Yuliya E.
Silina
ab,
Claudia
Fink-Straube
a,
Heiko
Hayen
c and
Dietrich A.
Volmer
*b
aLeibniz Institute for New Materials (INM), Saarbrücken, Germany
bInstitute of Bioanalytical Chemistry, Saarland University, D-66123 Saarbrücken, Germany. E-mail: Dietrich.Volmer@mx.uni-saarland.de; Fax: +49 681 302 2963; Tel: +49 681 302 3433
cInstitute of Inorganic and Analytical Chemistry, University of Münster, Münster, Germany
First published on 19th March 2015
In this study, we propose a simple and rapid technique for characterization of free fatty acids and triacylglycerides (TAG) based on palladium nanoparticular (Pd-NP) surface-assisted laser desorption/ionization (SALDI) mass spectrometry (MS). The implemented Pd-NP material allowed detection of free fatty acids and TAGs exclusively as [M + K]+ ions in positive ion mode. Under negative ionization conditions, unusual trimetric structures were generated for free fatty acids, while TAGs underwent irreproducible degradation reactions. Importantly, the mass spectra obtained from Pd-NP targets in positive ion mode were very clean without interferences from matrix-derived ions in the low m/z range and readily enabled the detection of intact TAGs in vegetable oils without major fragmentation reactions as compared to conventional MALDI-MS, requiring only a minimal amount of sample preparation.
MALDI-MS offers several advantages for analysis of lipids, including simple and fast sample preparation, and the ability to analyze samples without prior derivatization. MALDI measurements, however, suffer from interferences of matrix peaks in the low m/z range (in particularly for m/z < 500), sweet spot phenomena, and poor reproducibility from lack of homogeneity of matrix/sample crystals.33–35 These problems can be potentially minimized or avoided by using ‘matrix-free’ LDI using inorganic substrates (surface-assisted laser desorption/ionization, SALDI32) instead of organic MALDI matrices. In SALDI, analyte molecules are desorbed and ionized upon laser irradiation from materials such as inorganic nanostructured substrates; MS subsequently analyzes the formed ions. The substrate is involved in the transfer of charge to the analyte and supports desorption/ionization, usually producing singly-charged ions with a little or no fragmentation.32 In addition, SALDI-MS is highly tolerant of the presence of salts, making analysis of untreated samples (e.g. diluted vegetable oils) readily possible. Moreover SALDI-MS can be used for determination of analytes that are poorly ionized in MALDI, for example, free fatty acids, which often require auxiliary reagents (e.g. alkali salts)1 or chemical derivatization.35
We have previously reported on the application of palladium-based nanoparticles for SALDI-MS of low molecular weight compounds, in particular on physicochemical parameters involved in ion formation; for example, conductivity, absorbance, ability to dissipate laser energy, melting effects, and surface disorders.36–38
In this study, we extend the application of Pd-NP materials to demonstrate the proof-of-principle for quantitative determination of fatty acids and TAGs in different vegetable oil samples. As will be shown, there are two general advantages of our approach over MALDI methods: (1) the technique generally provides only [M + K]+ ions, whereas MALDI can generate multiple species for each analyte (e.g. [M + H]+, [M + Na]+ and [M + K]+). This is important as the entire ion current is focused into one species, which increases sensitivity in quantitative application using, for example, selected ion monitoring (SIM) or selected reaction monitoring (SRM) on triple quadrupole mass spectrometers. Equally, unknown compounds can be confidently assigned a molecular weight in profiling, fingerprinting or metabolomics applications. (2) Our approach avoids the usual decompositions seen with TAGs, which are believed to be catalyzed by protons and has lead to significant “diacylglyceride (DAG) like” fragments. In our approach, this decomposition occurs only to a minor extent, thus improving diagnostic information in the higher mass TAG region of the spectra.
This outcome was very different from the negative ion mass spectra seen in DIOS-MS of fatty acids reported by Budimir et al., who reported deprotonated molecules as base peaks and additional, lower abundant cationized multimers, namely [2(M − H) + Na]− dimers and [3M − 2H + K]− trimers.42,43 In their work, the authors also observed selective coordination of Ag+ to give dimeric aggregates of the composition [2(M − H) + Ag]− after addition of AgTFA to the samples, while the trimers remained as [3M − 2H + K]− species.
MS/MS analysis of the [3M + 3H2O − H]− ions from our experiments provided exclusively the free fatty acids in the CID spectra (Fig. 2), even at very low ion activation energies, indicating only weak interactions within the trimer aggregate structures.
Budimir et al. also described heterodimers and heterotrimers for mixtures of fatty acids in their experiments; we detected these heterotrimers in experiments with fatty acid mixtures (Fig. 3a), but did not see any monomers or dimers from Pd-NP SALDI spectra in the entire investigated concentration range of up to 5 μg per spot.
Importantly, the [3M + 3H2O − H]− species were formed regardless of the investigated solvents the fatty acids were dissolved in (and then spotted onto the SALDI substrates); namely CHCI3, n-hexane, THF, or methanol. This observation suggests a direct involvement of the Pd material in the aggregation process and that analyte hydration originated during desorption/ion formation on the Pd substrate. McAlpin et al. have demonstrated that Lewis acid/base interactions between cation/anion pairs of metal oxides (MgO, ZnO, NiO, Fe2O3) and analytes can result in chemical transformation (transesterification/hydrolysis) of fatty acids in negative detection mode of metal oxide laser ionization (MOLI) mass spectrometry.44 The electroplated Pd material used in our experiments also contained oxygen as shown from Raman analysis of the Pd-NP film (Fig. S2, ESI†). Ion formation based on Lewis acid/base interactions as described by McAlpin et al.44 probably did not solely explain the ion formation in our experiments, however, because the almost exclusive formation of water trimers was only seen for galvanic Pd-NP, but not for a comparable PdO-NP material, which we generated from galvanic Pd-NP by heating the substrate in an air atmosphere at 400 °C for 3 h (see Experimental section).36 In the latter case, ion formation shifted almost entirely to deprotonated molecules with only low abundant residual [3M + 3H2O − H]− ions in the spectra, which may have been the result of remaining Pd-NP in the PdO-NP material. Rather, we propose that embedded/adsorbed water in the Pd-NP material was supplied during desorption/ion formation from electroplated Pd-NP to give [3M + 3H2O − H]−. This water was likely almost entirely removed from the substrate during heating to give PdO-NP, and that was probably the reason for the absence of water trimers from the PdO substrate and almost sole formation of [M − H]− ions (Fig. 3b). The role of adsorbed water, analyte acidity and terminal –OH groups was previously shown by Chen et al. for porous graphite and silicon substrates, suggesting a dominant role of the substrate's surface chemistry (hydrogen bonds, van der Waals interactions) during ion formation.45
Furthermore, a similar galvanic procedure that we used for synthesis of Ag-NP films gave substrates that generated exactly the same anion species for fatty acids (Fig. S3, ESI†).36 SALDI mass spectra obtained from electroplated Pd-NP exhibited higher signal intensities for anions and less chemical background than Ag-NP, however, which was probably due to the lower thermal conductivity of Pd.36–38
For the analytical application of Pd-NP, it was important that the [M + K]+ ion signals for all fatty acids were linear over almost five orders of magnitude (5–10000 ng mL−1) with coefficients of determination (R2) between 0.942 and 0.996 in positive ion mode (Table S1, ESI†). Fatty acid anions (using the described [3M + 3H2O − H]− trimers) were detected with similar absolute ion currents, but slightly less good correlation in the same range, with R2 values between 0.924 and 0.960 (Table S1†). Importantly, the observed exclusive formation of [M + K]+ ions from Pd-NP materials in positive ion mode, regardless of the analytes' chemical structures36–38 is a significant advantage for quantitative measurements in the multiple reaction monitoring (MRM) mode of triple quadrupole mass spectrometers as the ion current is focused into one species only and not distributed over multiple ions, as often seen in MALDI or electrospray ionization (e.g. simultaneous [M + H]+, [M + Na]+ and [M + K]+ formation); as well molecular weight assignments are less ambiguous for unknown compounds is discovery applications.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 SALDI mass spectra of TAG standards in positive ion mode: (a) tripalmitin (PPP, 30 ng μL−1); (b) triolein (OOO, 10 μg mL−1). (Laser fluence, 45%.) |
As observed for fatty acid standards above, [M + K]+ ions were formed for the major TAG components in the oil samples in positive ion mode, as well as minor signals for “DAG-like” (see below for definition) fragment ions at m/z 575, 601 and 603 (Fig. 5). Importantly, the Pd-NP-assisted LDI material generated mostly the intact TAG species without major fragmentation, as opposed to MALDI, where extensive fragmentation was seen for TAG species22 (Fig. S4 shows an example of a MALDI-MS analysis of cold-extracted olive oil in our experiments, showing extensive formation of “DAG-like” fragments from protonated precursor ions; see ESI†). Gidden et al. demonstrated47 for sodiated TAGs that fragmentation levels in MALDI could be strongly reduced by adding base to the sample/matrix, to remove catalyzing H+ ions form the matrix and preventing formation of protonated TAGs. The “DAG-like” fragments as described by Gidden et al.47 corresponded to losses of RCOOH and RCOONa from the protonated and sodiated TAGs, giving rise to ions in the m/z range of 573 to 627. Similar decompositions were seen by Calvano et al. for TAGs in LDI-TOF.31 In Pd-NP-assisted LDI in our experiments, only minor fragments in the same region were formed from losses of RCOOK (Fig. 5).
An intense cluster region of TAGs between m/z 895 and 925 was seen in our SALDI experiments (Fig. 5 and Table 1). Characteristic olive oil species were represented mostly by triolein (OOO, m/z 923) and OLL (m/z 919; Fig. 5). For rapeseed oil, a significant amount of TAG 54:
3 (m/z 923.3), 54
:
4 (m/z 921.3), 54
:
5 (m/z 919.3) (Table 1) was measured, while sunflower oil exhibited mainly TAG 54
:
5, 54
:
6, 54
:
4, 54
:
2.
Oil | SALDI positive ion mode | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
[M + K]+ (m/z) | TAG | Relative abundance (%) | LDI comparisonc (%) | |
a Only those TAGs are shown that were previously reported by LDI-TOF measurements.46 b “DAG-like” fragments as defined in ref. 47; L = linoleic acid, O = oleic acid. c As reported in ref. 46 for LDI-TOF (Na+ adducts) as compared to Pd-NP SALDI (K+ adducts). | ||||
Olive (I) cold extraction | 575.5 | TAG 30![]() ![]() |
9 | — |
577.5 | TAG 30![]() ![]() |
36 | 25 | |
601.6 | LLb | 11 | 15 | |
603.6 | LOb | 54 | 46 | |
897.7 | TAG 52![]() ![]() |
45 | 53 | |
923.7 | TAG 54![]() ![]() |
100 | 73 | |
925.7 | TAG 54![]() ![]() |
63 | 19 | |
Frying (II) olive | 899.3 | TAG 52![]() ![]() |
25 | |
897.3 | TAG 52![]() ![]() |
58 | ||
895.3 | TAG 52![]() ![]() |
20 | ||
919.3 | TAG 54![]() ![]() |
27 | ||
923.3 | TAG 54![]() ![]() |
100 | ||
925.3 | TAG 54![]() ![]() |
62 | ||
Rapeseed (III) cold extraction | 603.6 | LOb | 22 | |
893.3 | TAG 52![]() ![]() |
18 | ||
895.3 | TAG 52![]() ![]() |
23 | ||
897.3 | TAG 52![]() ![]() |
24 | ||
919.3 | TAG 54![]() ![]() |
82 | ||
921.3 | TAG 54![]() ![]() |
90 | ||
923.3 | TAG 54![]() ![]() |
100 | ||
925.3 | TAG 54![]() ![]() |
36 | ||
Rapeseed (IV) refined | 893.3 | TAG 52![]() ![]() |
32 | |
895.3 | TAG 52![]() ![]() |
24 | ||
919.3 | TAG 54![]() ![]() |
59 | ||
921.3 | TAG 54![]() ![]() |
79 | ||
923.3 | TAG 54![]() ![]() |
100 | ||
925.3 | TAG 54![]() ![]() ![]() |
46 | ||
Sunflower (V) cold extraction | 601.3 | LLb | 9 | 56 |
603.3 | LOb | 7 | 36 | |
895.3 | TAG 52![]() ![]() |
32 | 18 | |
897.3 | TAG 52![]() ![]() |
33 | 11 | |
917.3 | TAG 54![]() ![]() |
82 | 38 | |
919.3 | TAG 54![]() ![]() |
100 | 52 | |
921.7 | TAG 54![]() ![]() |
72 | 47 | |
925.3 | TAG 54![]() ![]() |
42 | 9 | |
Sunflower (VI) refined | 893.7 | TAG 52![]() ![]() |
34 | |
895.7 | TAG 52![]() ![]() |
27 | ||
917.7 | TAG 54![]() ![]() |
96 | ||
919.7 | TAG 54![]() ![]() |
100 | ||
921.7 | TAG 54![]() ![]() |
59 | ||
923.7 | TAG 54![]() ![]() |
28 |
FFAs (C18:
0–C18
:
3) were seen in cold extracted olive (I), rapeseed (III) and sunflower oils (V). No FFAs were detected in refined oils, as expected, as FFAs should not be present at significant levels in refined oils. Therefore, fortified refined oil samples were used to demonstrate the quantitative abilities of the SALDI assay for determination of FFAs. Several FFAs were added to refined rapeseed oils in the concentration range from 0.5 to 2% (Table 2). The obtained response behavior was linear in the investigated range, with precision values <15%, demonstrating that, in principle, SALDI-MS could be used for FFA quantification from oil samples.
FFA | Linearity | LOD (%) | Precision (RSD, %) | Recoverya | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
[M + K]+m/z | y = ax + b | R 2 | Added (%) | Found (%) | |||
a Shown for 2% (w/w) addition to rapeseed oil. | |||||||
C18![]() ![]() |
321 | y = 2083x − 64.5 | 0.997 | 0.2 | 6 | 2.0 | 1.79 ± 0.03 |
C18![]() ![]() |
319 | y = 4452x − 95.2 | 0.998 | 0.2 | 12 | 2.0 | 1.86 ± 0.05 |
C18![]() ![]() |
317 | y = 1652x + 89.5 | 0.992 | 0.2 | 14 | 2.0 | 1.98 ± 0.08 |
The compositions of TAG species for the various investigated oils as compared to typical levels from matrix free (LDI-TOF-MS) experiments are summarized in Table 1. As only a small number of oil samples was investigated here, no systematic comparison and interpretation of TAG distributions was attempted. Variations of TAGs as well as the simultaneous measurements of other components of the oil (e.g. phytosterols) may allow the described SALDI method to be used to detect adulterations of oil samples.48,49
We believe that the methodology shown in this study is a promising technique for determining distributions of biological molecules from complex samples without requiring extensive sample preparation. Potential future applications include the profiling of metabolites in metabolomics applications.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c5ay00705d |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2015 |