Open Access Article
Hongfei
Gao‡
a,
Huifang
Cheng‡
a,
Qijing
Liu
a,
Yulong
Xiao
a,
Marko
Prehm
b,
Xiaohong
Cheng
*a and
Carsten
Tschierske
*b
aKey Laboratory of Medicinal Chemistry for Natural Resources, Chemistry Department, Yunnan University, Kunming, Yunnan 650091, P. R. China. E-mail: xhcheng@ynu.edu.cn; Fax: +86 871 5032905
bInstitute of Chemistry, Organic Chemistry, Martin-Luther University Halle-Wittenberg, Kurt-Mothes Str. 2, 06120 Halle/Saale, Germany. E-mail: carsten.tschierske@chemie.uni-halle.de; Fax: +49 345 55 27346
First published on 7th January 2015
Bolaamphiphiles consisting of a bent 1,3-bis(phenylethynyl)benzene core with two terminal glycerol units, a lateral n-alkyl chain in the bay-position and a methyl group at the apex of the central 1,3-substituted benzene ring have been synthesized via Sonogashira coupling reactions as key steps. The thermotropic and solvent-modified or solvent-induced liquid crystalline (LC) phases of these compounds were investigated by POM, DSC and X-ray scattering. Compounds with medium alkyl chain length form a hexagonal honeycomb LC phase with non-centrosymmetric trigonal p3m1 symmetry as a monotropic LC phase. The addition of water increases the LC phase range, leading to enantiotropic p3m1 phases and induces LC phases for the non-mesomorphic compounds with shorter and longer lateral alkyl chains.
In the first step, to evaluate the influence of steric effects, we report herein the effect of an additional methyl group. This group was introduced at the apex of the bent core (in position 5 of the central 1,3-disubstituted benzene ring) in molecules 1/n consisting of a π-conjugated 1,3-bis(phenylethynyl)benzene bent-core, two terminal glycerol units and having a long lateral alkyl chain of variable length n in the 2-position (bay position) at the central benzene ring (see Scheme 2). Specifically, the influence of the length of the lateral chain and the effect of water as a polar solvent on LC self-assembly were investigated.
17 in a Sonogashira coupling reaction,18 leading to the 1,2-O-isopropylidene glycerol substituted 1,3-bis(phenylethynyl)benzenes 7/n. In the last step the 1,2-O-isopropylidene groups were cleaved with pyridinium p-toluenesulfonate (PPTS) in CH3OH.12,19 The final compounds 1/n were purified by repeated crystallization from petroleum ether/ethyl acetate mixtures (1
:
2). The detailed procedures and corresponding analysis data are collected and given in the ESI.†
12 and the effect of water on mesophase stability
| Compound | X | R | Phase transitions T/°C [ΔH/kJ mol−1] | a/nm | n cell | n wall |
T
cl b/°C |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| a Transition temperatures were determined by DSC (peak temperatures, second heating scan, 10 K min−1); abbreviations: Cr = crystalline solid; Colhex-3/p3m1 = hexagonal honeycomb LC phase with a trigonal p3m1 lattice; Iso = isotropic liquid; values in parentheses represent monotropic phase transitions only observed upon cooling. b Maxima of the LC–Iso transition temperatures observed by POM in the contact region between compounds 1/n and water. c Transition temperatures were determined by POM. d Values >90 °C cannot be determined with certainty, due to rapid water evaporation at these temperatures. | |||||||
| 1/6 | CH3 | C6H13 | Cr 92 Isoc | ∼96d | |||
| 1/12 | CH3 | C12H25 | Cr 94 Isoc | ∼92d | |||
| 1/14 | CH3 | C14H29 | Cr 48[12.1] (Colhex-3/p3m1 45[1.2]) Iso | 2.74 | 2.7 | 1.8 | ∼93d |
| 1/16 | CH3 | C16H33 | Cr 44[12.3] (Colhex-3/p3m1 41[1.7]) Iso | 2.77 | 2.65 | 1.8 | 74 |
| 1/18 | CH3 | C18H37 | Cr 74[11.1] Iso | 66 | |||
| 1/22 | CH3 | C22H45 | Cr 82 Isoc | 39 | |||
| 2/12 | H | C12H25 | Cr 94[24.5] (Colhex-3/p3m1 85[6.3]) Iso | 2.82 | 3.1 | 2.1 | |
The optical textures of the monotropic LC phases of compounds 1/14 and 1/16, as obtained by cooling from the isotropic liquid and observed between crossed polarizers, are characterized by highly birefringent spherulitic domains coexisting with large homotropically aligned regions appearing completely dark and interrupted by filament-like defects (see Fig. 1a and c). These textures indicate columnar LC phases which are optically uniaxial. As confirmed by investigations using a λ retarder plate (see Fig. 1b and d) the birefringence of the LC phases is negative, i.e. the high index axis, which is known to be parallel to the long axis of the π-conjugated cores, is perpendicular to the column long axis. This means that the bent aromatic cores of compounds 1/n are aligned perpendicular to the column long axis in the plane of the 2D lattice and this is in line with a polygonal honeycomb structure of these LC phases with a uniaxial square or hexagonal lattice.
The XRD patterns of both compounds are characterized by a diffuse wide angle scattering at d = 0.44–0.45 nm, confirming the presence of liquid like disorder and a series of sharper small angle scatterings, indicating the presence of a long range periodicity, as typically observed for LCs (Fig. 1e and f). There is one very strong and three weak small angle diffraction peaks with a ratio of their reciprocal spacings of 1
:
2
:
71/2
:
121/2 which can be indexed to the 10, 20, 21 and 22 reflections of a hexagonal lattice. This indicates hexagonal columnar mesophases for compounds 1/14 and 1/16 (Fig. 1e and f and Table S1, ESI†). The hexagonal lattice parameters ahex are 2.74 and 2.77 nm for compounds 1/14 and 1/16, respectively. This relatively small value of ahex, compared to the molecular dimensions, confirms that both hexagonal columnar mesophases should be formed by 3-hexagons, leading to a trigonal columnar phase with p3m1 symmetry (Colhex-3/p3m1 phases).12 In this case the side length of the hexagons (lhex) is related to the hexagonal lattice parameter (ahex) through lhex = ahex/31/2 ∼ 1.6 nm and this value is in agreement with the length of each leg (L = 1.5 nm) of the 1,3-bis(phenylethynyl)benzene unit of the molecules 1/n as measured with molecular models between the middle of the 5-methylresorcinol core and the end of the primary OH group of the glycerol unit, assuming a most extended conformation. The hexagonal lattice parameters of 1/14 and 1/16 are also very similar to that of the previously reported compound 2/12 (ahex = 2.82 nm, see Table 1) for which the trigonal symmetry was additionally confirmed by reconstruction of electron density maps.12 If there would be larger 6-hexagon cylinders, leading to a hexagonal p6mm symmetry (Colhex-6/p6mm, Scheme 1), a lattice parameter ahex around 4–5 nm would be expected.12 This means that in the Colhex-3/p3m1 phases of compounds 1/14 and 1/16 each side of the hexagon is made up of one arm of the bent molecules, as shown in Scheme 1b and Fig. 1g. In the honeycomb frames three molecules are organized in the circumference of each hexagonal cell with the bent aromatic cores arranged in the plane of the 2D-lattice and aligned perpendicular to the resulting channels, in line with the experimentally observed negative birefringence of these LC phases. In the resulting honeycomb walls two individual legs of adjacent bent shaped aromatic units are arranged parallel side-by-side. The dynamic hydrogen bonding networks between the glycerol end-groups fuse these walls to hexagonal honeycombs and the prismatic cells resulting inside these honeycombs are filled with the long alkyl chains in the 2-position. The nodes of the honeycomb are alternating, only three of them are formed by the hydrogen bonding networks of the glycerol groups and those between them are made up by the apexes of the bent-core units, thus leading to the reduced trigonal symmetry (plane group p3m1). According to the calculation in Table S2 (ESI†), the number of molecules in each unit cell with an assumed height of 0.45 nm (the maximum of diffuse wide angle scattering) is about three (ncell = 2.7–2.8), which is in line with the proposed mode of molecular organization (see Table 1 and Table S2, ESI†). The slight deviation from being exactly three could be due to a deviation of the core–core distance along the columns from the assumed value of 0.45 nm and to a slight staggering of the aromatic cores along the honeycomb walls, as known for previously reported LC honeycombs.4–8
Compound 1/12 has a higher melting point at T = 94 °C, which can be supercooled to T = 41 °C, when the compound slowly crystallizes without formation of any LC phase. Even at T = 30 °C no LC phase could be detected between the developing crystallites (see Fig. S1, ESI†). Thus, comparison of compound 2/12 without the 5-substituent and compound 1/12 with the 5-methyl group (Table 1) indicates that the melting point is increased and the LC phase is strongly depressed or even completely removed by introduction of the 5-substituent. This clearly indicates a mesophase destabilizing effect of this substituent, which is easily explained by steric distortion of the molecular packing into a honeycomb structure due to packing frustration at the nodes formed by the methyl substituted molecular apexes. However, if the 2-alkyl chain is further elongated the melting points are significantly reduced and Colhex-3/p3m1 phases can be observed for compounds 1/14 and 1/16, though the mesophase stability, i.e. the LC–Iso phase transition temperature is significantly lower than that observed for compound 2/12 without the methyl group. This means that an increased alkyl chain length is required to obtain LC phases for the methyl substituted compounds 1/n, but upon further chain elongation the mesophase stability is reduced (1/14 > 1/16), and for compounds 1/18 and 1/22 the LC phases are removed again. So the major conclusion is that, though the non-centrosymmetric trigonal columnar organization can be retained, the 5-methyl group has a significant mesophase destabilizing effect. This disturbance can partly be compensated by optimizing the 2-alkyl chain length and, as described further below, by adding appropriate solvents, stabilizing the columns comprising the hydrogen bonding networks.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 UV-vis absorption (left) and PL spectra (right) of 1/14 in THF solution (10−6 M) (solid lines) and solid thin film (dot lines). | ||
The mesophase regions of compounds 1/14 and 1/16 are significantly expanded and become enantiotropic by addition of water, not only as a result of mesophase stabilization, but also due to the reduction of the melting temperatures by the added solvent. This leads to broad temperature ranges of a trigonal columnar LC phase down to ambient temperature. The LC phase of the water saturated compound 1/16 was investigated by XRD at 25 °C (Fig. 4). The diffraction pattern is characterized by a diffuse wide angle scattering at d = 0.45 nm confirming the presence of an LC phase. The ratio of the reciprocal spacing in the small angle region is 1
:
2. Based on the observed textures a lamellar phase can be excluded and indexing as 10 and 20 reflections of a hexagonal lattice leads to ahex = 2.95 nm, which is slightly larger than that found for the pure 1/16 sample (ahex = 2.77 nm). Nevertheless, the value is still in the range expected for a hexagonal honeycomb phase with the p3m1 lattice (see Fig. S4 and Table S1, ESI†). This is in line with the incorporation of the solvent molecules into the columns formed by the hydrogen bonding networks between the glycerol units, thus leading to the swelling and a slight increase of the lattice parameter.
If the series of compounds 1/n is compared (see Table 1), it appears that the highest stability of the solvent induced LC phase is achieved for compounds with short chains and chain elongation decreases the mesophase stability. A possible reason could be restricted water uptake by the more hydrophobic long chain compounds. Moreover, the long alkyl chains can by themselves efficiently fill the space in the hexagonal cylinder cells thus leaving less space available for additional water molecules. This reduces the total number of possible hydrogen bondings and the honeycombs cannot be efficiently stabilized. The thermotropic as well as the solvent stabilized LC phases of compounds 1/14 and 1/16 represent Colhex-3/p3m1 phases, based on textural and XRD evidence. This is most likely also the case for the other homologues, as there is continuous development of the LC–Iso transition temperatures depending on the chain length and, in addition, all solvent-induced LC phases are optically negative as typical for honeycomb phases and indicated by investigation with a λ-retarder plate (see insets in Fig. 3). Nevertheless, there are some textural differences (see Fig. 3), which are most likely due to changes in the preferred alignment of the honeycombs depending on the chain length. Overall, it is most likely that all solvent induced LC phases indeed represent Colhex-3/p3m1 phases, though they cannot be stated with full certainty at present.
12 it is evident that the additional lateral methyl group at the apex reduces the mesophase stability, though the fundamental mode of self-assembly is not changed. This means that the non-centrosymmetric liquid crystalline phase is retained even in the presence of this substituent. This paves the way to new molecules with acceptor substituents at the apex for achieving nonlinear optically active LC materials.13 Moreover, water, as a typical protic solvent, was shown to stabilize, and widen or even might induce the non-centrosymmetric trigonal columnar phase ranges. This kind of trigonal columnar phase is extremely rare9,12,23 and most often hexasubstituted benzenes were previously used in attempts to design this kind of non-centrosymmetric LC phase.14 Especially lyotropic trigonal liquid crystalline phases were previously unknown.1 The approach presented here provides easy access to such LC phases with broad phase ranges including ambient temperature. Further structural modifications could potentially lead to liquid crystalline materials with significant second harmonic generation activity.13 Besides the non-centrosymmetric structure of the columnar phases the fluorescence properties of the investigated compounds are also of interest for potential applications.
A Mettler heating stage (FP 82 HT) was used for polarizing optical microscopy (POM, Optiphot 2, Nikon) and DSCs were recorded using a DSC-7 calorimeter (Perkin Elmer) at 10 K min−1. X-ray diffraction patterns of partially aligned samples were recorded with a 2D detector (HI-STAR, Siemens) using a small droplet on a glass surface; Ni filtered and pin hole collimated Cu-Kα radiation was used and the beam was parallel to the surface. The exposure time was 60 min. The sample-to-detector distance was 8.8 cm and 26.9 cm for the wide angle and small angle measurements, respectively. 2D frame integration was used to convert the patterns into one-dimensional intensity profiles and the evaluated peak positions were used for phase assignments. UV-vis absorption spectra were recorded on a UV-240 UV-visible spectrophotometer (Shimadzu, Japan). Fluorescence spectra were recorded using a Hitachi F-7000 fluorescence spectrometer (Hitachi, Japan). The spectral measurements were carried out at room temperature.
For investigation of the solvent-free samples the materials have been heated in an open sample to >120 °C before investigation to remove all water traces, and exposure of the dry samples to humid air was avoided during investigation. Investigation of the effects of water on the samples was carried out between ordinary (non-treated) circular microscopy glass slides (Plano) by inspection of the contact region between 1/n and water. In addition, compounds 1/n were mixed with excess water and heated between glass slides to determine the LC–Iso transition temperatures of the water saturated samples. In order to avoid evaporation of water from these samples at elevated temperature, the sandwiched glass plates were placed in an optical transparent glass pan with a planar surface together with an excess of water around the sample.
Footnotes |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c4nj01855a |
| ‡ Both authors contributed equally to this work. |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry and the Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique 2015 |