Baohua Zhang,
Xiuqin Zhan,
Pengyu Zhao and
Zhonghao Li*
Key Laboratory of Colloid and Interface Chemistry, Shandong University, Ministry of Education, Jinan 250100, China. E-mail: zhonghaoli@sdu.edu.cn; Fax: +86-531-88564750; Tel: +86-531-88363821
First published on 26th June 2015
Ionic liquids provide chemists with a versatile platform and many opportunities for constructing various interesting inorganic materials. Here, an ionic liquid-mediated synthesis route is proposed for the controlled synthesis of PtPd bimetallic particles. The synthesized PtPd particles have unique three dimensional nanostructures (3D) constructed by nanoparticle subunits. For the 3D nanostructures, the primary PtPd particles form aggregates with the characteristic of interparticle porosity. Among others, the Pt1Pd1 bimetallic particles exhibit superior electrocatalytic activity toward oxidation of methanol in an alkaline medium than the commercial state-of-the-art Johnson-Matthey platinum black catalyst (Hispec™ 1000). Furthermore, the catalytic activity towards p-nitrophenol reduction indicates that the synthesized Pt1Pd3 particles exhibit the highest catalytic activity in comparison with the studied various PtPd bimetallic particles, the monometallic Pt and the monometallic Pd particles. This study may pave the way for the efficient synthesis of three dimensional bimetallic nanostructures for improved catalytic applications.
Recently, ionic liquids have attracted great attention for the synthesis of inorganic particles due to their unique chemical and physical properties such as high solubilizing power and low vapor pressure.23–27 Specifically, inorganic synthesis in ionic liquids occasionally leads to materials that are difficult to achieve by using other synthesis routes.28,29 In the previous reported researches, ionic liquids have already been used as an environmental benign solvent, as a crystal growth modifier, or as an reactant precursor for the fabrication of inorganics.30–35 The reported works have demonstrated that ionic liquids can provide the chemists with a versatile platform for constructing various inorganic materials.36 The ionic liquids thus add great values to the inorganic materials community.
In our recent work, we reported a facile route for the synthesis of AuPd and AuPt bimetallic particles with the assistance of the imidazolium-based ionic liquids.37,38 The successful synthesis of these bimetallic particles indicates ionic liquid-assisted route might be very promising for fabrication of efficient bimetallic catalysts. However, our previous synthesized AuPd and AuPt particles are in micrometer scale. This is because the short carbon chain in the studied ionic liquids cannot have a better modification for the formation of small particles. In order to synthesize bimetallic particles with small size, it is of great interest to perform the synthesis with ionic liquid possessing long carbon chain in the cation. Herein, we report on the synthesis of PtPd bimetallic particles with the assistance of the ionic liquid 1-decyl-3-methyl imidazolium chloride (DMIMCl) which possesses long carbon chain. Interestingly, primary PtPd particles form aggregates with the characteristic of interparticle porosity, resulting in small 3D PtPd particles with tiny nanoparticles as the subunits. The PtPd particles exhibit excellent electrocatalytic and catalytic activities toward methanol electro-oxidation and p-nitrophenol reduction.
In order to understand whether the present DMIMCl ionic liquid plays a unique role for the formation of these 3D nanostructured particles with tiny nanoparticles as the subunits, the controlled synthesis without DMIMCl ionic liquid is performed with the synthesis condition similar to that of Pt1Pd1. Fig. 2a–c show the low and high magnification TEM images of the Pt1Pd1 particles synthesized without DMIMCl. It is found that particles with the size of 7.4 ± 1.3 nm form. The corresponding HRTEM image is shown in Fig. 2d. Based on the images in Fig. 2c and d, it is clear that these particles are not composed of nanoparticle subunits. Therefore these particles are not in 3D nanostructure shape. For a better comparison of the size of the Pt1Pd1 particles synthesized without and with DMIMCl, the corresponding size distribution histograms are shown in Fig. 2e and f. For the Pt1Pd1 particles synthesized without DMIMCl ionic liquid, the size distribution in Fig. 2e is obtained by direct counting of the particles because there are no subunits for the particles. For the Pt1Pd1 particles synthesized with DMIMCl, the size distribution in Fig. 2f is obtained by counting the subunits of the particles. From Fig. 2e and f, it is clear that the size of the Pt1Pd1 particles synthesized without DMIMCl is much larger than that of the Pt1Pd1 nanoparticle subunits within the 3D particles synthesized with DMIMCl ionic liquid. Therefore, it is clear that the DMIMCl ionic liquid plays an important role for the formation of the as-prepared 3D nanostructured particles with the tiny nanosubunits. In principle, the crystal growth process consists of nucleation and growth, which are influenced by the intrinsic crystal structure and the external conditions including the kinetic energy barrier, temperature, time, capping molecules, and so forth.41 The initial formed nuclei can further growth by consuming the reactants or the metastable primary particles. The growth by consuming metastable primary particles is mainly related to the well-known Ostwald ripening process which is usually apparent in high temperature synthesis. In our case, the synthesis is performed at room temperature, therefore the further growth of the particles could be attributed to the depletion of the reactant salts. During the synthesis with DMIMCl, many alloy nuclei form quickly after the addition of NaBH4 to the metal precursor solution. Because of the molecular structure of DMIMCl has a long carbon chain, it has a better stabilization for the particle formation, which could inhibit the further growth of the nuclei, resulting in very small nanoparticles. Compared with larger particles synthesized without DMIMCl, these very small nanoparticles are easily fused and aggregated for the formation of 3D nanostructures in consideration that small nanoparticles possess higher surface energies. Besides, it is known that 1,3-dialkylimidazolium ionic liquids can form a polymeric supramolecular structure.42,43 It is therefore reasonable to assume that the organized structure of the ionic liquid may have a template effect, which further helps the formation of the 3D nanostructures for the Pt1Pd1 particles synthesized with DMIMCl. Moreover, the inherent nature of the Pt and Pd component in the PtPd bimetallic particles might also be helpful for the cooperative formation of these interesting particles in the present of the ionic liquid. As a result, the 3D nanostructure with tiny nanoparticle subunits could be successfully formed with the assistance of DMIMCl ionic liquid.
