Ian W. Hamley*a, Ashkan Dehsorkhia, Valeria Castellettoa, Jani Seitsonenb, Janne Ruokolainenb and Hermis Iatrouc
aDepartment of Chemistry, University of Reading, Reading, RG6 6AD, UK. E-mail: I.W.Hamley@reading.ac.uk
bDepartment of Applied Physics, Aalto University School of Science, P.O.Box 15100, FI-00076 Aalto, Finland
cUniversity of Athens, Department of Chemistry, Panepistimiopolis Zografou, 157 71 Athens, Greece
First published on 28th March 2013
The self-assembly in aqueous solution of the alanine-rich peptide A12R2 containing twelve alanine residues and two arginine residues has been investigated. This oligomeric peptide was synthesized via NCA-polymerization methods. The surfactant-like peptide is found via FTIR to form antiparallel dimers which aggregate into twisted fibrils, as revealed by cryogenic-transmission electron microscopy. The fibril substructure is probed via detailed X-ray scattering experiments, and are uniquely comprised of twisted tapes only 5 nm wide, set by the width of the antiparallel A12R2 dimers. The packing of the alanine residues leads to distinct “β-sheet” spacings compared to those for amyloid-forming peptides. For this peptide, β-sheet structure coexists with some α-helical content. These ultrafine amyloid fibrils present arginine at high density on their surfaces, and this may lead to applications in nanobiotechnology.
In previous work, we have examined the self-assembly of the surfactant-like peptide A6K (prepared as TFA salt), introduced by Zhang et al.,8,9 into nanotubes.10 Flow-aligning X-ray diffraction enabled a detailed model for the helical arrangement of the peptides within the walls of the nanotubes to be proposed. This was based on salt-bridged dimers, with a two-residue offset shift between adjacent dimers.10 This research built on earlier work by Bucak et al. which indicated that, at sufficiently high concentration in aqueous solution A6K forms nanotubes with a very thin wall, possibly single wall nanotubes, stabilized by the headgroup charge.11
In the present work, we investigate the self-assembly, of A12R2, containing two arginine residue as headgroup. Arginine is a highly basic residue (pKa = 12 approximately12) incorporating a guanidinium group which due to delocalization of the charge is able to form bidentate hydrogen bonds.13 Cell-penetrating peptides such as the TAT protein transduction domain14 peptide or penetratin15 are often rich in arginine residues16 and are extensively used as potential delivery vehicles for siRNA and DNA. Compared to most cell-penetrating peptides A12R2 presents a greatly simplified surfactant-like design and in the present paper we examine its self-assembly behavior which turns out to have a number of remarkable features. The oligomeric peptide is synthesized using N-carboxyanhydride (NCA) polymerization which is a valuable technique for the synthesis of “block copolypeptides”.17 Standard solid phase synthesis methods would be extremely problematic for peptides of this type due to the multiple repeat units, which would lead to aggregation during synthesis causing the growing chain to fold back on itself, meaning that the incoming amino acid cannot be added causing chain termination usually between a 7-mer and 9-mer. This could be disrupted by placing aggregation disrupting units (“kinks”) in the chain, however this would disrupt the sequence. These problems are avoided using the NCA technique. We show here that A12R2 self-assembles into unprecedented ultrathin amyloid fibrils, with a width set by the length of the molecule, and a fundamental antiparallel dimer building unit.
The NCA of N-delta,N-omega-di-(benzyloxycarbonyl)-L-arginine (L-Arg(Di-Z)-NCA) was synthesized briefly as follows: N-alpha-(tert-butyloxycarbonyl)-N-delta,N-omega-di-(benzyloxycarbonyl)-L-arginine (Boc-L-Arg(Di-Z)-OH) was dissolved in ethyl acetate (∼4% w/w) followed by addition of triphosgene (moles triphosgene/moles of Boc-L-Arg(Di-Z)-OH = 0.35) under strong stirring and inert atmosphere at room temperature. After 10 minutes, an equivalent amount of triethylamine was added (in relation to Boc-L-Arg(Di-Z)-OH), the solution was immersed in an ice bath and was left for 5 hours. The unreacted species along with the HCl and the amino acid salts were removed by extraction with an aqueous alkali solution and water. The organic phase was introduced into a specially designed custom-made apparatus for extreme purification by three crystallizations with ethyl acetate and n-hexane under high vacuum conditions. The formed L-Arg(Di-Z)-NCA was stored at inert atmosphere at 0 °C.
The reactions used for the synthesis of the NCAs are given in Schemes 1 and 2.
![]() | ||
Scheme 1 Reactions used for the synthesis of the N-delta,N-omega-di-(benzyloxycarbonyl)-L-arginine N-carboxy anhydride. |
![]() | ||
Scheme 2 Reactions used for the synthesis of the L-alanine N-carboxy anhydride. |
The deprotection of the benzyloxycarbonyl groups of arginine was performed by dissolving the oligopeptide in trifluoroacetic acid followed by addition of a solution of HBr in acetic acid (10 equivalents for each equivalent of protection). The solution was stirred at 0 °C for one hour. The oligopeptide was precipitated in diethyl ether, and was centrifuged to be collected quantitatively, and the solid was rinsed three times with diethyl ether. The oligopeptide was dried, and then was suspended in water, was placed in a dialysis bag and was dialyzed against MilliQ water six times. The solution was then lyophilized to give the oligopeptide (70% yield). The reactions used are given in Scheme 3.
![]() | ||
Scheme 3 Reactions used for the synthesis of the A12R2 oligopeptide. |
The composition of the oligopeptide was verified by 1H NMR spectroscopy. The peaks used to obtain the composition were at 5.11 ppm which is the aliphatic –CH2 protons of the benzyl groups of the protected L-arginine and the one at 4.1 ppm which is the total α-protons of the amino acid groups. The efficiency of the deprotection of L-arginine was monitored with FT-IR and 1H NMR spectroscopy. The deprotection of the L-arginine was verified from the elimination of the peaks at 5.11 ppm (aliphatic –CH2 protons of benzyl group) along with the peaks at 7.3 ppm which corresponds to the aromatic protons of the protective groups. In the FT-IR spectrum, the significant reduction of the peaks at 698 and 738 cm−1 indicate the deprotection of the L-arginine.
Spectroscopic methods (CD and FTIR) were used to investigate secondary structure formation. FTIR spectra in the amide I′ region are shown in Fig. 1 and reveal a strong peak in the spectra for all three samples (0.5 wt%, 1 wt% and 2 wt%) at 1626 cm−1, which is ascribed to predominant β-sheet ordering.21,22 The peak at 1652 cm−1 may be assigned to a minority of α-helical structure (vide infra, there is also evidence from XRD for α-helical content).21,22 The shoulder peak at 1693–1694 cm−1 may be assigned to antiparallel β-sheet structure.21,23–25 There is also a peak in the amide II′ band at 1545 cm−1. The amide I′ region features are distinct from those for A6K, which only shows β-sheet features at high concentration, above about 15 wt%, above the critical aggregation concentration.10,11 Interestingly, the peak at 1608 cm−1 associated with the arginine side chain24,25 is not observed pointing to salt binding interactions.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 FTIR spectra for A12R2 in aqueous solution at the concentrations shown. |
CD spectra are also consistent with β-sheet structure, which increases with concentration. The spectra shown in Fig. 2 show a maximum at 195 nm and a minimum at 218 nm, these features being diagnostic of significant β-sheet content.26–28
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 CD spectra for A12R2 in aqueous solution at the concentrations indicated. |
Cryo-TEM revealed a mesh of fine fibrils covering the vitreous layer as shown in Fig. 3 which includes a representative image for a 2 wt% sample. In some regions where the film is thinner, areas showing single layers of fibrils could be observed (ESI Fig. S2,† includes typical images for a 5 wt% gel). In all cases, the diameter of the fibrils could be estimated at 5–6 nm. At high magnification, the fibrils appear to be twisted with a pitch of ca. 10 nm. The dense mesh of arginine-functionalized ultrathin fibrils obtained by self-assembly of A12R2 may be useful in applications such as antimicrobial coatings.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Cryo-TEM image from a 2 wt% solution of A12R2. The top inset shows an enlargement showing a helical twist with a pitch of (12 ± 2) nm and the bottom inset shows the corresponding intensity profile. |
SAXS intensity (I) profiles are shown in Fig. 4. The shape of the profiles was similar for all samples investigated in the concentration range 0.5–10 wt%, indicating a similar self-assembled structure is formed. Actually, the profiles measured under the same conditions, i.e. the dilute samples in capillaries superpose when adjusted for concentration in an I/c plot. The intensity profiles are consistent with a fibrillar structure as shown by the fit using a cylinder form factor. The fit parameters were cylinder radius R = 2.5 nm (length L = 25 nm fixed, kept relatively short consistent with the TEM images) with Gaussian polydispersity ΔR = 40%, relative electron density contrast η = 0.0001 and constant background BG = 0.0001. The radius agrees very well with the fibril diameter from cryo-TEM.
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 SAXS data at the concentrations indicated (measured at 20 °C for 0.5 wt% and 1 wt% and 25 °C for 10 wt%). The data for 0.5 and 1 wt% samples is for solutions mounted in capillaries, that for 10 wt% is for a gel mounted in a sandwich cell, the high q region of this data is influenced by the background subtraction. The line through the data for the 1 wt% sample is a fit to a cylinder form factor, as described in the text. |
Fibre X-ray diffraction was performed to investigate the self-assembled morphology at the level of the β-sheet structure. For the dried stalk, alignment was observed in the X-ray pattern as shown in Fig. 5(a). There are equatorial reflections corresponding to d = 7.7 A and 5.4 Å, and a strong meridional reflection at d = 4.42 Å. A further set of four off-axis reflections is observed at d = 3.74 Å. To quantify peak positions, one-dimensional integration was performed, the corresponding profiles being shown in Fig. 5(b) along with profiles for the hydrogel which did not show alignment in the 2D pattern. The hydrogel shows the same series of reflections as observed for the dried stalk, confirming that drying does not introduce artifacts. This was also confirmed by in situ synchrotron SAXS (ESI Fig. S3†) which shows reflections 7.6, 5.3 and 4.3 Å. Reflections at 5.5, 4.5 and 3.8 Å were reported for the related peptide A6K.10 However that peptide forms thin wall nanotubes in contrast to A12R2. However, the 5.3–5.5 Å reflection for the two peptides is assigned to a common feature, the stacking distance of β-sheets and the 4.3–4.4 Å reflection is due to the β-strand spacing. The 5.3–5.5 Å spacing is consistent with the 5.3 Å reflection observed for alanine-rich peptides29 and the polyalanine crystal structure.30,31 The spacing is much lower than the typical β-sheet stacking distance due to the efficient packing of small alanine residues. The spacing of the 4.4 Å reflection for A12R2 is also smaller than the usual 4.7–4.8 Å spacing of β-strands,32 and is consistent with a more tightly packed structure as observed for other alanine-rich peptides,29 and indicates shorter hydrogen bonds. The 7.7 Å repeat period (Fig. 6) has previously been assigned to the (100) reflection from an α-helical structure, coexisting with β-sheet structure for oligomeric alanine peptides (9–19 repeats)31 and the same assignment is used here. The 3.74 Å reflections appear not to be second order reflections from the 7.7 Å peak, first due to the difference in spacing with respect to 7.7 Å/2 but mainly due to the off-axis location of the reflections (not observed for the 7.7 Å reflection). Instead, they are ascribed to diffraction from planes containing Cα moieties.32,33 Our assignments of the observed periods are consistent with the orientation of the reflections shown in Fig. 5(b),34i.e. the 7.7 and 5.4 Å periodicities are perpendicular to the fibril axis, whereas the 4.4 Å (H-bonding) spacing is parallel to the fibril axis.32,33Fig. 6 shows a simplified schematic for the proposed structure that accounts for the 5 nm fibril width observed by both cryo-TEM and SAXS and the spacings (and orientation of reflections) obtained from XRD. In Fig. 6, only two stacked twisted tapes within the fibrils are shown, in reality there will be more (at least ∼10 based on the corresponding Bragg peak width) in order that a 5.4 Å Bragg reflection is observed, and to produce a 5 nm diameter fibril. The propeller-like twisting within the fibrils results from the electrostatic repulsion between the terminal R2 units within the antiparallel A12R2 dimers that are proposed as the fundamental structural building block (Fig. 6). These are stabilized by strong hydrogen bonding of alanine residues and efficient stacking of the small methyl side chains, as well as the electrostatic repulsion of the arginine units which is minimized with an antiparallel configuration. The observation of fibrils based on stacked ribbons is consistent with prior reports,35 however the basic stacking unit based on dimer-wide tapes is unprecedented to our knowledge.
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 (a) Fibre X-ray diffraction pattern measured from a stalk dried from a 2 wt% solution. (b) Fibre X-ray diffraction intensity profiles measured with a dried stalk, or from a 17.4 wt% in situ hydrogel. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 Proposed model showing ribbon (left) with width equal to an antiparallel A12R2 dimer (right). The A2 units are indicated in the ribbon schematic in red. The β-strand spacing is 4.4 Å (not to scale), and the pitch of the helix is ca. 10 nm. The β-sheet stacking distance (displacement between tapes) is 5.3 Å, only two stacked tapes are shown for clarity. |
The self-assembly of the peptide A12R2 is governed by a balance between the desire to reduce the electrostatic repulsion of the terminal arginine residues which produces an antiparallel dimer, and also leads to a twist of the fibrils and the stacking of the alanine residues. The repeating alanine sequence leads to closely stacked β-strands and β-sheets due to the efficient steric packing of the methyl side chains. These findings are in agreement with reports on alanine-rich silk-mimic peptides29 and polyalanine,30,31 and point towards the possibly generality of this mode of packing in peptides with multiple alanine repeats. In contrast to these prior reports the A12R2 peptide has been designed to be amphiphilic, incorporating a cationic di-arginine headgroup.
The structure detailed in this work provides the basis to rationally design other ultra-thin amyloid peptide fibrils. The arginine coating of the A12R2 fibrils is presented at high density and this has potential for functionalization in a variety of applications. For example the bidentate nature of the arginine guanidinium units leads to favorable interactions with phosphate groups. We also note that the fibrils form a high density “mat-like” structure at high oligopeptide concentration, suggesting possible applications in antimicrobial coatings since antimicrobial peptides are generally arginine-rich. These and related bionanoscience applications are under ongoing investigation in our group.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c3sm50303h |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2013 |