Miguel A.
Laguna-Bercero
*a,
Amir R.
Hanifi
b,
Hernán
Monzón
a,
Joshua
Cunningham
b,
Thomas H.
Etsell
b and
Partha
Sarkar
c
aInstituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Aragón (ICMA), CSIC- Universidad de Zaragoza, C/ Pedro Cerbuna 12, E-50009, Zaragoza, Spain. E-mail: malaguna@unizar.es
bDepartment of Chemical & Materials Engineering, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta T6G 2V4, Canada
cEnvironment & Carbon Management, Alberta Innovates – Technology Futures, Edmonton, Alberta T6N 1E4, Canada
First published on 6th May 2014
Nd2NiO4+δ infiltrated into porous yttria stabilized zirconia (YSZ) is proposed in this work as a cathode for solid oxide fuel cells (SOFCs). In order to obtain nickelate single phase, calcination times and temperatures of the salt precursors are studied. Anode supported microtubular cells using this cathode are fabricated and characterized, showing power densities of about 0.76 W cm−2 at 800 °C and a voltage as high as 0.8 V. No degradation is detected after 24 hours under current load, assuring reasonable stability of the cell. Preliminary solid oxide electrolysis cell (SOEC) results show slightly better performances in comparison with SOFC operation. It is believed that infiltration of nickelate salt precursors followed by calcination proposed in this work avoids high temperature sintering of the nickelate phase with the electrolyte and as a consequence, prevents their reaction. For this reason, infiltrated nickelates are very attractive for their use as intermediate temperature (IT) SOFC cathodes.
From all these families, the nickelates Ln2NiO4+δ, with Ln = Nd, La or Pr, have been widely investigated.7 For example, Mauvy et al. studied the electrochemical behaviour of nickelate-type cathodes and concluded that the Nd-derivative would present the best performance.9 This material has been also proposed as an oxygen electrode for SOEC applications.10 The phase presenting the highest oxygen diffusion parameters is Pr2NiO4+δ (PNO).11 The main drawback of these nickelate phases is their reactivity with standard YSZ or GDC electrolytes. For example, a significant reaction was observed between La2NiO4+δ (LNO) and GDC (gadolinia doped ceria) at 900 °C with the formation of the higher order Ruddlesden-Popper phases.12 Similar results were found by Amow et al. on cobalt doped LNO and GDC composites.13 In addition, Montenegro-Hernández et al.14 studied the chemical compatibility of Ln2NiO4+δ (Ln = La, Pr, Nd) with both GDC and YSZ electrolyte materials, showing that La2NiO4+δ reacts with both YSZ and GDC above 900 and 700 °C, respectively; the Pr-derivative showed inconclusive results due to Pr2NiO4+δ decomposition; and finally the Nd-derivate reacts with both YSZ and GDC at about 1000 °C. From all the literature data we can conclude that, although IT-SOFCs are intended to be used at temperatures below 800 °C, the use of the nickelates as SOFC electrodes is very limited, as typical sintering temperatures are usually higher than 1000 °C in order to get strong adhesion at the electrode/electrolyte interface and also a suitable microstructure.
In order to avoid sintering the nickelate phase with the electrolyte and, as a consequence avoid their reaction, infiltration of nickelate salt precursors followed by calcination is proposed in this work. Infiltration is found to be an efficient technique for high performing electrode fabrication in SOFCs. It is carried out in order to improve the catalytic activity and/or increase the ionic or electronic conductivity in fuel cell anodes and/or cathodes. While the fine dispersed infiltrate particles enhance the catalytic activity, the connected nano-sized particles (which have a high surface area) introduce conduction pathways and can lower the cell resistance and thereby improve the electrochemical performance. This process enables reduction of the cell operating temperature and thus improvement in the long term stability of the cells.15–19 For example, it is possible to modify the microstructure of a conventional LSM-YSZ composite oxygen electrode by infiltrating LSM nanoparticles in order to increase the electrical performance of the cell.20–23
One of the advantages of this fabrication method is an increased TPB (triple-phase boundary) length compared with the standard LSM–YSZ composite due to the smaller size of the dispersed LSM particles with a higher surface area. In addition, no sintering process for the LSM cathode is needed and, as a consequence, formation of non-conducting secondary phases such as La2Zr2O7 and also coarsening of the catalyst during sintering will be eliminated.
Remarkable results against anode thermal and redox cycling were demonstrated by Hanifi et al. by infiltrating Ni–SDC nanoparticles into the anode support.24 They showed that after 100 thermal and 10 redox (with air purging as anode oxidant) cycling tests, the cell showed extremely high resistance to both thermal and redox cycling as confirmed by unaltered OCV values and a crack free anode and electrolyte microstructure confirmed by SEM analysis. Infiltration of Ruddlesden-Popper materials into YSZ porous structures was first proposed by Choi et al.25 They fabricated Lan+1NinO3n+1 (n = 1, 2, 3)-YSZ composites as cathodes for planar SOFCs, obtaining maximum power densities of 0.717, 0.754 and 0.889 W cm−2 at 750 °C for La2NiO4, La3Ni2O7 and La4Ni3O10, respectively.