The morphologies of PtPd bimetallic particles with controlled composition are also characterized by TEM. For comparison, the monometallic Pt and Pd are also synthesized. Fig. 3 shows TEM images of samples obtained at various metal precursor molar ratios. For pure Pt, individual spherical nanoparticles with size of 3.8 ± 0.5 nm form (Fig. 3a). For the Pt3Pd1 as shown in Fig. 3b and c, it is found that nanoparticle-constructed 3D nanostructure forms, which is similar to Pt1Pd1 in Fig. 1. The size of the nanoparticle subunit is 3.0 ± 0.4 nm. However, individual spherical nanoparticles without 3D nanostructure form for the Pt1Pd3, in which the size of the nanoparticles is 3.3 ± 0.4 nm as shown in Fig. 3d and e. In principle, the crystal growth process is influenced by the intrinsic crystal structure and the external conditions. In comparison with the external conditions, the intrinsic crystal structure might also play an important role for the formation of specific morphologies. For example, the well-known soft template of cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB) can result in different morphologies for various kinds of inorganic particles, which implies that the intrinsic crystal structure play an important role for the formation of various nanostructured-particles. For the nanoparticle synthesis in ionic liquid, the intrinsic crystal structure also play an important role for the formation of different morphologies. For example, the ionic liquid tetrabutylammonium hydroxide (TBAH) can result in the formation of hollow ZnO mesocrystals with tube-like morphology while Ni(OH)2 and Co(OH)2 nanoplates are formed in TBAH.23,39 Therefore, the formation of the present individual spherical Pt1Pd3 particles could be attributed to their crystal structure in which the distribution of Pt and Pd atoms on the surfaces of the crystal largely changes the surface energies. In this case, the template effect of the ionic liquid does not work sufficient for the formation of the 3D Pt1Pd3 nanostructure. For pure Pd, individual spherical nanoparticles still form with the size of 4.1 ± 0.5 nm (Fig. 3f). Thus, the morphology of the PtPd bimetallic particles synthesized by the present ionic liquid route could be well controlled, which is largely dependent on their compositions. This is similar to our previous reported AuPd and AuPt bimetallic particles in which the morphologies are mainly determined by the composition of the metal components,37,38 demonstrating the important role of the inherent nature of the Pt and Pd component for the formation of the various particles.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 TEM images of the synthesized various PtPd bimetallic particles, pure Pt particles and pure Pd particles: (a) Pt, (b and c) Pt3Pd1, (d and e) Pt1Pd3, (f) Pd. |
Because of the unique nanostructures of the as-prepared PtPd particles, the synthesized PdPt particles were further characterized by their composition-dependent electroactivities. The electrocatalytic performance of the PtPd particles toward a methanol oxidation reaction was tested in the 1 M CH3OH and 1 M KOH solution at a scan rate of 50 mV s−1. For comparison, the electrocatalytic performances of the commercial state-of-the-art Johnson-Matthey platinum black catalyst (Hispec™ 1000), the as-prepared pure Pt and pure Pd were also tested. For the practical applications of the catalysts, the mass-normalized electroactivities are the most important criterion for judging the activities, therefore the total metal (Pt and Pd) loaded on the GCE is controlled at the same. Fig. 4a shows the cyclic voltammograms (CVs) of methanol oxidation with the various catalysts in a 1 M CH3OH and 1 M KOH aqueous solution. The current densities are normalized to the total metal mass that loaded on GCE. Characteristic anodic peaks in the forward and reverse sweeps associated with methanol oxidation are observed. The peak current densities are 0.38, 0.40, 0.64, 0.29, 0.23 and 0.53 A mg−1 for Pt, Pt3Pd1, Pt1Pd1, Pt1Pd3, Pd and commercial Pt black catalyst, respectively. Among the studied catalysts, the Pt1Pd1 exhibits the highest mass-normalized current density for the methanol oxidation. The onset potentials (Eonset) for methanol oxidation are −0.727, −0.553, −0.661, −0.758, −0.786 and −0.718 V for Pt, Pt3Pd1, Pt1Pd1, Pt1Pd3, Pd and commercial Pt black catalyst, respectively. The corresponding forward peak potential (Ef) for methanol oxidation is −0.186, −0.236, −0.223, −0.146, −0.201 and −0.159 V for Pt, Pt3Pd1, Pt1Pd1, Pt1Pd3, Pd and commercial Pt black catalyst, respectively. Although the commercial Pt black catalyst has a lower Eonset than that of the Pt1Pd1, the Ef of commercial Pt black