C. Aydogana,
B. Kiskana,
S. O. Hacioglub,
L. Topparebcde and
Y. Yagci*af
aIstanbul Technical University, Faculty of Science and Letters, Department of Chemistry, Maslak, 34469, Istanbul, Turkey. E-mail: yusuf@itu.edu.tr
bMiddle East Technical University, Department of Chemistry, 06800, Ankara, Turkey
cDepartment of Biotechnology, Middle East Technical University, 06800 Ankara, Turkey
dDepartment of Polymer Science and Technology, Middle East Technical University, 06800 Ankara, Turkey
eThe Center for Solar Energy Research and Application (GUNAM), Middle East Technical University, 06800 Ankara, Turkey
fDepartment of Chemistry, Faculty of Science, King Abdulaziz University, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia
First published on 10th June 2014
A novel electrochemical redox process for the manipulation of adhesion of polybenzoxazine thermosets on metal surfaces is reported. The method pertains to the electrochemically driven hydroquinone–quinone redox couple. Several antraquinone based bisbenzoxazines possessing phenyl, benzyl and methyl furfuryl substituents were synthesized and characterized. The antraquinone bisbenzoxazines were shown to readily undergo thermally activated ring-opening polymerization in the absence of a catalyst forming cross-linked networks on metal surfaces. The substituent effect on thermal curing behaviour and thermal stability of the cured polymers were investigated. The strong binding affinities of phenolic hydroxyl groups of the anthraquinone moiety in the cured polymers promote adhesion on the metal surface. Electrochemical oxidation converts hydroquinone groups into quinone moieties resulting in the dismantling of the coated films. The generality of this electrochemical method is demonstrated by initial results on platinum electrodes as well as steel plates.
Apart from straightforward synthesis, another striking feature of benzoxazines is their undemanding polymerizability in the absence of a catalyst at temperatures between ca. 160–250 °C.5,42–44 Depending on the specific groups on the monomer, even much lower polymerization temperatures were reported.45–47 Polymerization occurs through heterocyclic ring-opening reaction yielding a network possessing phenolic groups and amine bridges in the structure (Scheme 2).48–50 It is known that polymers involving hydroquinone–quinone or similar redox couples have diverse applications ranging from electrical conductors, batteries, electrode coatings for sensors, catalysts for electrochemical reactions, antioxidants to reaction inhibitors.51 When incorporated into benzoxazines, the redox cycle between quinone–hydroquinone couples would make these compounds particularly useful as electroactive thermosets. Some properties of the polybenzoxazines can, thus, be altered in a cyclic manner between two distinct points by electrochemical stimulus.
The adhesion of polybenzoxazines onto steel surfaces is acquired by the attractions between phenolic hydroxyls and iron atoms.33,52 Quinone–hydroquinone conversions can affect the hydroxyl content of polybenzoxazines and as a consequence, the adhesive property can dramatically be changed between these two redox points.
Herein, we describe our efforts to synthesize benzoxazine monomers possessing anthraquinone groups in the structure to generate corresponding polybenzoxazine networks by thermally activated ring opening polymerization capable of changing adhesion property by external electrochemical stimulation.
Single scan cyclic voltammogram of monomers and polymers were recorded in 0.1 M tetrabutylammonium hexafluorophosphate (Bu4N+PF6−)/acetonitrile (ACN) solution. For this experiment, Pt foil electrode was used as the working electrode. Monomers were dissolved in CHCl3 and drop casted on Pt electrode. Resulting CVs were recorded in Bu4N+PF6−/ACN electrolyte system. Then, to explore the redox behaviour of polymers, freshly prepared Pt electrodes stored in the oven for 3 hours at 180 °C. Single scan CVs of resulting polymers were also investigated with the same conditions used for the monomers. (Note: abbreviations of corresponding polymers are as; PB-Ant-A for aniline, PB-Ant-Bn for benzylamine, PB-Ant-F for furfurylamine based polybenzoxazines).
13C CPMAS NMR spectrum was collected using an Inova 500 MHz NMR Varian system fitted with a Jacobsen brand CP-MAS probe. 13C CPMAS spectra were acquired at 125.654 MHz using Si3N4 rotors set to 6 Hz. Pulses were separated by a 1 s delay.
The structure of the monomers was confirmed by spectral analysis. As can be seen from Fig. S1–S3,† the 1H-NMR spectra of the monomers exhibit the specific signals of benzoxazine ring. Notably, the two broad signals in the range of 4.9 and 3.7 ppm corresponding to –CH2 protons of benzoxazine rings are revealed. The FT-IR absorption bands of the benzoxazines were previously reported in detail.53,54 In Fig. S4,† the important bands of infra–red absorptions of benzoxazines observed at 932 and 1496 cm−1 can be attributed to the benzene ring and the peak at 1229 cm−1 is assigned to the asymmetric stretching of C–O–C group of oxazine ring. A detailed view of the region below 1700 cm−1 of Fig. S4 is included in the ESI as Fig. S5.†
It is well known that 1,3-benzoxazines and related polymeric precursors can be cured by thermally-activated ring-opening polymerization and the exothermic process can be monitored using differential scanning calorimeter (DSC). The curing maximum varies from 160 to 250 °C, depending on the functionalities present on the benzoxazines or related polymeric precursors. In some cases, even curing temperatures below 160 °C was also reported.47 Fig. 1 shows the overlaid DSC profiles of antraquinone–benzoxazines. It is clear that the monomers are curable and the curing temperature varies between 180–230 °C. In detail, an exotherm belonging to B-Ant-A is detected having an onset of polymerization reaction at 221 °C with a maximum at 227 °C. On the other hand, the exotherm of B-Ant-Bn has a maximum at 195 °C; also, B-Ant-F shows an exothermic peak starting from 170 °C and reaching its maximum at 181 °C. B-Ant-F and B-Ant-Bn monomers exhibited an endotherm right after the end-set temperatures showing that some volatile compounds are formed or sublimation occurred at that temperature. However, benzoxazine coated Pt electrodes were treated at 180 °C, which is even below the maximum cure temperature. Thus, possible side product formation during thermal treatment can be discarded (Table 1).
Benzoxazine | Curing maximum (°C) | On-set (°C) | End-set (°C) | ΔH (J g−1) |
---|---|---|---|---|
B-Ant-A | 229 | 221 | 234 | −118 |
B-Ant-Bn | 196 | 170 | 230 | −111 |
B-Ant-F | 181 | 170 | 202 | −107 |
The polymerization of benzoxazines occurs in response to the benzoxazine ring structure having distorted semi-chair conformation. The ring strain created from this molecular structure assists six-membered ring to undergo ring-opening reaction under thermal conditions with a mechanism through two main pathways. The first step is the heterolytic cleavage of the C–O bond of the oxazine yielding a carbocation. Subsequent attack of the corresponding carbocation occurs to either the ortho or para position of the neighbour aromatic ring, which can be considered as a kind of Friedel–Crafts reaction.
Thus, cross-linked structures can easily be obtained even using mono-functional benzoxazines with free ortho and para positions on the phenolic structure. Due to the nature of the reaction mechanism, if the benzoxazine monomer contains aromatic ketonic moieties in the structure, these groups can survive under curing condition. Indeed, the FT-IR spectra of cured monomers reveal the ketonic carbonyl in the range between 1670–1685 cm−1 indicating the preservation of the quiononic structure (Fig. S6 and S7†). Moreover, the progress of the curing reaction was monitored by IR and the each cure stage, from 120 to 210 °C, is shown in Fig. S7.† Expectedly, the bands corresponding to the oxazine and substituted benzene rings at 1373, 1214, 1068 and 987 cm−1 decrease and finally disappear with increasing temperature. Ultimately, polybenzoxazine resins exhibiting a redox capability through hydroquinone–quinone transformation can readily be obtained by thermally activated curing of the corresponding monomer (Scheme 4).
![]() | ||
Scheme 4 Thermally induced ring-opening polymerization of antraquinone–benzoxazines and subsequent redox process. |
In order to prove that the ring-opened materials are truly polybenzoxazines and discard possible thermal degradation during the curing process, solid state NMR was conducted (Fig. S8†). According to the NMR results, two types of polybenzoxazine structures are present in the final product. The first structure has free phenolic hydroxyl groups as a result of Friedel–Crafts reaction. The second phenoxy ether type structure is formed by the attack of imine intermediate to the phenolic oxygen. Similar reactions were previously reported by Wang et al.55,56 Scheme 5 briefly illustrates the mechanism of the formation of the two types of the polymers.
![]() | ||
Scheme 5 Plausible mechanism for polymerization of benzoxazine monomer producing two different types of polybenzoxazine. |
The electroactivity of the monomers and resulting polymers was investigated by cyclic voltammetry. As illustrated in Fig. 2, while aniline, benzyl and furfuryl based benzoxazines have oxidation peaks at around 1.5 V, all peaks were irreversible and all oxidations disappear in the CVs of polymers. While the reduction behaviors of monomers compared to polymers (Fig. 3), in the negative side there is a significant change in the reduction peaks from −0.5 V to −1 V.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Single scan cyclic voltammogram of polymers PB-Ant-A (a), PB-Ant-Bn (b), and PB-Ant-F (c) based polybenzoxazines in 0.1 M (NH4+PF6−)/ACN solution at a scan rate of 100 mV s−1. |
Quinone–hydroquinone transformation generates a cycle between tetrahydroxy and dihydroxy aromatic structures. It is well known that, phenolic hydroxyl groups promote the adhesion of molecules to metals.57 Using quinone–hydroquinone cycle generate two different adhesion strength since the number of phenolic hydroxyls doubles in reduced form and this structure has high adhesion strength on steel surfaces. The oxidized form of the polybenzoxazine resins showed a drastic decrease in adhesion and simply dismantled from the surface of the steel specimen. Moreover, it can also be considered that the increase of the internal stress of the materials caused by the volume change may contribute to the dismantling behaviour. The adhesion values and the photographs of dismantling of the polybenzoxazine resins are presented in Table 2 and Fig. 4, respectively.
Polymer | Reduced form | Oxidized form |
---|---|---|
PB-Ant-A | 5B | 0B |
PB-Ant-Bn | 5B | 0B |
PB-Ant-F | 5B | 0B |
Standard tests for measuring adhesion by tape test58 were carried out on stainless steel plates (5 cm × 5 cm). Polymers were prepared using the same procedure described for Pt foil electrode. All polymers are well adhered and durable versus adhesion tests.
In order to confirm the proposed redox mechanism, electrochemical studies were combined with FTIR spectral analysis. Thus, monomer films were prepared on stainless steel (5 cm × 5 cm) electrodes by spray processing and then polymerized at 180 °C similar to the Pt electrodes. Resulting polymers were subjected to the constant potential at −0.3 V for 20 hours to reduce the carbonyl bonds in the polymer backbone to –OH units. Although the initial current was 3 μA, it was drastically decreased to 0.5 μA after 20 h reduction. FTIR spectra of the polymer films before and after reduction were recorded. The concurrent appearance of a new peak at 2965 cm−1 and disappearance of the carbonyl peak at 1655 cm−1 clearly confirms the successful redox process (see Fig. S9†). When the reduced polymer films were subjected to oxidation at +1.8 V, dismantling of film was observed in a matter of seconds due to the oxidation of the polymer resulting in the formation of ketone moieties.
Thermogravimetric behaviour of the cured polybenzoxazines was investigated by TGA under nitrogen atmosphere. The TGA and derivative thermal gravimetry (DTG) profiles are shown in Fig. 5 and 6, respectively. Thermal characteristics are also summarized in Table 3. It can be seen that aniline functional anthraquinone based polybenzoxazine shows significantly higher thermal stability than the other two polybenzoxazines. Moreover, methyl furan based polybenzoxazine has higher char yield compared to benzyl based benzoxazine. The differences observed in their thermal stability can be explained by the aromatization of the furan groups. This phenomenon is well known and reported in carbonization studies of furans.59,60
Polymera | T5%b (°C) | T10%c (°C) | Tmaxe (°C) | Char yieldd (%) at 800 °C |
---|---|---|---|---|
a Curing was performed in TGA at 220 °C for 15 min. under N2 stream (200 mL min−1).b T5%: the temperature for which the weight loss is 5%.c T10%: the temperature for which the weight loss is 10%.d Yc: char yields at 800 °C under nitrogen atmosphere.e Tmax: the temperature for maximum weight loss. | ||||
PB-Ant-A | 211 | 233 | 296 | 19 |
PB-Ant-Bn | 159 | 171 | 200 | 1 |
PB-Ant-F | 156 | 168 | 192 | 11 |
DTG curves of benzyl and methyl furan based polybenzoxazines exhibit peaks at 192 °C, 200 °C and inflection points at 240 °C, 254 °C, respectively. However, aniline based polybenzoxazine showed a peak at relatively higher temperature, 296 °C, indicating a different degradation pathway than that of benzyl and furan derivatives.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: NMR, FT-IR spectra of monomers and polymers. See DOI: 10.1039/c4ra03763d |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2014 |