of the colloid observed in DSC reveal a first order transition which indicates that all molecules undergo the transition in unison.20 The driving force for the gelation of the colloid can be attributed to the aggregation of the salt components so as to favor the hydrogen bonding interactions within the solvent EG.
Fig. 1c shows the variation in the viscosity of the colloidal suspension within a temperature range of 25–65 °C. A sharp change in viscosity (almost 104) characteristic of sol–gel transition of the colloid was observed at a temperature close to 55 °C. The temperature associated with the sudden change in the viscosity values corresponds closely with the transition temperature observed in DSC both on heating and cooling.
The mechanical properties of the prepared colloidal suspension were analyzed from the frequency response measurements at room temperature at a strain amplitude of 0.05% (Fig. 1d). The loss modulus and storage modulus shown in figure signifies the fluid and solid phase behavior respectively. The moduli exhibit least dependence to the frequency as is evident from the figure. The loss modulus is lower than that of the storage modulus at all the frequencies studied. These characteristic features observed in the frequency sweep measurements confirm the soft solid behavior of the suspension.21 The elastic and viscous moduli of the suspension at room temperature were measured from the strain amplitude measurements at a constant angular frequency of 0.5 rad s−1 as given in Fig. S2.† There is no linearity in the response over a range of strain amplitude between 0.1 to 100%. The elastic modulus lags behind the viscous modulus beyond the critical yield strain of 1% amplitude, indicating a permanent deformation of the structure.
The cryo-SEM image of the colloidal suspension was obtained to examine the sample morphology. Fig. 2a shows the evenly distributed spherical aggregates of ∼50 nm. The spherical features could have formed by the aggregation of TBABF4 in EG. These spherical aggregates of TBABF4 can be stabilized by the weak hydrogen bonding interactions between BF4− and –OH groups of EG. The aggregation behavior of [C4mim][BF4] have been studied by many groups. Bowers et al. observed that these ionic compounds form spherical aggregates in aqueous solution above its critical aggregation concentration.22 Dorbritz et al. observed the aggregation behaviour of [C4mim][BF4] in methanol, 2-propanol, and ethyl acetate by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry.23 The group observed that on decreasing the polarity of the solvent and increasing the concentration of the salt, the size of the aggregates could be increased. However, the three dimensional network structures characteristic of gel structure was not observed in the cryo-SEM images.
The birefringence observed in polarizing optical microscope (Fig. S3†) at room temperature confirms the crystallinity of the suspension. X-ray diffraction studies were carried out to probe into the nature of the suspension at different temperatures and also with respect to the components. The room temperature XRD patterns of the suspension exhibited additive features of both the components viz., sharp diffraction peaks corresponding to [TBA]+[BF4]− throughout the spectra and the broad peak of ethylene glycol in the wide angle region (Fig. 2b). A comparison of the XRD spectra of the colloidal suspension and its components, viz., [TBA]+[BF4]− and EG is shown in (Fig. S4†). There was no significant shift in peaks or absence of any peak as compared to [TBA]+[BF4]− which indicate that the secondary interactions of [BF4]− with EG do not hinder the crystallinity of the salt. It can also be noted that beyond the gel → sol transition temperature of the colloid, the entire set of sharp peaks of the suspension disappears due to the melting of salt as observed in Fig. 2b.
The ionic characteristics of the suspension were measured by electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) using two parallel planar Pt electrodes at the open circuit potential. The Bode phase diagram (Fig. S5a†) of the colloid at room temperature shows that the phase angle remains zero at frequencies beyond 6 kHz and hence 10 kHz was optimized for our studies. At this high frequency, the capacitive reactance contribution to impedance is negligible and the system is defined by the solution resistance. The Bode plots at different temperatures from which the ionic conductivities of the suspension were measured are provided in Fig. S5b.† Fig. 2c shows the variation in ionic conductivity of the suspension in a temperature range of 25–60 °C.
The ionic conductivity values varied between 0.5 and 12.67 mS cm−1. The values are 2–4 orders of magnitude greater than those reported on polymeric ionic gels (PEG or PEO).24 Sekhon et al. reported an ionic conductivity of the order 10−4 S cm−1 for ionic gels formed from a mixture of ternary solvent, salt and a polymer (PVdF).25 The ionic gels prepared by the gelation of DMSO associated with an ionic conductivity of ∼15 mS cm−1. However the study showed that there was no decrease in ionic conductivity before and after the phase transition. This was attributed to the fact that ions were not part of the gel network.12 The ionic conductivity of the gels formed from ionic liquid compatible cyclic carbonate network varied from 7 μS cm−1 to 3.2 mS cm−1 with increase in ionic liquid composition.26 It is evident from Fig. 2c that the phase transition corresponding to gel → sol at 55 °C, is associated with a seven fold increase in the ionic conductivity. This can be explained by the collapse of the spherical aggregates of quaternary ammonium salt at temperatures above 55 °C, causing the release of a large number of ions. A scheme of the colloid in sol and gel phases are provided in Fig. 2d. Further, it was observed from the rheological characteristics that the viscosity decreases drastically at the phase transition temperature, which can contribute to an increase in ionic mobility.
