Milana Lisunova‡
a,
Xingfei Wei‡a,
Drew DeJarnetteb,
Gregory T. Forcheriob,
Keith R. Berrya,
Phillip Blakea and
D. Keith Roper*ab
aRalph E. Martin Department of Chemical Engineering, 3202 Bell Engineering Center, USA. E-mail: dkroper@uark.edu; Fax: +1 479 575 7926; Tel: +1 479 575 6691
bMicroElectronics-Photonics Program, Institute for Nanoscience and Engineering, University of Arkansas, Fayetteville, AR 72701, USA
First published on 29th April 2014
Photothermal transduction of light to heat by evaporated and electroless plated gold (Au) films has been compared. Bare film was compared to film decorated by an ordered lattice of Au nanocylinders. The effects of plasmonic absorption of incident light, heat dissipation in the substrate, and interfacial effects between Au nanoparticles and the substrate were evaluated. Differences in the photothermal response of the films emerged due to interactions between these effects. Significant photothermal transduction was achieved by 30–40 nm Au grains as well as by conglomerate nanocylinders assembled from Au grains. An electroless Au film decorated with conglomerate Au nanocylinders ordered into a hexagonal array enhanced attenuation by 22% and increased light-to-heat conversion by 26%. This was attributed to photon-plasmon coupling. An evaporated Au film of 57 nm thickness attenuated 30% of incident light, compared to 45% attenuation for the electroless film of 35 nm thickness. The evaporated film had a photothermal response of 280 °C per watt of incident light in contrast to 1400 °C per watt for the electroless film.
However, dissipative thermal losses from plasmonic absorption in 2D ordered lattices, which impacts cost-effective implementation of lattices in solar photovoltaic or sensor applications, remains relatively unexamined. Quantitative characterization of dissipative absorption in 2D lattices has been constrained by limited availability of lattices of sufficient area to support calorimetric evaluation.20–22 On the other hand, thermoplasmonic transduction has been widely evaluated for random nanoparticles in single-phase fluid suspensions23 and on solid substrates24 and at two-phase solid–fluid interfaces.25 Micro-scale thermoplasmonic systems exhibit predictable thermodynamic and transport behaviors.26 It has been reported that isolated plasmonic NP are about 97 ± 8% efficient in converting photon to heat energy.24 Govorov et al. showed irradiating plasmonic NP at a frequency near resonance can drive the NP through a phase transformation when they are in thermal contact with a polymer or a solid matrix, such as ice.27,28 Plasmonic photothermalization can be so strong as to recrystallize plasmonic nanoparticles, which leads to shape transformation.29 Vaporization of water24 and other optofluidic effects coming from heated metal plasmonic nanoparticles has been reported. In particular, embedding NP in flexible biocompatible polymers enhances thermoplasmonic transduction in proportion to nanoparticle concentration.30 Halas, El-Sayed, and their collaborators showed plasmonic photothermalization was viable for thermal ablation of cancer and bacteria.31–35
Extrapolation of photothermal effects of isolated NP to ordered lattices of NP has been constrained to date by electrodynamic, electrostatic, and thermal considerations. Govorov et al.36 predicted that ordering NP into lattices screens the electric field inside the lattice in a way that reduces or increases total heat dissipation, depending on the incident light polarization. Emergence of coupling between photons diffracted by the lattice structure and plasmons supported by NP at the nodes is anticipated to enhance photothermal effects at coupling frequencies.11,12 Conversely, reducing the lattice constant would eliminate coupling but increase dissipative adsorption from lattices with NP at a higher area density. Sixteen plasmonic nanoparticles in a square lattice under incident illumination at 104 W cm−2 produced a temperature increase of 25 K versus 5 K for a single nanoparticle under the same conditions.36 Beyond these brief evaluations, examination of thermoplasmonics in ordered NP lattices remains limited, despite its significance to dissipative absorption.37,38
This work examines the effects of nanostructure on thermoplasmonic transduction in continuous and semi-continuous Au film alone, and in conjunction with 2D ordered lattices of Au NP. Au nanofilms (continuous film and hexagonal array) with similar grainy morphology and dimensions were produced by electroless plating (ELP)39 onto an electron resist patterned by electron-beam lithography (EBL).40 The electroless film and film plus NP lattice were lifted off the electron resist and underlying ceramic substrate using adhesive tape.41 Electroless films were compared with conventional Au nanofilms produced by metal evaporation. The grainy Au morphology resulting from batch ELP increased thermoplasmonic dissipation relative to evaporated films. Nanostructures composed of self-assembled Au grains during electroless deposition exhibited higher absorption, attenuation light-to-heat energy conversion than smooth evaporated films which yield lower thermal responses due to increased optical scattering.
Fig. 2 compares transmission UV-vis extinction spectra in air of ELP Au grainy film, ELP grainy film decorated with hexagonal arrays of conglomerate nanocylinders, and evaporated Au film. The two grainy Au films exhibit broad extinction spectra arising from the random distribution of the nanoparticles and porous structure. The spectra from the evaporated Au is similar, albeit with a different slope (500 nm to 850 nm). In contrast to the UV-vis spectra of the undecorated Au films, the film decorated with Au nanocylinders exhibits an additional feature at 547 nm. All the Au films exhibit an extinction minima (transmission peak) at 500 nm. This feature has been attributed to photoluminescence caused by electron transitions and recombination between filled d-bands and the Fermi-level conduction band in the Au.39,44 Numerous reports indicate photoluminescence is pronounced in Au films with a thickness less than 60 nm.45–49
To interpret the transmission spectra, discrete dipole approximation (DDA) of representative nanostructures was performed. First, to evaluate the effect of nanostructure shape on the spectra, a single conglomerate Au nanocylinder and a solid Au nanocylinder were simulated (see Fig. 3) using a shape file generated in Matlab. Both cylinders had a 120 nm outer diameter, 40 nm wall thickness, and were 100 nm in height. The Au dielectric constant for the simulations was taken from Johnson and Christy.50 The propagation of light was along z direction, parallel to the axis of the nanocylinder. The conglomerate and solid cylinders each displayed two characteristic extinction peaks at 729 nm/564 nm and 702 nm/562 nm, respectively. While the solid cylinder extinction peak consisted of 20% absorption, the conglomerate extinction was comprised of 70% absorption at the plasmon wavelength. Note that percentages were estimated using the area under the curves, not at the peak wavelength. From these results, Au grains with diameter of 40 nm assembled into a nanocylinder could be expected to produce a higher absorption/scattering yield ratio compared to a solid Au nanocylinder, despite overall similarity across the extinction spectra. This is consistent with the fact that particles larger than 60 nm in radius exhibit primarily scattering behavior under resonant illumination.51 The nanostructure (shape, aspect ratio) defines the absorption and scattering. For instance, nanoparticles shaped as a hollow cage and a solid rod, despite similar effective radiuses, possess different scattering/absorption yield ratios.44,52
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Extinction, absorption, and scattering efficiency spectra of the solid cylinders (top) in comparison to grained cylinder shaped (bottom) by DDA simulations. |
Second, to evaluate the effect of decoration by an ordered 2D lattice, the grainy cylinders in a hexagonal array with a period of 700 nm were simulated, as well as Au grains assembled in continuous films. Au grains in a continuous film possess a broad spectra shaped similarly to the experimental spectra (see Fig. 2). The broadening depends on the dimensions of the clusters (assembled grains form a cluster). The experimentally observed spectra could result from a superposition of plasmonic responses from clusters of different sizes. The simulations for both films show an extinction minima close to 500 nm (512 nm for the hexagonal array and 500 nm for the grains assembled in continuous films), which is similar to the experimental spectra (see Fig. 2). However, the hexagonal lattice of cylindrical nanoconglomerates (see Fig. 4) display features that are smoothed in experimentally observed spectra (see Fig. 2). These features may be attributed to the effect of the Au grainy background and the broad shape distribution of cylinders. The defects of the surface53 also lead to the broadening of the UV-vis spectra.
In order to quantitate geometric optics of the Au nanostructures, a bi-directional spectroscopy apparatus constructed around an integrating sphere54 was employed to measure reflection (R) and transmission (T) of the thin films. With this apparatus, attenuation (A) could be determined by:
A = 1 − T − R | (1) |
Attenuation includes both dissipative plasmonic absorption and bulk non-resonant losses from the sample.38 As shown in Fig. 1, the plasmonic absorptive nanostructure consists of conglomerate Au metal nanocylinders deposited on top of a gold film which is adhered to the dielectric substrate (Fig. 5). The dielectric substrate was 70 μm thick. It transmitted 92% of incident green light, reflected 1.72%, and had a resulting attenuation of 6%. The dielectric substrate on which 40 nm Au grains were deposited in a film attenuated 45%, while the same substrate and film decorated by grainy conglomerate Au nanocylinders attenuated >54%. Note that, the estimated volume of grainy film with and without nanocylinders was approximately the same (see ESI†). The observed differences in attenuation could be due to differences in Au particle morphology or from the addition hexagonal ordered nanostructures. The ordered nanostructures create a potential for far field inter-particle coupling. It is noteworthy that the Au films decorated by conglomerate Au nanocylinders transmit a lower percentage of light (10% less) compared to Au film without the nanocylinders. At the same time, reflection improved slightly from 6.7% to 9.3% suggesting that nanocylinders scatter light at a comparable level to grainy Au films.
The effect of nanostructure on optical attenuation was further analyzed using the evaporated Au which produced a smooth film of about 57 nm in height. The attenuation of the Au smooth film was 30%, compared to 45% attenuation by the 35 nm grainy film. Attenuation decreased despite a higher amount of the deposited Au (1.4 fold higher). Recent reports concur that nanostructure impacts optical attenuation. Cai et al. improved reflection properties (reflection <0.5% in the visible region and <2% in the near infrared region) of TiO2 nanorod arrays by optimizing the graded reflective index profile that results from the hierarchical tips-on-rod structure of the microcrystalline nanorods.55 Liu et al.56 improved light attenuation by approximately 30% by designing organized TiO2 nanoparticles.
ELP Au films with and without Au nanocylinders exhibited a photothermal response to incident green light at a wavelength of 532 nm. Measured temperatures of ELP Au films increased as the power of incident light increased from 0 to 45 mW: from 22 °C to 62 °C for Au film alone; and from 22 °C to 76 °C for Au film decorated with nanocylinders (see Fig. 6). The variation is linear for both samples. Higher temperature variation of ΔT = 54 °C for the film decorated with nanocylinders, compared to ΔT = 40 °C for the undecorated Au grainy film was consistent with its higher attenuation level. Higher photothermal response at larger attenuation was previously reported by Roper and coworkers for a 7 μm layer of Au nanoparticles (NP) penetrated into 130 μm thick polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) films;57 and for a random distribution of Au nanoparticles in PDMS.30 Higher attenuation in the latter was coincident with a larger concentration of embedded Au NP.
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 The temperature versus the applied power (green laser) of the hexagonal array of the Au cylinder-nanoconglomerates on the Au grainy film (background), Au grainy film and Au evaporated film. |
The photothermal response of the grainy thin films could result from interaction between several factors. The protrusion of the conglomerate nanocylinders from the surface of the grainy film could absorb and transduce more light to heat. Interparticle coupling between scattered photons and plasmon noted in ordered lattices that impacts the electromagnetic field enhancement12–14,16,18,21,24 could also increase photothermal transduction. The low intimate bonding (interfacial contact) of nanocylinders at the surface could reduce measurable heat dissipation. To evaluate the effect of ambient conditions, the top of the Au film was insulated by optically transparent tape. The evaporated Au film shows a negligible thermal response to irradiation under similar conditions (see Fig. 6). The difference in thermal response between the smooth evaporated film and the grainy ELP film appears largely due to the different absorption/scattering cross section of the films. This suggests that the thermal response is not only determined by the mass of deposited Au, but also by interactions arising from the deposited Au nanocylinders as well as the intrinsic nanostructure of each Au film and feature.
The photon-to-heat conversion of the nanocylinder-decorated film and bare grainy film, respectively, were up to 1700 °C W−1 and 1400 °C W−1. These are comparable to previously reported values for Au NP embedded in polymer films at significantly lower Au content, about ∼0.04 vol%. It is noteworthy that reducing Au asymmetrically into thin PDMS increased the photon-to-heat conversion relative to more uniform Au NP reduction by about a factor of two.57
The method used to measure photon-to-heat conversion provides a measure of dissipated heat from the excited nanoparticles to the polymer substrates. There is an emerging interest in distinguishing local temperature variation due to plasmonic excitation of nanoparticles in a lattice. The measurement is precluded by ultra-fast heat dissipation (100–380 ps)58 from the high thermo-conductive Au plasmonic nanoparticles of about 110 (W m−1 K−1) as well as ultra-low time relaxation of about <10−9 s.28,38,59 One study reported plasmonic metamaterials' transient temperature increased about 795 K during an ultrafast photothermal process.60,61 Improved understanding of photon-to-phonon energy conversion by nanoparticles and heat dissipation to the surrounding environment is a widespread goal. For instance, Zeng and Murphy62 used a finite element analysis heat transfer model to compare temperature variation of randomly distributed NP over a long duration with short, high-powered pulsed laser heating. The local temperature increased from 300 K to 750 K for NP with a radius of 20 nm and from 300 K to 650 K for NP with radius of 40 nm as the volume fraction of NP increased from 0 to 0.01. Not surprisingly, increasing the gold content improved the temperature increase: local temperature increased from 300 K to 3000 K for NP with radius of 40 nm and from 300 K to 650 K for NP with a radius of 20 nm as the amount of NP per unit volume increase from 0 to 3 × 107 (nm−3). The study concluded that for a given number of NP per unit volume, the temperature increased as NP size increased, while at constant volume fraction the temperature variation was not affected by NP size. Carlson et al.63 reported a discontinuous differences between the measured temperature of the substrate and the local temperature of 40 nm Au NP of about 800 K due to interfacial effects (such as effective dielectric constant and the interface conductance) that limit heat transport to the sensor films. Binding of plasmonic NP to the surface was reported to affect the heat flow in the film and measured heat dissipation. Analysis of melting points of metals suggests that plasmonic NP could attain a local temperature of thousands of Kelvin.64,65 However, measured temperature increases are only on the order of a few tens of degrees due to the difference in the heat capacities as reported by Ashcroft.66
It is possible that the higher thermal response of grainy Au films compared with smooth evaporated films could result from electromagnetic field enhancement via coupling of photoluminescent and surface plasmonic modes.67–70 Enhancement of electromagnetic field due to coupling between plasmon modes and photoluminescence emission has been reported in hybrid materials that include Au nanoparticles, such as CdS nanoparticles on the Au films,66 ZnO deposited on Au nanoparticles,68 and dye doped by Au nanoparticles.71 However, the lack of research on photoluminescence coupling with plasmonic modes in non-hybrid Au nanostructures could motivate further work in this area.
In conclusion, this work considered the thermoplasmonic response of conglomerate Au films with and without attendant nanostructures. Effects of heat dissipation in the substrate-tape, energy harvesting and conversion by plasmonic Au nanostructures (absorption versus scattering, transmission/attenuation/reflection), and interfacial effects between Au nanoparticles and substrate were considered. The increase in photothermal responses for grainy electroless Au film when decorated with a lattice of conglomerate Au nanocylinders appeared to result from several factors. Films composed of Au grains from 30–40 nm in diameter and nanocylinders assembled from such Au grains absorb a higher percentage of light than smooth evaporated films that results in higher light to heat conversion. The presence of a lattice of conglomerate Au nanocylinders on the grainy Au film increased attenuation 22% and enhanced light to heat conversion by 26%. Weak interfacial bindings of the cylinders, due to porosity of the grain Au substrate, affected the heat flow and allowed an increase in light detection of only 26%.
Overall, an increase in photothermal response of films produced by electroless plating was observed compared with metal evaporated films. Evaporated Au film of 57 nm thickness had less attenuation of 30% compared to grainy film of 35 nm which attenuated 45%, and a lower thermal response of 280 °C W−1 in contrast to 1400 °C W−1 for the grainy film.
Hexagonal arrays of particles were simulated using an infinite coupled dipole approximate (CDA).11,12,19 Nanoparticles in the CDA were treated as single, point dipoles with specified dipole polarizability as a function of incident wavelength, particle composition and morphology, and surrounding dielectric environment. Polarizability values for the individual nanoparticles were determined by summing constituent polarizabilities using the DDA as described in recent paper.77 Electric fields from each nanoparticle in the hexagonal array were summed on a center particle to determine extinction efficiency of incident light.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c4ra03351e |
‡ The two authors contributed equally. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2014 |