M. B.
Avinash
and
T.
Govindaraju
*
Bioorganic Chemistry Laboratory, New Chemistry Unit, Jawaharlal Nehru Centre for Advanced Scientific Research, Jakkur, Bangalore, 560064, India. E-mail: tgraju@jncasr.ac.in
First published on 27th January 2011
The chemistry of molecular assemblies involves weak yet complex non-covalent interactions, and the molecular organization of the π-conjugated material is crucial in determining the performance of an organic electronic device. Herein we demonstrate a bioinspired design strategy to tune the self-assembly of naphthalenediimides (NDIs) by minute structural variations, π–π stacking, hydrophobic interactions and metal interactions. We address some of the limitations associated with current design strategies, such as restriction to a specific molecular interaction or the difficulty in controlling the assembly due to several complicated intermolecular interactions. Hydrophobic-effect-induced J-type aggregation and sodium-interaction-induced H-type aggregation of tryptophan-appended NDIs have been illustrated. 1H NMR spectra further reveal sodium cation–π interactions in tryptophan-appended NDIs, while NMR and IR spectroscopic studies confirm the structural variations associated with the molecular assembly. In summary, the molecular organization has been successfully transformed from nanospheres to particles, nanobelts, fibers and fractals. Such drastic changes in the morphology are clear and striking evidence of the importance of non-trivial weak non-covalent forces.
Molecular interactions and their organization are the basis for various biological and non-biological systems. The molecular recognition process is complicated as it is influenced by several factors. Nature provides an exhaustive illustration of the elegance with which non-covalent interactions can be employed to cater for various requirements. To mimic Nature's versatility in controlling molecular interactions, we employ supramolecular design principles. Despite significant advances in supramolecular chemistry, direct control of molecular organization remains a daunting task, and although we have improved our ability to tune the selectivity and specificity of weak, complicated molecular interactions, the field is still in its infancy. Controlling the non-covalent assembly of aromatic moieties with variable functionality into well-defined architectures remains a challenging task for chemists.
The main challenge in organizing aromatic moieties lies in controlling and optimizing the relatively strong π–π interactions by adjusting the substituents. The most commonly employed strategy to functionalize arylene diimides is with a long-chain alkyl, alkoxy or phenyl substituent.19,20 The solubility is crucial for the solution processing of individual molecules, and this requires appropriate side-chain modification. Substitution with long or branched alkyl groups can aid solubility in organic non-polar solvents, while their hydrophobic effect in polar solvents can facilitate aromatic stacking. Generally, linear alkyl chains lead to 1D architectures while branched chains lead to 0D agglomerates.19 Increasing the size of the aromatic core can aid in molecular packing, but planarity and solubility can be affected.
Solvent–molecule interactions are yet another factor affecting the morphology of molecular self-assembly. Moreover, aggregation can vary from being spontaneous to being a rate-controlled process, depending on the alkyl chain length. In contrast to alkyl chains, alkoxy imide substituents (bolaamphiphiles), being hydrophilic, engenders solubility in polar solvents, although they can still be assembled in non-polar solvents. Amphiphiles with alkyl and alkoxy imide substituents on either side are also employed in molecular designs, while phenyl substituents offer rigidity and additional aromatic interactions. However, all these substituents are somewhat restricted to simple, specific interactions such as hydrophobic, hydrophilic or aromatic interactions, and lack a combination of non-covalent forces that can act in a cooperative manner. This limitation led us to look for better alternatives, and we realized that a solution might lie with amino acids.
Amino acids are important structural and signaling biomolecules due to their molecular recognition and distinctive sequence-specific self-assembly properties.21,22 Herein we report on an exclusive investigation of the molecular organization of NDI appended with two tryptophan moieties (Scheme 1). The choice of tryptophan as an imide substituent is unique due to its polar carboxylic acid group and an indole aromatic heterocycle offering both hydrophilic and hydrophobic properties in a single moiety. In addition, tryptophan provides interaction sites for metal binding, flexibility with regard to functionalization, and biocompatibility. Our work demonstrates the possible ways in which these properties can be exploited. Di-tryptophan-appended NDI has excellent solubility in polar solvents. A small structural modification such as using the methyl ester of tryptophan improves solubility in non-polar solvents. J-type aggregation was induced by hydrophobic forces in the tryptophan-appended NDIs. We also show that NDIs can be self-assembled as H-type aggregates by the addition of sodium hydroxide, which involves sodium cation–π interactions. All these features bring about drastic changes in the morphology of NDIs by transforming them into well-defined architectures. The molecular organization can be changed from nanospheres to particles, nanobelts, fibers and fractals, the latter having a broad range of applications due to their wide range of length scales.23 In our work, the well-defined architectures produced have been thoroughly characterized by photophysical, spectroscopic and morphological studies. Such drastic changes in the morphology of NDIs architectures are clear and striking evidence of the importance of these weak, complicated non-covalent forces. Thus, our bioinspired design strategy provides opportunities to adjust the molecular organization for various potential applications.
![]() | ||
| Scheme 1 Chemical structures of tryptophan (NDI 1) and tryptophan methyl ester (NDI 2) appended naphthalenediimides. | ||
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 UV-vis spectra of NDI 1 (a) and NDI 2 (b) in acetonitrile (100 μM) with increasing percentage of added water. UV-vis spectra of NDI 1 (c) and NDI 2 (d) in 10% aqueous acetonitrile (100 μM) with the addition of NaOH (in equiv). | ||
Solvent-dependent CD studies on the aggregation mode of NDI 1 are shown in Fig. 2a. The negative band at 221 nm for NDI 1 in acetonitrile was shifted to 213 nm (Δλ = 8 nm) in 90% aqueous acetonitrile. The n–π* transition in amides is dependent on solvent, and increasing the solvent polarity by adding water shifts the n–π* transition to lower wavelengths. With increasing solvent polarity, the 221 nm (n–π* transition) band is quenched preferentially, rather than the 202 nm (π–π* transition) band. The spectral band features of NDI 1 almost disappeared in 90% aqueous acetonitrile. The broad band centered at 276 nm was also found to quench with increasing solvent polarity, without any shift in band position. The π–π* transition bands of NDI at 335 nm, 352 nm and 372 nm were found to have a bathochromic shift to 337 nm, 357 nm and 378 nm respectively, similar to the bathochromic shift observed during absorption spectroscopic studies (Fig. 1a). Thus, the bathochromic shift of the NDI CD bands induced by hydrophobic effect can also be attributed to J-type aggregation. The CD study of hydrophobic effect on NDI 2 is shown in Fig. 2b. NDI 2 exhibits a bathochromic shift with respect to NDI (π–π*) bands, but a hypsochromic shift with respect to the imide (221 nm) band, similar to NDI 1. In 60% aqueous acetonitrile, NDI 2 shows a 1 nm hypsochromic shift of the 221 nm band, and a ∼1 nm bathochromic shift for the 352 nm and 372 nm bands. The hypsochromic shift of the 221 nm band and the bathochromic shift of NDI bands observed in CD measurements are due to the different mechanisms involved, as already discussed.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 CD spectra of NDI 1 (a) and NDI 2 (b) in acetonitrile (100 μM) with increasing percentage of added water. CD spectra of NDI 1 (c) and NDI 2 (d) in 10% aqueous acetonitrile (100 μM) with added NaOH (in equiv). Concentration-dependent CD spectra of NDI 1 (e) and NDI 2 (f) in acetonitrile. | ||
Surprisingly, NDI 1 with NaOH was found to display a bathochromic shift of the 221 nm negative band (Fig. 2c). A bathochromic shift of 2 nm was observed with 10 equiv of NaOH. The bands above 240 nm showed minimal changes for various equiv of NaOH. At 100 equiv of NaOH the bands above 240 nm completely disappeared. This is in agreement with the disappearance of the characteristic spectral features as observed in the absorption spectroscopic studies (Fig. 1c). Interestingly, the 202 nm band due to the π–π* transition of imide was found to have a hypsochromic shift. The NaOH-mediated interaction of NDI 1 is believed to shift the 202 nm band to below 200 nm. In addition, positive band-like features were observed at 210 nm and 240 nm. CD studies on NDI 2 with NaOH reveal spectral features similar to NDI 1 (Fig. 2d). A bathochromic shift of only 1 nm was observed for the 221 nm band in the case of NDI 2.
Concentration-dependent CD studies of NDI 1 and NDI 2 are shown in Fig. 2e and Fig. 2f respectively. The chiral-field-induced π–π* transitions of tryptophan result in a very broad negative band centered at 276 nm. However, the chiral-field-induced π–π* transitions of NDI result in negative bands at 335 nm, 352 nm and 372 nm. For low concentrations of NDI 1 (1 μM and 10 μM) in acetonitrile these characteristic bands above 240 nm were not observed. Unlike NDI 1, the CD spectrum of 500 μM NDI 2 shows bands at 282 nm, 356 nm and 375 nm. The concentration-dependent bathochromic shifts of bands at >240 nm are attributed to J-type aggregation of NDI 2. The reduced solubility of NDI 2 is believed to aid in their molecular organization.
O of carboxylic acid groups, 1580 cm−1 to aromatic νC
C and the 1670 cm−1 peak is attributed to the imide νC
O vibrational frequency, commonly known as the amide I band. The chemical environment constrained by conformation alters the amide I band, but the lack of conclusive structure–spectra correlations in the literature along with their several categories complicates the unambiguous assignment of amide I bands with the corresponding secondary structure. On the basis of the observed vibrational absorption frequency at 1670 cm−1, we attribute NDI 1 to a class of β-turn conformations.28 NDI 1 in 90% aqueous acetonitrile shows peaks at 1580 cm−1, 1666 cm−1 and 1704 cm−1 corresponding to aromatic νC
C, imide νC
O and νC
O of carboxylic acid functional groups respectively. These changes in the vibrational frequencies are attributed to hydrophobic-effect-induced structural variations. However, in the case of NDI 2 the peak at 1719 cm−1 is attributed to ester νC
O, and the 1580 cm−1 peak to aromatic νC
C, while the 1705 cm−1 and 1678 cm−1 peaks are assigned to the imide νC
O vibrational frequencies (see ESI†). NDI 2 showed slight changes in the vibrational modes in 60% aqueous acetonitrile. In another experiment NaOH was added portionwise to an acetonitrile solution of NDI 1; the corresponding spectral changes are shown in Fig. 3. With successive addition of NaOH, the carboxylic acid νC
O and imide carbonyl νC
O were found to shift towards lower frequencies. The carboxylic acid νC
O was found to be at 1700 cm−1, while the imide carbonyl νC
O at 1660 cm−1 with 2 equiv of NaOH (deprotonation of carboxylic acid protons). For 100 equiv of NaOH, very broad vibrational modes at 620 cm−1, 800 cm−1, 1429 cm−1, 1574 cm−1, 1598 cm−1 and ∼3000 cm−1 were observed. These changes in the vibrational modes clearly indicate the NaOH mediated interaction with NDI 1.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 IR spectra of NDI 1 (acetonitrile) with the addition of NaOH (in equiv). | ||
![]() | ||
| Fig. 4 Chemical structure of NDI 1 with proton assignments (top) and 1H NMR spectra of NDI 1 in CD3CN with varying percentage of added water (0–65%). | ||
![]() | ||
| Fig. 5 1H NMR spectra of NDI 1 in 10% aqueous CD3CN with increasing amounts of added NaOH (0–100 equiv). All the 1 H NMR spectra were recorded with different equiv of added NaOH while maintaining the solvent composition of 10% aqueous CD3CN. | ||
![]() | ||
| Fig. 6 (a) FESEM micrograph of NDI 1 nanospheres obtained from 100% acetonitrile solution. (b) The corresponding TEM micrograph of NDI 1 nanospheres. (c) FESEM micrograph of NDI 1 particles obtained from 90% aqueous acetonitrile solution. (e) FESEM micrograph of NDI 1 fractals formed by 10% aqueous acetonitrile solution containing 2 equiv of NaOH. (d) and (f) are corresponding high-magnification micrographs of (c) and (e) respectively. | ||
The interplay between hydrogen bonding, solvophobic forces and aromatic stacking decides the molecular organization and hence their morphology. The intermolecular hydrogen bonding between carboxylic acid groups of NDI 1 in cooperation with the solvophobic and aromatic interaction leads to nanospheres in acetonitrile solution. The presence of water in aqueous acetonitrile solution of NDI 1 disrupts the intermolecular hydrogen bonding. The mutual interactions involving solubility due to carboxylic acid groups and the hydrophobic-effect-induced aromatic interaction leads to J-type aggregation. The particles are believed to be formed from disordered organization of J-type aggregates, as indicated by absorption and morphological studies.
NDI 2 also forms spherical aggregates from acetonitrile solution as shown in Fig. 7a and 7b. The presence of the methyl ester of tryptophan in NDI 2 results in no significant changes in the aggregation mode with respect to NDI 1 from acetonitrile solution. From the absorption spectroscopic study we had observed a bathochromic shift of not more than 2 nm for the NDI π–π* transitions, a hypsochromic shift of 1 nm for the 221 nm (CD) band. Surprisingly, the molecular self-assembly of NDI 2 from 60% aqueous acetonitrile differs distinctly. NDI 2 forms fibers from 60% aqueous acetonitrile. The FESEM micrograph with a high aspect ratio fibers (bundle of nanobelts) is shown in Fig. 7c and 7d. AFM data revealed the transformation of NDI 2 nanospheres (D = a few hundred nm) into nanobelts and then into microfibers (see ESI†). The nanobelts bundle together to form long fibers that have a thickness of a few 100 nm to a few micrometers (see ESI†). The formation of spherical aggregates from NDI 2 suggests that intermolecular hydrogen bonding (carboxylic groups) need not be necessary, as the aggregation is mainly facilitated by solvophobic and aromatic interactions. However, the presence of the methyl ester reduces the solubility in water, and moreover the dominance of hydrophobic forces in cooperation with aromatic interactions leads to 1D aggregation.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 7 FESEM micrographs of NDI 2 nanospheres obtained from 100% acetonitrile solution (a) and fibers (bundle of nanobelts) obtained from 60% aqueous acetonitrile (c). (b) and (d) are corresponding high-magnification micrographs of (a) and (c) respectively. | ||
Analogous to the morphological changes induced by the bathochromic shift due to hydrophobic effect, NaOH too was found to affect the morphology. Deprotonation of the carboxylic acid protons in NDI 1 was found to result in hardly any change in the absorption spectra. However, deprotonation results in drastic changes in the morphology of NDI 1. With 2 equiv of NaOH, the formation of the sodium salt of NDI 1 results in the formation of fractals (Fig. 6e, 6f). For 10 equiv of NaOH, distinct microstructures of NDI 1 are formed (see ESI†). With further increase of NaOH (100 equiv), agglomeration of NDI 1 was observed (see ESI†). NDI 2 also results in similar fractals for 2 equiv of NaOH and agglomerated masses for 100 equiv of NaOH. We also studied the morphological changes as a function of concentration of NDIs. At higher concentration (1 mM) NDI 1 agglomerates (see ESI†), while 1 mM NDI 2 transforms into 1D nanobelts (Fig. S5, ESI†). The reduced solubility and the enhanced solvophobic forces are believed to enforce 1D assembly of NDI 2 (1 mM) aromatic cores into J-type aggregates, as indicated by CD studies (Fig. 2f).
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Experimental methods, synthesis, NMR, IR, FESEM, TEM and AFM. See DOI: 10.1039/c0nr00766h |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2011 |