V.
Körstgens
a,
S.
Pröller
ab,
T.
Buchmann
a,
D.
Moseguí González
a,
L.
Song
a,
Y.
Yao
a,
W.
Wang
a,
J.
Werhahn
c,
G.
Santoro
d,
S. V.
Roth
d,
H.
Iglev
c,
R.
Kienberger
c and
P.
Müller-Buschbaum
*a
aTechnische Universität München, Physik-Department, Lehrstuhl für Funktionelle Materialien, James-Franck-Str. 1, 85748 Garching, Germany. E-mail: muellerb@ph.tum.de
bTechnische Universität München, Munich School of Engineering, Herzig Group, Lichtenbergstr. 4, 85748 Garching, Germany
cTechnische Universität München, Physik-Department, Lehrstuhl für Laser- und Röntgenphysik, James-Franck-Str. 1, 85748 Garching, Germany
dDeutsches Elektronen-Synchrotron (DESY), Notkestr. 85, 22607 Hamburg, Germany
First published on 13th January 2015
Titania nanoparticles are produced by laser ablation in liquid in order to initiate functionalization of titania with the polymer for the active layer. By combining these titania nanoparticles and water-soluble poly[3-(potassium-6-hexanoate)thiophene-2,5-diyl] (P3P6T) hybrid solar cells are realized.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Basic set-up of the laser ablation process for (a) aqueous titania powder suspension and (b) solid titanium target in water. |
On the one hand the processing of titania nanoparticles is carried out starting with a solid target (titanium foil, 0.89 mm thick, Alfa Aesar), whereas on the other hand titania powder (titanium(IV) oxide powder in a rutile phase, particle size <5 μm, Sigma-Aldrich) in aqueous suspension is the source material for the laser ablation experiment. The laser radiation is provided by using a home-built titanium:sapphire laser system delivering pulses at a central wavelength of 810 nm with a pulse energy of 290 ± 20 μJ and a repetition rate of 1 kHz. The pulse duration tpulse of 270 ± 50 fs was measured by frequency-resolved optical gating.16 The laser beam was focused on the sample via a fused silica lens (f = 100 mm) as shown in Fig. 1. The beam diameter in the focal plane dlaser = 30.9 ± 0.2 μm was determined by using a beam camera (BeamPro, Photon Inc.). The estimated pulse intensity in the focus of about 1.4 × 1013 W cm−2 is much higher than the expected ablation threshold. For processing both targets (the titanium dioxide powder dispersed in water and the solid titanium foil, respectively) a stirring plate is applied, as the laser ablation process in liquid flow is more efficient and yields more reproducible results.17 In the case of the ablation process from powder (Fig. 1a), a glass vial containing a magnetic stir bar and the titania suspension is placed on the stirring plate. The stirring of the suspension yields the needed flow and the probability of hitting a huge amount of particles with the laser beam is high. Yet not all original powder particles cross the laser focus. For the solid target on the other hand (Fig. 1b), the laser beam would always hit the same point yielding insufficient ablation rates. Thus, the stirring plate with the target holder including the target and the magnetic stir bar is placed on a movable plate. Hence, by adjusting the motion parameters of the motor, the target is moved with respect to the laser focus in x- and y-direction yielding a large-area treatment in a circular trace (Fig. 1b). After laser ablation processing of the titanium target or the white titanium dioxide powder, respectively, a bluish suspension develops. This change in color can be attributed to rutile titanium dioxide nanoparticles.18–20 Furthermore, the presence of Ti2+ and Ti3+ species might influence the color and was previously found in laser ablation products.19,21 Thus, the change in color is a first hint of successful laser ablation of the material.
The titanium dioxide powder purchased from Sigma Aldrich is non-spherically shaped, but rather shows rough edges, as depicted in the scanning electron microscopy (SEM) image in Fig. 2a. The size declaration by the manufacturer is <5 μm. For the original titania powder a diameter of (750 ± 465) nm with very few particles >3 μm is found by SEM analysis. After laser ablation of the material a mean value of 150 nm with a distinct size distribution is obtained from the SEM images (Fig. 2b). The accumulation of round shaped small particles around larger source particles yields uncertainties for the particle size measurement. In contrast, the particles ablated from a titanium target have a spherical shape with sizes in the range of 5 to 150 nm with an average diameter of 25 nm (Fig. 2c).
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 SEM images of (a) the source titania powder, (b) laser-ablated material from titania powder and (c) laser-ablated material from solid titanium target. |
In order to functionalize the fabricated nanoparticles, the aqueous suspension of the laser-ablated product is removed from the laser beam and an aqueous P3P6T solution is added. A P3P6T:TiO2 suspension with a weight ratio of 1:
1 of the components is achieved. The suspension is put in the laser focus for a short additional treatment in order to enhance the functionalization process. The resulting P3P6T:TiO2 compound serves as the active layer in hybrid solar cells. The steps of the solar cell fabrication are shown in Fig. 3. In the chosen inverted cell geometry the electrons are extracted via a transparent conductive oxide (TCO) electrode. As TCO-substrates fluorine doped tin oxide (FTO) is used, since the blocking layer has to be calcined and FTO has better temperature stability as compared with indium tin oxide. A compact titania layer is selected as the hole blocking layer, which reduces the contact of the hole conductor with the FTO and therefore prevents charge recombination (Fig. 3a). The active layer made of the P3P6T:TiO2 compound prepared from laser-ablated titania from a titania powder suspension is deposited by spin coating. Thereafter, the sample is transferred to a heating plate at 70 °C to evaporate the remaining solvent. For the P3P6T:TiO2 compound prepared from laser-ablated titania from a solid titanium target, solution casting is chosen due to the lower concentrations achieved in the ablation process (Fig. 3b). An electron blocking layer of poly(3,4-ethylene dioxythiophene):poly(styrenesulfonate) (PEDOT:PSS) is applied from a dilution of PEDOT:PSS with isopropyl alcohol (IPA) in the volume ratio 1
:
10 (Fig. 3c). The last step before characterizing the solar cell is the evaporation of gold top contacts (Fig. 3d) followed by annealing. An annealing step at 140 °C for 10 min is chosen as this treatment showed an improvement in crystallinity of the hole-conducting polymer and thus in the performance of solar cells based on poly(3-hexylthiophene) (P3HT), which is similar to the used P3P6T.22 All obtained hybrid solar cells are functional. However, the efficiencies η achieved for solar cells containing laser-ablated titania out of aqueous titania powder suspension reached only (0.12 ± 0.03)%. In particular the low short circuit current density ISC = (0.36 ± 0.05) mA cm−2 causes the low efficiency, since open circuit voltage UOC = (0.68 ± 0.03) V and fill factor FF = (46 ± 7)% are both in a very promising range. For hybrid solar cells containing laser-ablated titania from a solid titanium target only a much lower efficiency of 0.02% could be achieved as a consequence of lower values of ISC (0.14 mA cm−2), UOC (0.47 V), and FF (29%).
To understand the reasons which limit the efficiencies of the aqueous processed hybrid solar cells, the crystalline structure of the titania nanoparticles is investigated. X-ray diffraction (XRD) measurements are performed on spin-coated films of P3P6T and the P3P6T:TiO2 compound based on laser ablation of the titania powder annealed at 120 °C (Fig. 4a). Additionally, a pure film of laser-ablated TiO2 is cast on a glass substrate and investigated for comparison. The titania film shown in Fig. 4a is not calcined. The theoretical positions for rutile and anatase TiO2 phases23 are depicted by green and blue bars, respectively. For the pure titania film, the main crystal phase is rutile. However, a certain amount of anatase phase can be found. For comparison, the material as purchased (without laser ablation) is mainly in its rutile phase. The production of both, the rutile and the anatase phase by laser ablation in solution under controlled conditions was previously observed.24,25 After laser ablation of a rutile titania powder target, the presence of rutile, anatase and brookite structure was reported.21 The main crystalline phase for titania ablated from a solid target is rutile (see ESI†). The fabrication of a mixed phase of rutile and anatase by laser ablating a titanium target was observed by Tian et al.26 They concluded that the rapidly changing temperature and pressure are responsible for the observed coexistence of both phases.26
Although there are several studies on the application of P3P6T in photovoltaics,27–31 there are only a few hints in the literature on the crystallinity in the corresponding films, reporting P3P6T to be amorphous.27 Accordingly, no literature values for lattice spacings, crystal planes or orientation are available. In our investigation, the pure P3P6T film exhibits (100) and (010) Bragg peaks (Fig. 4a) comparable to those found for P3HT.22 For the P3P6T:TiO2 compound, clear diffraction peaks (indicated by black arrows in Fig. 4a) are observable, which are caused by TiO2. All observed titania peaks in the P3P6T:TiO2 sample can be attributed to the rutile phase in the (110), (101), (111), (211) and (220) planes. For the pure titania film it is already seen that the rutile phase is dominating, even though the anatase phase is present, too. To further investigate the orientation of the crystals, grazing incidence wide angle X-ray scattering (GIWAXS) measurements are performed using the Micro- and Nanofocus X-ray scattering Instrument P03 of the PETRA III synchrotron source in Hamburg, Germany.32,33 The two-dimensional (2D) GIWAXS data of the P3P6T:TiO2 film are shown in Fig. 4b. Due to the powder-like arrangement of the titania particles a ring-shaped intensity distribution of the corresponding Bragg peaks is seen. As for the XRD data, the rutile phases with (101) and (110) Bragg peaks can clearly be identified and are marked in green. Additionally, the (111) Bragg peak of the rutile phase can be identified at the top of the 2D data. Furthermore, an anatase phase signal, corresponding to the (101) plane, is observed and denoted in blue/white. Higher orders, as seen in XRD, are outside the detector range. To quantify the GIWAXS data, cake cuts are performed in vertical (85°–95°) and horizontal (1°–10°) directions. The lattice spacing for the polymer according to Bragg's equation is (1.10 ± 0.01) nm in the [100] direction and (0.38 ± 0.01) nm in the [010] direction. Furthermore, the crystallite size is calculated using the Scherrer equation, whereas for a pure P3P6T film the crystallite size for the (100) peak is (13.9 ± 0.9) nm, it decreases for the sample containing TiO2 to (7.5 ± 0.8) nm. It is further observed that the intensity of the polymer Bragg peaks decreases by adding TiO2. This indicates less crystallinity of P3P6T due to adding TiO2. Similar observations are found in the literature for P3HT:PCBM blends.34 Thus, the diffraction experiments clearly prove the crystallinity of pure P3P6T. In addition, an indication of crystallinity is found from the shoulder of the UV-vis absorption spectra of the pure P3P6T film as well as in the P3P6T:TiO2 film (Fig. 5a). Furthermore, the titania out of the ablation experiment strongly absorbs below 400 nm, as shown in Fig. 5a. For determining the indirect band gap, the Tauc equation is applied. Averaging over several spectra yields the value of (2.82 ± 0.03) eV for the original powder and (2.5 ± 0.3) eV for the material after laser ablation. Titania in its rutile phase is known to have an indirect band gap of 3.02 eV, while in its anatase phase it has an indirect band gap of 3.23 eV.35,36 For a mixed phase, it is known that a band alignment occurs and a deviation from the pure band gap is possible.26 As the rutile phase is thermodynamically more stable, the laser-ablated particles may be more likely in the rutile than in the anatase phase. Thus, a dominating rutile phase is expected for the laser ablation products as confirmed by X-ray characterization (Fig. 4). However, all the values obtained for the indirect band gap are lower than the expected one for the rutile phase of 3.0 eV. Different phases also show higher band gaps. An amorphous phase is expected to have a band gap value of 3.3 eV, and a brookite phase to have a band gap of 3.4 eV.37,38 The observed lower value could originate from the lower transmission as the films are turbid and therefore scatter strongly. In the case of the ablated material another factor could play a role. As the particles are smaller, more oxygen vacancies might be found. It was shown that the ablation products often contain Ti3+.21 These oxygen vacancy states are located 0.75–1.18 eV below the conduction band.31,39 The functionalization of the laser-ablated titanium dioxide particles after mixing with P3P6T and additional laser treatment is verified by Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy. The samples could not be measured as a thin film but on the dry powder extracted from the respective films. To see the effect of functionalization, pristine P3P6T, pure laser-ablated TiO2 produced out of the titania powder and the corresponding P3P6T:TiO2 compound are investigated. Furthermore, to observe the influence of the subsequent adding and functionalizing of the particles with polymer, pristine P3P6T is mixed with dried laser-ablated TiO2 powder. This sample is denoted as “P3P6T/TiO2 blend” as it constitutes a simple mixture of the dry components without expecting any special binding between the components. The obtained infrared spectra for the samples using TiO2 powder as ablation target are depicted in Fig. 5b (for zoom in and attributed bands see ESI†). For TiO2, the signal is obtained at low wavenumbers of 600–400 cm−1. For the polymer, the two ranges 3100–2700 cm−1 for the methylene group, and 1700–1200 cm−1 for the carboxylate group (Fig. 5b) are of interest. Compared with the P3P6T:TiO2 compound, no shift or additional absorbance is obtained for the P3P6T:TiO2 blend. However, the signal of TiO2 is strongly suppressed for the P3P6T:TiO2 compound. This, however, is an indication of the coating of the titania particles but not necessarily of a functionalization, as no absorbance peak is found upon combining the materials. For the compound denoted P3P6T:TiO2* in Fig. 5b prepared with titania nanoparticles ablated from a titanium target, the characteristic carboxyl vibrations of P3P6T at 1395 and 1555 cm−1 are hardly recognizable. However, the polymer is still present in the sample and a new vibration band is observed at 1700 cm−1, which does not exist for the other spectra. Thus, the new vibration band at 1700 cm−1 might be attributed to the coupling of the polymer to the laser-ablated TiO2. This indicates a success in functionalization and coupling of the polymer end-group to the TiO2 nanoparticles. For the previously described sample produced with TiO2 powder as target, it might not be seen, since the ratio of the laser-ablated TiO2 to the original powder after the ablation process is too low for allowing the full amount of the polymer to couple with the ablated TiO2.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Full scheme of the production of solar cells, additional spectra and details of the measurement techniques. See DOI: 10.1039/c4nr06782g |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |