Justin H. Lo†a, Geoffrey von Maltzahn†a, Jacqueline Douglassb, Ji-Ho Parkc, Michael J. Sailorde, Erkki Ruoslahtifg and Sangeeta N. Bhatia*ah
aHarvard-MIT Division of Health Sciences and Technology, 77 Massachusetts Ave. 76-453, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA. E-mail: sbhatia@mit.edu
bDepartment of Chemical Engineering, MIT, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02139, USA
cDepartment of Bio and Brain Engineering, Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology, Yuseong-gu, Daejeon 305-701, Korea
dMaterials Science and Engineering Program, University of California, San Diego, La Jolla, CA 92093, USA
eDepartment of Chemistry and Biochemistry, Department of Bioengineering, Department of Nanoengineering, University of California, San Diego, La Jolla, CA 92093, USA
fCancer Research Center, Sanford-Burnham Medical Research Institute, La Jolla, CA 92037, USA
gCenter for Nanomedicine and Department of Cell, Molecular and Developmental Biology, University of California, Santa Barbara, CA 93106, USA
hHoward Hughes Medical Institute, Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, MIT, David H. Koch Institute for Integrative Cancer Research, MIT, Department of Medicine, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, MA 02115, USA
First published on 4th June 2013
The success of nanoparticle-based cancer therapies ultimately depends on their ability to selectively and efficiently accumulate in regions of disease. Outfitting nanoparticles to actively target tumor-specific markers has improved specificity, yet it remains a challenge to amass adequate therapy in a selective manner. To help address this challenge, we have developed a mechanism of nanoparticle amplification based on stigmergic (environment-modifying) signalling, in which a “Signalling” population of gold nanorods induces localized unveiling of cryptic collagen epitopes, which are in turn targeted by “Responding” nanoparticles bearing gelatin-binding fibronectin fragments. We demonstrate that this two-particle system results in significantly increased, selective recruitment of responding particles. Such amplification strategies have the potential to overcome limitations associated with single-particle targeting by leveraging the capacity of nanoparticles to interact with their environment to create abundant new binding motifs.
Nanoparticle amplification has been used to great effect for ultra-sensitive cancer diagnostics, such as using gold nanosphere-mounted DNA bar codes for PCR-based detection of scarce proteins.6 Our group has recently begun exploring the possibility of harnessing amplification in the tumor setting through modalities including (1) dynamic nanoparticle-mediated upregulation of targetable surface receptors via the cellular machinery7 and (2) integration of nanoparticles into the self-amplifying coagulation cascade to generate targetable microclots.8 However, the possibility of exploiting the tumor environment as a substrate for amplified targeting has not yet been explored.
We hypothesize that amplification of nanoparticle binding can be mediated by selective disruption of tumor-associated extracellular matrix (ECM), thus incorporating a manner of “stigmergic” coordination, in which insoluble environmental cues left by a signalling population recruit an overwhelming responding population. ECM molecules adopt intricate superstructures that display rigid, repeating epitopes, and physical interruption of these structures can alter mechanosensitive binding sites. For instance, tensile disruption of fibronectin fibers has been shown to functionally eliminate binding epitopes recognized by pathogenic bacteria.9 Simultaneously, formerly cryptic motifs can emerge,10 serving as plentiful yet disease-specific binding sites.
In this work, we have constructed an amplification system around the denaturation of collagen, in which the signalling population consists of gold nanorods that accumulate near collagen and, as a result of near-infrared laser-induced surface plasmon resonance, denature collagen fibrils. These fibrils are then targeted by a responding population of fibronectin fragment-functionalized iron oxide nanoparticles that actively target denatured but not intact collagen (Fig. 1).
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 Schematic of nanoparticle amplification via photothermal denaturation of collagen. Near-infrared irradiation induces surface plasmon resonance in gold nanorods, locally heating collagen and exposing cryptic epitopes. Fibronectin fragment-conjugated nanoworms recognize denatured collagen but not intact fibrils, allowing them to ‘Respond’ to gold nanorod activity. This process produces specific, amplified accumulation of responding nanoparticles at sites of gold nanorod localization. |
To construct a collagen-centric amplification system out of nanoparticles, we developed a signalling mechanism to induce local hyperthemia and paired this with a secondary signal-responsive mechanism that would recognize and accumulate at binding sites revealed by hyperthermia. We selected PEG-protected gold nanorods as the signalling component, as they can heat the local environment through near infrared laser-mediated surface plasmon resonance (Fig. 2A and B). PEGylated gold nanorods are amenable to use as cancer therapy because of their small size, favorable circulation half-life of ∼17 hours,15 and peak excitation wavelength in the first near-infrared optical window (Fig. 2A), a range of wavelengths to which skin and other tissues are more permissive compared to visible or ultraviolet light.16
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Nanoparticle components comprising the signalling and responding modules. (A) Absorbance spectrum of gold nanorods. Inset: TEM of gold nanorods, scale bar: 40 nm. (B) Left: visible-light photograph of gold nanorod solution (left) and saline solution (right). Right: thermographic image contrasting heating response of gold nanorods (light) and saline solution (right) to near-infrared laser (λ = 808 nm). (C) TEM images of intact collagen fibers and collagen denatured by heating (inset). (D) The gelatin-binding proteolytic fragment of fibronectin (FnF, red) is used as a targeting domain, conjugated to a dextran-coated iron oxide nanoworm (NW) bearing near-infrared fluorescent tracking dye (green). Inset: TEM of iron oxide NW. Scale bar: 20 nm. (E) Size distributions of nanoworms conjugated to dye only (blue) or dye and FnF (red), as measured by dynamic light scattering. |
Heating collagen disrupts its tri-helical tertiary structure (Fig. 2C), revealing cryptic epitopes which represent a tumor-specific target for therapeutic secondary particles. We used a 45 kDa gelatin-binding fibronectin fragment (FnF) to target denatured collagen (Fig. 2D). To establish the minimal temperature that enables FnF recognition of the cryptic collagen I epitopes, we measured the temperature-dependent binding of unconjugated FnF to collagen-coated wells in a 96-well plate, compared to the binding of albumin control (Fig. 3A). Binding of FnF and albumin to uncoated plates was minimal and not temperature-dependent.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Characterization of the responding nanoparticles. (A) Relative binding of fluorescently labeled fibronectin fragment (FnF) or bovine serum albumin (Alb) to wells coated in collagen (Coll) or left uncoated, as a function of the temperature to which the collagen-coated or uncoated wells were subjected prior to protein addition. Temperature was regulated by water bath. Asterisks in (A) and (B) indicate statistical significance by two-way ANOVA with Bonferroni post test across temperatures, comparing against 37 °C (*: p < 0.05, **: p < 0.01, ***: p < 0.001). Error bars indicate standard deviation. (B) Relative temperature-dependent binding of FnF-conjugated nanoworms (FnF-NW) and albumin-conjugated nanoworms (Alb-NW) to collagen- or albumin-coated wells. Temperature was regulated by water bath. Inset: representative scans of fluorescent FnF-NWs (green) bound to collagen incubated at room temperature or 49 °C. Scale bar: 2 mm. (C) Normalized binding curves contrasting relative binding to denatured collagen as a function of FnF or FnF-NW concentration. (D) Normalized temperature-dependent binding curves, combined from (A) and (B), contrasting the relative binding of free FnF and FnF-NW to collagen heated to different temperatures. Asterisk indicates p < 0.05 by two-way ANOVA with Bonferroni post test (FnF-NWs vs. free FnF). Curve fit is a variable-slope sigmoidal dose response. |
Since practical applications would incorporate FnF as a targeting moiety rather than a standalone polypeptide, we generated representative responding nanoparticles that embody the typical size and multivalency of a potential therapeutic or diagnostic nanoparticle. For the backbone of these particles, we used aminated dextran-coated iron oxide nanoworms (NWs), which are elongated particles consisting of linear chains of approximately spherical cores.17 The NW backbone was selected because of its paramagnetic properties, demonstrated to be useful for MRI diagnostic applications. NWs with amine-conjugated near-infrared tracking fluorophores (VivoTag-S750) were functionalized with either FnF or albumin. Using dynamic light scattering, we determined that NWs with covalently linked FnF (FnF-NWs) had an average hydrodynamic diameter of 52.2 nm, versus 36.5 nm for NWs with near-infrared dye only, a size increase consistent with the addition of 45 kDa polypeptides over the surface of the nanoparticles (Fig. 2E).18
The temperature-dependent binding of the functionalized nanoworms was examined (in an analogous setup to the free protein experiment) to confirm their binding response to idealized collagen heating (Fig. 3B; see inset for representative imaging). To determine the effects of multivalency, we measured concentration-dependent binding of free FnF versus FnF-NW on a molar basis of protein or NW cores (Fig. 3C). These curves demonstrated a leftward shift along the concentration axis, indicating higher denatured collagen binding affinity for the FnF-NW formulation relative to free FnF. Furthermore, when the FnF and FnF-NW temperature-dependent binding curves from Fig. 3A and B are normalized for specific binding and compared head-to-head, there is an offset between the binding curves, with half-maximal binding temperatures of 43.4 °C for free FnF and 41.7 °C for FnF-NW (Fig. 3D).
Combining the signalling and responding components, we characterized the behavior of the full two-nanoparticle system. We introduced gold nanorods over collagen or control substrate (bovine serum albumin) in a 96-well plate and irradiated the wells to 45 ± 1 °C at steady-state, with nanorod concentrations and laser intensities based on experimental kinetic heating curves including those displayed in Fig. 4A. The laser power density required to heat the nanorods to the target temperature under these conditions was <0.5 W cm−2. After removal of the nanorods, the wells were then incubated with nanoworms conjugated to FnF or control albumin. Under these conditions, we observed a statistically significant six-fold increase in binding of the FnF-NWs to collagen over baseline unheated controls (p < 0.001), whereas combinations with control substrate or control targeting moieties showed no such increase (Fig. 4B). To demonstrate basic spatial specificity of the two-particle system, we added gold nanorods to specific wells of a collagen-coated 96-well plate in a pattern (Fig. 4C, inset; nanorod-containing wells denoted by red fill) and irradiated all wells equally with the near-infrared laser. Responding nanoparticles only accumulated appreciably in wells with nanorods, confirming that there was minimal heating independent of the nanorods (Fig. 4C).
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Amplification of nanoparticle accumulation through stigmergy. (A) Representative heating kinetics of gold nanorods at different concentrations (black circles: 0.0, green squares: 12.5, blue triangles: 17.7, purple triangles: 33.9, red diamonds: 70.6, all in μg mL−1), under constant irradiation by an 808 nm laser (∼120 mW cm−2). (B) Conjugated nanoworm binding to collagen or albumin substrates exposed to either unirradiated nanorods (left) or nanorods irradiated by near-infrared (NIR) laser to 45 °C (right). ***indicates p < 0.001 by two-way ANOVA with Bonferroni post test for irradiated vs. unirradiated. (C) Collagen-coated 96-well plate with nanoworms added only to wells in a pattern based on the “MIT” logo. The entire plate was irradiated by near-infrared laser as in (B), and all wells in the image were subsequently incubated with FnF-NWs. |
The consistency in binding enhancement across our different experimental configurations speaks to the modularity of the targeting moiety and its potential for use with a therapeutic responding particle rather than a diagnostic one such as the iron oxide NWs. The changes in collagen structure induced by either water bath or gold nanorod heating were not rapidly reversed when hyperthermia was withdrawn, as the responding particles in these experiments were only added after plates were cooled to 4 °C, suggesting that the system is forgiving towards temporal spacing between the two particle populations. This contrasts with amplification schemes which rely upon direct particle-to-particle interaction or catalysis, or the transient accumulation of soluble signalling intermediates. These findings corroborate evidence in the literature that the collagen I denaturation–renaturation process displays significant hysteresis, with much slower renaturation, and that reformed collagen fibrils have significant representation of homotrimers and partially unwound gelatin.12
The practicality of harnessing the instability of collagen fibrils was borne out in our temperature-dependent binding studies, wherein the binding of free FnF showed half-maximal binding at ∼43.4 °C, while the FnF-NWs reached half-maximal binding at ∼41.7 °C. Importantly, these target temperatures lie within the bounds of mild hyperthermia previously described for non-ablative cancer therapy to enhance drug uptake.20 The lower temperature threshold for functionalized NWs versus free peptide (Fig. 3D) is favorable because it brings the temperatures required for optimal binding down from temperatures that could induce counterproductive coagulation. The basis of the binding at lower temperatures – and hence, with fewer binding sites – may be multivalent presentation of the FnF, which is supported by the lower concentration threshold for binding seen in FnF-NWs versus free FnF (Fig. 3C). Therefore, the use of nanoparticles as the responding element confers improved binding characteristics on account of multivalency.
On the signalling side of the amplification scheme, the need for nanoparticle “antennae” for the outwardly straightforward task of inducing hyperthermia is for the purposes of confining heat-mediated changes to a local site of disease, promoting specificity and safety. Because laser-induced heating only occurs where the nanorods have accumulated, as demonstrated in Fig. 4C, and because accumulated heat generally dissipates poorly from tumors,21 employing temperatures in the range of 40–45 °C in the tumor represents reduced risk of hyperthermic damage to surrounding tissue compared to local thermoablative tumor therapy.22,23 The choice of local heating rather than whole-body hyperthermia, modeled here by the water bath, helps to avoid the side-effects or mortality associated with elevating the entire body over 42.5 °C,21 and the 122–376 mW cm−2 laser power intensity used in our experiments (measurements not shown) is below or comparable to the conservative 330 mW cm−2 limit on occupational exposures to 808 nm light up to 3 × 104 s.24
Gold nanorod-mediated photothermal denaturation of ECM components as a mechanism of indirect signal amplification also presents potential benefits in future translation of such a system into animals. The TEM images of heat-induced unwinding of collagen (Fig. 2C) suggest the possibility of modifying the ECM in a manner which may promote greater transport through the barrier-like tumor stroma, which has been a strategy pursued previously through enzymatic25,26 and receptor-based27 means. In addition, the application of hyperthermia itself induces changes outside of ECM denaturation, and we predict that recruitment of the responding particles would be further enhanced in vivo due to transient vascular changes associated with tumor hyperthermia.28
Footnote |
† These authors contributed equally to this work. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2013 |