Xue Gong,
Wenjiao Zhou,
Yaqin Chai,
Yun Xiang* and
Ruo Yuan
Key Laboratory of Luminescent and Real-Time Analytical Chemistry, Ministry of Education, School of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, Southwest University, Chongqing 400715, PR China. E-mail: yunatswu@swu.edu.cn; Fax: +86-23-68252277; Tel: +86-23-68252277
First published on 12th December 2014
Small molecule/protein interactions have a key role in drug discovery, clinic diagnosis and protein–metabolite interactions in biology. By using the specific interaction between folic acid (FA) and folate receptor (FR) as a model, the development of a label-free and sensitive colorimetric approach for the detection of the FR biomarker is described. The sensing approach relies on the coupling of the FR-induced terminal protection of FA-linked ssDNA strategy with significant signal amplification by self-assembled DNAzyme polymers. The FR binds to the FA-ssDNA and protects the FR/FA-ssDNA from digesting by exonuclease I. The terminal protected ssDNA further triggers autonomous self-assembly of two G-quadruplex sequence-containing hairpin DNAs into DNAzyme polymers, which result in intensified color change of the probe solution for label-free and highly sensitive colorimetric detection of FR. The terminal protection mechanism and the self-assembly formation of the DNAzyme polymers are characterized by using polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, and the sensing parameters are optimized as well. Under optimal experimental conditions, the detection limit of 0.35 pM for FR can be obtained by using a UV-Vis spectrophotometer and the presence of as low as 5 pM of FR can be directly visualized by the naked eye. The developed method is also selective and can be applied to detect FR in serum samples, which makes this approach a sensitive platform for sensing different types of small molecule/protein interactions.
The terminal protection of small molecule-linked DNA reported by the Jiang group14 has emerged as an ideal approach for detecting interactions between small molecules and their protein receptors. The assay mechanism was based on the employment of small molecule-tethered DNA as probes to bind to the target proteins through small molecule/protein interactions, which prevented the ssDNA from digesting by exonuclease I (Exo I) and generated electrochemical current responses for detecting the target proteins. The ssDNA involved in the assay protocol can not only offer the capability of selective capture of the target proteins but also provide versatile subsequent signal amplification means for achieving high sensitivity due to the nucleic acid nature of the ssDNA. By following this terminal protection mechanism, a number of methods for protein detections have been recently reported in connection with various electrochemical15,16 and fluorescent17–19 signal transduction techniques. Despite these advances, the development of simple, sensitive, homogeneous and label-free approaches for the detection of small molecule/protein interactions has been rarely reported. The electrochemical methods for the detection of small molecule/protein interactions commonly require the immobilization of the ssDNA on the electrode surface, while the fluorescent approaches involve the conjugation of the fluorescent tags, which potentially increase the complexity and cost for the assay methods. Therefore, the exploration of a label-free and sensitive approach without using any complex instrument will facilitate the monitoring of small molecule/protein interactions.
Colorimetric detections have gained increasing attention due to the extreme simplicity, low cost and especially the macroscopically observable characteristics when encountering the target analyte.20,21 Gold Nanoparticles (AuNPs), with unique optical properties associated with their surface plasmon resonance and high extinction coefficients, are perfectly suitable for colorimetric assays.22,23 However, the AuNP-based colorimetric assays are limited by their compromised sensitivities,24,25 time consuming (about 20–48 h for nanoparticles preparation and probe-conjugation)26 procedures and susceptibility to sensing environments with false positive signals (ionic strength, temperature, etc.).27,28 With regards to these challenges in AuNP-based colorimetric detection approaches, a new class of functional nucleic acid probes, the peroxidase mimicking DNAzymes, have been increasingly used recently. The DNAzyme contains a complex of hemin and a single-stranded guanine-rich nucleic acid (G-quadruplex), which can catalyze H2O2-mediated oxidization of 2,2-azinobis(3-ethylbenzothiozoline)-6-sulfonic acid (ABTS) to generate a blue-green colored product, ABTS˙− (λmax = 421 nm).29,30 This class of DNAzymes offers significant advantages, including easy synthesis, thermal stability, and has been extensively used as biocatalytic labels in amplified biosensing of proteins,31 metal ions32 and small molecules.33
Herein, based on terminal protection of small molecule-linked ssDNA and significant signal amplification by self-assembled hemin/G-quadruplex DNAzyme polymers, we report on a label-free, homogenous and highly sensitive colorimetric platform for the detection of folate receptor (FR), a biomarker associated with numerous malignancies, including myelogenous leukemias, ovarian, lung, kidney and breast cancers.34–36 The association of FR with the folic acid (FA)-linked ssDNA prevents the ssDNA from digesting by Exo I, and the protected ssDNA triggers the hybridization chain reaction (HCR) self-assembly formation of numerous DNAzymes, which catalyze the conversion of colorless ABTS to green colored ABTS˙− and lead to significant color change of the probe solution for colorimetric detection of FR down to the sub-picomolar level.
![]() | ||
Scheme 1 Illustration of the label-free and sensitive colorimetric detection of FR based on the terminal protection strategy and self-assembly of hemin/G-quadruplex DNAzyme polymers. |
The FR-induced terminal protection and HCR formation of the DNA polymers were first verified by native PAGE (16% gel). As shown in Fig. 1A, the FA-ssDNA (2 μM) alone exhibits a clear band (lane a), and the incubation of FA-ssDNA with FR (1 μM) leads to the appearance of a new band with lower electrophoretic mobility (lane b), indicating the successfully association of FR with the FA moieties of the FA-ssDNA. Subsequent addition of Exo I (20 U) to the mixture of FR and FA-ssDNA results in the disappearance of the band corresponding to the FA-ssDNA (lane c vs. b), which suggests the digestion of the un-protected FA-ssDNA by Exo I. After the deactivation of Exo I and further incubation of the mixture with H1 (5 μM) and H2 (5 μM), bands with various electrophoretic mobility, which correspond to the characteristic bands of HCR,40 are observed, suggesting the self-assembly formation of the DNA polymers triggered by the FR-protected ssDNA. The proof-of-concept application of this strategy for amplified colorimetric detection of FR was also evaluated. According to Fig. 1B, the mixture of H1 and H2 exhibits minimal UV-Vis absorption (curve a) with the addition of hemin and subsequent incubation with ABTS and H2O2 because the G-quadruplex-forming sequences are initially locked in the stems of the hairpin DNAs. The incubation of FA-ssDNA (0.5 μM) with Exo I (20 U) in the absence of FR, followed by further incubation with H1 (2 μM) and H2 (2 μM), shows slight increase in UV-Vis absorption (curve b vs. a) compared with that of the mixture of H1 and H2, indicating that the FA-ssDNA is digested by Exo I and is unable to trigger HCR between H1 and H2. However, when FR (30 pM) is first incubated with FA-ssDNA, followed by further incubation with Exo I, deactivation of Exo I and the addition of H1 and H2, significant increase in UV-Vis absorption is observed (curve c vs. b). Such increase is basically due to the formation of numerous DNAzymes by self-assembly of H1 and H2 with the FR-protected ssDNA as discussed previously. The results here clearly demonstrate that the binding of FR to the FA-ssDNA can protect the FA-ssDNA from digesting by Exo I and the protected ssDNA can trigger HCR amplification to substantially intensify the color change of the probe solution for sensitive detection of FR.
In order to achieve optimal analytical performance, the effects of the amount of Exo I and Exo I-catalyzed digestion time on the UV-Vis absorption of the probe solutions were investigated. The amount of Exo I was optimized within the range of 2–14 U. As shown in Fig. 2A, by incubating the FA-ssDNA probes (0.5 μM) with different amounts of Exo I at 37 °C for 40 min, the UV-Vis absorption intensity of the solution gradually decreases with increasing amount of Exo I until 10 U and then reaches a plateau. Therefore, 10 U was selected as the optimized amount of Exo I. The effect of Exo I digestion time was investigated by monitoring the UV-Vis absorption of the solution in the absence of FR. From Fig. 2B, we can see that the absorption intensity decreases rapidly with the augment of the digestion time and there is no significant decrease after 30 min, indicating complete digestion of FA-ssDNA by Exo I. The Exo I digestion time was thus fixed at 30 min for subsequent experiments.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Effects of (A) the amount of Exo I and (B) Exo I cleavage time on the UV-Vis absorption intensity of the FA-ssDNA probe solution. Error bars, SD, n = 3. |
Under optimal conditions, the application of the proposed terminal protection strategy for quantitative detection of FR was evaluated. From Fig. 3A, we can clearly see that the presence of FR from 0 to 100 pM results in gradual increase of the UV-Vis absorption and the intensity at 421 nm exhibits a linear correlation to the corresponding concentration of FR with a coefficient of correlation of 0.998. According to the calibration plot in the inset of Fig. 3A, the detection limit for FR is calculated to be 0.35 pM based on the standard 3σ rule. As shown in Fig. 3B, it is clear that the color change of the probe solution is gradually intensified with increasing concentration of FR from 0 to 100 pM by naked eye, which is consistent with the UV-Vis absorption in Fig. 3A. Compared with the blank test (Fig. 3B, b vs. a), as low as 5 pM of FR can be directly visualized by naked eye. Such visual detection limit for FR is comparable to those methods based on electrochemical41 or fluorescent transduction strategies,42 which further demonstrates the significant signal amplification capability of the developed method. The dramatic signal amplification is closely related to the design of the hairpin DNAs, in which each hairpin DNA (H1 or H2) contains one locked G-quadruplex-forming sequence, and after HCR, the amount of the DNAzymes is significantly enhanced compared to other common approach for HCR formation of the DNAzymes.43
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 (A) Typical UV-Vis absorption spectra of the colorimetric method for the detection of different concentrations of FR. From bottom to top: 0, 1, 5, 10, 25, 50, 75, 100 pM. Inset: the corresponding calibration plot of the concentration of the FR vs. the absorbance intensity. Error bars: SD, n = 3. The amount of Exo I (10 U); 30 min incubation time for Exo I. Other conditions, as in Fig. 1B. (B) Photograph for visual detection of FR at different concentrations: (a) 0, (b) 5, (c) 10, (d) 25, (e) 50, (f) 75 and (g) 100 pM. |
The specificity of the proposed method for FR detection was investigated by comparing the color change of the probe solution with the presence of the target FR against other control proteins, including BSA, SA, and IgG. Based on the results shown in Fig. 4, the presence of the control proteins (each at the concentration of 50 pM) causes negligible color changes compared with the blank test, while the addition of the target FR (50 pM) leads to clear color change, indicating the high selectivity of the method. This further reveals that the control proteins are unable to interact with FA-ssDNA and to prevent FA-ssDNA from digesting by Exo I, leading to negligible color changes of the probe solutions.
To check the potential applicability of the proposed method for the monitoring of FR in real samples, recovery tests for FR in diluted human serum samples (10%) with the standard addition approach were performed. According to the results list in Table 1, the recoveries for the added FR fall in the range from 94% to 103%, indicating that the developed method is suitable for real samples.
Samples | Added FR (pM) | Found FR (mean ± RSD, pM) | Recovery (%) |
---|---|---|---|
1 | 5 | 4.7 ± 0.61 | 94 |
2 | 20 | 19.5 ± 1.6 | 97.5 |
3 | 50 | 50.9 ± 1.9 | 101 |
4 | 75 | 77.5 ± 3.5 | 103 |
In summary, we have shown that the coupling of terminal protection of FA-ssDNA with HCR amplification formation of the DNAzyme polymers can lead to label-free and highly sensitive colorimetric detection of FR. The association of FR with FA-ssDNA protects FA-ssDNA from digesting by Exo I, and the protected ssDNA further triggers the self-assembly of G-quadruplex sequence-containing hairpin DNAs to form DNAzyme polymers, which cause significantly intensified color change of the probe solution to achieve highly sensitive detection of FR down to 5 pM with naked eye. Besides, without the involvement complex instruments, our approach for protein biomarker detection is cost-effective. Moreover, the developed sensing method is also selective against the control proteins. With these advantages, the reported approach can be easily expanded for label-free and sensitive detection of different types of small molecule/protein interactions by changing the corresponding affinity pairs (e.g., biotin/streptavidin), which provides new alternatives for early diagnosis of cancers and drug developments.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |