Yuyan Liu*a,
Hongjun Kanga,
Xianyun Gongab,
Liqin Jianga,
Yuting Liua and
Sonquan Wu*a
aSchool of Chemical Engineering and Technology, Harbin Institute of Technology, Harbin 150001, P. R. China. E-mail: liuyy@hit.edu.cn; wusongquan@hit.edu.cn; Fax: +86-0451-86413711; Tel: +86-0451-86413711
bSchool of Science, Department of Chemistry, Harbin University, Harbin 150086, P. R. China
First published on 24th April 2014
Chemical decomposition of an epoxy resin (E-51) cured with methyl tetrahydro phthalic anhydride (MeTHPA) in near-critical water conditions was investigated under different concentrations of acid–base catalyst. The optimal catalytic concentration of KOH catalyst ranged from 0.5 mol L−1 to 1.0 mol L−1, while that of H2SO4 catalyst was 0.4 mol L−1. Meanwhile, the decomposition ratio of the E-51/MeTHPA system could reach up to 97.7–100%. In addition, FT-IR results of the solid residue of the E-51/MeTHPA system before and after near-critical water treatment showed that the changes of the molecular structure were mainly reflected in the changes of the relative contents of mixed ether bonds, cross-linked bonds and other functional groups. The decomposition products in the acetone phase were identified by GC-MS. The results suggested that the main compositions and relative peak areas of the decomposition products varied with the change of the concentration of acid–base catalyst. Finally, a possible decomposition reaction mechanism was proposed for the E-51/MeTHPA system.
So far, the known recycling technologies for epoxy resin mainly include mechanical recycling,4 thermal recycling5–7 and chemical recycling.8 Among them, the chemical recycling is a new and promising route to transform polymer matrices of high molecular weight into low molecular weight molecules.9,10 In recent years, supercritical water (SCW, T = 374 °C, P = 22.1 MPa) and near-critical water (NCW, temperature at 250–350 °C) methods, which belong to chemical recycling methods, have been considered novel and effective methods to degrade epoxy resin due to the fact that water is nontoxic, cost-effective, readily available and is classed as a green media.11–13 In previous studies, P. H. Raul et al. succeed in recycling carbon fiber composites under subcritical and supercritical conditions using alcohols as reactive-extraction media.14 Y. P. Bai et al. recycled carbon fibers from CFRP in supercritical water in the presence of oxygen and found that oxygen could promote the decomposition of epoxy resin.15 J. Liu et al. recycled carbon fiber reinforced epoxy resin composites in subcritical water with the addition of phenol and KOH and discovered that the combination of KOH and phenol could promote the decomposition efficiency.16
In this study, near-critical water (NCW) method was applied to investigate the decomposition of E-51/MeTHPA system. The effects of different catalyst types and concentrations on the decomposition ratio and decomposition products of E-51/MeTHPA system were investigated to obtain the optimal decomposition condition. Meanwhile, a possible decomposition reaction mechanism was proposed for E-51/MeTHPA system.
:
84.7
:
1 and then stirred constantly with a glass rod until a homogeneous mixture was obtained. The above blend was injected into the stainless steel mold before reaching the gel time and cured at 100 °C for 2 h and then heated to 150 °C for another 5 h. Finally, the cured epoxy resin was cut into cubic samples with size of 20 mm × 20 mm × 2 mm.
:
10 (g mL−1). The reactions were carried out at 270 °C for 45 min in a near-critical condition. When the decomposition reaction was finished, the removable reactor was put into cold water and cooled to room temperature. The aqueous phase decomposition products were collected. The solid residues were immersed in acetone for 24 h, washed 3 times with distilled water and dried at 100 °C for 24 h in a vacuum oven. Finally, the collected acetone immersing liquid was analyzed by GC-MS and the dried solid residues were weighted to calculate the decomposition ratio using the following formula (1). The decomposition ratio was averaged with each experiment repeated three times.
![]() | (1) |
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 The curve of decomposition ratio of the E-51/MeTHPA cured system versus the concentration of H2SO4 catalyst. Reaction conditions: T = 270 °C, t = 45 min, feedstock = 1/10 (g mL−1). | ||
Fig. 4 shows the influence of the concentration of KOH catalyst on the decomposition ratio of E-51/MeTHPA system in near-critical water. As can be seen from Fig. 4, the decomposition ratio of the E-51/MeTHPA system was almost 41.1 wt% without adding the KOH catalyst. When the concentration of KOH catalyst was 0.05 mol L−1, the decomposition ratio of the resin system significantly increased to 85 wt%. With the increasing concentration of KOH catalyst, the decomposition ratio continued to increase in general. When the concentration of KOH catalyst increased to 0.5 mol L−1, the E-51/MeTHPA system was decomposed completely and the decomposition ratio nearly reached 100 wt%. From the above analysis, the optimal catalytic concentration of KOH catalyst was in the range from 0.5 mol L−1 to 1.0 mol L−1.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 4 The curve of decomposition ratio of the E-51/MeTHPA cured system versus the concentration of KOH catalyst. Reaction conditions: T = 270 °C, t = 45 min, feedstock = 1/10 (g mL−1). | ||
Compared the effects of acid catalyst (H2SO4) and base catalyst (KOH) on the decomposition ratio of the E-51/MeTHPA system, it could be concluded that they all could improve the decomposition ratio of the resin system, and the decomposition ratio could reach 97.7–100 wt%. This could be explained as the following: the decomposition ratio of the resin system was determined by the concentration of hydroxyl or hydronium ions in near-critical water condition and the outstanding effect of KOH and H2SO4 catalysts on the decomposition ratio of the E-51/MeTHPA system mainly resulted from a promotion effect of the concentration of hydroxyl or hydronium ions.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 5 The FT-IR spectra of original resin and catalytic decomposition residues: (a) original resin; (b) H2SO4 catalytic decomposition residue and (c) KOH catalytic decomposition residue. | ||
From the above analysis, we could find that the changes of the structure of solid residue were mainly reflected in the content change of ether, ester bond and other functional groups in catalytic decomposition process. Carbon–carbon bond and ether bond in the main chain of epoxy as well as the crosslink bond of the E-51/MeTHPA system were broken under the action of hydrolysis, and then combined with the active hydrogen or hydroxide ions in the system to form substances with stable structure.
The main components the liquid decomposition in near-critical water condition with 0.5 mol L−1 KOH catalyst were shown in Table 2. From the Table 2, it could be found that the major components of the liquid decomposition products were phenol, benzyl alcohol, p-isopropylphenol, p-isopropenyl phenol, bisphenol A and 2,6-di-tert-butyl-4-methylphenol (BHT), whose relative peak area were 64.69%, 2.95%, 7.90%, 3.89%, 0.85% and 7.13% respectively. Meanwhile, the majority of decomposition products were phenolic compounds and anhydride related products were still not detected in an alkaline environment of high concentration. Compared to Table 1, it could be found that the relative peak area of phenol compound in the liquid decomposition products increased from 48.09% to 64.69%, which could be explained that the mixed ether bonds in the main chain generated the large-scale fracture and the inhibition degree of hydrolysis of the ester bond strengthened. The relative peak area of bisphenol A compound decreased from 6.97% to 0.85%, which might be attributed to the decrease of stability of bisphenol A, which could be transformed into phenol and p-isopropenyl phenol with the increasing of concentration of KOH catalyst. Therefore, the change of the concentration of KOH catalyst had selectivity to the compositions of the liquid decomposition products.
Likewise, the major components of the liquid catalytic decomposition products in near-critical water condition with different concentration of H2SO4 catalyst were investigated by GC/MS. Table 3 presents the major components of the liquid catalytic decomposition products in near-critical water condition with 0.1 mol L−1 H2SO4 catalyst. The major compounds the major components of the liquid decomposition products were phenolic compounds, anhydrides and a small quantity of alcohols, whose relative peak area were 43.62%, 18.69% and 7.44% respectively. This result indicated that H2SO4 played an important part in promoting the hydrolysis of ether bond in the main chain and cross-linked bonds between resin and curing agent. Hydrolysis of ether bond was still dominant relative to that of cross-linked ester bond.
Table 4 shows the major components of the liquid catalytic decomposition products in near-critical water condition with 0.4 mol L−1 H2SO4 catalyst. It could be found that the major components of the liquid decomposition products were still phenolic compounds, anhydrides and a small quantity of alcohols, whose relative peak area were 32.1%, 33.88% and 2.78% respectively. Compared with Table 3, the relative peak area of phenol, anhydrides and aromatic dicarboxylic acid increased significantly, implying that the increasing of H2SO4 catalyst concentration was advantageous to the hydrolysis of the cross-linked bonds between the resin and curing agent. Through the above analysis, it could be concluded that the change of the concentration of H2SO4 catalyst had selectivity to the way of bond breaking of the resin system.
In summary, it could be concluded that KOH and H2SO4 catalysts could promote the fracture of mixed ether and ester bonds in different extent and change the composition of the liquid decomposition products. When KOH was used as catalyst, the content of phenolic compounds was higher, implying that KOH catalyst restrained the hydrolysis of ester bonds and had a stronger role in promoting the hydrolysis of ether bonds. When H2SO4 was used as catalyst, the breaking proportion of ether bonds and ester bonds were in equal.
Near-critical water is considered to be an excellent reaction medium for organic chemical reactions. The decomposition reaction mechanism of the E-51/MeTHPA system in the near-critical water is proposed. Based on the previous analysis, the hydrolysis of mixed ether bonds and cross-linked bonds of the E-51/MeTHPA system was the main way of bond breaking. Scheme 1 illustrates possible mechanisms of the decomposition reaction of the E-51/MeTHPA system with different acid–base catalysts.
![]() | ||
| Scheme 1 Possible decomposition mechanism of the E-51/MeTHPA cured system in near-critical water with acid–base catalysts. | ||
From the results of GC-MS, phenol and phenol derivatives in the decomposition products were in high proportion when KOH was used as catalyst. On the above basis, KOH catalyst could accelerate the breakage of ether bond of the E-51/MeTHPA system, while the breakage of ester bond was restrained. Therefore, the decomposition reaction could be followed the path 2, 3 or 2, 3, 4 in Scheme 1, where the path 2, 3 was the main path. First, the hydronium ions attacked the ether bond in the main chain and decomposed them into bisphenol A monomer or other oligomers. After the bisphenol A could be further decomposed to phenol, p-isopropylphenol, p-isopropenyl phenol and other substances. However, when H2SO4 was used as the catalyst, the proportion of phenolic compounds was equivalent to that of anhydride compounds. H2SO4 catalyst had the same promotion effect on the breakage of ether bond and ester bond. Therefore, the decomposition reaction could be mainly followed the route 1, 2, 3, 4 in Scheme 1. First, the hydronium ions attacked the ether bond ester bond simultaneously in the main chain and decomposed them into bisphenol A, 3-methyl-4-cyclohexene-1,2-dicarboxylic acid, methyl tetrahydro phthalic anhydride and other oligomers, which could be followed the path 1, 2 in the Scheme 1. Then, the bisphenol A could be decomposed to phenol and the phenol could further undergo rearrangement reactions with some small molecules (i.e. propylene and methyl) to form the 2,6-di-tert-butyl-p-cresol and 2-tert-butyl-p-cresol, which could be followed the path 3, 4 in the Scheme 1.
| Methods | Temperature (°C) | Time (min) | Liquid yield (%) | Purity of phenol (%) | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pyrolysis | 400 | 60 | 35.1 | 2.4 | Sato et al.17 |
| Pyrolysis (CaCO3) | 61.9 | 9.4 | |||
| Nitric acid | 80 | 6000 | 100 | — | Dong et al.18 |
| Microwave (HNO3) | 120 | 75 | 100 | — | Bolasodun et al.19 |
| SCP (no KOH) | 293 | 20 | 92.12 | 30.76 | Jiang et al.20 |
| SCP (0.8% KOH) | 264–282 | 92.65 | 10.53 | ||
| NCW (0.4 M KOH) | 270 | 45 | 100 | 64.69 | This work |
| NCW (0.5 M H2SO4) | 97.7 | 18.67 |
In the present study, the near-critical water (NSW) was used for the decomposition of the E-51/MeTHPA system. The differences of the reaction condition, the acid–base catalyst, liquid yield and purity of phenol among the pyrolysis, nitric acid catalytic, microwave treatment, super-critical isopropanol (SCP) and near-critical water treatment (NSW) could be shown in Table 5. The advantages of the near-critical water treatment could be demonstrated as follows. First, the temperature applied in near-critical water treatment (270 °C) was much lower than the pyrolysis (400 °C) and the treatment time was shortened obviously, compared to the nitric acid treatment, so the energy consumption could be reduced. Second, high purity of phenol (64.69%) could be obtained by using near-critical water treatment with 0.5 mol L−1 KOH catalyst, which was much higher than that of the pyrolysis and SCP. Therefore, the high purity of phenol could be further purified to synthesize some other compounds (i.e. phenolic resin). Finally, during the treatment process, the reaction media was water, which is classed as a green media, due to its nontoxic, cost-effective, readily available.
(2) FT-IR results of the solid residue of the E-51/MeTHPA system before and after near-critical water treatment showed that the changes of the molecular structure were mainly reflected in the changes of relative contents of mixed ether bonds, cross-linked bonds and other functional groups. Mixed ether bonds in the main chain and cross-linking of the E-51/MeTHPA system were broken under the action of hydrolysis, and then combined with the active hydrogen and hydroxide ions in the system to form substances with stable structure.
(3) GC-MS was used to investigate the composition of liquid decomposition products in near-critical water condition with acid–base catalyst. When KOH was used as catalyst, phenol and phenol derivatives in the decomposition products were in high proportion. However, when H2SO4 was used as the catalyst, the major compositions of liquid decomposition products mainly included phenolic compounds and anhydride compounds.
(4) KOH and H2SO4 had different influences on the way of decomposition of the E-51/MeTHPA system. KOH catalyst could accelerate the breakage of ether bond of the E-51/MeTHPA system, while the breakage of ester bond was restrained. However, H2SO4 catalyst had the same promotion effect on the breakage of ether bond and ester bond.
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2014 |