Yiqun Wanga, 
Kaichang Koua, 
Guanglei Wu*ab, 
Ailing Fengc and 
Longhai Zhuoa
aThe Key Laboratory of Space Applied Physics and Chemistry, Ministry of Education and Shaanxi Key Laboratory of Macromolecular Science and Technology, School of Science, Northwestern Polytechnical University, Xi’an 710129, P. R. China. E-mail: wuguanglei@mail.xjtu.edu.cn;  Fax: +86 29 8339 5372;   Tel: +86 29 8339 5372
bCenter of Nanomaterials for Renewable Energy (CNRE), State Key Laboratory of Electrical Insulation and Power Equipment, School of Electrical Engineering, Xi’an Jiaotong University, Xi’an 710049, P. R. China
cInstitute of Physics & Optoelectronics Technology, Baoji University of Arts and Sciences, Baoji 721016, P. R. China
First published on 26th June 2015
Thermosetting terpolymers composed of bis allyl benzoxazine (Bz-allyl), cyanate ester (BADCy) and 4,4′-bismaleimidodiphenyl methane (BMI) were prepared via co-curing reactions. The curing kinetics of Bz-allyl/BMI/BADCy were investigated via non-isothermal DSC at different heating rates using the Flynn–Wall–Ozawa method. The dielectric, thermal and mechanical properties of Bz-allyl/BMI/BADCy terpolymers were systemically investigated in detail through mechanical measurement, scanning electron microscopy (SEM), dynamic mechanical analysis (DMA) and thermo-gravimetric analysis (TGA). The results show that a suitable addition of Bz-allyl can enhance the impact strength and flexural strength as well as reduce the dielectric constant and the dielectric loss of BMI/BADCy. The dynamic mechanical analysis reveals that the cross-link density of the blend is higher than BMI/BADCy. The higher crosslinking density of the terpolymer led to good thermal stability of the terpolymer. Scanning electron microscopy analysis shows the distinct characteristics of ductile fracture of the blends. All of these changes in properties are closely correlated to the copolymerization between Bz-allyl and BMI/BADCy, which could form an interpenetrating polymer network in the system.
Polycyanurates derived from the thermal curing of cyanate ester possess high thermal properties, low dielectric constants and good mechanical properties after being fully cured to form a triazine network.9–13 However, the thermal characteristics are inferior to those of conventional bismaleimide systems. Blends of cyanate ester and bismaleimide have been realized to derive systems bearing the good physicochemical attributes of the two components, i.e. the heat resistance of bismaleimide and the mechanical properties of polycyanurates.14–18 Some blend systems were investigated by the addition polymerization of bisphenol A dicyanate (BADCy) and 4,4′-bismaleimido diphenylmethane,19 and also BADCy and 2,2′-bis[4-(4-maleimido phenoxy)propane].20,21 Commercial blend formulations of bismaleimide–cyanate known as B-T resins are available, which are extensively used as materials for engineering materials in aircrafts, reinforced plastics, and injection-molding powders, as well as materials in electric motor coil windings, etc.22 However, according to research on the bismaleimide–cyanate system,23,24 the copolymerization of bismaleimide with cyanate resin will result in an interpenetrating network (IPN) structure with high thermal and mechanical properties. Some novel allyl-functionalised aryl cyanate esters have been developed to be incorporated into cyanate ester/bismaleimide blends.25–29 The addition of a small amount of allyl-functionalised aryl cyanate esters may increase the Tg of the overall network by linking the polycyanurate network to the poly-bismaleimide network. So, bis allyl benzoxazine, which has allyl groups, is selected to modify bismaleimide–cyanate ester, and the composite is expected to possess better performance.
In this work, bis allyl benzoxazine (Bz-allyl) is utilised to modify BMI/BADCy resins, aiming to regulate their dielectric, heat resistance, and mechanical properties. The effects of Bz-allyl on the moisture resistance, mechanical, dielectric and thermal properties of Bz-allyl/BADCy/BMI composites were investigated to develop high performance materials.
![[thin space (1/6-em)]](https://www.rsc.org/images/entities/char_2009.gif) :
:![[thin space (1/6-em)]](https://www.rsc.org/images/entities/char_2009.gif) 3. The mixture was heated to 160 °C and maintained at that temperature with stirring until a homogeneous liquid was obtained. The liquid was maintained at that temperature for an additional 0.5 h, which is the BMI/BADCy prepolymer. After that, the mixture was cooled to 140 °C, the Bz-allyl was added, and then the ternary mixture was maintained with stirring for 20 min and a brown-red transparent liquid was obtained. Bz-allyl was blended with BMI/BADCy in different mass ratios of 3%, 6%, 9% and 12%. The blends were denoted as BBz3, BBz6, BBz9 and BBz12, respectively.
3. The mixture was heated to 160 °C and maintained at that temperature with stirring until a homogeneous liquid was obtained. The liquid was maintained at that temperature for an additional 0.5 h, which is the BMI/BADCy prepolymer. After that, the mixture was cooled to 140 °C, the Bz-allyl was added, and then the ternary mixture was maintained with stirring for 20 min and a brown-red transparent liquid was obtained. Bz-allyl was blended with BMI/BADCy in different mass ratios of 3%, 6%, 9% and 12%. The blends were denoted as BBz3, BBz6, BBz9 and BBz12, respectively.
DSC measurements were performed with a Q1000DSC thermoanalyzer system (USA) ranging from room temperature to 380 °C under a N2 atmosphere. A dry nitrogen flow of 40 ml min−1 was used as the purge gas. Samples of about 10 mg were enclosed in aluminium DSC capsules. Dynamic mechanical analysis (DMA) was performed with a Switzerland Mettler-Toledo DMA with a sample size of 45 mm × 6 mm × 3 mm. DMA tests were carried out from 25 to 380 °C with a heating rate of 3 °C min−1 at 1 Hz. TGA tests were performed by using a Netzsch STA 449C thermogravimetric analyzer (Germany) at a heating rate of 10 °C min−1 under a N2 atmosphere from 20 to 800 °C.
The dielectric constant ε and loss factor tan![[thin space (1/6-em)]](https://www.rsc.org/images/entities/char_2009.gif) δ were measured using a high-frequency QBG-3 Gauger and a S914 dielectric loss test set (Shanghai AE Electron Equipment Co. Ltd, Shanghai, China) at a frequency between 10 and 60 MHz. The sample dimensions were (25 ± 0.02) × (25 ± 0.02) × (3 ± 0.02) mm3.
δ were measured using a high-frequency QBG-3 Gauger and a S914 dielectric loss test set (Shanghai AE Electron Equipment Co. Ltd, Shanghai, China) at a frequency between 10 and 60 MHz. The sample dimensions were (25 ± 0.02) × (25 ± 0.02) × (3 ± 0.02) mm3.
Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) was performed on a TESCAN VEGA3 LMH instrument. The SEM accelerating voltage was 20 kV. The water absorption of a sample was determined by swelling in distilled water for 20 h at 100 °C. The sample dimensions were (10 ± 0.02) × (10 ± 0.02) × (3 ± 0.02) mm3. FT-IR spectra were recorded on KBr pellets from 400 to 4000 cm−1 with a resolution of 4 cm−1 on a Nicolet IS10 IR spectrometer (USA).
The non-isothermal DSC thermograms at the heating rates of 5 °C min−1, 10 °C min−1, 15 °C min−1, 20 °C min−1 and 25 °C min−1 are shown in Fig. 2. Obviously, the heating rate exerts a great influence on the curing process. With increasing the heating rate, the exothermic curing peaks were shifted to a higher temperature. Information about the nature of the curing reaction such as onset temperature (Ti), peak temperature (Tp), and endset temperature (Te) at different heating rates could be derived, which are listed in Table 1.
| Heating rate (°C min−1) | Onset temperature (Ti) (°C) | Peak temperature (Tp) (°C) | Endset temperature (Te) (°C) | 
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 | 112 | 195 | 251 | 
| 10 | 115 | 212 | 268 | 
| 15 | 116 | 214 | 283 | 
| 20 | 120 | 220 | 290 | 
| 25 | 128 | 226 | 291 | 
Various models had been proposed for analyzing the non-isothermal curing behavior of polymers.30–32 According to the relationship between the peak temperature and heating rate (β), the apparent activation energies (Ea) of the curing reaction of the terpolymer are 101.9 and 104.7 kJ mol−1 calculated using the Kissinger and Ozawa methods, respectively33,34 (Fig. 3). The Ea values from the Kissinger and Ozawa methods are quite close to each other and their differences may be caused by the different assumptions.
|  | ||
| Fig. 3 Representations of the Kissinger and Ozawa methods for calculating activation energy from non-isothermal data for the copolymer. | ||
The reaction activation energy also could be calculated using the Flynn–Wall–Ozawa (FWO)35 (eqn (1)) multiheating rate method at different values of conversion.
| log ![[thin space (1/6-em)]](https://www.rsc.org/images/entities/char_2009.gif) β = log[AEa/RG(α)] − 0.4567Ea/RT − 2.315 | (1) | 
For a constant conversion α, the plot of log![[thin space (1/6-em)]](https://www.rsc.org/images/entities/char_2009.gif) β versus 1/T obtained from DSC thermograms using various heating rates should render a straight line, where the slope allows the determination of the apparent activation energy. According to the Flynn–Wall–Ozawa method, linear relationships of log
β versus 1/T obtained from DSC thermograms using various heating rates should render a straight line, where the slope allows the determination of the apparent activation energy. According to the Flynn–Wall–Ozawa method, linear relationships of log![[thin space (1/6-em)]](https://www.rsc.org/images/entities/char_2009.gif) β versus 1/T at various degrees of conversion are established in Fig. 4. Fig. 5 presents activation energy as a function of conversion. It can be seen that the activation energy values tended to increase with the degree of conversion.
β versus 1/T at various degrees of conversion are established in Fig. 4. Fig. 5 presents activation energy as a function of conversion. It can be seen that the activation energy values tended to increase with the degree of conversion.
To investigate the possible curing reactions of BBz9, FT-IR measurements were carried out. FT-IR spectra of BBz9 before and after curing are shown in Fig. 8. As a result, the absorption at 947 cm−1 assigned to the oxazine ring in the benzoxazine ring structure disappeared after curing. The absorptions at 2271 and 2236 cm−1 assigned to the cyanate ester group also disappeared. The new absorptions at 1564 and 1371 cm−1 assigned to the triazine group appeared. The appearance of an absorption band at 1213 cm−1 revealed the generation of ether bonds, which may be due to the reaction between BMI and PBz-allyl as shown in Scheme 2d.
In the process of BMI and BADCy curing, the thermal reaction of BMI and BADCy can occur as shown in Scheme 1a and b, respectively. However, the curing mechanism of the Bz-allyl/BMI/BADCy blends is different from that of BMI/BADCy. Ene, Diels–Alder, homopolymerization, and alternating copolymerization reactions are involved in the modification of BMI/BADCy with Bz-allyl.36 The ene reaction occurs at a lower temperature compared with that of the other reactions as shown in Scheme 2c. The cure reactions of the blends of BADCy with BMI can occur as shown in Scheme 1.37 Additionally, parts of Bz-allyl undergo ring-opening polymerization to form polybenzoxazine and generate the phenolic hydroxyl group as shown in Scheme 2a, which can react with the BMI/BADCy as shown in Scheme 2d and e. With increasing temperature, Bz-allyl can react completely, but the allyl group seldom reacts (Scheme 2b) because of the stability of the radical due to resonance.38 On the one hand, the polymerization of the Bz-allyl/BMI/BADCy blends forms ether bonds, which results in good flexibility of the polymer. On the other hand, it may be attributed to the network structure of high crosslinking density formed in the Bz-allyl/BMI/BADCy blends. Moreover, the hydrogen bond is a physical interaction which will increase the impact strength and flexural strength of BMI/BADCy blends. Therefore, it can be concluded that the addition of Bz-allyl can efficiently improve the mechanical properties of BMI/BADCy resins.
|  | ||
| Fig. 9 SEM images of fracture surfaces of Bz-allyl/BMI/BADCy systems: (a) BMI/BADCy, (b) BBz3, (c) BBz6, (d) BBz9 and (e) BBz12. | ||
Fig. 9a–e presents SEM images of the fracture surfaces of BMI/BADCy, BBz3, BBz6, BBz9 and BBz12, respectively. It can be observed that the BMI/BADCy resin has a smooth and riverlike fracture surface (Fig. 9a), exhibiting a typical brittle feature. While with the addition of Bz-allyl into the BMI/BADCy resin, the fracture surface becomes rougher and is accompanied with more ductile sunken areas, which is consistent with the improved impact strength of the composites. For the BMI/BADCy resin, BBz3 and BBz6, as shown in Fig. 9a–c, with the content of the Bz-allyl increased, it can be observed that the riverlike fracture surfaces become more concentrated. The aspect ratios of cracks on the river region of the blend (Fig. 9c) are smaller than those of the BMI/BADCy resin (Fig. 9a), and there are more ductile sunken areas than for the BMI/BADCy resin. In the case of the BBz9 system, as shown in Fig. 9d, the fracture surface is much rougher than those of the BMI/BADCy resin, BBz3 and BBz6 systems, and there exists a large amount of ductile sunken areas, which can absorb the energy of fracture and hinder the crack propagation, exhibiting a typical rough feature. In addition, BBz12, as shown in Fig. 9e, has large ductile sunken areas in the matrix, and the surface scaly roughness is more obvious. In summary, the Bz-allyl/BMI/BADCy blend has a rough surface, more dimples and ductile sunken areas, and is of high ductility and thus can absorb more energy during the impact process. The possible reason is that the co-curing of Bz-allyl and BMI/BADCy has largely enhanced the toughness of the resin. Therefore, the impact strength of the composite with high Bz-allyl content is increased. The features of the fracture surfaces of Bz-allyl/BMI/BADCy systems accord well with the mechanical properties.
![[thin space (1/6-em)]](https://www.rsc.org/images/entities/char_2009.gif) δ and storage modulus of the cured blends of BMI/BADCy, BBz3, BBz6, BBz9 and BBz12 are shown in Fig. 10 and 11. From the dynamic mechanical spectra, it is observed that the cured BMI/BADCy (Fig. 11) exhibits well-defined dynamic mechanical damping peaks centered at 245 and 308 °C, which are ascribed to the glass transitions of polycyanurate and polybismaleimide, respectively.21 The corresponding temperatures for BBz3 are 246 and 371 °C from Fig. 11. In contrast, only one dynamic mechanical damping peak at about 262 °C is observed for cured BBz9 (Fig. 11). Two glass transitions undoubtedly confirmed that the cured BMI/BADCy and cured BBz3 included two kinds of network. However, one single glass transition indicates that BBz6, BBz9 and BBz12 are a homogeneous network. There is only a single Tg so we speculate that there are further reactions between Bz-allyl and BMI/BADCy.
δ and storage modulus of the cured blends of BMI/BADCy, BBz3, BBz6, BBz9 and BBz12 are shown in Fig. 10 and 11. From the dynamic mechanical spectra, it is observed that the cured BMI/BADCy (Fig. 11) exhibits well-defined dynamic mechanical damping peaks centered at 245 and 308 °C, which are ascribed to the glass transitions of polycyanurate and polybismaleimide, respectively.21 The corresponding temperatures for BBz3 are 246 and 371 °C from Fig. 11. In contrast, only one dynamic mechanical damping peak at about 262 °C is observed for cured BBz9 (Fig. 11). Two glass transitions undoubtedly confirmed that the cured BMI/BADCy and cured BBz3 included two kinds of network. However, one single glass transition indicates that BBz6, BBz9 and BBz12 are a homogeneous network. There is only a single Tg so we speculate that there are further reactions between Bz-allyl and BMI/BADCy.
As can be seen, all of the composites exhibit a slightly higher storage modulus than the BMI/BADCy resin in the glassy state. This result may be attributed to the higher modulus of PBz-allyl. So the initial modulus of the Bz-allyl/BMI/BADCy blends was increased by the increase of Bz-allyl content. The Tg of the Bz-allyl/BMI/BADCy blends is summarized in Table 2. With the increase of Bz-allyl content, the Tgs of the cured blends shifted to the higher temperature. Based on the rubber elasticity theory and the following eqn (2),39 we calculated the crosslinking densities of the different crosslinked systems and the data are shown in Table 2.
| ρ = E/3φRT | (2) | 
| Sample | Td5 (°C) | Td10 (°C) | Char yield (%) | Tg (°C) | Crosslinking density (103 mol m−3) | 
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BMI/BADCy | 441 | 446 | 35.8 | 245, 308 | 1.83 | 
| BBz3 | 427 | 433 | 46.6 | 246, 271 | 1.92 | 
| BBz6 | 405 | 415 | 45.2 | 248 | 2.15 | 
| BBz9 | 387 | 406 | 43.1 | 262 | 2.28 | 
| BBz12 | 379 | 401 | 43.3 | 267 | 2.32 | 
It is known to all that polybenzoxazine possesses a lower electrical capacitance than other thermosetting materials but also is less sensitive to changes in frequency.41 As Fig. 12 and 13 show, it can be seen that the dielectric constant values and the dielectric loss factors of the Bz-allyl/BMI/BADCy resin systems decreased with the content of Bz-allyl firstly. Then the dielectric constant values and the dielectric loss factors slightly increased with the further addition of Bz-allyl into the BMI/BADCy resin system. When the Bz-allyl content in the cured Bz-allyl/BMI/BADCy resins was 9 wt%, the dielectric constant values and the dielectric loss factors of the blends reached the minimum values of 3.02 and 0.0158 at 10 MHz, respectively. On the one hand, it was due to the triazine rings and diphenyl ether with low dielectric constant and dielectric loss factor. On the other hand, the dielectric constant could be reduced by the decrease in the dipole polarization in more highly crosslinked systems. The dielectric loss factor is also related to the crosslinking density based on its effect on the lagging of dipole polarization. But at high frequency there is no time for the polarization of dipoles. So the dielectric loss factor is insensitive to the crosslinking density at high frequency, which led to no obvious difference in the measured values of the dielectric loss factor. Wang et al. reported that the high cross-linking density and high viscosity during the final curing stage of cyanate esters hindered the mobility of residual cyanate groups.42 However, according to Wang’s conclusion, when Bz-allyl increased, the network structure of high crosslinking density formed by Bz-allyl/BMI/BADCy hindered the curing of BMI/BADCy, which caused the increase of the dielectric constant and the dielectric loss factor. Therefore, both the dielectric constant and loss factor of Bz-allyl/BMI/BADCy blends decrease compared with BMI/BADCy. It can be concluded that a suitable content of Bz-allyl in Bz-allyl/BMI/BADCy blends creates good dielectric properties and they retain good dielectric stability.
As can be seen from Fig. 15, different from an observable weight loss peak at around 420 °C on the differential curve of the Bz-allyl/BMI/BADCy systems, there was no obvious weight loss of Bz-allyl/BMI/BADCy blends under 350 °C. In Table 2, the Td5 of BMI/BADCy is 441 °C, while for BBz9 it is 387 °C. The char yield at 800 °C of BMI/BADCy is 35.8%, while for BBz9 it is 43.1%. The better thermal stability of BMI/BADCy compared to BBz9 may be attributed to the excellent thermal stability of BMI/BADCy, and more triazine rings in BMI/BADCy. The addition of Bz-allyl does not significantly sacrifice the thermal resistance of BMI/BADCy. However, the thermal stability of the BBz systems may be attributed to the increased cross-linking degree of the Bz-allyl/BMI/CE blends which results from the reaction between Bz-allyl which undergoes ring-opening polymerization to form polybenzoxazine, allyl groups react with BMI/CE resins and generate the phenolic hydroxyl group which increases the interactions between molecules.
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |