Egipto Antunes,
Célia F. Cruz,
Nuno G. Azoia and
Artur Cavaco-Paulo*
CEB – Centre of Biological Engineering, University of Minho, 4710-057 Braga, Portugal. E-mail: artur@deb.uminho.pt
First published on 15th January 2015
The study of the interaction between hair filaments and formulations or peptides is of utmost importance in fields like cosmetic research. Keratin intermediate filament structure is not fully described, limiting the molecular dynamics (MD) studies in this field despite its high potential to improve the area. We developed a computational model of a truncated protofibril, simulated its behavior in alcoholic based formulations and with one peptide. The simulations showed a strong interaction between the benzyl alcohol molecules of the formulations and the model, leading to the disorganization of the keratin chains, which regress with the removal of the alcohol molecules. This behavior can explain the increase of peptide uptake in hair shafts evidenced in fluorescence microscopy pictures. The model developed is valid to computationally reproduce the interaction between hair and alcoholic formulations and provide a robust base for new MD studies about hair properties. It is shown that the MD simulations can improve hair cosmetic research, improving the uptake of a compound of interest.
The hair fiber is usually divided into three zones: the cuticle (outermost zone, Fig. 1G), the cortex (surrounded by the cuticle), and in the center zone of thicker hairs, the medulla (Fig. 1F). The cuticle corresponds to a stratified layer of thin and flat overlapping cells, like fish scales, and acts as a chemical and physical barrier, protecting the inner zones. The medulla is constituted by hollow cells with amorphous material and air spaces.1
The cortex has long, cylindrical assembled cortical cells surrounded by the cell membrane complex (Fig. 1A). Macrofibrils (Fig. 1B) and intermacrofibrilar material composes the cortical cells. The macrofibrils can be further divided into microfibrils (Fig. 1D) and a surrounding matrix (Fig. 1C) composed of associated proteins, cytoplasmatic and nuclear remains of keratinocytes. The microfibrils are also known as intermediate filaments, and are composed of 4 protofibrils (Fig. 1E), which have 2 protofilaments, each one with two dimers of α-helix coiled-coil keratins. Fig. 1 illustrates the hierarchical structure of the hair fiber.
In the intermediate filaments assembly, the α-helix coiled-coil dimer of keratin is made with one keratin of type I (acidic keratins) and one of type II (basic or neutral keratins), forming a heterodimer, since this assembly is much more stable than a homodimer.2 Each α-keratin has four coiled-coil domains (denominated as 1A, 1B, 2A and 2B), three linker domains (L1, L12, and L2), and the head and tail terminal domains. This structure is shared with all intermediate filaments such as vimentin, desmin and lamins, and is represented in Fig. 2.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Top: Representation of one vimentin intermediate filament dimer, with its domains discriminated. Bottom: Representation of three models of intermediary filaments dimers pairing. The pictures were rendered using the structure obtained by Zhao Qin and colleagues.3 |
The assembly of the keratin dimer is made by pairing each domain of one α-keratin with the same domain of the adjacent α-keratin (see Fig. 2 Top), while the assembly of one protofilament (two dimers) is anti-parallel. It is not completely clear how the protofilament assembly is made, and there are three main modes of pairing described, namely the A11, A12 and the A22 (see Fig. 2).4 The A11 mode is defined by the antiparallel overlap of 1B segments, the A22 mode by the antiparallel overlap of 2B segments and the A12 mode by the antiparallel overlap of intermediate filaments dimers. The higher assemblies in octamers (protofibrils), micro and macrofibrils of the IFs, are not fully characterized, at the molecular level, mainly in the hair IFs. The few literature about this thematic, incised more in the vimentin IFs due the existence of crystallographic models for these filaments, or in the skin keratins due to the skin diseases that affect many humans,5–8 however these filaments are different from hair IFs.
There are 54 elements of the human keratin family (skin and hair keratins), 28 of type I and 26 of type II. It was found that keratin 31, 33a, 34, 38b, 81, 85 and 86 are the most abundant keratins in the hair9 and, for example, keratin 31 is mostly expressed in lower and mid cortex, while keratins 34 and 86 are mostly expressed in mid and upper cortex.10–12 It seems that the pairing of the protofilament is not predefined in terms of the keratins elements, allowing competition between the keratins and different pairs can be found.12
Molecular dynamics (MD) has been applied with success in the study of complex biomaterials, providing unique and detailed molecular information inaccessible by others techniques. The systems studied by MD are increasing in number, diversity and complexity, from single proteins in water,13 to cell membranes14,15 or even stratum corneum.16–18
Despite all potential of MD simulations, this technique has only been applied in the study of hair in a few works.19–22 The MD has a great potential to boost some aspects in the hair products development research, speeding up the process while saving resources and money. Previously our group studied the affinity between fragments of pulmonary associated surfactant protein D (SPD) and α-keratin, in formulations containing benzyl alcohol, propylene glycol and ethanol.19 SPD is a surfactant protein synthesized in the lung and due to the ability of these kind of peptides to interact with hair lipids they have been study as helper agents in the recovery of damaged hair.19,23,24 Here we are extending the scope of this previous work by building a bigger computational model of a hair and changing formulations composition. The new model describe a truncated protofibril (8 keratins), assembling the 2B domains of keratin 34 and keratin 86, as a simplified model of one hair shaft. This model was subject to several MD simulations with different formulations. The SPD fragment chosen was the one with less affinity to keratin in the previous work, to facilitate the evaluation of differences in peptide affinity due to the formulations. The simulations results were compared with experimental tests performed with real hair. We intent to show that the affinity of peptides can be increased by formulations composition and that this property, together with the stronger interactions of the formulations with the hair, can be assessed by MD simulations.
In all simulations the procedure was the same, namely we begun with the energy minimization of the systems for 500 steps with steepest descent method. Then the systems were subject to a short simulation (3 ns), in the canonical ensemble or NVT (number of molecules, volume and temperature constants), to relax the structures and generate velocities according to a temperature of 300 K. The production simulations were performed with the isothermal–isobaric ensemble or NPT (number of molecules, pressure and temperature constants), with simulation times ranging from 65 to 510 ns. Berendsen coupling was used to maintain the temperature at 300 K with a relaxation time of 0.7 ps, and also a Berendsen coupling to maintain the pressure at 1 atm, with a time constant of 3 ps and a compressibility of 3 × 10−5 bar−1.30 The simulation box was dodecahedric, the integration time step of 30 fs and the Lincs algorithm was used as bond constrainer.31 To the non-bonded interactions, cut offs and shifts at 12 Å were applied, with a decrease of the van der Waals forces between 9 and 12 Å, and a decrease of electrostatic forces throughout the whole interaction distance.
The concentration of benzyl alcohol ranged between 0.5 and 3% (v/v), since the benzyl alcohol solubility limit in water is 3.5 g/100 mL at 20 °C and 4.29 g mL−1 at 25 °C, and solutions with 4% of this alcohol present some turbidity (see Fig. 3 and 4 in ESI† material).
The behavior of the hair model in the formulations was simulated for 510 ns, with the same protocol described above. After the simulations the systems evolution and the final structure of the protofibrils were evaluated either visually or statistically, measuring properties such as the radial distribution function (RDF), the root mean square deviation (RMSD), the radius of gyration (RG) and the solvent accessible surface area (SAS).
Besides the experimental tests, described in the next section, we also assess the effect of BE3, and B3 formulations in the interaction of one SPD fragment (QAAFSQ) with the hair through MD. This peptide corresponds to a small fragment of a glycoprotein synthesized by alveolar type II cells and by non-ciliated bronchiolar epithelial cells35 and was chosen because the previous work had demonstrated low affinity with keratin dimer. Thus it is expected that the increase of affinity of this peptide with hair will be easier to demonstrate. We create one system for each formulation, with 4 replicas each, containing the hair model and 6 peptides. The behavior of the systems was simulated for 510 ns, and in the end the formulations were removed from the simulation box, water was added and the behavior of the aqueous systems was simulated for another 510 ns.
We also performed some preparatory simulations of the protofibril and the BE3 formulation using the gromos 43A1-S3 force field36 with the same methodology of the coarse grained simulations This united atom force field provides atomic detail to the system however turns the system huge and more computing demanding. The results of these simulations were similar to the coarse grained simulations (see ESI† material, Fig. 5), but we only obtained computing performances of 0.4 ns/24 h against 50 ns/24 h in the coarse grained simulations. Once the lack of atomic detail seems do not affect the properties studied in the coarse grained simulations (the results of united atoms and coarse grained simulations are similar), and these simulations are much less computing demanding (allowing simulate longer time scales), we advance in the work with only the coarse grained simulations.
Afterwards, the different formulations, whose compositions are described in Table 1 were tested in the bleached hair fibers.
Label | Benzyl alcohol | Ethanol | Propylene glycol |
---|---|---|---|
Vol (%) | |||
OF | 0.5 | 10 | 1.5 |
BE0.5 | 0.5 | 10 | 0 |
BE1 | 1 | 10 | 0 |
BE1.5 | 1.5 | 10 | 0 |
BE2 | 2 | 10 | 0 |
BE2.5 | 2.5 | 10 | 0 |
BE3 | 3 | 10 | 0 |
B1.5 | 1.5 | 0 | 0 |
B2 | 2 | 0 | 0 |
B2.5 | 2.5 | 0 | 0 |
B3 | 3 | 0 | 0 |
In order to ease the analysis of the formulation effect, we use the engineered SPD fragment covalently linked, in the N-terminus, to the fluorescent dye 5(6)-carboxytetramethylrhodamine, succinimidyl ester (or 5-TAMRA). This peptide was synthesized by JPT Peptide Technologies GmbH (Berlin, Germany). After treatment cross sections of the hair fibers samples were analyzed by fluorescence microscopy. The hair fibers were initially embedded in an epoxy resin and 15 mm transversal cuts were obtained using a microtome (Leitz). The samples were analyzed using an inverted fluorescence microscope Leica DMIL at a magnification 20×. The most representative images were chosen.
We joined 4 dimers of truncated keratin 34-keratin 86 chains (from the L2 link to C tail) and simulate its assembling in water, to build a truncated protofibril model (see ESI† file for more information). The assembled keratinaceous octamer in the end of these simulations presented structural properties similar to the literature description of the intermediate filaments. Since the precise determination of protofibril atomic structure is out of the scope of this work, we move ahead for the interaction simulations.
The time evolution of the system BE4 is depicted in the Fig. 3. It is clear the destabilization of the fiber, which is promoted by the formulation, since the initial protofibril structure is stable in water. It is also clear the tendency of the benzyl alcohol molecules to be located near the hair model, interacting with its keratins. Both effects are also evident in all other systems, with and without ethanol, and the destabilization seems to increase with the benzyl alcohol concentration (see Fig. 1 and 2 in ESI†).
The RDF analysis confirms the benzyl alcohol tendency to be located near the hair model. This analysis defines the ratio between the local and average concentration of the target molecules, at a given distance. The value 1 indicates a random distribution of the molecules, and higher values indicate a tendency of the molecules to be located at such distance. The RDF analysis of systems BE2 and B2 is presented in the Fig. 4. All the other systems presented similar RDF distribution pattern.
It is clear that the RDFs values for benzyl alcohol molecules are very high at small distances, with some initial peaks corresponding to solvation layers, decreasing for bigger distances. For higher distances the RDF values are lower than 1, confirming that the benzyl alcohol molecules tend to be located near to the hair, as it was shown in Fig. 3. The ethanol and water behavior are remarkably distinct to benzyl alcohol, while similar to each other; the RDFs values in both cases are lower than 1, increasing towards this value as the distance increase. The absence of ethanol does not change the RDF behavior of both water and benzyl alcohol.
The degree of destabilization observed in the simulations appears to increase with the concentration of the benzyl alcohol in the systems. However it is hard to visually evaluate the differences between systems with lower variation of benzyl alcohol concentration, problem that is overcome by the structural analysis of the hair model in the system.
The RMSD indicates the spatial deviation of the hair structure from its starting conformation. The average values from the final 110 ns of simulation in the different systems are presented in the Table 2.
RMSD (nm) | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
BE0.5 | BE1 | BE1.5 | BE2 | BE2.5 | BE3 |
0.83 ± 0.04 | 1.03 ± 0.03 | 1.10 ± 0.04 | 1.25 ± 0.03 | 1.26 ± 0.02 | 1.19 ± 0.04 |
B1.5 | B2 | B2.5 | B3 | ||
0.98 ± 0.02 | 1.30 ± 0.04 | 1.19 ± 0.03 | 1.15 ± 0.03 |
The systems presented an overall increase of RMSD values with the increase of benzyl alcohol content, and there are no significant differences between the systems with or without ethanol. The RMSD values show a substantial spatial deviation of the protofibril initial structure, which seems to be linked to the benzyl alcohol concentration. However the evaluation of RMSD values cannot be directly linked to the destabilization observed in the simulations because movements like torsions, rotations, and stretching also contribute to the RMSD values but do not lead to the lateral dissociation observed in the simulations.
To better understand the effect of the formulations in the stability of the hair model, the RG and SAS values were evaluated. These values are presented in the Fig. 5. The SAS analysis provides information about the area of the hair model that is accessible to the solvent, being related with the hair model destabilization because the lateral dissociation of the keratins increases the area of the proteinaceous material accessible to the solvent. On the other hand, in MD studies, the RG measures the compaction of the structure of proteins. We measured the RG relative to the transversal axis of the cylindrical protofibril, and the values were normalized, which allows the evaluation of the lateral disassembling of the keratins chains since it follows this axis.
The RG and SAS values showed a global tendency to increase with the increase of benzyl alcohol concentration. As in the RMSD analysis, are bigger the differences between the RG and SAS values in the lower and higher benzyl alcohol concentration than between the RG and SAS values in formulations with or without ethanol.
The fluorescence microscopy pictures in the Fig. 5 clearly showed an increase of fluorescence in the hair. The pictures showed one interesting feature – the hair treated with formulations containing ethanol presented much lower fluorescence in the inner zones of hair cortex. At this point it is clear that the formulations composition will affect the stability of the keratins assembly in the hair shaft, and that this destabilization is able to ease the penetration of the peptide into the hair. In order to evaluate, at a molecular level, the interaction of the peptide with the hair model some simulations were performed. Some snapshots of the evolution of one system composed by the hair model and 6 SPD fragments, during 1020 ns, are presented in Fig. 6. In the first half of the simulation the proteinaceous material was dissolved in the BE3 formulation and the second half only in water.
Once again the formulations promote the destabilization of the keratin assembly, allowing the penetration of the peptide into the interior of the fiber. Nonetheless the interaction of the peptide with the keratins is not very strong while the formulation is present, but when the formulations are removed, what is equivalent to washing the hair after the incubation with the formulations, the peptide stays attached to the fiber. What seems to be clear is that the formulations do not increase the affinity of the peptide towards the hair. Instead, the formulations are able to facilitate the penetration of the peptide into the fiber, increasing the amount of peptide that penetrates the fiber and interacts with the keratins. This behavior is in agreement with the fluorescence pictures, showing how the peptide can be absorbed by the hair. The same simulations were made for the formulations B3 (results not showed), and the behavior was similar, the lateral expansion of the keratins in hair model was bigger when the formulations do not contain ethanol, and this can be the cause of the difference in fluorescence patterns showed in the microscopy studies. Bigger expansions can lead to more peptide being trapped in the hair fibers, while allowing the peptide to penetrate deeper into the hair shaft.
The small solubility range of benzyl alcohol in aqueous solutions limited the number of different formulations is this work. This is a limitation of the experimental procedure, were we are using aqueous solutions to mimic cosmetic formulations. We also made simulations with higher concentration of benzyl alcohol (see ESI Fig. 1 and 2†), that were excluded from the work because the impossibility to compare with fluoresce tests, due to the solubility problems. However, in the cosmetic field the formulations used in commercial products are not solutions, but are instead gels, lotions, shampoos, among others, where the concentration of benzyl alcohol could be higher than its solubility in water. With the simulations it is possible to overcome solubility problems like this one, turning the screening of new formulations easier than in other models, like the ones using aqueous solutions.
With the MD simulations we were able to select formulations with better performance in the enhancement of peptide absorption by the hair. But the hair model built allows the study of many other features and phenomena, as long as its inherent peculiarities are taken into account. This can be of great interest to researchers in fields of applied research, such as cosmetic applications, to fundamental research.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Details about the keratin protofibril model built, pictures of the time evolution of the systems in the interactions simulations, and information about the benzyl alcohol parametrization are described in this file. See DOI: 10.1039/c4ra13901a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |