Senbin
Chen
a,
Matthias
Schulz
a,
Bob-Dan
Lechner
b,
Clement
Appiah
a and
Wolfgang H.
Binder
*a
aChair of Macromolecular Chemistry, Faculty of Natural Science II (Chemistry, Physics and Mathematics), Martin-Luther University Halle-Wittenberg, von-Danckelmann-Platz 4, Halle (Saale) D-06120, Germany. E-mail: wolfgang.binder@chemie.uni-halle.de
bPhysical Chemistry, Faculty of Natural Sciences II (Chemistry, Physics and Mathematics), Martin-Luther University Halle-Wittenberg, von-Danckelmann-Platz 4, Halle (Saale) D-06120, Germany
First published on 25th September 2015
We report the design and synthesis of novel supramolecular dendrimers, formed by the association of X–Y2 type single-chain polymeric building blocks Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2, with (poly(n-butyl acrylate) PnBuA) separating the two specific interacting supramolecular moieties X (barbiturate, Ba) and Y (Hamilton wedge, HW). Based on a one-pot two-step synthesis, the mid-Ba and α,ω-HW functionalized X–Y2 type polymer, Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2, is generated via a direct thiol–bromo click reaction with Ba-(PnBuA-RAFT)2, (Mn,NMR = 5.0 kDa, Mn,SEC = 4.8 kDa, Đ = 1.25, prepared via reversible addition–fragmentation chain transfer (RAFT) polymerization), successfully attaching the heterocomplementary supramolecular moieties (HW) at both chain ends in a one-pot fashion at room temperature within one hour. The so obtained Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2 (Mn,NMR = 7.1 kDa, Mn,SEC = 6.7 kDa, Đ = 1.23) assembles into supramolecular dendritic polymers via hydrogen-bonds (H-bonds), illustrating impressive viscosity enhancement in the bulk state (at 20 °C by a factor as high as ∼1839). Atomic force microscopy (AFM) investigations reveal large but defined disc-like objects when spin-coated from a Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2 solution, enabling to tune morphology at the mesoscale to generate hierarchical strucutures by choice of the solvent.
Among those, the design of supramolecular dendritic architectures is special, as it requires appropriate design of the assembling components. Thus one widely investigated synthetic strategy relies on mixing two heterocomplementary components, namely Xn and Ym, where n ≥ 2 and m ≥ 3,28 or via self-organization of a X–Yn (n ≥ 2) type single-chain building block-an approach, where only few examples29–32 have been reported, all of them focusing on low-molecular-weight compound systems. To the best of our knowledge, the preparation of X–Yn (n ≥ 2) type single-chain polymeric macromolecules has not been exploited, presumably due to the tedious synthesis requiring a complete attachment of supramolecular entities – an issue which is often hampered by less robust chemistries and/or time-consuming complicated purification procedures, especially when applied onto polymers as the central scaffold.
It is known that the advance of click reaction33,34 has paved a way for new opportunities in the fabrication of supramolecular architectures based on polymeric macromolecules.4,35–38 In addition to the well-known copper-catalysed alkyne–azide cycloaddition click reaction,39 metal-free thiol-based chemistries have been also identified as a highly robust synthetic approach recently.40,41 Compared to other thiol-based efficient coupling reactions, such as the thiol–ene, the thiol–yne, the thiol–isocyanate and the thiol–epoxy reaction, the investigation of the thiol–bromo click reaction still remains limited,42 although several examples have been reported very recently.43–47
We here describe the synthesis of novel supramolecular dendritic polymers using X–Y2 type heterotropic single-chain polymers, namely the mid-Ba and α,ω-HW functionalized polymer Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2, where PnBuA is separating the two specific interacting supramolecular moieties X (Ba) and Y (HW). We are using a one-pot two-step reaction, successfully linking the HW moieties onto both polymer chain ends directly after the polymerization reaction. From its design we target the generation of a X–Y2 architecture, equipped with the Ba/HW moieties, displaying a high association constant of approximately 105 M−1,11 in turn leading to the formation of a non-crosslinked, dendritic macromolecule via supramolecular specific association. The synthesis of the X–Y2 type heterotropic single-chain polymer Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2 relies on the combination of the thiol–bromo click reaction together with a PnBuA-polymer prepared by RAFT polymerization. The easy, yet complete conversion of the dithioester moiety of the RAFT-made polymer into a reactive thiol group via aminolysis facilitates the subsequent direct polymer functionalization relying on the above mentioned thiol-based efficient coupling reaction (Fig. 1).40 Subsequent association yields the expected supramolecular dendrimers, displaying large but defined disc-like nanoscopic structures spin-coated from a Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2 solution in chloroform. Moreover, the disc-like structures can be tuned to generate hierarchical morphologies by changing the solvent from chloroform to less polar toluene.
Fig. 1 Synthetic route to the mid-Ba and α,ω-HW functionalized X–Y2 type polymer Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2 and its self-assembly to afford the supramolecular dendritic polymers. |
Primary evidence of the successful synthesis of the mid-Ba and α,ω-HW functionalized X–Y2 type polymer Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2 is provided by 1H NMR (Fig. 2). Compared to the spectrum of the starting material, Ba-(PnBuA-RAFT)2, the complete disappearance of the characteristic phenyl protons (7.95, 7.53 and 7.39 ppm in Fig. 2, bottom) ortho to the dithiobenzoate group, along with the emergence of the Hamilton wedge imide protons (8.68 ppm in Fig. 2, top), as well as the pyridyl and phenyl protons (8.02, 7.77 and 7.63 ppm in Fig. 2, top) indicates the successful linking of HW moieties onto the polymer chain ends.
Furthermore, matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization-time of flight mass (MALDI-TOF MS) spectrometry has been used to prove the attachment of two HW moieties via the thiol–bromo click reaction. Mass spectra of the starting material Ba-(PnBuA-RAFT)2 and final product Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2 are shown in the linear mode, (see Fig. S3A and C (ESI†)) obtained by ionization of polymer chains assisted with dithranol as matrix and sodium iodide as the cationization agent. As seen in Fig. S3 (ESI†), comparing the MALDI-TOF spectrum of Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2 (ESI, Fig. S3A†) to the initial starting material Ba-(PnBuA-RAFT)2 (ESI, Fig. S3C†), the shift towards high mass clearly indicates the successful attachment of both HW moieties via the thiol–bromo-click reaction. Both MALDI-TOF spectra (ESI, Fig. S3B and D†) underline the presence of a main series ( and ① refer, respectively, to Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2 and Ba-(PnBuA-RAFT)2), along with other minor series (, ②&③): each set of ions is separated by 128.1 Da, reflecting the repeating unit of the nBuA monomer (calculated 128.08 Da). The detailed simulation of MALDI-TOF MS spectrometry for Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2 (Fig. 3A, corresponding to Fig. S3A in the ESI†) is subsequently accomplished, proving the assignment of the main series (), located at 6098.7965 Da (Fig. 3C), to a mid-Ba, α,ω-HW functionalized species [Ba-(nBuA15.5-HW)2 + Na]+, i.e., [C32H54N2O7–((C7H12O2)15.5–C40H53N6O7S)2 + Na]+, which matches well with the simulated pattern (m/zaverage = 6098.7304 Da). The observed isotopic patterns of the minor series (), illustrated in Fig. 3B and C, also agree well with the simulated structure, proving that the one-pot two-step reaction proceeded efficiently, thus further ascertaining the successful macromolecular modification, also showing no residual trace of an only mono- or non-functionalized polymer.
Fig. 3 MALDI-TOF MS of Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2 (A) full spectrum, (B) expansion and (C) simulation of the isotope pattern. |
However, to fully establish a complete end-group transformation from Ba-(PnBuA-RAFT)2 to Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2, liquid chromatography at critical conditions (LCCC) is conducted (Fig. 4). To this end, Ba-(PnBuA-RAFT)2 and Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2 are subsequently characterized by LC at near-critical conditions (dichloromethane/acetonitrile, DCM/ACN, 89/11, v/v at 25 °C) reported for PnBuA.50 Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2 under these conditions is however partially retained on the reversed phase Atlantis column. Thus, overcoming this retention-effect is accomplished by adding 0.5% methanol (MeOH) to the mobile phase (i.e. DCM/ACN/MeOH, 89/10.5/0.5, v/v/v). As seen in Fig. 4 (bottom) for the mixed sample (Ba-(PnBuA-RAFT)2 + Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2), no major changes in the retention time compared to the pure Ba-(PnBuA-RAFT)2 (Fig. 4, middle) is observed, indicating that the 0.5% methanol addition does not have any negative effect on the LCCC conditions, but rather helped in solubilising the polar end-group to enhance a better movement of the polymer in the column. Most importantly, the results from the LC show different retention times for Ba-(PnBuA-RAFT)2 (4.65 min, Fig. 4, middle) and Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2 (6.26 min, Fig. 4, top). The signal of the starting polymer Ba-(PnBuA-RAFT)2 is not present in the spectrum of final pure Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2 (see Fig. 4/top), which undoubtedly confirms the successful macromolecular conversion via the thiol–bromo click reaction.
A first indication of self-assembly of Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2 is provided by 1H NMR studies (Fig. 2). Compared to the spectrum of Ba-(PnBuA-RAFT)2 (Fig. 2, bottom), in addition to the appearance of Hamilton wedge protons in the expected stoichiometric amounts, a considerable downfield shift of the barbiturate imide protons from 8.12 to 12.79 ppm is observed: a strong indication for the formation of the expected H-bonded complex (Fig. 2, top). In order to prove the effect of H-bonding more clearly, the addition of small amounts of a polar solvent MeOD-d4 into the CDCl3 solution is performed (Fig. 5), which leads to a significant upfield shift of the barbiturate NH protons to 10.89 and 10.54 ppm in Fig. 5B and C, respectively, revealing the partial dissociation of the supramolecular structures by action of the hydrogen breaking solvent. It is also noteworthy that the barbiturate NH protons are difficult to detect in the mixed solvent of CDCl3/MeOD-d4 (Fig. 5B and C).
Fig. 5 Partial 1H NMR spectrum of Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2 recorded in different solvents at 27 °C, [Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2] = 2 mM. (A): CDCl3, (B): CDCl3/MeOD-d4 (10/1, v/v), (B): CDCl3/MeOD-d4 (10/2, v/v). |
Rheological measurements have been subsequently performed in the bulk state to achieve more insight into the relaxation dynamics of supramolecular structures. Thus Ba-(PnBuA-RAFT)2 and Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2 are investigated by frequency-dependent measurements at different temperatures (ESI, Fig. S4†). The zero shear viscosities (η0) are then plotted as a function of temperature (Fig. 6). As expected, the absolute values of η0 decrease with increasing temperature in both cases. In comparison to the starting material Ba-(PnBuA-RAFT)2, the supramolecular polymer self-assembled from Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2 demonstrates impressive viscosity enhancements (at 20 °C by a factor as high as ∼1839). In comparison, our recently developed supramolecular linear structures49 display viscosity enhancements only by a factor of ∼42 at 20 °C: such striking differences in viscosity enhancements (1839 vs. 42) undoubtedly prove the generation of three-dimensional supramolecular dendritic structures by Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2, compared to the one-dimensional supramolecular linear structures generated from same polymer with similar molar mass.
Fig. 6 Zero shear viscosity (η0) vs. temperature for Ba-(PnBuA-RAFT)2 (open square), and Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2 (closed square). |
In order to further prove the formation of dendritic associates, we have conducted frequency-dependent melt rheology of Ba-(PnBuA-RAFT)2 and Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2 in the temperature ranging from 20 to 70 °C (ESI, Fig. S5†). In all cases, Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2 exhibits much higher storage (G′) and loss (G′′) moduli than Ba-(PnBuA-RAFT)2 under same conditions (frequency and temperature). Moreover, no intersection of the storage and the loss modulus is observed (ESI, Fig. S5†), indicating the viscous property of the sample, together with small angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) profile which doesn't show any clusters (Fig. S6†), we can exclude supramolecular aggregation or crosslinking (gelation) and thus can prove the formation of nonclustered dendritic supramolecular polymers.
A final insight into the morphology and size of the supramolecular dendrimers formed by Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2 is corroborated by AFM investigations (intermittent contact mode in air) exerted from solution. Fig. 7 shows typical AFM images of aggregates, obtained by spin-coating on a silicon wafer from a Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2 solution in chloroform or toluene. The presence of supramolecular nanostructures is firstly evidenced using chloroform as solvent (Fig. 7A and B, c = 1 g L−1): the images show defined disc-like objects predominately with diameters (d) of ∼180 and 310 nm, but all of the disc-like objects are remarkably uniform in height (5–6 nm, Fig. 7A, ESI, Fig. S7A and B†). In fact, recent reports have demonstrated that the discontinuity in diameter of objects is a striking feature for the presence of high-generation supramolecular dendrimers.31,32 While using less polar toluene as solvent at the same concentration, the AFM results exhibit even larger (d = ∼250, 340 and 430 nm) disc-like objects (Fig. 7C) with again uniform heights (∼5 nm, ESI, Fig. S7C and D†), but a denser surface coverage, explainable by the expected higher degree of association. In addition, diffusion-ordered NMR (DOSY NMR) spectroscopy of a Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2 solution in toluene-d8 demonstrates discrete diffusion coefficients which further confirm the differences in the homogeneous size of the self-assembled dendritic supramolecular polymers (ESI, Fig. S8†). Interestingly, we also observe elongated nanodomains at the top the discs (Fig. 7C and D, ESI, Fig. S7C and D†), which are harder than the surrounding materials (Fig. 7D, brighter in the corresponding phase image). This interesting hierarchical morphology can be ascribed to the stiff H-bonding aggregates being surrounded by a soft PnBuA polymer matrix. Altogether, the large size of nanoscopic structures observed clearly confirms the presence of dendritic supramolecular polymers formed by the Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2. In order to study the influence of polar solvent on the morphology of Ba-(PnBuA-HW)2, a mixed solvent system (chloroform/methanol, 1/1, v/v) is used, as seen in Fig. S9.† The addition of polar methanol result in the complete disappearance of previously obtained disc-like morphology, clearly demonstrating the at least partial dissociation of the supramolecular structures, thus being in agreement with the expected solvent-dependent characteristics of H-bonds.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Details of polymerization and synthesis, SEC traces, MALDI-TOF MS spectroscopy, temperature-dependent rheology, shear modulus studies, SAXS profile, AFM height images and DOSY NMR spectrum. See DOI: 10.1039/c5py01329a |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |