Asghari Gulab,
Zareen Akhter*b,
Rumana Qureshib and
Arshad S. Bhattia
aDepartment of Physics, COMSATS IIT, Islamabad, Pakistan
bDepartment of Chemistry, Quaid-i-Azam University, Islamabad 45320, Pakistan. E-mail: zareenakhter@yahoo.com
First published on 18th April 2014
A poly(azomethine)ester was synthesized via solution phase polycondensation of isophthaloyl chloride and preformed 4-((2-(4-hydroxibenzylideneamino)ethylimino)methyl)phenol (SB). Various aliphatic and aromatic moieties were incorporated in the parent chain to process them and for examining their effect on the conducting properties. To provide an insight into the electronic properties, DFT calculations at the 6-31G/B3LYP level were carried out. Emphasis was placed on exploring the Frontier electron density, energy gaps and electrostatic potential maps to predict their conducting behaviour and electrophilic/nucleophilic reactivity. Our results based on experimental data and theoretical studies showed that in spite of some discrepancies, the electronic properties can be approximated theoretically to design a material having the desired properties for organic electronic devices. The material was characterized by FTIR, 1H NMR spectroscopic studies and elemental analysis.
Nowadays, these polymers can be designed theoretically employing density functional theory (DFT) calculations of their optimized molecular geometries. Performing DFT calculations on conducting polymers is challenging because of their size (large number of atoms); however, they can be approximated using oligomeric/repeat unit model compounds. Addition of different sequences to the chain creates wide possibilities for the modification of their properties.17
To the best of our knowledge, there are only few articles describing the structural elucidation and predictive study of electrical properties (complemented by experimental data) of newly synthesized macro chains.17 Thus, we report herein, the synthesis and characterization of poly(azomethine)ester (PAME) and a variety of aliphatic/aromatic terpolymers. The structure–property relation in terms of electrical conductivity is discussed. G0W3 was employed for the 3D electron density mapping of the chains. ΔE along with HOMO/LUMO coefficients were calculated and compared with the experimental data.
Synthesis of the monomer SEM-EDX of a neat and doped material is given in the ESI,† whereas the thermal behaviour and molecular weight by laser light scattering will be discussed in our future article.
PAMEs were found to be insoluble in all the organic and inorganic solvents owing to the presence of bulky aromatic groups in the main chain.18,19 In an attempt to process the material, different commercial diols (Pr, H, Si, B or F, Scheme 2) containing aromatic, semi-aromatic, silyl and fluoro moieties were assimilated in the parent polymer chains (PI) to improve their solubility in organic or inorganic solvents.19 Subsequently, five aliphatic/aromatic terpolymers were synthesized, which were still insoluble in any solvent. After various attempts, eventually, the material was solubilized by supra molecular modification employing p-toluene sulphonic acid.9 The macrochains become completely soluble in DMSO and sparingly in THF, ethanol and methanol.
The structure of the synthesized PI was confirmed by the presence of characteristic absorption peaks in their respective areas. Significant changes were observed in the spectral properties of initial compounds and products as some of the signals disappeared and some new signals appeared. Stretching vibration for (CO) and (C–O) appearing in the range of 1720–1750(s) cm−1 and 1101–1200(s) cm−1, respectively, confirmed the presence of ester linkage in PI. An additional peak around 1600–1645(s) cm−1 confirmed the presence of azomethine linkage in the macrochains. Two symmetric peaks in the ester and azomethine region in each terpolymer confirm the successful incorporation of diol moieties in the parent chain. The FTIR spectra showed characteristic peaks related to the added diols in addition to the one common in all the spectra. The aliphatic absorption band (C–H aliphatic) appeared around 3000–2900 cm−1 in the spectra of PIH and PIPr. The characteristic FTIR absorption peaks for the (Si–O–Si) group present in silanol containing polymers like PISi appeared as doublet around 1020 cm−1 and 2900 cm−1. The presence of aromatic C–H in polymers, such as PIF and PIB, was confirmed by the appearance of a peak around 3100 cm−1. Occurrence of C–Cl in the range of 780–540 cm−1 along with the disappearance of the hydroxyl group peak in PAME and its condensation terpolymers revealed that they have an acid chloride group at the terminal.18–20
1H NMR spectroscopy was also used for the structural analysis of PAMEs. The study was performed after the protonation of samples with p-toluene sulphonic acid (dopant engineering) in DMSO, using TMS as the internal reference. 1H NMR studies showed the presence of all types of protons expected for the proposed structures. Resonance in the range of 8.5–7.7 ppm, common for all spectra, was attributed to the presence of the HCN proton, whereas the signal that appeared in the range of 6.9–7.9 ppm showed aromatic protons. In addition to these signals, which were common in all the spectra, the polymer having aliphatic diols (Pr and H) showed multiple signals in the range of 0.7–2.3 ppm (aliphatic –CH). The polymer (PIB) showed additional signals in the range of 7.0–8.0 ppm (additional aromatic rings of the added diols) and 2.3 ppm (–CH3 present in bisphenol A). PIF showed resonance around 7.4 to 8.1 (aromatic rings), slightly deshielded owing to the presence of electronegative F (CF3) in the added diol. The silanol based material exhibited additional resonance peaks at 1.9–2.1 (CH3 attached to Si). The signal present in the range of 2–2.5 (–CH3) and 2–2.2 (OH) confirm the protonation in the main chain. OH group appeared at the lower field owing to the magnetic anisotropy of the aromatic ring present in the p-toluene sulphonic acid group.18–20
The calculations for the elemental analysis of polymers were done on the basis of the structure of repeat units present in the polymer chain. The data for C, H and N content in the polymers were found to be in relatively good agreement with the presumed structure for the condensation terpolymer. The Si in the copolymers having dimethylsiloxane reacts with C at a high temperature to make a ceramic material. Therefore, their elemental analysis was not possible19,20 and such polymers are currently investigated as precursors to ceramic materials.
Codes | ΔE eV | Holes | LUMO coefficients |
---|---|---|---|
a Neat.b Silver doped.c Polymer blends. Conductivity of PANI at R.T is 1 S cm−1. | |||
aPI, N = 4.1 × 10−14, bSD = 3.44 × 10−5, cPB = 1.54 × 10−3 | LUMO = −0.0824, HOMO = −0.1949, ΔE = 0.11 | 41 | −0.032(3C), 0.033(11C), −0.046(13C), 0.030(15C), −0.021(16C), 0.35(37O), 0.002(37O), −0.0002(38O), −0.04(41H), −0.79(42H), −0.71(43H), −0.64(44H), −0.15(45H), 0.0033(47H), −0.0008(48H), 0.016(49H) |
aPIF, N = 4 × 10−14, bSD = 3.4 × 10−4, cPB = 3.5 × 10−3 | LUMO = −0.02051, HOMO = −0.09950, ΔE = 0.08 | 69 | −0.012(41O), −0.0008(49H), 0.0089(50C), 0.077(51C), −0.056(53C), −0.11(62C), 0.35(64C), −0.11(66C), −0.09(71O), 0.58(73C), −0.13(76F), −0.3(77F), 0.27(78F), 0.03(79C), 0.076(81F), −0.012(41O), −0.0006(49H), 0.009(50C), 0.077(51C), −0.05(53C), −0.104(62C), 0.38(64C), −0.103(66C), −0.09(71O), 0.5(73C), −0.16(74C), −0.39(76F), −0.29(77F), 0.25(78F), 0.033(79F), 0.16(81F) |
aPISi, N = 5 × 10−15, bSD = 4.5 × 10−7, cPB = 4.0 × 10−6 | LUMO = −0.13330, HOMO = −0.171254, ΔE = 0.04 | 113 | 0.35(11C), 0.37(13C), 0.38(15C), 0.12(16C), 0.002(H19), 0.004(21C), 0.0045(22C), 0.0006(23C), 0.01(24C), 0.00105(25C), 0.00105(25C), 0.20(26C), 0.0006(27H), 0.002(28H), 0.0022(29H), 0.005(30H), 0.8(31C), 0.021(32C), 0.78(34C), 0.02(35C), 0.0025(36C), 0.137(37N), 0.363(38N), 0.005(39O), 0.2(40O) |
aPIPr, N = 5.9 × 10−16, bSD = 6.4 × 10−8, cPB = 6.1 × 10−7 | LUMO = −0.09850, HOMO = −0.14642, ΔE = 0.05 | 53 | −0.005(11C), −0.007(12C), 0.02(13C), −0.05(14C), 0.03(15C), −0.016(16C), −0.007(17H), −0.005(18H), 0.01(19H), −0.0077(20H), 0.01(21C), 0.44(22C), −0.34(23C), 0.23(24C), 0.32(25C), −0.56(26C), −0.009(27H), 0.0049(28H), 0.005(29H), 0.04(30H), 0.29(31C), 0.16(32C) |
aPIH, N = 4.1 × 10−15, bSD = 5.4 × 10−6, cPB = 5 × 10−7 | LUMO = 0.0012, HOMO = −0.04434, ΔE = 0.042 | 57 | 0.016(50C), 0.002(51H), 0.0013(52H), 0.002(53H), −0.00143(54H), −0.002(55H), −0.009(56H), 0.0091(57H), 0.0032(58C), −0.0020(59C), 0.00064(60C), −0.0005(61O), −0.0001(62H), −0.00043(63H), −0.0003(64H), 0.0006(65H), −0.0006(66H), 0.00116(67H), −0.00028(68H), −0.00055(69H), 0.00013, −0.049(70C) |
aPIB, N = 1.5 × 10−13, bSD = 1.9 × 10−4, cPB = 1.5 × 10−2 | LUMO = −0.09312, HOMO = −0.12752, ΔE = 0.04 | 75 | −0.00003(1C), −0.0037(2C), −0.003(3C), −0.0036(4C), −0.00036(5C), 0.0036(6C), −0.00006(7H), 0.00013(8H), −0.00062(9H), −0.00014(19H), −0.0004(11C), −0.0004(12C), −0.003(13C), 0.115(21C), −0.064(22C), −0.005(23C), 0.05(24C), −0.038(25C), −0.025(26C), 0.00145(27H), 0.00063(28H), 0.00034(29H), 0.0054(30C), −0.0082(31C), 0.004(32C), 0.001(33C), −0.07(34C), −0.00004(N), −0.0007(36N), 0.02(38O), 0.055(39O), 0.103(40O), −0.011(41O), −0.002(44H), 0.00135(45H), 0.00132(46H), 0.0003(48H), 0.0031(49H), −0.1(51C), −0.114(52C) |
The influence of the structure on the electrical properties of condensation terpolymers was also studied. The material with continuous conjugation in the chain (PI and PIB) showed maximum conductivity; however, PIF has relatively low conductivity owing to the presence of the highly electronegative hexafluoroisopropylidene group in the macrochain. The polymers based on methylene and silyl spacers have the lowest conductivity among all, which might be because of the suspension of conjugation in the chains due to the presence of these moieties. The study also showed that the lower conductivity of the neat material, as the undoped polymers, usually have an energy gap of >2 eV, which is too high for conduction.11–13 Since most organic polymers do not have intrinsic charge carriers, the required charge carriers could be introduced in the material either by partial oxidation (p-doping) with electron acceptors (e.g. I2 and AsF5) or by partial reduction (n-doping) with electron donors (e.g. Na and K). Through a doping process, charged defects (e.g. polaron, bipolaron and soliton) could be introduced in the structures, which then serve as charge carriers. For the presented work, all the polymers were doped with silver involving the removal of electrons from the HOMO of poly(azomethine)esters and thus forming positive hole and counter anions. Elimination of two electrons from the same energy level form a bipolaron, which causes a decrease in the band gap and thus, increase in the conductivity of the material.12,13
Polymer matrix was also blended with PANI. The trend of conductivity was found to be the same as was in a neat material; however, the material blended with PANI was found to be more conducting as compared to the silver doped material, which was in accordance to the literature, Table 1.
In spite of intensive research, the relationship between morphology, chain structure and conductivity is still poorly understood. However, it is assumed that conductivity should be higher for the higher degree of crystallinity and better alignment of the chains; however, this could not be confirmed for PANI, which is amorphous in nature. To explain whether the trend observed in conductivity can be explained theoretically considering the molecular properties, DFT calculations were carried out.
Based on literature, in addition to ΔE, the carrier movement and the movement of holes are also involved in the conduction process, where holes (theoretically) are regions where there is no electron density and the coefficients (mixing ratio) of atoms involved in HOMO are zero. In addition, the coefficients of atoms involved in LUMO are also important as they facilitate the carrier movement up to the point, and it is also known that the higher the coefficient, the greater is the electron density on excitation. Zero or very low LUMO coefficients are visualized as impaired carrier movement.
To explain the results, the coefficients of the atoms involved in HOMO were examined to study the role of intrinsic holes (zero coefficient shows the presence of a hole) as they seem to contribute in the conduction process. Since there is significant involvement of LUMO in conduction, these coefficients were also investigated, as shown in Table 1.
The highest conductivity observed in polymer, PIB, can now be explained by considering its low band gap, number of HOMO (holes) and contribution of LUMO. Both PI and PIF have approximately the same conductivity although both differ in their band gaps. The good electrical conductivity of these polymers may be due to the presence of holes in HOMO and the significant LUMO electron density at the connecting atoms (centers). The polymer PISi showed less conductivity although it has a ΔE value of 0.04, which might be due to the presence of low electron density at some centers in the chain. Thus, low eigen values are responsible for the lower conductivity of polymer PISi as compared to others as expected. The polymers PIPr and PIH have low ΔE (0.05 a.u. and 0.04 a.u., respectively), which indicate an easier excitation of electrons from HOMO to LUMO. However, the conductivity of these polymers was low, i.e., 5.9 × 10−16 and 4 × 10−15, respectively, as compared to the PIB.22,23
Our calculations showed that a low band gap does not ensure facile conduction as no correlation was found in the band gap and conductivity. The results suggest that the presence of intrinsic holes as well as significant contribution from the atoms in LUMO also contribute to the conductivity (Fig. 1).
The electrostatic potential V(r) maps are well-known for the identification of one species by the other; thus, this methodology can be used to evaluate the electronic distribution around the molecular surface for the macrochains. The electrostatic potential has been used primarily for predicting sites and relative reactivities towards electrophilic attacks, and in the studies of biological recognition and hydrogen bonding interactions. It can be seen that the macromolecules are stable with an almost uniform distribution of charge density. The oxygen and nitrogen atoms are surrounded by a greater negative charge surface, making these sites potentially more favorable for an electrophilic attack (red). Among these two sites, the nitrogen atoms having higher values are more susceptible to attacks, which support the H bonding of p-toluene sulphonic acid in dopant engineering. Similarly, those with minimum electron density are prone to nucleophilic attack (blue color), as shown in Fig. 2. The representative electrostatic potential data for PI are given in Table 2.20–23
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Electrostatic potential map, PI: yellow color around N and O atoms indicates an electron rich area prone to the electrophilic attack. |
Atoms | Electrostatic potential | Atoms | Electrostatic potential | Atoms | Electrostatic potential |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
C34 | 0.0027 | C14 | −0.0005 | C13 | −0.0065 |
O39 | −0.026 | C15 | −0.007 | O49 | 0.002 |
O40 | −0.007 | C16 | −0.015 | N32 | −0.02 |
H51 | 0.0165 | C11 | −0.0174 | H44 | −0.028 |
C23 | −0.0013 | C12 | −0.0106 | C48 | 0.007 |
C21 | 0.0038 | H18 | −0.012 | N36 | −0.0065 |
C26 | 0.001 | H17 | −0.0174 | H50 | 0.009 |
C25 | −0.00162 | H19 | 0.0074 | H46 | −0.00023 |
C29 | −0.0025 | H20 | 0.0055 | H27 | 0.0138 |
H28 | 0.0072 | C33 | −0.010 |
PANI was prepared as reported previously.16,17 PAME/PANI was taken in the weight ratio percentage of 9:
1. The powder was ground, blended in a crucible for homogenous mixing and dried in oven at 40 °C for 6 h. The material doped with silver or blended with PANI was compressed into pellets under a 5 ton load for conductivity measurements at room temperature.16,17
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Synthesis of monomer, SEM-EDX of neat and doped material. See DOI: 10.1039/c4ra02443e |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2014 |