The selected configuration for the present study is the microtubular geometry (mT-SOFC), as they have recently attracted much interest due to their superior resistance to thermal cycling, shorter start-up/shut-down times and higher volumetric power densities in comparison with the traditional planar geometry.26–28 Results including the fabrication of the cell and infiltration processes, microstructural and structural analysis, as well as electrochemical studies will be described.
For infiltration of the Nd2NiO4+δ (NNO) phase, YSZ (calcined at 1500 °C, milled for 72 h in water and dried) was mixed with 20 vol% graphite, dispersant (Menhaden fish oil), azeotropic solvent (toluene/ethanol) and binder (polyvinyl butyral). The components were mixed at 300 rpm for 1 h in a planetary mill prior to coating. The mixture was then applied to the sintered electrolyte by briefly dip coating. The tube was heat treated at 300 °C and 700 °C for 1 h to burn off the organic components and graphite and sintered at 1350 °C for 3 h to form a thin porous layer of about 35 μm in thickness.
In order to infiltrate Nd–nickelate into the porous support, 0.73 g Ni(NO3)2·6H2O and 2.19 g Nd(NO3)3·6H2O were mixed with 0.3 g of a polymeric dispersant (Triton X-45, Union Carbide Chemicals and Plastics Co. Inc.) and 1 g water. The mixture was heat treated at 100 °C to give a high viscosity, concentrated solution. The viscous solution drops were placed on the surface of the thin porous YSZ layer. The tube was then dried at 120 °C for 15 minutes then heat treated at 350 °C for 15 minutes to co-precipitate the NiO and Nd2O3. The infiltration procedure was repeated four times to deposit sufficient infiltrated particles into the YSZ matrix.
To calculate the open porosity of the porous YSZ layer (prior to cathode infiltration), a 3 mm disk was cast (with the same recipe used for the porous YSZ layer) and sintered at 1350 °C for 3 h. A density measurement was carried out on the disk applying Archimedes principle showing 50 vol% open porosity for the disk with a similar microstructure and porosity to that of the porous YSZ layer. By measuring the weight of the anode support, electrolyte and the coated thin porous YSZ layer during cell fabrication, the volume of the infiltrate in the YSZ structure was calculated based on the weight gain of the cathode following infiltration taking into account the density of YSZ and the Nd2NiO4+δ.
In order to track the phase evolution following calcination between 800–1000 °C, similar Nd–nickelate recipes as explained above were prepared in separate porcelain crucibles and each batch was heat treated at a specific temperature. The active surface area of the cathodes was 1.1 cm2.
XRD patterns of the cathode samples were directly collected over the surface of the tubes using CuKα radiation in a D-Max Rigaku instrument. The percentages were calculated based on the intensity ratios among the main peaks for each phase. SEM analysis was carried out on polished transverse cross-section samples using a Merlin field emission SEM (Carl Zeiss, Germany). Electrochemical studies were performed using a potentiostat/galvanostat/FRA analyzer (Princeton Applied Research, Oak Ridge, USA) at temperatures between 600 °C and 800 °C using RT humidified pure hydrogen at the fuel electrode (QT = 100 sccm) and 20% oxygen/80% nitrogen (QT = 100 sccm) at the oxygen electrode site. Excess hydrogen was used in order to avoid concentration polarization at high current densities. Fuel utilization was about 10%. Electrical connections were made using four platinum wires. Ni foam was used as current collector on the fuel electrode side (inner side of the tube) and Au paste (Metalor) as the current collector on the oxygen electrode side. j–V (current density–voltage) measurements were recorded in galvanodynamic mode from OCV down to 0.5 V at a scan rate of 2.5 mA cm−2 s−1. Hydrogen consumption was analyzed using a gas chromatograph (Agilent Technologies MicroGC 900). Measured values corresponded to those predicted by Faraday's law. AC impedance measurements were recorded in galvanostatic mode using a sinusoidal signal amplitude of 20 mA over the frequency range of 500 kHz down to 0.1 Hz. Details of the experimental set-up can be found elsewhere30–32
Fig. 1 SEM images showing the interface between the YSZ electrolyte and porous YSZ infiltrated with the Nd–nickelate recipe. |
Calcination temperature (°C) | NiO (%) | Nd2O3 (%) | NdNiO3 (%) | Nd2NiO4 (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|
800 | 16.5 | 49.5 | 34.0 | — |
900 | 7.0 | 65.0 | — | 28.0 |
1000 | 10.0 | 26.0 | — | 64.0 |
However, a more detailed study (longer calcination times or even higher calcination temperatures) is needed in order to minimize and/or avoid the individual nickel and neodymium oxides, as we suspect this could further enhance the performance of the cathodes. In addition, to study the compatibility of the NNO infiltrated with YSZ, XRD patterns were also directly collected over the surface of infiltrated tubes calcined at temperatures from 800 to 950 °C for two hours. It is also notable that no secondary phases such as the Nd2Zr2O7 insulating phase were detected under these conditions.
As the cathode of cell A presents a mixture of phases, an analogue cell (cell B) was also tested after previous in situ annealing at 950 °C for 12 hours. This annealing was performed in an effort to produce a pure Nd2NiO4 phase at the cathode. However, the performance of the cell after annealing was poorer than the first cell, with maximum power densities of about 0.6 W cm−2 at 800 °C obtained. As a consequence, no further studies were performed using cell B, and further electrochemical results will refer to cell A.
Fig. 4 Nyquist plots for cell A collected under OCV conditions at (a) 600 °C, 650 °C, 700 °C and (b) 750 °C and 800 °C. |
Based on previous literature, the model proposed in this work contemplates five different major contributions to the whole cell impedance, consisting of an ohmic resistance (Re), two resistance-constant phase elements (R1CPE1) and (R2CPE2), and two finite length Warburg diffusion elements (W3 and W4). These elements account, respectively, for the electrolyte and lateral conduction through electrodes (Re), cathode charge transfer (R1CPE1), anode charge transfer (R2CPE2), and gas diffusion through the cathode (W3) and anode (W4). Although this model was previously proposed and validated for similar mT Ni–YSZ/YSZ/LSM–YSZ cells,37 the present assignation is still tentative due to the complexity of the system. As expected, both ohmic and electrode polarization are thermally activated. First a small contribution (R1CPE1) appears at frequencies around 20–25 kHz and the capacitance values are in the range of ∼10−4 F cm−2 (almost unaltered with temperature), associated with oxygen ions transferring through the electrolyte/cathode interface, as previously reported by Mauvy et al.9 The second contribution (R2CPE2) appears at around 1–5 kHz and based on previous studies was tentatively associated with anode charge transfer. The third contribution, also relatively small (W3), was attributed to gas diffusion within the porous cathode. The last contribution presents summit frequency values of around 6 Hz that seems to be temperature independent. As we are using an anode porous support, it is reasonable to assign this contribution to gas diffusion at the anode, in concordance with previous results.29
In addition, EIS spectra were also recorded under current load (200 mA) at 600 °C and the only clear conclusion in which we can be reasonably confident is that under those conditions all the polarization components decreased. However, due to the difficulty of introducing a reference electrode and also due to the limitation of the model, it was not possible to present detailed information about cathode and anode overpotentials. Detailed studies as a function of the partial pressures at both the anode and cathode are needed in order to fully understand the different processes taking place in the cell.
Fig. 5 (a) Chronopotentiometry at 0.7 V and 600 °C for cell A; (inset) j–V curves before and after the chronopotentiometric study. |
Fig. 7 XRD pattern of Cell A and Cell B cathodes following heat treatment at 800 and 950 °C, respectively. Pt peaks are due to the current collector. |
The difference between the XRD patterns of the Nd–nickelate nitrate salt recipe (Fig. 2) and that of the cathode (Fig. 7) are associated with the presence of YSZ in the cathode. While formation of the Nd2NiO4 phase is enhanced at temperatures above 800 °C in the Nd–nickelate recipe (due to improved reaction of NiO and Nd2O3), it appears that the Nd–nickelate reacts with YSZ from the cathode and forms the undesired Nd2Zr2O7 phase. As previously shown in Section 3.2, annealing at 950 °C for shorter times (2 hours) does not lead to Nd2NiO4 decomposition. However, longer annealing times at 950 °C (12 hours) confirmed that Nd2NiO4 reacts with YSZ to form Nd2Zr2O7. Therefore, it seems that the ideal temperature for heat treatment of the infiltrated cathode should be between 800–850 °C using longer annealing times.
Post-mortem SEM observations are also consistent with XRD analysis. In Fig. 8 we can observe two polished transverse-cross sections of cells A and B. Both images were taken at low kV using an InLens detector in order to increase the contrast of the conductive phases. Anodes of both samples present a homogenous distribution of Ni particles. If we observe the cathode, cell A (Fig. 8a) presents a homogeneous distribution of conductive particles (due to the Nd2NiO4 and the Nd2O3 phases). However, conductive species can only be observed on top of the cathode for cell B (Fig. 8b) as there are no conductive phases at the cathode/electrolyte interface, due to the formation of the insulating Nd2Zr2O7 phase, previously detected by XRD analysis. Finally, Fig. 8c shows the microstructure at the NNO/YSZ cathode of cell A after operation. The fine particles of Nd–nickelate still show great connectivity and no apparent grain growth, in concordance with the short-term electrochemical results. Further experiments are also needed in order to understand the influence of the minority cathode Nd2O3 and NiO phases on the electrochemical behaviour of the cell.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2014 |