catalyst is much higher than that of the Pt1Pd1. Therefore, it is clear that the Pt1Pd1 bimetallic particles have superior electrocatalytic properties toward methanol oxidation than others, which is attributed to the electronic coupling between Pt and Pd metals being optimized at the atomic percentage of Pt is ca. 50%. The differences in electrocatalytic activity of the various PtPd bimetallic particles can be attributed to their different morphology, composition and surface structure. It is known that the methanol oxidation reaction is structure-sensitive. Therefore, the change in the surface atom arrangements (the distribution of the atoms on the crystal surface) of bimetallic PtPd nanocrystals could easily result in the changes of activities for methanol oxidation even though the catalysts have similar shape and size.13 The value of If/Ib (in which If and Ib are the forward and backward peak current densities, respectively) is usually used to evaluate the CO poison tolerance of Pt based catalysts in the methanol oxidation reaction.16 From Fig. 4a, the calculated value of If/Ib for 3D Pt1Pd1 and commercial Pt black catalyst is 5.2 and 2.8, respectively, demonstrating the superior poison tolerance of Pt1Pd1. The electrochemical stability of Pt1Pd1 and commercial Pt black catalysts for methanol oxidation is also investigated by chronoamperometry (CA) experiment for 10000 s (Fig. 4b). It is seen that the current decay of Pt1Pd1 particles is much slower, indicating their better electrochemical stability and electrocatalytic activity toward methanol oxidation. Pd is much cheaper than Pt, therefore one can expect that the present synthesized Pt1Pd1 catalyst might have promising applications in the fuel cell field.
One of the important applications of the metal particles is to catalyze some reactions that are otherwise unfeasible.44 p-Nitrophenol is a well-known pollutant with high toxicity and poor biological degradability. The hydrogenation of p-nitrophenol to p-aminophenol is very useful because of the important applications of p-aminophenol as an analgesic and antipyretic drug.45 Without metal catalyst, the reduction of p-nitrophenol to p-aminophenol using aqueous NaBH4 is negligible since the reaction is kinetically restricted in the absence of a catalyst.46 The composition-dependent catalytic performance of the as-synthesized PtPd particles towards the reduction of p-nitrophenol by NaBH4 is thus investigated. Fig. 5a shows the UV-vis spectra of p-nitrophenol aqueous solution in the absence and presence of NaBH4. The solution is pale yellow color with the UV-vis absorption peak at about 316 nm in the absence of NaBH4. Once adding NaBH4, the color of the solution becomes yellow with the absorption peak shifting from 316 nm to 399 nm, indicating the formation of p-nitrophenolate ions. Fig. 5b shows the time-dependent UV-vis spectra of the p-nitrophenol solution with NaBH4, demonstrating the negligible changes without metal catalysts. Fig. 5c shows the typical time-dependent UV-vis spectra of the p-nitrophenol solution with NaBH4 after the addition of Pt1Pd1 particles. It is found that the peak at 399 nm decreases rapidly with time, accompanying a color change to colorless finally. This indicates the effective catalytic property of the particles towards the reduction of p-nitrophenol. Since the concentration of NaBH4 in the system is in largely excess in comparison with that of p-nitrophenol, the concentration of BH4− can be regarded as constant during the reaction. Accordingly, pseudo-first-order kinetics could be used to evaluate the apparent kinetic reaction rate constant of the reaction. Based on the UV-vis spectra, the relationship between lnCt/C0 and the reaction time for the synthesized Pt, Pt1Pd3, Pt1Pd1, Pt3Pd1 and Pd catalysts is shown in Fig. 5d. The calculated apparent kinetic reaction rate constant for the synthesized Pt, Pt1Pd3, Pt1Pd1, Pt3Pd1 and Pd catalysts is 0.0196, 0.1386, 0.1192, 0.1128 and 0.0829 min−1, respectively. It is clear that the PtPd bimetallic catalysts have a higher catalytic activity in comparison with Pt and Pd catalysts, indicating the important synergistic effect of Pt and Pd species. Among the studied metal catalysts, the synthesized Pt1Pd3 particles show the highest catalytic activity for the reduction of p-nitrophenol. The calculated mass-normalized kinetic reaction rate constant of the Pt1Pd3 is 1.7325 mg−1 min−1, which is much higher than the reported Pt/γ-alumina (0.064 mg−1 min−1)47 and Pt1.4Pd1 (0.6 mg−1 min−1)45 catalysts. Thus, such PtPd bimetallic catalyst might be very useful towards the important reduction reaction of p-nitrophenol.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |