Open Access Article
Lukas
Bruder
*,
Marcel
Mudrich
and
Frank
Stienkemeier
Physikalisches Institut, Universität Freiburg, 79104 Freiburg, Germany. E-mail: lukas.bruder@physik.uni-freiburg.de
First published on 12th August 2015
Phase-modulated wave packet interferometry is combined with mass-resolved photoion detection to investigate rubidium atoms attached to helium nanodroplets in a molecular beam experiment. The spectra of atomic Rb electronic states show a vastly enhanced sensitivity and spectral resolution when compared to conventional pump–probe wave packet interferometry. Furthermore, the formation of Rb*He exciplex molecules is probed and for the first time a fully resolved vibrational spectrum for transitions between the lowest excited 5Π3/2 and the high-lying electronic states 22Π, 42Δ, 62Σ is obtained and compared to theory. The feasibility of applying coherent multidimensional spectroscopy to dilute cold gas phase samples is demonstrated in these experiments.
Likewise, precise phase control is a key issue in higher order schemes such as optical multidimensional spectroscopy.7 Several phase stabilization methods have been developed8–19 to make two-dimensional electronic spectroscopy (2DES) accessible to the visible20 and ultraviolet optical range.21 2DES has been applied to systems ranging from atomic vapors10,15 to complex molecular systems in the liquid phase22,23 and bulk semiconductor nanostructures.24 However, complementary investigations of dilute cold targets in molecular beams are yet missing.
Recently, the Marcus group has established a collinear passively phase-stabilized 2DES scheme based on continuous acousto-optic phase modulation combined with lock-in demodulation (PM2D spectroscopy).15 A variant of this technique has been implemented by the Cundiff group.17 PM2D spectroscopy has been combined with fluorescence and photocurrent detection15,17,25 and the applicability to highly dilute solutions was demonstrated.26 The signal recovery capabilities of lock-in amplification and the incorporation of incoherent observables make this approach an ideal candidate for single-molecule or molecular beam studies. Initially, the phase modulation (PM) technique was demonstrated in a WPI experiment of atomic Rb vapor using fluorescence detection (PM-WPI).27 In the current work, we combine this PM-WPI scheme with mass-resolved photoion detection to investigate a dilute molecular sample in a supersonic beam setup.
Helium nanodroplet isolation has been established as a unique technique for spectroscopic studies at millikelvin temperatures.28–30 Atoms, molecules as well as complexes or clusters can be isolated in a weakly perturbing helium environment providing an ideal matrix where the spectroscopic resolution is significantly improved; not only in comparison with experiments in room temperature solvents,31,32 but also when compared to other cryogenic matrices or clusters.33 Time-resolved experiments using femtosecond (fs) lasers34 have focused on various photodynamical processes of doped He droplets. These include vibrational WP propagation,35,36 complex formation,37,38 fragmentation dynamics,34 desorption39,40 and various aspects of energy dissipation and decoherence.41,42
Alkali metal atoms and small complexes, which are weakly bound at the surface of the droplets, were among the first species to be studied by electronic spectroscopy in He droplets.43 Upon excitation to the lowest excited P state, the enhanced interaction with helium leads to the formation of alkali–helium exciplex molecules which desorb off the droplet and can be probed in the gas phase.5,37,38,44,45 The formation dynamics has been discussed for different alkali exciplexes (Na*He, K*He, and Rb*He).38,44–47 Moreover, comparative studies using He droplets formed with the fermionic isotope 3He have been performed in order to probe the influence of superfluidity of the droplets.37
WPI experiments for the first time enabled us to access the vibrational energies of such unstable complexes.5 However, since only differences between individual vibrational levels are accessible using this technique, the assignment of vibrational states could not been done rigorously, and in particular the role of higher-lying electronic states correlating with the 5D atomic asymptote has not been included. Later, femtosecond pump–picosecond probe experiments have probed the dynamics of individual vibronic levels.38 These measurements confirmed the previous rough assignment; however the spectral resolution stayed behind the one achieved using the WPI technique. In the current work, we present a new experimental approach to study the vibronic structure of cold isolated molecular samples by PM-WPI using photoion detection. The new PM technique provides both a direct access of vibronic energies and a vastly enhanced spectral resolution, which allows us to determine a large number of contributing states. In this way the involved potentials can be accurately tested on a level beyond that of current ab initio calculations.
000.34 Doping of the He droplets with Rb atoms is achieved in a heated vapor cell which is stabilized to a temperature TRb = 358 K. At this temperature, the Rb vapor pressure is such that on average only one Rb atom is attached to each droplet. The fs laser pulses intersect the doped droplet beam perpendicularly inside the ion extraction region of a commercial quadrupole mass spectrometer (QMS). Since atoms and exciplexes tend to desorb off the droplets upon electronic excitation,40 the photo-ionized atoms and exciplexes are detected in the gas phase. Rb and Rb*He ions are resolved well separated from each other in the mass spectrum.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 Schematic illustration of the molecular beam machine. A helium cluster beam traverses differentially pumped vacuum chambers housing the droplet source, pick-up cell and detector, respectively. | ||
The formation of Rb*He molecules is based on the attractive interaction of Rb excited states with He atoms, mainly due to a missing Pauli repulsion in the nodal region of extended electron orbitals having an angular momentum of l > 0. However, a complete understanding of the formation and desorption process of metal–He exciplexes at He droplets is still missing. Different models have been discussed in order to interpret the formation of alkali–helium exciplexes and the measured time dependent signals. Tunneling processes have been modeled48–51 and direct laser-excitation of bound states in the excited pair potential has been discussed.39,47,52,53 In Fig. 2 the potentials of the relevant states for our experiment are plotted and the pump–probe scheme is illustrated by vertical arrows.
In more detail, we consider a simple system consisting of a few discrete energy eigenstates |i〉,|1〉,…,|N〉 as shown in the inset of Fig. 3. The pump pulse excites a coherent superposition of the initial state |i〉 and excited states |n〉 lying within the laser bandwidth. This WP evolves freely in time until the probe pulse excites a second WP. The interference of the two WPs induces a modulation of the excited state populations with respect to the pump–probe delay τ. Probing the excited state populations while systematically scanning τ yields a typical quantum beat signal58
![]() | (1) |
The PM-WPI approach of the Marcus group effectively extracts the pure WP interference contribution of eqn (1) by combining acousto-optic PM with lock-in demodulation. A detailed description of the PM-WPI scheme is given by Tekavec et al.27 We apply this technique in an almost identical optical setup (schematically shown in Fig. 3). Briefly, pump–probe pulse pairs of adjustable delay are generated in a Mach–Zehnder type interferometer and are collinearly superimposed afterwards. An acousto-optic modulator (AOM) is placed in each branch of the interferometer, which shifts the carrier frequency of pump and probe pulses individually by the applied acoustic frequencies, denoted Ωj, j = 1, 2. Phase-locked driving of the two AOMs thus imparts a well-defined difference frequency Ω21 = Ω2 − Ω1 onto the two-pulse intensity function of the copropagating pulses. In principle, this is equivalent to shot-to-shot phase-cycling, where the relative phase between pump and probe pulses is incremented by Δϕ = Ω21/νrep (νrep being the laser repetition rate) between each laser shot.17 Eventually, this results in excited state populations in the sample that exhibit, besides the typical quantum beat of eqn (1), an additional continuous modulation with the difference frequency of the AOMs
![]() | (2) |
| R(τ,t) = R0[1 + cos(ωMτ − Ω21t)]. | (3) |
![]() | (4) |
When comparing the outcome of a conventional WPI experiment (eqn (1)) with the outcome of a PM-WPI experiment (eqn (4)), several advantages of the latter method become obvious. In PM-WPI experiments, one measures the actual optical transition frequencies relative to the monochromator frequency, resulting in a strongly undersampled quantum beat signal. Therefore, the same information content can be inferred from a much smaller amount of sampling points. Moreover a time-delay jitter due to mechanical instabilities within the interferometer scales to a significantly less extent and the laboratory noise in general is strongly suppressed by the lock-in demodulation process. As mentioned above, the phase modulation scheme introduces shot-to-shot or dynamic phase-cycling.17 As a consequence, only pathways which imprint an Ω21-modulation in the final population state are extracted, resulting in a post-selection of all optically induced excitation pathways. In this way, solely contributions from electronic WP interference are detected, whereas contributions originating, for instance, from pure vibrational WPs are removed from the signal. More details about post-selection by phase-cycling can be found in ref. 58.
For the PM-WPI optical setup we employ a titanium:sapphire oscillator producing pulses of about 200 fs duration and 70 cm−1 spectral width (FWHM) at a repetition rate of 80 MHz. The average laser power is about 2 W at the laser exit window, leading to pulse energies of 1.7 nJ (pump) and 5.2 nJ (probe) before entering the vacuum apparatus. The laser beam is focused using a lens of 150 mm focal length, resulting in a beam diameter of 40 μm at the interaction volume. For the presented atomic Rb measurements, the monochromator is set to 12897.78 cm−1 and time domain interferograms are acquired by sampling the pump–probe delay in 30 fs steps from 0 to 50 ps while 1000 data points are averaged for each delay position. For the Rb*He exciplex measurements, the monochromator is set to 12904.15 cm−1, the pump–probe delay is scanned from −100 to 120 ps in increments of 50 fs and 1500 data points are averaged for each delay position. The QMS signal is amplified before feeding it into the lock-in amplifier. The monochromator signal is acquired using an avalanche photo diode, band-pass filtered and amplified. Signal demodulation is done with a lock-in time constant of 30 ms and 18 dB roll-off. Demodulated in-phase (X) and in-quadrature (Y) signals are acquired simultaneously to reconstruct the complex-valued amplitude Z = X + iY. A discrete Fourier transform of Z is performed after applying a Gaussian window function and zero-padding. The frequency axis of the obtained spectrum is shifted by the amount of the monochromator frequency in order to reconstruct the absolute transition frequencies. In the case of exciplex experiments, the frequency spectrum is additionally deconvoluted with the pump–probe autocorrelation function, analogous to the procedure applied in ref. 59.
Two effects are responsible for the drastic difference in signal quality achieved by the two experimental techniques. On the one hand, the PM-WPI data are measured in the rotating frame defined by the monochromator frequency, which results in strong undersampling of the quantum beat frequencies. In the conventional WPI experiment (Fig. 4(b)) the optical transition frequencies are fully sampled as shown in the inset, whereas in Fig. 4(a) the pump–probe transients are measured in the rotating frame and thus downshifted from ≈380 THz to below 3 THz (refer to the top frequency scale in Fig. 5). This significantly reduces the demands on phase stability in the optical setup. In the presented conventional WPI experiment, phase errors have been partially compensated by tracking the interferogram of a HeNe laser while scanning the pump–probe delay whereas no phase corrections have been applied in the PM scheme. Nonetheless, the latter case exhibits a drastic improvement in resolution and an excellent signal-to-noise ratio. At the same time, less data points are required to obtain the same information: the PM-WPI data set (0–50 ps pump–probe delay, 50 fs step size) comprises only 1.6% of the sampling points acquired in the fully sampled case (0–63 ps pump–probe delay, 0.6 fs step size).
On the other hand, imprinting a well-defined modulation onto the WPI signal allows utilizing efficient lock-in detection to extract weak signals from very large background contributions. This advantage of the PM method is particularly important when investigating highly dilute samples. In He droplet beam experiments, target densities are estimated to fall below 108 cm−3
34 which usually puts a severe constraint on the achievable signal-to-noise ratio; the lock-in amplification in the PM scheme, however, provides great background suppression.
A Fourier transform of the pump–probe transient yields a fully resolved vibrational spectrum of the exciplex molecule (Fig. 6) with a spectral resolution of 0.3 cm−1 (FWHM). Comparing the spectral lines with the position of the 5P3/2 → 5D5/2,3/2 atomic Rb transitions (black dashed lines), an intuitive interpretation is possible: the closely spaced spectral lines in the vicinity of the atomic transitions involve mainly vibrational modes energetically close to the dissociation limits. Lines at larger frequencies correspond to transitions of lower lying vibrational modes in the 12Π3/2 electronic state and the line splitting originates from the congestion of the higher-lying PECs.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 6 Rb*He exciplex spectrum obtained from PM-WPI (black) and fs pump ps probe (red) measurements.38 Relative transition frequencies inferred from conventional WPI5 are also shown (blue scale on top). Black dashed lines indicate the 5P3/2 → 5D5/2,3/2 atomic Rb transitions. In the PM-WPI spectrum, one peak originating from the laboratory noise appears at the employed monochromator frequency (asterisk). | ||
Let us compare our data with previous photoionization studies of the Rb*He exciplex. In a conventional WPI experiment5 the signal quality was not sufficient to deduce the absolute transition frequencies through a direct Fourier analysis; relative distances between vibrational levels were deduced instead. To compare with our PM-WPI results, we assign the relative frequencies obtained in ref. 5 to the distances between spectral features in our study (Fig. 6, blue scale on top). We find good agreement albeit our spectrum exhibits a factor 10 better resolution and allows a more unambiguous interpretation. A different approach for achieving vibrationally resolved data on Rb*He exciplex molecules has been pursued in a femtosecond pump–picosecond probe experiment.38 This study provided absolute transition frequencies although at the cost of resolution which is factor 30 lower than that achieved in our measurement. After applying a red shift of 2 cm−1 to the corresponding data (red spectrum in Fig. 6) good agreement with our spectrum is obtained despite the different measurement schemes. The systematic shift can be attributed to coarse calibration of the pulse shaper that was used to generate the ps probe pulses. Calibration errors in the PM-WPI data can be excluded since calibration measurements with a Rb vapor cell have been carried out regularly during the measurements.
Previously, two types of dynamics have been observed when forming Rb*He exciplexes on the surface of He droplets. On the one hand, a fast process on the few ps timescale is observed5 which can be attributed to an impulsive response of the He droplet environment to the electronic excitation of the Rb atom. On the other hand, slow relaxation of vibrational modes on the ns timescale is observed and attributed to slow vibrational dephasing induced by the droplet environment.38Fig. 7 shows the time-domain data of the Rb*He exciplex obtained in our experiment. The absolute value of the complex-valued pump–probe transient is shown in (a); recorded (undersampled) quantum beats are enlarged in the inset. The pronounced exaggeration of the ion yield around the zero pump–probe delay (a narrow spike in Fig. 7(a)) is due to the temporal overlap of pump and probe pulses. Outside of this region, a fast decay of the ion yield within 1.5 ps is visible (a shoulder in Fig. 7(a)) which is in accordance with the observed dynamics in ref. 5. In order to make the time evolution of the most prominent spectral features directly accessible, a spectrogram representation of the time domain data obtained by short-time Fourier analysis (Gaussian window function of 4 ps FWHM, 0.5 ps step size) is shown in Fig. 7(b). The short-time Fourier transform results, however, in a temporal blurring. Thus the discussed fast decay is not observable in Fig. 7(b) but several beat features originating from closely spaced spectral lines are well resolved. Traces along these beats indicate a slow relaxation presumably on the ns timescale (not shown), which is in accordance with the results of ref. 38. However, a longer time window is needed to provide a reliable interpretation in our data.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 8 Experimental Rb*He exciplex spectrum compared with calculations based on the potentials of Pascale.52 The five upper panels show the calculated FCFs for transitions from the 12Π3/2 lower potential separately to each higher-lying potential (label). Adding up all five spectra yields the red spectrum in the bottom panel, which is compared to the experimental data (black). Transitions have been convoluted with a Gaussian of 0.3 cm−1 and blue shifted by 4 cm−1. For simplicity only most prominent peaks are labeled. | ||
The exciplex spectrum has also been calculated including rotational transitions, which yielded much poorer agreement with the experiment (not shown). Thus, rotational features seem to be missing in our measurement despite the fact that our spectral resolution is sufficiently high to reveal those. We assume that rotations are not observed because of efficient cooling by the He droplet environment. This is in accordance with previous vibronic WPI measurements of Rb dimers formed on the surface of He droplets, which also lacked spectroscopic signatures of rotational transitions.42
The combination of the PM approach with mass-resolved photoion detection allows us to specifically probe Rb*He exciplexes formed at the He droplet surface upon laser excitation. We achieve a significant enhancement of the signal-to-noise ratio and an excellent resolution when compared to other experiments on the same system. The WPI data reveals a fully resolved vibrational spectrum for transitions between the 5Π3/2 and the 22Π, 42Δ, 62Σ electronic states. A comparison with a spectrum from the diatomic potentials of Pascale clearly demonstrates that the experimental data are well suited to test fine details of pair interaction potentials. So far for the Rb*He molecule there is no set of potentials available to reproduce the details provided by the experiment and we expect our results to stimulate the development of more accurate potentials.
We note that our experiments provide a new and very promising perspective for applying coherent multidimensional spectroscopy to dilute supersonic beams. Particularly the unique capabilities of synthesizing tailor-made complexes in He droplets combined with two-dimensional spectroscopy could provide new insight into fundamental photophysical and photochemical processes.
| This journal is © the Owner Societies 2015 |