The colloidal suspension is associated with a fine balance of polar and non-polar components and is expected to have excellent solvent properties. The ambient temperature isotropic phase exhibited by these soft solids helps in solvent free processing of the suspension for experimental studies.
In this work, we show that application of an appropriate high frequency ac potential, as determined from electrochemical impedance spectroscopy and a simultaneous measurement of the ac current response can provide information on the changes, if any, of the ionic content in the bulk medium brought about by the enzyme–substrate reaction. Any transformation that arises due to progress of the enzyme–substrate reaction brings about changes in the bulk ionic characteristics which can very well be monitored by impedance. Since the process is happening in bulk, the accessibility of the active redox centers of the enzyme to the electrode surface is not essential, thereby providing an alternative to the method of complex surface modifications of the electrodes.
In our studies, a small volume (110 μL) of the sol containing a known concentration of urea was injected amidst two parallel Pt electrodes kept at a distance of 3 mm (Fig. S1†). The sol solidifies immediately to form a soft solid and the corresponding enzyme urease (1 μL of 1 mg ml−1 aqueous solution) was added. The soft solid nature of the matrix helps to overcome the problems such as solvent seepage and solvent evaporation that are usually associated with molecular solvents when used in microliter volumes. The enzyme–substrate reaction was allowed to take place in the soft solid matrix. The soft matrix would provide an environment that mimics a biological media which is an alternate to an aqueous buffer solution normally used in such studies. The urea–urease reaction is given as
| (NH2CONH2) + 2H2O → 2NH4+ + CO32− | (1) |
As is evident from eqn (1), the reaction yields ammonium ions and carbonate ions. The progress of the reaction is expected to increase the ionic conductance of the medium. The real time monitoring of ionic conductance was carried out by impedance spectroscopy at open circuit potential.
To optimize the frequency at which the measurements were to be performed, Bode phase plot of the colloidal suspension containing the substrate was studied over the entire range of frequencies from 100 kHz to 100 mHz at the open circuit potential (Fig. S6†). It was observed that at frequencies greater than 1 kHz, the impedance is contributed only by the resistance of the medium. We have optimized 20 kHz for our study as the phase angle was zero at this frequency.
The kinetics of urea–urease reaction was monitored at various concentrations of urea ranging from 0.5–5 mM. The observed changes in the ionic conductance with time were baseline corrected to remove the inherent ionic conductance of the soft solid-urea mixture. An increase in the ionic conductance with time was observed indicating that ions are generated with the progress of the reaction. It can be seen from Fig. 3b that for each concentration, the initial increase in ionic conductance is linear while it tends to plateau with time due to the saturation of the enzyme sites.
The initial rate of the urea–urease reaction was obtained from the slope of the linear segment of t = 0 to t = 80 s of Fig. 3b. Since the progress of the reaction is monitored as change in ionic conductance of the medium with time, the units of rate of reaction are expressed in terms of nS min−1 (Fig. 4). The plot of initial rate of the reaction vs. urea concentration was found to follow Michaelis–Menten eqn (2) with an adj. R2 of 0.96.
![]() | (2) |
![]() | ||
| Fig. 4 Michaelis–Menten fitting of the plot of the initial reaction rate vs. concentration of urea for the urease–urea reaction carried out in the TBABF4–EG colloidal matrix. | ||
Km is determined from the concentration of the substrate at which the rate of the reaction is exactly half of Vmax. Thus, a lower Km indicates that the maximum velocity of the reaction Vmax is attained at small substrate concentrations. Km is also a measure of enzyme–substrate binding affinity. It is evident from the eqn (S3)† that a low Km signifies a high binding affinity in the medium. The experiment was repeated to check the consistency of measurements and was averaged which gives a Km of 2.1 mM with a standard deviation of 0.1621. The Km values for the urea–urease reaction monitored under different experimental conditions were compared earlier by Qin & Cabral.32 In an unbuffered neutral medium, Km varied between 1.25–3.28 mM whereas the values were in the range of 9.5–20 mM in phosphate buffer and 1.2–3.8 mM in a citrate buffer. The value obtained in our studies is very much close to that obtained (Km = 1.8 mM) for the urea–urease reaction done in an unbuffered gel matrix of polyacrylamide.15
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Additional details on the characterization of the colloidal suspension. The basics of the electrochemical concepts used for the ionic conductivity studies and enzyme kinetics are also provided. Bode plots of the colloid used for the electrochemical studies are also provided. See DOI: 10.1039/c5ra13303c |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |