Hong Yang*,
Ming Xu,
Ling-Xiang Guo,
Hao-Fan Ji,
Jun-Yu Wang,
Bao-Ping Lin*,
Xue-Qin Zhang and
Ying Sun
School of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Jiangsu Province Hi-Tech Key Laboratory for Bio-medical Research, Southeast University, Nanjing 211189, China. E-mail: yangh@seu.edu.cn; lbp@seu.edu.cn; Fax: +86 25 52091096; Tel: +86 25 52091096
First published on 22nd December 2014
This manuscript presents a facile thiol–ene photo-click chemistry method to prepare magnetic stir bar-encapsulated polysiloxane-based organocatalyst gels under benign conditions, and develops a Stir Bar-Encapsulated Catalysis (SBEC) technique. Through thiol–ene addition chemistry, we graft olefin-terminated organocatalysts (i.e. MacMillan catalyst, proline catalyst, and N-heterocyclic carbene catalyst) onto poly[3-mercaptopropylmethylsiloxane], which is further photo-crosslinked to coat the embedded magnetic stir bar. The prepared magnetic stir bar-encapsulated polysiloxane-based organocatalyst gels can be put into reaction flasks to perform stirring and catalysis functions at the same time. The most important benefit of SBEC technique is to infinitely simplify the catalyst/product separation procedure by using a simple stir-bar-retriever, even without any precipitation/filtration steps. The catalytic performances of three different organocatalyst gels applied in asymmetric Diels–Alder reaction, asymmetric aldol reaction and benzoin condensation reaction respectively are also examined herein.
To support catalysts on polysiloxane gels, conventional noncovalent immobilization methods8 are to occlude catalysts such as Grubbs' catalysts,9,10 BINAP-Ru,11,12 Salen-Mn13 and DuPHOS-Rh,14 into polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) films or slabs. Although this strategy is very convenient and efficient, catalyst leaching even in aqueous solution is an inevitable and serious problem.14 In order to overcome this defect, covalent immobilization method provides another solution by chemically linking the catalysts onto the polysiloxane matrixes. Previously reported protocols always relied on a platinum-catalyzed hydrosilylation reaction of polymethylhydrosiloxane (PMHS) and olefin-terminated catalysts or ligands to build polysiloxane-based catalysts.15–17 However, this approach also has several obvious disadvantages: (1) hydrosilylation reaction efficiency is quite variable and unpredictable so that the catalyst grafting ratio is beyond control; (2) noble metal, platinum is very expensive and meanwhile is difficult to be removed from the products, which might complicate the following catalytic applications; (3) the preparation procedure usually requires long reaction time, plenty of solvents and a high reaction temperature.
Herein, we present a facile thiol–ene photo-click chemistry method18–20 to prepare polysiloxane-gel-based organocatalysts under benign conditions. As shown in Fig. 1, we use instead of PMHS, poly[3-mercaptopropylmethylsiloxane] (PMMS)21,22 which bears one mercapto group in every monomer unit, and graft olefin-terminated organocatalysts (MacMillan catalyst C1, proline catalyst C2, and N-heterocyclic carbene (NHC) catalyst C3) onto PMMS chain. Meanwhile, by mixing the above systems with a photo-initiator (2,2-dimethoxy-2-phenylacetophenone, DMPA) and a variety of olefin-functional crosslinkers, a series of organocatalyst-immobilized polysiloxane gels can be synthesized by UV-initiated thiol–ene click chemistry. Compared with traditional hydrosilylation procedure, this thiol–ene photo-click protocol, as a greener and cleaner approach, has an almost 100% reaction conversion; uses cheap photo-initiators as catalysts, which are much easier to be removed; and requires very mild reaction conditions such as minute-scale reaction time, solvent-less environment-friendly process and ambient temperature, etc.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Preparation methods and molecular structures of polysiloxane-gel-based organocatalysts herein this manuscript. |
