Ichiro Tanabe*,
Takayuki Ryoki and
Yukihiro Ozaki*
Department of Chemistry, School of Science and Technology, Kwansei Gakuin University, Gakuen 2-1, Sanda, Hyogo, Japan. E-mail: i-tanabe@kwansei.ac.jp; ozaki@kwansei.ac.jp
First published on 19th January 2015
Absorption spectra of anatase and rutile TiO2 modified with various sizes of Au nanospheres (5–60 nm) in the 150–300 nm region were measured by using attenuated total reflection spectroscopy. The smaller Au nanospheres induced larger spectral changes, which mean larger electronic state changes and higher charge-separation efficiency enhancements. In fact, TiO2 with the smaller Au nanospheres showed the higher photocatalytic activities. In contrast, although Au nanorods with various aspect ratios or Au nanocubes were deposited instead of Au nanospheres on TiO2, their spectra (i.e. electronic states) were not significantly changed. Therefore, it was revealed that while there was little shape dependence, the smaller Au nanoparticles induced the larger electronic state change. This may be due to the difference in the potential gradient generated in the interfacial region between TiO2 and the metal, and the smaller Au nanoparticle deposition leads to the higher photocatalytic activities.
The photocatalytic activity, which is strongly related to the electronic states of TiO2, depends not only on metal kinds14 but also on nanoparticle sizes.18–22 Therefore, it is important to reveal the effects of modified nanoparticle sizes on electronic states and photocatalytic activities for designing TiO2-based materials. The effects of the size of Au nanoparticles on the photocatalytic activities of TiO2 have been reported from several groups.18–22 Idriss and co-workers measured a catalytic hydrogen production rate from ethanol under UV light irradiation by using TiO2 with various sizes of Au nanoparticles (3–30 nm).18 They found that, when they adopted anatase TiO2, the Au particle size did not affect the normalized reaction rates per Au atom over the 3–12 nm range, and the normalized reaction rate was suppressed at larger Au sizes. In the case of rutile TiO2 with Au nanoparticles with 20–35 nm diameter, the photocatalytic activity were almost the same independent from the Au nanoparticle size. Tatsuma's group reported that TiO2 modified with metal nanoparticles such as Au and Ag which absorb visible light due to localized surface plasmon resonance (LSPR) can be applied to visible-light-driven photocatalysis and photovoltaic cells.23,24 They changed the deposited Au nanoparticle size; 15 nm, 40 nm, and 100 nm; and found that the quantum efficiency increased with increasing particle size while the maximum photocurrent decreased under visible light irradiation.19 Heretofore, there are few reports about the electronic state changes of TiO2–Au nanoparticle depending on Au nanoparticle size.22 Photocatalytic activity is strongly related to its electronic states, and therefore, insight into the electronic states may lead to a mechanism elucidation of the photocatalytic enhancement and developments of high efficiency optical materials such as the solar cells.
Far-UV (FUV, 140–200 nm) and deep-UV (DUV, 200–300 nm) region provides substantial information about the electronic states of materials,25–28 and therefore, it is of high importance to explore the FUV-DUV region of TiO2 and metal modified-TiO2 materials. However, it is difficult to systematically measure its optical properties in the FUV-DUV regions because of their large absorption (the absorbance index α is ∼106 to 107 cm−1 in the 200–300 nm region).29 We have recently achieved to measure the FUV-DUV (150–300 nm) spectra of TiO2 and metal-modified TiO2, and found that the effects of the modified metal (Pt, Pd, and Au)30 and TiO2 crystalline forms (anatase and rutile)31 over their electronic states and photocatalytic activities. To measure the spectra in the FUV and DUV regions, we employed our original spectrometer that is based on attenuated total reflection (ATR),25 which enables us to obtain the spectra of liquid and solid samples such as water,26 aqueous solutions,27 and organic molecules28 in the 140–300 nm region. In this method, samples are placed on a sapphire internal reflection element (IRE), and the ATR spectra are measured using an evanescent wave as a probe light.
In this study, we measured ATR spectra of anatase and rutile TiO2 modified with spherical Au nanoparticles whose diameters were changed between 5 nm and 60 nm, and revealed their electronic states depending on the Au size. In all cases, spectral intensities changed upon the Au nanoparticle depositions. In the case of anatase TiO2, the spectral intensities in the longer wavelength region (>∼210 nm) decreased, while that in the shorter wavelength region (<∼210 nm) increased. On the other hand, when rutile TiO2 was used, spectral intensity over the whole wavelength increased. In both cases, the amount of spectral intensity changes increased with the decreasing of Au nanospheres. The spectral changes mean the electronic state changes; electrons transfer from TiO2 to Au and enhancement of charge separation efficiency of TiO2; and thus, the smaller Au nanoparticles induced larger electronic state changes. Subsequently, their photocatalytic activities were estimated based on a photo-induced degradation reaction of methylene blue. As a result, TiO2 with smaller Au nanoparticles showed larger photocatalytic activity, which means that the larger electronic state changes leads to the higher photocatalytic activities. In addition, Au nanorods and Au nanocubes were deposited on TiO2 instead of Au nanospheres. There were no significant difference among ATR spectra of TiO2 with three kinds of Au nanorods which have same diameter (25 nm) and different lengths (34, 47, and 60 nm). Then, an ATR spectrum of TiO2 with Au nanospheres (diameter ∼60 nm) and that of TiO2 with corresponding size nanocubes were almost the same. These results indicate that the amount of electronic state changes of TiO2 was mainly depends on the Au nanoparticle diameter rather than Au nanoparticle shapes. In this way, we have revealed the effects of Au nanoparticle size and shape in the electronic states of TiO2, which is strongly related to their photocatalytic activities.
As we have previously reported,30 the decrease in the intensity in the longer wavelength region is due to charge transfer at the TiO2–metal interface, and the increase in the shorter wavelength region is due to the enhancement of the charge-separation efficiency upon the deposition of metal nanoparticles. The work function of TiO2 (∼4.0 eV for anatase TiO2) is smaller than that of Au (∼4.7 eV).14 Therefore, when TiO2 contacts the Au nanoparticles, electrons in TiO2 inflow to the Au nanoparticles until both the Fermi levels become equal.1 As a result, the number of electrons in relatively high-energy levels (i.e., electrons that can be excited at a relatively longer wavelength) is decreased, resulting in the suppression of spectral intensity in the longer wavelength region. In this case, Fermi level and band-gap energy of TiO2 should become lower and smaller by 0.7 eV at a maximum. However, these electronic state changes upon the metal modification are occurred mainly in the interfacial region between metal and TiO2. Hence, they can't be detected enough by the general UV-vis spectroscopy or electrochemical equipment which measured not only the interfacial region but also bulky region. By using our ATR-FUV-DUV spectroscopy, we can obtain the information of the electronic state changes obviously. In contrast, Au nanoparticles on TiO2 can act as a sink for photo-excited electrons, resulting in the enhancement of the charge-separation efficiency and an increase in the spectral intensity in the shorter wavelength region. This enhancement process may also occur in the longer wavelength region; however, the total change in the spectral intensity is affected by this enhancement as well as by the decrease in the number of electrons upon contact between TiO2 and Au nanoparticles. Here, it is noted that the degree of spectral changes both in the longer wavelength region and the shorter wavelength region increased with the decreasing of deposited Au nanoparticle size. When the amounts of colloids were regulated so that the weights of Au nanoparticles were almost the same (∼1.3 × 10−4 g on 1 g TiO2), the amount of spectral changes also decreased with the increase of Au nanoparticle size as shown in Fig. S3.† In addition, we had examined effects of the protecting agents on the ATR spectra in our previous work.30 It had been made certain that the protecting agents have no substantial effects on the ATR spectra because the spectra show no substantial changes upon removing or changing the protecting agents.
When rutile TiO2 was used (Fig. 1g), after the deposition of Au nanoparticles, the spectral intensity increased over the entire wavelength region as in the case of the depositions of Au nanoparticles, which were different from the results of anatase TiO2. This difference of the spectral changes between anatase and rutile TiO2 is the same as our previous study which adopted Pt nanoparticles,31 and it reflects that the charge-separation efficiency of rutile TiO2 is more enhanced than that of anatase TiO2 by the deposition of metal nanoparticles. In addition, the differences of the spectral shape between rutile TiO2 and anatase TiO2 are due to the differences in the electronic structures of their phase, which is corresponding with previous calculation results.31 Then, it is important point that the amount of spectral changes also increased with the decrease in the deposited Au nanoparticle size.
1 − I/I0 | (1) |
The photocatalytic activities of TiO2 only and TiO2 with 5, 10, 20, and 60 nm Au nanospheres were 0.30 ± 0.030, 0.51 ± 0.031, 0.41 ± 0.024, 0.37 ± 0.043, and 0.33 ± 0.058 (average ± standard deviation, n = 3). As shown in Fig. 2, the photocatalytic activity is enhanced upon the deposition of Au nanospheres, and the photocatalytic activity strongly depends on the Au size; TiO2 with the smaller Au nanoparticles showed the higher photocatalytic activity. Although Au nanoparticles also have catalytic activities, the amount of Au was quite low and they have little effects on the present activities. Wei and co-workers reported that photocatalytic activity of TiO2 with ∼5 nm Au was larger than that of TiO2 with ∼40 nm Au under the UV light irradiation, and the present results are corresponding with them. From these results of ATR spectra (Fig. 1) and photocatalytic activities (Fig. 2), it is concluded that, with the decrease of the Au size, the electronic state changed more largely and the photocatalytic activities increased. That is to say, the correlative relationship between the electronic state changes and the photocatalytic activities depending on the Au nanoparticle size is revealed.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Photocatalytic activities (1 − [I/I0]) of (a) anatase TiO2 with and without Au nanospheres with various sizes. |
As ascribed above, upon the contact between TiO2 and a metal, electrons in TiO2 are transferred into the metal. At the same time, potential gradient is generated in the interfacial region between TiO2 and the metal. This potential gradient prohibits re-combination between the electrons in metal and the holes in TiO2, and leads to the enhancement of charge-separation efficiency. The depth and width of the potential gradient depend on the Fermi levels, sizes, electric conductivity and other factors of TiO2 and the metal. In the present case, TiO2 was not changed and only Au nanoparticle size and shape were changed. In addition, even when the Au shape was changed, the width of the Au nanoparticle was not changed. That is to say, the diameter of all of the Au nanorods was 25 nm, though their length was changed. Therefore, from the ATR spectra in Fig. 1 and 3, it seems that the width of deposited Au nanoparticles largely effects on the electronic states of TiO2. In the past, Kamat and co-workers have measured Fermi levels of TiO2–Au nanoparticle samples (average diameters of Au nanoparticle were 3, 5, and 8 nm) under UV light irradiation, and concluded that the Fermi level of 3 nm Au nanoparticle was more negative than 8 nm Au nanoparticle by 40 mV.22 However, the particle range was strictly limited only from 3 nm to 8 nm, and there is no argument about the effect of shape of Au nanoparticles. The electronic states changes can be detected by using other various methods such as fluorescence analysis, light current measurements, and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS).33–35 In the present study, we have discussed not only the size effect in the wide range of 5–60 nm, but also the shape effect of the Au nanoparticles systematically and easily based on the FUV-DUV spectra. It is also noted here that the contact area between Au and TiO2 is changed depending on the Au size and shape. However, the spectra and the photocatalytic activities are almost the same, which mean that the difference of the contact area has no significant effect in the present cases.
TiO2 (1 g) and metal colloids (200 μL) were mixed in an agate mortar until the solvent completely evaporated off to the atmosphere. TiO2 particles with and without Au metal nanoparticles were placed on the sapphire IRE, and the FUV-DUV spectra were measured using an ATR spectrometer. In the FUV region, both H2O and O2 present in the atmosphere yield very intense absorptions, and thus the spectrometer must be purged with N2 gas. The ATR system employed in this study used a 30 W deuterium lamp as a light source. SEM images were observed by model S-5000 (Hitachi Ltd., Tokyo, Japan), operated at 20 kV.
Methylene blue was purchased from Wako Pure Chemical Industries, Ltd. A Hg–Xe lamp (Luminar Ace LA-300UV, Hayashi Watch Works) equipped with a UV-pass filter (wavelength = 300–350 nm, UTVAF-50S-34U, CVI Laser, LLC) was used as the UV light source. An aqueous solution of methylene blue (20 μM, 20 mL) was mixed with TiO2 only and TiO2–Au powder (5 mg) using a magnetic stirrer, followed by UV irradiation (∼10 μW cm−2) for 30 min. After the irradiation, TiO2 was separated from the solution by centrifugation (15000 rpm, 1 min). The absorption spectra of the methylene blue aqueous solutions were measured both before and after UV irradiation.
In this way, it is concluded that the electronic states of TiO2 depend largely on the modified Au size rather than Au shape. These results also show the usefulness of our original ATR spectroscopy for the investigation the electronic states of TiO2-based materials. Consequently, the electronic states of TiO2 depending on the deposited metal size and shape, which is strongly related to their photocatalytic activities, were systematically studied by this ATR spectrometer, leading to the development of high-efficiency photo-functional materials such as photocatalysis and solar cells.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Fig. S1–S6. See DOI: 10.1039/c4ra12503g |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |