Eduardo Beltrána,
Beatriz Robles-Hernándezb,
Nerea Sebastiánb,
José Luis Serranoc,
Raquel Giménez*a and
Teresa Sierra*a
aDepartamento de Química Orgánica, Instituto de Ciencia de Materiales de Aragón (ICMA) – Facultad de Ciencias, CSIC – Universidad de Zaragoza, 50009 Zaragoza, Spain. E-mail: rgimenez@unizar.es; tsierra@unizar.es; Tel: +34 976 762276
bDepartamento de Física Aplicada II, Facultad de Ciencia y Tecnología, Universidad del País Vasco UPV/EHU, 48080 Bilbao, Spain
cInstituto de Nanociencia de Aragón (INA), Edificio I+D, Universidad de Zaragoza, 50018 Zaragoza, Spain
First published on 16th May 2014
The bulk self-assembly of bent-core molecules based on the novel structure 2-methoxy-4,6-bis(1′,2′,3′-triazol-4′-yl)-1,3,5-triazine is reported together with their luminescent and electrochemical properties. Two families of compounds with lateral branches of different lengths have been investigated. Columnar mesomorphism with short stacking distances and periodic twisted structures were found. A compound exhibiting two hexagonal columnar mesophases that show different emission spectra and a transition from a bimolecular assembly to a unimolecular assembly is described.
Columnar mesophases are mainly based on discotic molecules12,13 but molecules with different shape anisotropies,14,15 such as star-shaped molecules,16 T-shaped molecules,17 phasmidics,18,19 dendrimers,20–23 bowl-shaped,24–29 half-disk,30–32 taper-shaped33–35 or bent-core36 molecules as examples, can also provide columnar mesophases. A delicate balance between non-covalent interactions such as H-bonding, π-stacking, van der Waals forces, microsegregation and steric effects provides the driving force for the effective filling of the free volume in a columnar arrangement.
The bent-core geometry is, of the unconventional shapes, an example of the tight relationship between molecular structure, supramolecular arrangement and properties of the material. Furthermore, this system highlights the importance of the assembly in transferring the molecular properties to the macroscopic level or in finding new and exciting properties on the micro- or nanoscale. Bent-core liquid crystals are achiral organic molecules that generally contain a 120° disubstituted aromatic ring and they are able to pack in a compact way to form lamellar or columnar phases.36–38 Some of the mesophases are endowed with chirality or polarity, and excellent properties that include ferroelectric or antiferroelectric behaviour, piezoelectricity, or nonlinear optical properties have been reported.39–41 The columnar arrangements found with these compounds are different to regular stacks of molecules and are actually defined as modulated phases formed by frustrated layers.42 On the other hand, the formation of properly stacked molecules in columnar mesophases of bent-core molecules has also been observed in some cases,43–45 and the interest in these systems lies in the possibility of obtaining a macroscopic polarization along the columnar axis and polar switching.46–52
Heterocyclic derivatives have been widely explored in the molecular design of columnar liquid crystals, as the dipole originating from the heteroatoms plays an important role in the columnar stabilization and may give rise to additional properties such as increased electron affinity, as occurs for nitrogen-rich aromatics (azaaromatics).53 In this regard, we recently described the synthesis and properties of a new class of compounds based on the nitrogen rich star-shaped core 2,4,6-tris(1′,2′,3′-triazol-4′-yl)-1,3,5-triazine, which show columnar mesomorphism, luminescence and electron-acceptor characteristics.54,55 The triazole rings joined to the triazine ring confer flexibility to the core and this enabled these molecules to adopt unusual assemblies with different symmetry conformations in the columns.55
The aim of the work described here was to study the properties of the triazine–triazole group in a bent-core structure, based on the special self-assembly that this geometry provides. Thus, the synthesis and characterisation of novel compounds derived from 2-methoxy-4,6-bis(1′,2′,3′-triazol-4′-yl)-1,3,5-triazine and their bulk self-assembly in mesomorphic columnar structures are reported. The stacking found along the columns is compact with short intermolecular distances. The molecules are fluorescent and electroactive, thus endowing the assemblies with these properties. Two families of compounds (BTs and BTBs) with lateral branches of different lengths have been investigated (Scheme 1).
The target BTs and BTBs were prepared by direct reaction of C with the aromatic azides A or B by adapting a synthetic procedure previously described for tris(triazolyl)triazines.54 The reaction gave the products in 60–80% yield at room temperature and in one-pot. The process involves two orthogonal reactions, the double alkyne deprotection and the double 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of the aromatic azides to the alkyne groups catalyzed by copper(I) (CuAAC click reaction58).
The 1H-NMR spectra display a singlet corresponding to the C5 proton of the triazolyl ring at 8.9–9.0 ppm, indicating that the 1,4-disubstituted triazole regioisomer is formed. In addition, both series show a singlet corresponding to the methoxy group at 4.30 ppm. The results indicate the compatibility of this methodology with the methoxy substitution of the triazine ring.
Compound | T/°C (ΔH/kJ mol−1)b |
---|---|
a Colh = hexagonal columnar mesophase, Colhp = hexagonal plastic columnar phase, Cr = crystalline phase, I = isotropic liquid, Dec = decomposition process, P = unknown phase.b Onset temperatures from DSC heating and cooling cycle at 10 °C min−1.c Temperature corresponding to the maximum of a broad peak. | |
BT2 | Cr 13 (3.8) [Cr′ + Cr′′] 169c (37.6) I |
I 164 (22.4) Cr′′ 141 (9.0) Cr′ 12 (4.1) Cr | |
BT4 | Colhp 104 (29.9) I |
I 100 Colh 96 (27.5) Colhp | |
BT6 | ColAh 59 (13.2) ColBh 121c (7.6) I |
I 116 (9.2) ColBh 42 (13.0) ColAh | |
BTB2 | Cr 85 (12.9) P 243 I + Dec |
BTB4 | Cr 115 (37.8) Cr′ 194 (48.4) I |
I 189 (47.3) Cr′ 86 (51.2) Cr | |
BTB6 | Colh 172 (27.5) I |
I 166 (29.4) Colh |
Compound | T/°C | Phase | d/Å | hk | Parametersa |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
a a = (2/√3) ((d10) + (d11)√3 + (d20)√4 + (d21)√7 +…/nreflections).b Sample heated at 100 °C and rapidly cooled down to 20 °C.c Reinforced along the meridian in an oriented pattern. (br) = broad halo. | |||||
BT4 | 20 | Colhp | 29.6 | 10 | a = 33.7 Å |
16.8 | 11 | ||||
10.9 | 21 | ||||
4.4 (br) | |||||
3.8 | |||||
3.4 | |||||
20b | Colh | 30.8 | a = 35.6 Å | ||
4.4 (br) | |||||
BT6 | 20 | ColAh | 31.8 | 10 | a = 36.9 Å |
18.6 | 11 | c = 3.3 Å | |||
15.5c | |||||
4.3 (br) | |||||
3.3c | 01 | ||||
100 | ColBh | 26.0 | 10 | a = 30.0 Å | |
12.7c | |||||
4.5 (br) | |||||
BTB6 | 20 | Colh | 37.4 | 10 | a = 43.2 Å |
15.1c | c = 3.4 Å | ||||
4.4 (br) | |||||
3.4c | 01 |
Compound BT4 displayed a columnar phase from room temperature up to 104 °C, at which point the transition to the isotropic liquid occurred. In the cooling process, two transitions were observed due to the appearance of an additional columnar mesophase over a small temperature range (monotropic mesophase). The DSC thermogram shows that the two transitions are partially overlapped (ESI, Fig. S2†). By POM, a pseudofocal-conic texture of a columnar mesophase started to appear at 100 °C on cooling the isotropic liquid (Fig. 1a, inset) and a decrease in birefringence was observed on further cooling at 94 °C (Fig. 1a). The XRD pattern obtained at room temperature for compound BT4 shows three reflections in the small angle region in a ratio 1:
1/√3
:
1/√7, which is consistent with a hexagonal symmetry for the columnar mesophase (Fig. 2a). In the high angle region, the typical diffuse halo at 4.4 Å, related to the fluid character of the decyloxy tails, and two additional reflections located at 3.8 Å and 3.4 Å, which are related to stacking, are observed. These latter two reflections are indicative of a certain 3D order of the phase and are compatible with a hexagonal plastic columnar phase13 (Colhp) with a cell parameter of 33.7 Å. A diffractogram of the monotropic mesophase of BT4 was obtained by rapid cooling at room temperature and this shows only a sharp maximum in the small angle region and a diffuse halo at 4.3 Å (Fig. 2b). This kind of pattern does not unambiguously confirm a hexagonal symmetry but rules out other columnar symmetries and it has been observed for hexagonal columnar phases of several non-conventional mesogens.43,59–63 The diffractogram, together with the observed POM texture, led us to propose that the small-angle maximum corresponds to the (10) reflection of a hexagonal columnar mesophase with a cell parameter (a) of 35.6 Å. Taking into account the cell parameter of these two columnar phases, the unit cell should contain about two molecules (Z = 2) on the reasonable assumption that the density is around 1 g cm−3.64 On the basis of these data, a model is proposed for the molecular arrangement in a columnar stratum in which two bent-core molecules are disposed with their molecular dipoles in an antiparallel manner to form a disk like unit (Fig. 2c). This arrangement allows efficient space filling and a partial interdigitation of the polar methoxytriazine groups belonging to two antiparallel molecules.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Diffractograms corresponding to BT4 in (a) Colhp and (b) Colh. (c) Proposed model for the arrangement of two molecules of BT4 in a columnar slice. |
Compound BT6 displays two enantiotropic hexagonal columnar mesophases (ESI, Fig. S3†). In the cooling process, a dendritic texture typical of a columnar mesophase developed at 116 °C (Fig. 1b). This texture became blurred at 42 °C, i.e., at the transition to another columnar mesophase, and remained stable at room temperature (Fig. 1c). The diffractogram observed for the room temperature mesophase (ColAh) is consistent with a hexagonal columnar mesophase with a cell parameter (a) of 36.9 Å and intracolumnar order with a stacking periodicity (c) of 3.3 Å (Fig. 3a). For the high temperature mesophase (ColBh) a cell parameter of 30.0 Å, which is much smaller than the low temperature phase, was measured and there is a loss of the regular molecular stacking along the columns (Fig. 3b and Table 2). Based on density calculations for the unit cell similar to those performed for BT4, the low temperature mesophase should contain about two molecules per unit cell (Z = 2), whereas the high temperature mesophase, with a 6.9 Å decrease in the (a) parameter, should contain only one (Z = 1). This means that in the ColAh-to-ColBh transition there is a change in the mode of arrangement, from a bimolecular assembly to a unimolecular assembly. A similar decrease in the cell parameter has been reported for derivatives of tris(triazolyl)triazine when they show bimolecular or unimolecular arrangements in the columnar mesophase.8 It is remarkable that in this case, the triazine–triazole group is in a different molecular geometry, a bent-shape and not a star-shape, and the two different columnar arrangements with hexagonal symmetry are found in the same compound with a first-order transition between them.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Diffractograms corresponding to compound BT6 in (a) ColAh at 20 °C and (b) ColBh at 100 °C, (c) partially oriented pattern at 20 °C, (d) partially oriented pattern at 100 °C. |
For both mesophases, it was also possible to prepare partially aligned samples (Fig. 3c and d). It was observed that some maxima were reinforced in the meridian region (direction parallel to the columnar axis), indicating that there are additional periodic modulations of the electronic density along the columns. In the room temperature mesophase (ColAh) these maxima are found at 15.5 Å and 3.3 Å. To account for this we propose a model in which two molecules are arranged in an antiparallel manner in a column slice (Fig. 4a), and these dimers are stacked at 3.3 Å and arranged periodically along the columnar axis, in such a way that each slice is rotated along the column in order to give a periodicity of 15.5 Å. This situation can be explained by considering that there is a repetitive situation every 15.5/3.3 slices, i.e., approximately 4.5 dimers. Since each dimer has a binary symmetry axis, 4.5 dimers or 9 molecules mutually rotated by 40° will constitute a 180° turn (Fig. 4b). Therefore, in a 360° full turn there will be 9 dimers (18 molecules) and the twisted periodic structure will have a pitch distance of 15.5 × 2 = 31 Å.
In the case of the high temperature mesophase (ColBh), with Z = 1, the interdisk distance is not observed but there is a diffuse maximum that is reinforced in the meridian at a distance of 12.7 Å. This can be assigned to a stacking correlation of about 4 molecules, for which we propose an arrangement of the four molecules as two interdigitated dimers mutually rotated by 90° (Fig. 4c). Thus, the transition ColAh-to-ColBh on heating can be visualised as follows, the two molecules of the dimer situated in one columnar slice in the low temperature phase start to interdigitate and overlap, resulting in stacking of interdigitated antiparallel dimers (Fig. 4b), thus leading to a decrease in the diameter of the columns.
In view of these arrangements and the possible orientation of the polar molecules along a column to give rise to a polar response, electric fields up to 60 V μm−1 were applied by sandwiching BT6 in a Linkam cell (5 μm thick). The sample was very viscous and reorientation effects or polar switching was not observed in either of the two mesophases. The dielectric permittivity at 1 kHz was measured using an HP4192 impedance analyzer. The transition between the two columnar phases, as well as the transition to the isotropic phase, was clearly visible as a change in the dielectric permittivity (Fig. 5). However, despite the fact that both columnar phases have a rather low permittivity value, this value is lower in the high temperature ColBh and this could be due to the interdigitated antiparallel arrangement of the dimers.
Compound BTB6 exhibits a stable enantiotropic columnar mesophase from room temperature up to the clearing point at 172 °C. Curled birefringent filaments were observed by POM on cooling from the isotropic liquid into the mesophase (Fig. 1d). The enthalpy value, 29.4 kJ mol−1, is consistent with a highly ordered mesophase and the fluidity found at room temperature demonstrates the mesomorphic nature (ESI, Fig. S4 and S5†). The XRD pattern only displays a reflection in the low angle region but, together with two additional reflections that are reinforced in an orthogonal direction, this allows us to assign the mesophase as hexagonal columnar with a cell parameter of 43.2 Å and a periodic interdisk distance of 3.4 Å. Density estimations indicate that the number of molecules per unit cell is two (Z = 2). Analysis of a partially aligned sample of this compound revealed that, as before, there are two reflections that are reinforced in the meridian region, one at 3.4 Å (interdisk distance) and an additional one at 15.1 Å (Fig. 6). In contrast to BT6 the reflections are unusually strong and are very well defined, which indicates that the intracolumnar order has a longer range.62 These results are also in agreement with the type of growth of the mesophase texture from the isotropic liquid. As discussed for the ColAh phase of BT6, the intramolecular periodic distance of 15.1 Å led us to propose a similar arrangement for BTB6, in which there is a twisted periodic structure formed by 4.5 stacked dimers (9 molecules) mutually rotated by 40° along the columnar axis. Therefore, for BTB6 a similar model to the one represented for the ColAh of BT6 would apply (Fig. 4b).
Compound | λTHFabs/nm (log![]() |
λcyclohexaneabs/nm (log![]() |
λTHFem/nm | λcyclohexaneem/nm | λfilmabs/nm | λfilmem/nm | Φ |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Low solubility.b Quantum yields in THF relative to 9,10-diphenylanthracene (Φ = 0.9 in cyclohexane).69c Quantum yields in THF relative to 2-(4-biphenylyl)-5-phenyl-1,3,4-oxadiazole (PBD) (Φ = 0.8 in benzene).70 | |||||||
BT2 | 283 (4.63), 289sh (4.61) | —a | 366 | —a | 270, 286sh | 405 | 0.10b |
BT4 | 277 (4.73) | 283 (3.67), 300 (3.50) | 446 | 380 | 254, 302 | 459 | 0.64b |
BT6 | 255 (4.50), 294 (4.61) | 253 (4.49), 293 (4.50) | 464 | 397 | 266, 305 | 473 | 0.13b |
BTB2 | 275 (4.97) | —a | 378 | —a | 282 | 441 | ≤0.01c |
BTB4 | 273 (4.92), 291 (4.85) | 276 (3.84), 295 (3.81) | 376 | 393 | 273, 295, 303sh | 425 | ≤0.01c |
BTB6 | 284 (4.87) | 283 (4.93) | 375 | 347 | 284 | 406 | ≤0.01c |
In solution, for both BTs and BTBs the maximum absorption is located in the UV spectrum below 300 nm and, due to their absorption coefficient values, is consistent with π–π* transitions. In the condensed phase the profile is similar to that obtained for the solutions but with small red-shifts. Compounds of the BT series are fluorescent in THF solution in the blue-green region of the visible spectrum and they have low or moderate quantum yield values. The emission maxima are dependent on the number of peripheral long tails, with a clear red-shift observed when the number increases from two to six. The Stokes shifts therefore increase, with values of 82 nm, 169 nm and 170 nm for BT2, BT4 and BT6, respectively. These values are consistent with a higher charge transfer and/or conformational relaxation in the excited state on increasing the number of peripheral chains, as described for star-shaped compounds with a similar triazole–triazine group54 or with other nitrogenated mesogens.63,65 The emission maxima are also red-shifted on increasing the polarity of the solvent from cyclohexane to THF. This effect is found in molecular systems with electron donor groups (alkoxy) linked to an electron acceptor group (triazine) by a similar conjugated system55 and it is known as positive solvatofluorochromism.66
For the BTB series the emission bands in solution appear in the near-UV region, the emission maxima in THF are almost insensitive to the number of long tails of the compounds and the Stokes shift values are around 100 nm. The main difference between BTs and BTBs is that the introduction of the benzoyloxy groups increased the possibility of non-radiative deactivation pathways and much lower quantum yield values than for BT series are found.
All compounds show luminescence as thin films at room temperature in the blue-green region of the visible spectrum. BT derivatives show, as in solution, a red-shift on increasing the number of chains at the periphery. The opposite is found for the BTBs, indicating that in this case the polarity of the excited states is different. The emission spectra of BT6 in both columnar phases were also measured (Fig. 7). The spectra of the two phases show a broad band consistent with compact or homogeneous packing, but at slightly different wavelengths, 473 nm for ColAh and 464 nm for ColBh. The longer emission wavelength of the low temperature mesophase is consistent with the observed longer degree of intracolumnar order.67
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Synthetic procedures and characterisation data, DSC thermograms, UV-Vis and emission spectra and electrochemical data. See DOI: 10.1039/c4ra02926g |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2014 |