Furthermore, inspired by Stir Bar-Sorptive Extraction (SBSE) technique,23 we use organocatalyst-immobilized PMMS gel instead of PDMS, to coat magnetic stir bar, and develop a Stir Bar-Encapsulated Catalysis (SBEC) technique. As shown in Fig. 2, a plastic vial containing a magnetic stir bar and the mixture of PMMS, organocatalyst C1, photoinitiator DMPA and crosslinker L3, was UV illuminated for 20 minutes (Fig. 2A–C) to form a cross-linked gel (Fig. 2D). After breaking up the plastic vial, the prepared magnetic stir bar-encapsulated polysiloxane-based organocatalyst gel (Fig. 2E) could be put into a reaction flask to perform stirring and catalysis functions at the same time (Fig. 2F). The intrinsic motivation and the most important benefit of this approach are to infinitely simplify the catalyst/product separation procedure to using a simple stir-bar-retriever (Fig. 2G), even without any precipitation/filtration steps.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Preparation protocol of magnetic stir bar-encapsulated polysiloxane-based organocatalyst gels: (A) a magnetic stir bar and plastic pipette-head vials. (B) The plastic vial was filled with a magnetic stir bar and the mixture of PMMS, organocatalyst C1, DMPA and crosslinker L3. The oily mixture was UV-illuminated (C) and became a crosslinked gel (D), which was cut out off the vial (E). (F) The obtained organocatalyst gel was performing both stirring and catalysis functions (S1.avi†). (G) A stir-bar-retriever was used to separate the catalyst from products (S2.avi†). |
All 1H NMR spectra were obtained using a Bruker HW500 MHz spectrometer (AVANCE AV-500) and recorded in CDCl3 (internal reference 7.26 ppm). The enantiomeric excess (ee) values were analyzed by Waters 1525 High-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) with chiral columns. A UV lamp (20 mW cm−2, λ = 365 nm; LP-40A; LUYOR Corporation) was used to irradiate the samples to perform the photo-crosslinking reactions.
For preparing magnetic stir bar-encapsulated polysiloxane-based organocatalyst gels, efficient crosslinkage based on the design of crosslinker and crosslinking ratio plays a crucial role in building a stable polymeric network. Based on our previous experiments, commercial PMMS are short oligomers with an estimated degree of polymerization (D.P.) around 30.27,28 Thus, in order to form a stable cross-linked PMMS gel, the molar percentage of the crosslinking sites should be at least higher than 7–8 mol% and herein we set 15 mol% as a constant crosslinking ratio for all the experiments. Three crosslinkers, triallyl cyanurate (L1, TAC), 1,6-hexanediol diacrylate (L2), poly(ethylene glycol)diacrylate (L3, average Mn ∼700) were tested in the experiments respectively. In comparison, although all three crosslinkers could be successfully used to synthesize polysiloxane gels, the gels containing a much longer and flexible crosslinker, poly(ethylene glycol)diacrylate are more elastic and stable than other brittle gels prepared by triallyl cyanurate or 1,6-hexanediol diacrylate crosslinkers.
As shown in Fig. 2, before UV illumination, we first dissolved an organocatalyst into a small amount of methylene chloride which was then mixed with PMMS, photoinitiator and crosslinker to form an oily liquid. The mixture was then poured into a vial containing a magnetic stir bar. Herein, we chose a soft plastic container (PE pipette head, Fig. 2A) in stead of glass vials, because compared with scissor-cut plastic pieces, shattered glass would easily damage the prepared gels in the last step. After UV illumination, the oily liquid became a crosslinked gel (Fig. 2D), which was cut out of the plastic vial and immersed in dry methylene chloride several times to wash out unreacted small molecules. The desired magnetic stir bar-encapsulated polysiloxane-based organocatalyst gel was prepared. However, our prototype manufacturing system has two technique problems: (1) magnetic stir bars are randomly embedded in PMMS gels and we can not precisely arrange the locations and postures of stir bars placed in the gels. Thus, the prepared organocatalyst gels will have physically vulnerable points where the stir bars touch on the walls of plastic container, and this imperfectness results in a moderate stirring effect (see the stirring movie, SI1.avi†). (2) The organocatalyst gels are partially crosslinked and would be better to be stored in organic solvents to maintain elasticity. For example, we have tried to remove all the solvent from the gels via vacuum, which unfortunately caused the spontaneous fission of gels.
Although some flaws exist in our prototype products at present, future industrial manufacturing can be expected to realize technique improvements. Herein, we prepared three magnetic-stir-bar-encapsulated organocatalyst gels, PMMS-g-C1L3, PMMS-g-C2L3 and PMMS-g-C3L3, which were used in catalyzing asymmetric Diels–Alder reaction, asymmetric aldol reaction and benzoin condensation reaction respectively.
The imidazolidinone compound developed by MacMillan,29 might be the most famous organocatalyst which has been widely used in a variety of organocatalytic processes and has been unsurprisingly immobilized on different polymeric supports.24,25,30–34 Polysiloxane gel catalyst, PMMS-g-C1L3 bearing MacMillan imidazolidinone was applied to promote a classical asymmetric Diels–Alder reaction of cyclopentadiene and cinnamic aldehyde.
As shown in Table 1, roughly 50%:
50% mixture of endo and exo cycloadducts (determined by 1H NMR analysis of crude products) were isolated in all the experimental trials. To convert the grafted imidazolidinone C1 to the catalytically active intermediate, an equimolar amount of a Bronsted acid is required to protonate the supported organocatalyst. Traditionally, HBF4 has been proven to be a very efficient acid in this reaction system,24 however in our case, this choice provided negative results (entry 1), possibly due to the strong lewis acidity and F− ion of HBF4 which might be able to destroy C–S–C and Si–O bonds. The alternative use of trifluoroacetic acid in acetonitrile/water (95/5) solvent provided an optimal 88% yield with moderate endo (96%) and exo (78%) ee values (entry 3). The recovered PMMS-g-C1L3 gel was recycled five times to test the catalytic performances. As can be seen from the reported data (entry 4–8), the conversion efficiency and catalyst stereoselectivity were maintained at around 70% reaction yield and 77% ee, although slightly lower than the first trial's result. Nonetheless, PMMS-g-C1L3 gel can be conveniently employed to catalyze asymmetric Diels–Alder cycloadditions.
Entrya | Recycle number | Acid | Solvent | Yieldb (%) | Exo/endoc (%) | Exo ee (endo ee)d (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Reactions were carried out using cinnamic aldehyde (1 equiv.) and cyclopentadiene (5 equiv.) at 0 °C for 24 h.b Isolated yield.c Determined by crude NMR.d Determined by chiral HPLC. | ||||||
1 | 0 | HBF4 | CH3CN/H2O (95/5) | 0 | — | — |
2 | 0 | TFA | MeOH/H2O (95/5) | 52 | 51/49 | 66 (83) |
3 | 0 | TFA | CH3CN/H2O (95/5) | 88 | 51/49 | 78 (96) |
4 | 1 | TFA | CH3CN/H2O (95/5) | 73 | 55/45 | 77 (77) |
5 | 2 | TFA | CH3CN/H2O (95/5) | 66 | 53/47 | 78 (79) |
6 | 3 | TFA | CH3CN/H2O (95/5) | 74 | 51/49 | 74 (77) |
7 | 4 | TFA | CH3CN/H2O (95/5) | 72 | 51/49 | 73 (72) |
8 | 5 | TFA | CH3CN/H2O (95/5) | 64 | 54/46 | 70 (79) |
Polymer-supported L-proline represents another very important class of organocatalysts for C–C bond constructions such as asymmetric aldol reaction.25,35–46 Following literature protocols, we tested the catalytic performance of polysiloxane gel PMMS-g-C2L3 applied in a classical enantioselective aldol reaction of 4-nitrobenzaldehyde and cyclohexanone. As illustrated in Table 2, solvent plays a crucial role in enantioselective property. The reaction carried out in methanol/H2O (1/1, v/v) system provided moderate yields and low ee (34–38%), while using pure water solution resulted in high conversion (>80%) and high ee values (96–99%). Unlike traditional homogeneous reactions which would have a significant decrease in both stereo- and enantioselectivity along with raising reaction temperature,47–50 our PMMS-g-C2L3 catalyst gel slightly favors higher temperature possibly due to the hydrophobicity of polysiloxanes expelling water from catalytic centers to stabilize the transition state of forming enamine species by excluding competitive hydrogen bonding with water. This phenomena is consistent with Monteiro's observation.46
Entrya | Recycle number | Solvent | Temperature (°C) | Yieldc (%) | Anti/synd (%) | Anti eee (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Reactions were carried out using 4-nitrobenzaldehyde (1 equiv.) and cyclohexanone (7 equiv.) for 48 h.b Catalyst: PMMS-g-C2L2.c Isolated yield.d Determined by chiral HPLC.e Determined by chiral HPLC. | ||||||
1 | 0 | MeOH/H2O (1/1) | 25 | 68 | 89/11 | 38 |
2 | 0 | MeOH/H2O (1/1) | 50 | 65 | 92/8 | 34 |
3 | 0 | H2O | 25 | 80 | 88/12 | 90 |
4b | 0 | H2O | 50 | 82 | 88/12 | 96 |
5 | 0 | H2O | 50 | 85 | 90/10 | 99 |
6 | 1 | H2O | 50 | 87 | 86/14 | 91 |
7 | 2 | H2O | 50 | 76 | 90/10 | 72 |
8 | 3 | H2O | 50 | 75 | 81/19 | 60 |
9 | 4 | H2O | 50 | 69 | 85/15 | 24 |
10 | 5 | H2O | 50 | 73 | 56/44 | 22 |
The recovered PMMS-g-C2L3 gel was reused five times to test the recyclability of catalyzing the asymmetric aldol reaction. As shown in Table 2, the first two runs provided satisfying reaction yields and high ee values (entry 5–6), however the enantioselectivity decreased dramatically starting from the third recycle (entry 7–10). Besides the lack of exploration in optimal reaction conditions, one possible reason might be that since the recovered PMMS-g-C2L3 gel was always kept in solvents to avoid gel fission, some leftover chemicals might “poison” or racemize the grafted L-proline catalyst.
Incorporating imidazolium salts into the polymer backbones or side chains has been proven to be an efficient way to develop recyclable polymeric NHC catalysts.26,51–58 Inspired from Cowley's work,26 we designed and synthesized an imidazolium monomer C3, and grafted it onto crosslinked PMMS gels. With PMMS-g-C3L3 catalyst in hand, we examined its ability of catalyzing a typical benzoin condensation reaction.
As shown in Table 3, the solvent effects were first investigated and we found that DMSO could provide a moderate reaction yield as well as a small amount of benzil product due to the mildly oxidative reaction environment. However, poor recyclability with lower yields (entry 4–8) was observed after the first run, which might arise from the catalyst regeneration step. To regenerate the imidazolium salt from reactive carbene intermediate, a solution of 4.0 M HCl in 1,4-dioxane was used to immerse-wash the recovered PMMS-g-C3L3 gel. Due to the hydrophobicity of polysiloxanes, only the externally grafted imidazolium monomer C3 could be possibly regenerated, which might cause the obvious loss of catalytic performances.
Entrya | Recycle number | Solvent | Yieldb of benzoin product (%) | Yieldb of benzil product (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|
a Reactions were carried out using dry DMSO and DBU (15 mol%) at r.t. under N2 for 48 h.b Isolated yield. | ||||
1 | 0 | H2O | Trace | 0 |
2 | 0 | DMF | 58 | 7 |
3 | 0 | DMSO | 63 | 5 |
4 | 1 | DMSO | 54 | 9 |
5 | 2 | DMSO | 47 | 7 |
6 | 3 | DMSO | 32 | 6 |
7 | 4 | DMSO | 35 | 4 |
8 | 5 | DMSO | 32 | 5 |
Incorporating magnetic stir bars into crosslinked PMMS gels can provide the corresponding organocatalyst gels an ability to perform stirring and catalysis functions at the same time (SBEC technique). The most important benefit of this technique is to infinitely simplify the catalyst/product separation procedure to using a simple stir-bar-retriever, even without any precipitation/filtration steps. Although our organocatalyst gels are prototype products bearing several technique problems and the catalytic performances are modest, we hope this “proof-of-idea” work would open interesting perspectives and bring some useful information for heterogeneous catalysis community.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c4ra16351f |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |