K. B.
Gona
a,
J. L. V. N. P.
Thota
a,
Z.
Baz
a,
V.
Gómez-Vallejo
b and
J.
Llop
*a
aRadiochemistry and Nuclear Imaging Group, CIC biomaGUNE, Paseo Miramón 182, San Sebastián, 20009 Guipuzcoa, Spain. E-mail: jllop@cicbiomagune.es; Tel: +34 943 00 53 33
bRadiochemistry Platform, CIC biomaGUNE, Paseo Miramón 182, San Sebastián, 20009 Guipuzcoa, Spain
First published on 21st April 2015
Due to their high boron content and rich chemistry, dicarba-closo-dodecaboranes (carboranes) are promising building blocks for the development of drug candidates with application in Boron Neutron Capture Therapy. However, the non-invasive determination of their pharmacokinetic properties to predict therapeutic efficacy is still a challenge. Herein, we have reported the unprecedented preparation of mono-[125I] iodinated decaborane via a catalyst-assisted isotopic exchange. Subsequent reactions of the radiolabelled species with acetylenes in acetonitrile under microwave heating yield the corresponding 125I-labelled, Cc-substituted o-carboranes with good overall radiochemical yields in short reaction times. The same synthetic strategy was successfully applied to the preparation of 131I-labelled analogues, and further extension to other radioisotopes of iodine such as 124I (positron emitter) or 123I (gamma emitter) can be envisaged. Hence, the general strategy reported here is suitable for the preparation of a wide range of radiolabelled Cc-substituted o-carborane derivatives. The labelled compounds might be subsequently investigated in vivo by using nuclear imaging techniques such as Single Photon Emission Computerized Tomography or Positron Emission Tomography.
Besides presenting low or no toxicity, an ideal BNCT drug candidate should be able to deposit >20–35 μg 10B per g of tumour to secure therapeutic efficacy, and guarantee tumour-to-normal tissue and tumour-to-blood ratios greater than five to prevent damage to healthy tissue in the path of the neutron beam.2 In addition, it should ideally incorporate (or enable the straightforward incorporation of) a positron or a gamma emitter to facilitate the determination of its pharmacokinetic properties using non-invasive, in vivo imaging techniques such as Positron Emission Tomography (PET) or Single Photon Emission Computerized Tomography (SPECT), to allow candidate-by-candidate screening to predict therapeutic efficacy.
1,2-Dicarba-closo-dodecaboranes (ortho-carboranes or o-carboranes) are polyhedral clusters containing boron, hydrogen and carbon atoms and were first reported in the early 1960s simultaneously by two groups.3 The unique physico-chemical properties of o-carboranes, i.e. rigid geometry, rich derivative chemistry, thermal and chemical stability and exceptional hydrophobic character, together with their high boron content, make them suitable building blocks for the preparation of candidates for BNCT drugs.4–6 Indeed, functionalized o-carboranes have been proposed as targeted boron-rich drugs able to selectively accumulate in tumour tissue.7
Cc-selectively functionalized o-carboranes can be obtained by treatment of o-carborane with a strong base (e.g., alkyl lithium salts) and subsequent reaction with an electrophile. Unfortunately, monolithiation of o-carboranes at carbon competes unfavourably with dilithiation, leading to complex mixtures. Alternatives for the preparation of mono-substituted o-carboranes, e.g. blocking one of the Cc positions with a –Si(Me)2CMe3 (TBDMS)8 or by using dimethoxyethane as a solvent,9 have been developed. Alternatively, the reaction of decaborane‡ (B10H14) with a Lewis base to form a reactive complex (B10H12L2),10 and further reaction with an alkyne can be used for the preparation of Cc-functionalized o-carboranes. This 2-step reaction usually offers variable chemical yields and requires longer reaction times (from several hours to days) at elevated temperatures, especially in the case of hindered alkynes.3a Variants of the method including the use of ionic liquids11 and the use of metal salts to enhance the yields have been reported, with satisfactory results.12 These routes enable the preparation of a large collection of o-carborane derivatives, including BNCT drug candidates.13
Very recently, we have reported the mono-[18F]fluorination of o-carborane via nucleophilic substitution using the carboranyl iodonium salt as the precursor, and subsequent mono-functionalization at one of the Cc atoms by formation of the lithium salt and reaction with an aldehyde.14 The incorporation of the positron emitter (18F) enables external tracking after administration into living organisms using PET. Despite the usefulness and novelty of this strategy, post-radiolabelling chemical reactions and tedious work-up are required, limiting the widespread application of this methodology.
Radioiodination represents an attractive alternative to radiofluorination. The radioiodination of nido- and closo-derivatives of monocarbon carboranes,15 dodecahydro-closo-dodecaborate (2-),16nido-o-carborane17 and dicarba-nido-undecaborate18 have been reported in the literature. Here, in continuation of these previous studies, and in pursuit of a general strategy for the preparation of radiolabelled o-carboranes, we report an unprecedented strategy. Our approach relies on the preparation of radiolabelled decaborane using 125I (a radioactive isotope which decays by electron capture with a half-life of nearly 59 days) and catalytic isotopic exchange (Fig. 1).
Further reaction with alkynes using acetonitrile, which acts both as a Lewis base and as the solvent, yields the corresponding radiolabelled o-carborane derivatives in a one-pot, one-step reaction. The same synthetic strategy could be successfully translated to the preparation of analogues radiolabelled with 131I (a radioactive isotope which decays by beta and gamma emission, with a half-life of nearly 8 days). Hence, the general strategy reported here might be used for the efficient preparation of a variety of radiolabelled o-carboranes by using the same radiolabelled precursor (125I-labelled or 131I-labelled iododecaborane) and just modifying the alkyne. Notably, translation of the methodology to other positron (124I) or gamma (123I) emitters, more convenient for their use in in vivo imaging, should be straightforward.
125I-radiolabelling was carried out by adapting the previously reported palladium catalyzed iodine exchange reaction on iodinated dicarba-closo-dodecaboranes.20 Briefly, 1-iododecaborane (4.04 μmol) in toluene (100 μl) was reacted with 370 KBq (10 μCi) of Na[125I]I (solution in 0.1 M aqueous NaOH) in the presence of Hermann's catalyst (HC, 0.1 mg in 100 μl of toluene) at 100 °C for 5 min (Fig. 1). Radiochemical conversion (RCC) values, as determined by high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) using radiometric detection were 70 ± 4% (see Fig. S7A in the ESI† for an example of a chromatographic profile). Longer reaction times and higher temperature values led to a decrease in RCC, suggesting a progressive deiodination of the precursor and the labelled species in competition with the isotopic exchange reaction. The crude reaction mixture was finally purified by solid phase extraction (SPE) to remove the unreacted Na[125I]I. With this aim, the reaction mixture was diluted with water and passed through a C-18 cartridge, which was further rinsed with water. The final elution with acetonitrile (1 mL) yielded pure 1-[125I]iododecaborane in overall radiochemical yield of 58 ± 7% (see Fig. S7B† for the chromatographic profile of the purified product).
The work reported herein was first conducted with 125I, which was selected for convenience (it is widely available) and economical reasons. However, the results can be translated to other radioisotopes of iodine, more convenient for imaging studies and with shorter half-lives such as 123I (a gamma emitter with T1/2 = 13.2 h) or 124I (a positron emitter with T1/2 = 4.2 days). In order to prove the suitability of the strategy when other iodine radioisotopes were used, the same procedure was repeated but Na[131I]I (solution in 0.1 M aqueous NaOH) was used as the labelling agent. Equivalent radiochemical yields (56 ± 4%) were achieved.
In order to develop a methodology applicable to shorter lived radioisotopes of iodine (such as the above mentioned 123I and 124I) we emphasized on developing a one-pot, one-step, fast and efficient method for the reaction of 1-[125I]iododecaborane (or 1-[131I]iododecaborane) with different alkynes to obtain radiolabelled substituted o-carboranes. Generally, strategies involving Lewis bases require two steps, and hence our first attempts were performed with ionic liquids under microwave heating. Despite not previously reported in the context of the preparation of o-carboranes in ionic liquids, microwave heating was expected to significantly decrease reaction times. This was tested in model compounds using decaborane as the precursor (see Table 1). Experimentally, decaborane and the corresponding alkynes (1:
3 molar ratio) were dissolved in biphasic toluene/ionic liquid (1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride, bmimCl) in a microwave vial and heated at 140 °C under microwave irradiation for 1 minute (Fig. 2, method A). Overall yields after purification for the six compounds assayed (2–7) ranged from 68 ± 6% to 85 ± 7%, resulting in a significant reduction of the reaction time when compared to conventional heating, according to published data (Table 1).12 Unfortunately, the translation of these conditions to the preparation of 125I-and 131I-labelled analogues of compounds 2–7 resulted in low RCC values as determined by radio-HPLC (<5% in all cases). Longer reaction times (up to 20 min) only improved RCC values slightly up to 5–10%.
Compd | Alkyne | Y. ILa | Y. MeCNb | Y. CHc |
---|---|---|---|---|
a Yield obtained in this work: microwave heating, reaction time of 1 min, using ionic liquids. b Yield obtained in this work: microwave heating, reaction time of 20 min, using MeCN both as the Lewis base and solvent. c Yield reported in the literature, using ionic liquids under conventional heating (CH) with reaction time of 7 min; NR: not reported in the literature. | ||||
2 | 1-Octyne | 85 ± 7% | 75 ± 7% | 91% |
3 | Phenylacetylene | 68 ± 6% | 65 ± 4% | 71% |
4 | 1-Hexyne | 71 ± 6% | 72 ± 9% | NR |
5 | 1,8-Nonadiyne | 72 ± 6% | 71 ± 7% | 63% |
6 | 4-Ethynyltoluene | 75 ± 8% | 76 ± 3% | NR |
7 | Ethyl propiolate | 72 ± 4% | 69 ± 5% | 84 ± 4% |
In pursuit of simple alternatives applicable to the preparation of radioiodinated o-carboranes, we assayed an experimental scenario based on a one-pot, one-step, microwave-assisted synthetic route without using ionic liquids. Exploratory studies were initially conducted with non-labelled decaborane; in a typical experiment, decaborane and alkyne (1:
3 molar ratio) were dissolved in acetonitrile in a microwave vial and heated at 120 °C for 20 min under microwave irradiation (Fig. 2, method B). Excellent yields were obtained for the six alkynes assayed (65 ± 4 to 76 ± 3%, Table 1), while reaction times could be significantly decreased when compared to reported values using the conventional 2-step method (e.g., 23 h for compound 2, 10 h for compound 3).
Despite the fact that this method proved successful for the preparation of the substituted carboranes reported here, the determination of the real scope of MW-assisted formation of closo-carborane derivatives and the effect of different parameters (e.g. chemical properties of the alkynes, polarity, size, etc.) on the reaction yield and formation of by-products would require assays using a larger collection of alkynes and a more systematic analysis. Such an investigation was out of the scope of the current work.
As a proof of concept that this strategy is suitable for the preparation of radiolabelled o-carboranes, these experimental conditions were applied to the preparation of four 125I-labelled o-carboranes (Fig. 3). Experimentally, the purified labelled 1-[125I]iododecaborane was dissolved in 100 μl of acetonitrile in a 2 mL microwave vial. The corresponding alkyne (14 μmol), was added and the mixture was heated under microwave irradiation at 120 °C for 40 min. Good RCC values, as determined by radio-HPLC, were obtained (see Table 2). Subsequent purification using radio-HPLC yielded pure compounds with overall radio chemical yields (RCYs) of 22 ± 3%, 33 ± 2%, 31 ± 3% and 36 ± 4% for [125I]8, [125I]9, [125I]10 and [125I]11, respectively (Table 2). Compounds 8–11 were also prepared using 131I, with equivalent radiochemical conversion and yields. Identification of the labelled compounds was carried out by radio-HPLC and co-elution using reference standard compounds (Fig. S8–S11†).
Compound | Alkyne | RCC (%) | RCY (%) |
---|---|---|---|
[125I]8 | Phenylacetylene | 69 ± 4 | 22 ± 3 |
[125I]9 | 4-Ethynyltoluene | 89 ± 3 | 33 ± 2 |
[125I]10 | Ethyl propiolate | 84 ± 4 | 31 ± 3 |
[125I]11 | 6-Heptyn-1-yl p-toluenesulfonate | 70 ± 5 | 36 ± 4 |
It is worth mentioning that when the iodinated decaborane is used (both in radioactive and in non-radioactive conditions), the reaction with unsymmetrical acetylenes results in a mixture of two unavoidable positional isomers (see Fig. 3), with the iodine atom attached to the 9- and 12-positions. Separation of these isomers was out of the scope of this work, although it might be required for subsequent in vivo applications. This could be achieved, for example, using chiral HPLC. In addition, the values of specific activity should also be taken into consideration, as they may gain relevance when moving to in vivo studies. Because the labelling strategy relies on isotopic exchange and low amounts of radioactivity were used, the final specific activity values were estimated to be around 0.1 MBq μmol−1, taking into account that 10 μCi (0.37 MBq) of radioiodine were used to label 1 mg of 1-iododecaborane. These values may be increased significantly by using higher amounts of radioactivity.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Spectroscopic data and chromatographic profiles. See DOI: 10.1039/c5dt01049g |
‡ Decaborane is a powerful toxin affecting the central nervous system, and can be absorbed through skin. It forms an explosive mixture with carbon tetrachloride. Special precaution must be taken for its manipulation. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |