Yiyang
Lin
a,
Xinhao
Cheng
a,
Yan
Qiao
a,
Cailan
Yu
b,
Zhibo
Li
c,
Yun
Yan
a and
Jianbin
Huang
*a
aBeijing National Laboratory for Molecular Sciences (BNLMS), College of Chemistry and Molecular Engineering, Peking University, Beijing, 100871, China. E-mail: jbhuang@pku.edu.cn; Fax: +86-10-62751708; Tel: +86-10-62753557
bCAS Key Laboratory of Photochemistry, Institute of Chemistry, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, 100080, People's Republic of China
cState Key Laboratory of Polymer Physics and Chemistry, Institute of Chemistry, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, 100190, PR China
First published on 14th January 2010
The creation of photo-modulated multi-state and multi-scale molecular self-assemblies was realized by the ingenuous utilization of a binary-state molecular switch, sodium (4-phenylazo-phenoxy)-acetate (AzoNa). Depending on the irradiation time, the binary state of the azobenzene group (i.e. trans/cis isomerization) can be exploited to generate multi-state nanostructures (including wormlike micelle, vesicle, lamellar structure, small micelle) by the coupling of conventional surfactant CTAB. Meanwhile, the conformation transition of azobenzene at molecular scale (∼Å), stimulated by light input can be amplified to regulate molecular architectures at mesoscopic scale (from nanometer to micrometer), leading to significant changes in solution property at macroscopic scale (naked-eye visible scale). By exposing to UV or visible light, the multi-state and multi-scale molecular self-assemblies can be reversibly controlled. It is proposed that light-triggered structural changes in the dipole moment and geometry of azobenzene group, which impart a significant effect upon molecular packing of surfactant aggregates, were responsible for this peculiar phenomenon.
Among these external stimuli, light is expected to be more advantageous and of significant importance. First, vision and other light-triggered biochemical transformations, such as photomovement at various biological levels, photomorphogenesis, and conversion of light energy into chemical energy in plants, represent sophisticated biological processes in which optical signals are recorded and transduced as physicochemical events.9 Second, in contrast to redox regent, pH change, salinity and stress, light signal can be operated in a clean environment free of any additional reagent. Third, light input is the most reliable strategy to tailor molecular assembly in view of its ready availability as a mild energy source.10 Also, another advantage of light over electric or ultrasound is that, light can be directed at a precise spatial location; this becomes especially valuable in nanoscience and nanotechnology applications, such as sensor systems, nanoelectronics, microfluidic, information storage and MEMS devices.11
Therefore, light is considered as an ideal external trigger signal to manipulate molecular assemblies at different hierarchical levels. The research interest involves host–guest chemistry, surfactant self-assembly, molecular machines, surface chemistry, controlled drug release, etc. For example, Sakai has controlled the formation and disruption of vesicles by light input in aqueous mixtures of a azobenzene-modified cationic surfactant and an anionic surfactant.12 Whitten has described the supramolecular aggregates of a series of azobenzene-contained phospholipids and related compounds in bilayer assemblies and other microheterogeneous media.13 Raghavan and coworkers provided a new class of photorheological fluids that undergo wormlike micelles to short cylindrical micelles transition.14 Eastoe has utilized UV light to change the ordering in lyotropic lamellar (Lα) phases.15
Despite the number of studies dedicated to investigations of photo-modulated molecular assemblies, there are still open questions remained to be addressed. In most cases, the light signal was translated into discrete “On” and “Off” states of molecular or supramolecular assemblies in a giving system such as photo-mediated aggregation/disaggregation processes, hydrophobic/hydrophilic surface, sol–gel transition, random coil/α-helix transitions, capture/release of guest molecules, and organized nanostructures with two distinct morphologies. This mainly originates from the fact that, light-active compounds usually exhibit two states such as trans/cis isomerization in azobenzene, open/close form in diarylethene, monomer/dimer transition in thymine. On the other hand, in these reports, light was mainly utilized to control molecular self-assembly in the microscopic scale. Nevertheless, the ultimate object of modern chemistry is to manipulate or assemble molecules into complex molecular architectures with morphological diversity at every level.
Stimulated by the curiosity in this field, we are interested in the creation of light-modulated multi-scale and multi-state molecular self-assemblies. In this paper, the peculiar light-active self-assembled system, consisting of azobenzene derivative and conventional surfactant, can exhibit four distinct states depending on illumination time. Combined with the result of transmission electronic microscopy (TEM), rheology, polarizing optical microscopy (POM), dynamic light scattering (DLS), small angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) and macroscopic appearance, we have demonstrated that diverse molecular self-assemblies including small micelle, wormlike micelle, global vesicle, and lamellar structures can be regulated by UV light, accompanied by the variation of solution properties, e.g. rheology, flowing birefringence, and phase separation. Moreover, both microstructures and solution properties can be reverted by further stimulation of visible light.
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 (a) The molecular structure of AzoNa. (b) and (c) 1H NMR spectra of AzoNa in D2O before and after UV light irradiation, respectively. |
The trans/cis transition can be further evidenced by UV-vis spectra (Fig. 2a). Before irradiation, the spectrum is dominated by the 344 nm absorption which is ascribed to π–π* absorption band of the trans-azobenzene moiety. As UV irradiation proceeds, the 344 nm absorption band decreases with concomitant increase of the π–π* and n–π* bands of the cis isomer at around 290 nm and 460 nm, respectively. A photostationary state was attained within 30 min. When the irradiated solution was then exposed to visible light, the trans-azobenzene can be reverted to cis-azobenzene. The trans/cis isomerization of the azobenzene unit in AzoNa could be repeated many times without decomposition of the components (Fig. 2b). Therefore it is anticipated that AzoNa can be developed as a binary-state molecular switch for constructing photo-modulated molecular assemblies.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 (a) UV-vis absorption spectra of AzoNa solution (0.1 mM) at different time of UV irradiation; (b) the absorbance at 344 nm of AzoNa solution by alternate irradiation at UV and visible light, respectively. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 Structural evolution and phase behavior in the solution of 30 mM CTAB and 50 mM AzoNa varied with UV irradiation time. |
Before UV illumination (donated as state one), the sample was equilibrated under visible light to generate a transparent, gel-like appearance (Fig. 4a). Upon tilting or mild tapping of the sample vial, intense birefringence can be detected when viewed under a crossed polarizer (Fig. 4b). On returning to the vertical position, the birefringence disappears again (Fig. 4c). Dynamic and steady rheology was further performed to investigate the flowing properties of this solution. As Fig. 5a shows, the sample exhibits typical rheological behavior of viscoelastic solution: at low oscillating frequency, the storage modulus G′ was dominant; while the loss modulus G′′ was dominant at high frequency. Steady rheology indicates the sample exhibits shear-thinning behavior with a Newtonian plateau of around 80 PaS viscosity. Combined with the result of viscoelasticity and flow-birefringence, it is suggested that long flexible wormlike micelles in the CTAB/AzoNa solution. The entangled of wormlike micelle can be responsible for high viscoelasticity.17 In a tilted state, the stress imposed deformation from gravity can cause alignment of wormlike micelle with the flow, which in turn leads to flow-birefringence. When shear is stopped, the worms rapidly revert to an isotropic state, and the birefringence disappears.18
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Macroscopic appearance of CTAB/AzoNa solution before UV irradiation (state one): (a) in the absence of polarizer; (b) tilted under polarizer; (c) rest under polarizer. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 5 (a) Dynamic frequency sweep before UV irradiation showing strongly viscoelastic response; (b) steady shear property before UV irradiation with a Newtonian plateau and a shear-thinning behavior. |
When the sample was irradiated with 365 nm UV light for 0.5 h (donated as state two), the homogeneous solution separates into biphasic solution (see inset in Fig. 6). The upper phase has orange color with slightly bluish while the bottom phase is dark yellow. A strong birefringence can be detected under crossed polarizer (see inset in Fig. 6). Rheological measurement reveals the different flowing behavior of the upper and lower phase. As shown in Fig. 6, the upper phase is water-like with low viscosity while the lower phase exhibits shear-thinning behavior with a high viscosity.
![]() | ||
Fig. 6 Steady rheology of CTAB/AzoNa exposed to UV light for 0.5 h (state two). The inset shows the macroscopic appearance of CTAB/AzoNa solution: (a) in the absence of polarizer; (b) in the presence of polarizer. |
FF-TEM, SAXS, and POM were further employed to explore the molecular self-assemblies. The FF-TEM image in Fig. 7a demonstrates the formation of global vesicles with 40–70 nm diameters in the upper phase, which is in coincide with rheological result. On the contrary, FF-TEM gives clear evidence of ordered lamellar structures in the lower phase (Fig. 7b), which is responsive for the high viscosity and strong birefringence. A typical Maltese crosses texture under POM was notable in the lower phase (Fig. 8a), confirming the existence of lamellar structures. Small Angle X-ray Scattering gives the quantitative description of molecular packing in the lamellar structures. As shown in Fig. 8b, a strong scattering signal (q = 1.5 nm−1) could be found, which corresponds to a d-spacing of 4.2 nm and agrees well with double molecular length of CTAB (∼2.1 nm). Hence, it is believed that CTAB adapts ordered tail-to-tail packing in the lamellar phase with AzoNa incorporating into surfactant headgroup (inset in Fig. 8b).
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 Freeze fracture-TEM image of CTAB/AzoNa after exposed to 365 nm UV light at state two: (a) upper phase; (b) lower phase. |
![]() | ||
Fig. 8 Lamellar phase of the lower phase in CTAB/AzoNa solution after exposed to 365 nm UV light at state two: (a) microscopy under polarizer (scale bar = 50 μm); (b) SAXS profile of the lamellar phase. |
Further increasing UV irradiation time to 1.0 h results in a homogeneous viscous solution as shown in the inset of Fig. 9a (donated as state three). This solution shows evident viscoelasticity, but not strong enough to be detected with dynamic oscillation experiment. Steady shear rheology in Fig. 9a shows shear-thinning behavior with a viscosity of 0.2 PaS. Under cross polarizer, no birefringence can be observed. The cryo-TEM image clearly demonstrated wormlike micelle formation in this viscoelastic solution (Fig. 9b). Dynamic light scattering reveals a slow mode that may correspond to structural relaxation of wormlike micelle network (Fig. S2).†
![]() | ||
Fig. 9 a) Steady shear of the CTAB/AzoNa solution after exposing to 365 nm UV light for 1.0 h (state three). The inset represents the appearance of the homogeneous solution. b) Cryo-TEM image of CTAB/AzoNa solution at state three. |
As the irradiation time increases to 3.0 h or longer (donated as state four), a homogeneous and dark yellow solution was obtained (see the inset in Fig. 10a). The steady shear result manifests a Newtonian fluid with low viscosity. Dynamic light scattering clearly demonstrates the existence of small aggregates with the hydrodynamic radius of approximate 3 nm (Fig. 10b), which is close to the extended length of CTAB molecule. Combined with the result of rheology and DLS, it is reasonable to believe that dispersed, small global micelle was formed at this state.
![]() | ||
Fig. 10 (a) Steady shear and (b) dynamic light scattering of CTAB/AzoNa solution after exposing to 365 nm UV light for 3.0 h (state four). The inset in Fig. 10a shows the macroscopic appearance of the homogeneous solution. |
It has been realized that molecular self-assemblies in the cationic-anionic surfactant systems mainly aroused from tight packing of oppositely charged surfactants, which is closely related to the stoichiometry and steric factor of cationic/anionic species. In the pseudo catanionic surfactant mixture of CTAB/AzoNa, although the concentration of both CTAB and AzoNa remains constant, the stoichiometry and steric factor in surfactant aggregates can be changed by light illumination. This is because, azobenzene can undergo photo-induced isomerism accompanied by large structural change as reflected in the dipole moment and change in geometry. The isomerization involves a decrease in the distance between the para carbon atoms in azobenzene from about 9.0 Å in the trans-form to 5.5 Å in the cis-form. Likewise, trans-azobenzene has no dipole moment while the dipole moment of the nonplanar cis-compound is 3.0 D.10 It is believed that the difference in dipole moment can lead to the variation of hydrophobic/hydrophilic balance of azobenzene isomers. For example, in azobenzene-contained surfactants, the greater hydrophobicity of trans-surfactant gives it a lower critical micelle concentration.19 Specifically, it is found that trans-AzoNa is highly hydrophobic with a solubility of 25 mM while light-triggered cis-AzoNa is more hydrophilic with a solubility of higher than 100 mM. Arising from electrostatic attraction and high hydrophobicity, trans-AzoNa can strongly intercalate into CTAB headgroup, which contributes to hydrophobic interaction and the screen of electrostatic repulsion.20 In contrast, cis-AzoNa cannot effectively penetrate into surfactant aggregates as a consequence of hydrophilicity enhancement and fail to promote close packing of cationic-anionic species due to bulky steric limitation of cis-azobenzene.
Further experiments were conducted to confirm the above proposal. First, the aggregate-promoting ability of trans- and cis-AzoNa was distinguished by critical micelle concentration or CMC obtained from conductivity data (Fig. 11a), wherein the CMC value of CTAB/trans-AzoNa system (∼0.055 mM) is notably lower than that of CTAB/cis-AzoNa system (∼0.13 mM). So it is believed that trans-AzoNa can better promote surfactant aggregates. Second, the change in molecular packing of CTAB/AzoNa aggregates caused by photo-triggered trans/cis isomerization was clarified by steady florescence. Nile Red was chosen as the fluorescence probe because its excitation peak occurs at a long wavelength (575 nm) where absorption by the azobenzene group is minimal21 and also because its emission is very environment-sensitive.22 Nile Red fluorescence intensity is much greater in hydrophobic environments than in hydrophilic environment. Following excitation at 575 nm, the fluorescence emission spectrum was measured for each sample at different irradiation time. As shown in Fig. 11b, the initial solution gives strong Nile Red emission while continuing UV irradiation results in the decrease of fluorescence intensity. When UV irradiation time reaches 3.0 h, the Nile Red emission lowers to almost one eighth of the value before UV irradiation. Apparently, trans-AzoNa can lead to tight packing of cationic-anionic species while cis-AzoNa may cause loose molecular packing.
![]() | ||
Fig. 11 (a) Conductivity of CTAB/AzoNa (1![]() ![]() |
Combined with these results, we provide a possible scheme for the occurrence of photo-modulated multi-scale and multi-state molecular assemblies (Fig. 12). Before UV illumination (state one), trans-AzoNa can intercalate into the paraside layer of aggregates driven by electrostatic attraction and hydrophobic effect.20 So the homogeneous visoelastic solution consisting of negatively charged wormlike micelle was attained, in which trans-AzoNa is in excess to CTAB. After further illumination of UV light (state two), a portion of the trans-AzoNa transformed into cis-AzoNa which is more hydrophilic and could not incorporate into surfactant aggregate. Consequently CTAB/trans-AzoNa mixture in the aggregates approaches the equimolar ratio and the aggregates charge was nearly neutralized, giving birth to biphasic surfactant solution consisting of bilayer vesicle and planar lamellae. In the lower phase, the cis-fraction of AzoNa is about 32% (the estimation of cis-AzoNa is described in the Supporting Information).† In the upper phase, the cis-fraction of AzoNa is slightly higher than that in the lower phase; however, the exact value cannot be obtained. After continuous UV light illumination, the concentration of trans-AzoNa in solution was further reduced and the amount of trans-AzoNa (∼37%) is lower than that of CTAB, leading to the formation of positively charged cylindrical micelle and homogeneous solution (state three). When trans-AzoNa was mostly converted into cis-AzoNa (∼83%), the electrostatic repulsive between CTAB headgroup becomes dominating factor that limits closely packing of surfactant molecule, resulting into positively charged global micelle (state four). The zeta-potential value at this stage (∼3.0 mV) clarified the formation of positively charged micelle. In a word, the trans/cis molar ratio of AzoNa is responsible for the structural evolution of surfactant aggregates. In a complementary experiment, state two and state three can be created by mixing the solutions in state one and state four at the mixing proportions of 2:
1 and 1
:
2, respectively.
![]() | ||
Fig. 12 Representative scheme of photo-modulated multi-scale and multi-state self-assembled systems. |
To summarize, the photo-modulated multi-state molecular assemblies with distinct morphologies can be elegantly achieved via light stimulus. Meanwhile the photo-modulated multi-state molecular assemblies can be also amplified to solution properties at macroscopic scale. In addition, the photo-modulated self-assemblies can be reverted by exposing to visible light.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Synthesis of the azobenzene derivative. See DOI: 10.1039/b916721h |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2010 |