Hyuk-Tae Kwona,
Jae-Hun Kimb,
Ki-Joon Jeonc and
Cheol-Min Park*ad
aSchool of Materials Science and Engineering, Kumoh National Institute of Technology, Gumi, Gyeongbuk 730-701, Republic of Korea. E-mail: cmpark@kumoh.ac.kr; Fax: +82-54-478-7769; Tel: +82-54-478-7746
bSchool of Advanced Materials Engineering, Kookmin University, Seoul 136-702, Republic of Korea
cDepartment of Environmental Engineering, Inha University, 100 Inha-ro, Nam-gu, Incheon 402-751, Republic of Korea
dOutstanding Research Group Program, Convergence Technology Research Institute, Kumoh National Institute of Technology, Gumi, Gyeongbuk 730-701, Republic of Korea
First published on 5th September 2014
CoxP binary compounds, CoP and Co2P, were synthesized using simple solid-state synthetic routes, and their potential as anode materials for Li-ion batteries was investigated. Electrochemical Li reactivity was possible on the CoP electrode, whereas the Co2P electrode did not react with Li. The electrochemically driven partial recombination reaction of the CoP electrode was thoroughly demonstrated using ex situ X-ray diffraction and extended X-ray absorption fine structure analyses. To enhance the electrochemical performances of CoP, its carbon-modified nanocomposite was prepared. The nanocomposite consisted of well-dispersed CoP (active with Li) and Co2P (inactive with Li) nanocrystallites, as well as amorphous P within the amorphous carbon matrix. The partially disproportionated CoP/C nanocomposite electrode exhibited good electrochemical performance with a high initial charge capacity of 531 mA h g−1 (or 855 mA h cm−3), a cycling durability of 407 mA h g−1 (or 655 mA h cm−3) over 200 cycles, a good initial coulombic efficiency of ca. 75%, and a fast rate capability (2C: 435 mA h g−1, 3C: 410 mA h g−1).
| Insertion (addition) reaction: MxPy + zLi → LizMxPy | (1) |
| Conversion reaction: MxPy + 3Li → yLi3P + xM | (2) |
The formation of LizMxPy by insertion reaction (1) results in good electrochemical behavior attributable to stable crystalline structures, which is advantageous for high-performance anode materials. Souza et al. demonstrated a quasi-topotactic-intercalation mechanism, where lithium is inserted into the binary MnP4 phase to form a cubic ternary Li7MnP4 phase.26 Furthermore, a quasi-intercalation reaction between black phosphorus and a LiP phase,25 as well as a topotactic reaction between VP and a LiVP phase,27 were reported by Park et al. On the other hand, conversion reaction (2) produces a nanocrystalline metal and Li3P, which affords advantageous features in terms of less severe structural stress. Most P-based compounds show the conversion reaction when the electrodes were fully Li inserted phase.26–39
The interesting insertion/extraction behaviors of P-based materials have motivated numerous studies into the use of these materials as possible Li-ion battery anodes. Among the various P-based materials, Co–P binary compounds (CoP3, CoP, and Co2P) have been actively investigated by many researchers. Co–P compounds can be synthesized easily using solid-state synthetic routes, such as heat-treatment and the ball-milling technique, and have high reversible capacities of >1000 mA h g−1. Owing to these favorable properties, various materials using Co–P compounds have been reported, including pulsed laser deposited CoP thin films, partially lithiated CoPx, electrodeposited Co–P alloys, and thermally decomposed CoxP nanostructures. However, the cycle performances of these materials are still poor.33–39
Based on the Co–P binary phase diagram, CoP and Co2P compounds were synthesized using simple high energy mechanical milling (HEMM) and their suitability as anode materials for rechargeable Li-ion batteries was tested. The electrochemical reaction mechanism of the as-prepared CoP electrode is discussed in this paper on the basis of the ex situ X-ray diffraction (XRD) and extended X-ray absorption fine structure (EXAFS) analyses, along with the differential capacity plot (DCP). Additionally, to enhance the electrochemical performances of CoP, its carbon-modified nanocomposite was suggested as a high-performance anode material for rechargeable Li-ion batteries.
:
1. The vial was assembled in an argon-filled glove box and an HEMM process (Spex-8000) was conducted under an Ar atmosphere for 6 h. To obtain the CoP/C composite, the same HEMM process was carried out using the synthesized CoP powder and carbon (Super P, Timcal) for 6 h. The preliminary electrochemical tests showed that the optimal amounts of CoP and C were 60% and 40% by weight, respectively.
:
1 by volume, Panax STARLYTE) as the electrolyte. All the cells were tested galvanostatically between 0.0 and 2.0 V (vs. Li/Li+) at a current density of 100 mA g−1 using a Maccor automated tester, with the exception of the rate-capability tests. The gravimetric capacity was calculated on the basis of the weight of the active materials, and the volumetric capacity was calculated by multiplying the gravimetric capacity by the tap density (CoP/C: 1.61 g cm−3, graphite: 1.27 g cm−3), which was measured using a powder tap density tester (BT-301, Bettersize). Li was inserted into the electrode during the discharge reaction and was extracted from the working electrode during the charge reaction.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 (a) Co–P binary phase diagram, and XRD patterns with ball-and-stick models (P: purple, Co: green) of the crystalline structures of (b) CoP and (c) Co2P. | ||
The voltage profiles of the CoP and Co2P electrodes are shown in Fig. 2a and b, respectively. The first discharge and charge capacities of the CoP electrode were 915 and 778 mA h g−1, respectively, with a high initial coulombic efficiency of 85%. Considering the theoretical capacity of CoP (894 mA h g−1) and a solid electrolyte interphase (SEI) layer formation reaction near 0.7 V, it can be concluded that the synthesized CoP electrode was fully reacted with Li. Although the CoP electrode exhibited a high initial coulombic efficiency, it showed poor cyclability. The drastic decrease in the capacity of the CoP electrode was caused by the large volume change due to the formation of Li3P, which was associated with the pulverization of the active material as well as its electrical isolation from the current collector. On the other hand, small discharge and charge capacities were observed for the Co2P electrode owing to the reaction of the carbon conducting agent, which indicated that Co2P was inactive with Li. The inactivity of Co2P toward Li may be related to the high overpotential that caused the break up the Co–P bonds as above mentioned in comparison with the crystalline structure.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 Voltage profiles of the (a) CoP and (b) Co2P electrodes for the 1st, 2nd, 5th, and 10th cycles. | ||
The DCP for the first cycle of the CoP electrode (Fig. 3a) showed a large peak at 0.05 V during the discharge reaction and two broad peaks at 0.8 and 1.0 V during the charge reaction. In the second cycle, two DCP peaks at 0.64 and 0.05 V were observed during the charge reaction, whereas the DCP peaks during the discharge reaction were the same as those of the first cycle, indicating the involvement of interesting electrochemical reactions. Ex situ XRD analyses (Fig. 3b) were performed at the fully discharged state (0 V) and the fully charged state (2.0 V). However, no structural changes due to the amorphization of the active materials were observed for the CoP electrode during the discharge and charge reactions.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 Electrochemical reaction mechanism between CoP and Li: (a) DCP of 1st and 2nd cycles and (b) ex situ XRD results for the 1st cycle. | ||
To confirm the electrochemical reaction mechanism of the CoP electrode with more detail, Co K-edge EXAFS analyses of the CoP electrode were performed at selected potentials as referenced in the DCP (Fig. 3a), and the results are shown in Fig. 4. Fig. 4a shows that the main EXAFS peaks in the spectrum for the crystalline CoP and metallic Co were associated with the Co–P interatomic bond length (1.78 Å) and Co–Co interatomic bond length (2.14 Å), respectively. When the electrode was fully discharged to 0 V for the first cycle (Fig. 4b), the main EXAFS peak of the CoP phase was that of the Co metal showing the spectrum associated with the Co–Co interatomic bond length (2.14 Å). In the fully charged state of 2.0 V (Fig. 4c), the two main EXAFS peaks, corresponding to the Co (2.14 Å) and CoP (1.78 Å) phases, appeared together, which demonstrated that the CoP phase was partially recombined during the charge reaction of the first cycle. To confirm the DCP peak at 0.65 V during the second discharge, which was not observed in the first cycle (Fig. 3a), EXAFS analysis at the potential of 0.3 V during the second discharge was analyzed as shown in Fig. 4d, which showed no variation. This result indicated that the remaining P resulted from the partial recombination reaction was reacted with Li. The potential at ca. 0.65 V coincided with the reaction potential for the reaction between P and Li (P → Li3P),25 which also indicated the partial recombination reaction of the CoP electrode during the charge reaction. On the basis of the above DCP and EXAFS results, the reaction mechanisms of the first and subsequent cycles are suggested as follows:
![]() | ||
| Fig. 4 EXAFS spectra of the CoP electrode: (a) pristine CoP electrode, (b) Li insertion at 0 V (1st cycle), (c) Li extraction at 2 V (1st cycle), and (d) Li insertion at 0.3 V (2nd cycle). | ||
During the first cycle of the CoP electrode:
| - Discharge: CoP → Li3P + Co |
| - Charge: Li3P + Co → CoP + Co + P |
Subsequent cycles of the CoP electrode:
| - Subsequent discharge/charge: CoP + Co + P ⇄ Li3P + Co |
Fig. 5 shows a schematic diagram for the electrochemical conversion and partial recombination reaction of the CoP electrode during cycling. The EXAFS spectra clearly demonstrated the partial recombination of the CoP electrode during charge, which is a distinctive behavior for this electrode when compared with the reaction mechanisms of previously studied electrodes consisting of Co–P compounds.33–39 Generally, the recombination reaction during charge is advantageous in terms of the electrochemical performance of Li alloy-based anodes. This is because the compound phase is gradually decreased to nanocrystallites of 2–3 nm after a few cycles, which retain the same size throughout subsequent discharge/charge cycles by repeated conversion and recombination to form the compound phases within the composite.44,46–48
![]() | ||
| Fig. 5 Schematic diagram of the electrochemical reaction mechanism of the CoP electrode during cycling. | ||
Nanostructured composite materials are considered to be promising alternative solutions for high performance anode materials because they offer the following advantages: high capacity owing to their ability to provide a higher interfacial area, high rate capability because of their increased lithium ion diffusion rate, and stable cycling behavior owing to their ability to accommodate the strain generated during cycling.6,42,46,49 Among the various synthetic methods available for nanostructured composite materials, HEMM was most suitable for fabricating high-performance electrode materials. The HEMM technique plastically deforms the particles, which leads to work hardening and fracture of materials upon impact at temperature >200 °C and pressures on the order of 6 GPa.50 Upon consideration of the HEMM mechanism, the CoP/C nanocomposite was prepared using HEMM. In the XRD pattern of the CoP/C nanocomposites (Fig. 6), two phases composed of Co2P and CoP were confirmed, which indicated that the CoP phase within the CoP/C composite was partially disproportionated to Co2P and P (amorphous) as a result of the HEMM process. A similar disproportionation reaction has also been observed for SiO and CoSbx samples.51,52 SiO was disproportionated to nanocrystalline Si and SiO2 at high temperatures.51 CoSb3 and CoSb2 were disproportionated to nanocrystalline CoSb2 + Sb (amorphous) and CoSb + Sb (amorphous), respectively, by HEMM.52 The composition ratio of CoP, Co2P, amorphous P, and carbon in the partially disproportionated CoP/C composite was calculated using the Jade 9 software to compare the XRD peak intensities and was approximately 30
:
25
:
5
:
40 by weight, respectively.
The TEM bright-field and HRTEM images combined with selected-area diffraction (SAD) patterns and lattice spacing of the CoP/C nanocomposite are shown in Fig. 7a. The SAD patterns showed both CoP and Co2P phases, which indicated that some CoP within the CoP/C composite was partially disproportionated to ca. 10 nm-sized nanocrystalline Co2P and amorphous P, which is in agreement with the XRD results. The EDS mapping image confirmed that the nanocrystalline CoP and Co2P, amorphous P, and amorphous carbon were well dispersed within the composite, as shown in Fig. 7a. Therefore, it can be concluded that the CoP/C nanocomposite was composed of CoP (ca. 10 nm), partially disproportionated Co2P (ca. 10 nm), amorphous P, and amorphous carbon as illustrated schematically in Fig. 7b.
The voltage profile of the CoP/C nanocomposite electrode is shown in Fig. 8. The discharge and charge capacities of the first cycle for the CoP/C nanocomposite electrode within the voltage range of 0–2.0 V were 712 and 531 mA h g−1 (or 1146 and 855 mA h cm−3), respectively, with a relatively high initial coulombic efficiency of 75%. The initial irreversible capacity owing to the ball-milled amorphous carbon content (40 wt%) of the CoP/C nanocomposite was approximately 180 mA h g−1, which demonstrates that the active materials, such as CoP and partially disproportionated amorphous P, in the composite electrode were fully reversible with Li. The good electrochemical Li reactivity with the CoP/C composite is attributed to the well-dispersed CoP (active with Li), nanocrystalline Co2P (inactive with Li), and amorphous P (active with Li) within the amorphous carbon matrix formed by the partial disproportionation reaction.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 8 Voltage profile of the CoP/C nanocomposite electrode for the 1st, 2nd, 5th, 10th, and 100th cycles. | ||
Comparisons of the cycling performances were made for CoP, CoP/C, and the commercially available mesocarbon microbeads (MCMB)–graphite electrode cycled at 100 mA g−1 (voltage range: 0.0–2.0 V). The gravimetric and volumetric capacities of the CoP electrode, as shown in Fig. 9a and b, respectively, decreased gradually after a few cycles. The capacity decrease was caused by mechanical cracking and crumbling, which was attributed to the large volume change during the formation of the Li3P phase. The reversible capacity and capacity retention of the CoP/C nanocomposite electrodes were significantly enhanced compared with those of the CoP electrode. The CoP/C nanocomposite electrode showed a very stable capacity of 407 mA h g−1 (or 655 mA h cm−3) for over 200 cycles, corresponding to ca. 77% of the initial charge capacity. The volumetric capacity of the CoP/C nanocomposite electrode was much higher than the MCMB–graphite electrode, as shown in Fig. 9b. The good cycling behavior of the CoP/C nanocomposite electrode was attributed to the uniform distribution of active CoP nanocrystallites, the presence of a well-dispersed nanocrystalline Co2P inactive matrix that prevents the agglomeration of active materials during cycling, and the amorphous carbon buffering matrix that alleviates the effect of the volume expansion on the active materials, as illustrated in Fig. 7c.
The rate capability test of the CoP/C nanocomposite electrode was also conducted in the potential range between 0.0 and 2.0 V. Fig. 10a and b show the cyclability of the CoP/C nanocomposite electrode as a function of the C rate, where C is defined as the full use of the restricted charge capacity of 530 mA h g−1 in 1 h. At rates of 2C and 3C, the CoP/C nanocomposite electrode showed very high charge capacities of 435 and 410 mA h g−1, respectively, corresponding to ca. 79% and 75% of the charge capacity for the rate at 0.1C with stable cycling behavior. The rate capability of the CoP/C nanocomposite electrode was excellent compared with that of the commercially available MCMB–graphite electrode. The fast rate capability of the CoP/C nanocomposite electrode was ascribed to the presence of the ca. 10 nm-sized nanocrystalline CoP and partially disproportionated amorphous P, which contributed short Li diffusion paths. Additionally, the well-dispersed, partially disproportionated Co2P phase within the amorphous carbon matrix acted as an inactive conductor and contributed to the fast rate capability.
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2014 |